In previous SimCity games simulation was performed on the macro scale - not on each citizen. Any micro-scale view was just a visualization of the macro simulation. This meant you couldn't follow a sim's car from home to work and back, but it also meant scalability and the freedom to have a proper simulation model rather than a grossly dumbed-down one.
Agent-based simulation is the correct implementation (i.e., closest to reality) technically, but only in a world where we have infinite CPU power. A macro-simulation like previous SimCity games would have meant far fewer corners cut and a much less buggy behavior that are the result of emergent negative agent-agent interactions.
To take your analogy - SimCity 3000 and SimCity 4 use billboards and textures for fake smoke. SimCity 5 tries to go all-in and simulate the hydrodynamics of each particle - but has to cut so many corners to run that it doesn't even look like smoke anymore.
Note that in SimCity 2013 you still can't really do this. A sim finds a new job every day and finds a new home at the end of the day. Really.
You may be right there's just no way to salvage the current SimCity 5 problems (if that's what you're implying), but I don't think the current issues ruin the game at all. For me the illusion mostly holds up and the pathfinding issues are mostly corner cases. So I don't think it's a fundamental problem with the game design and I think a few AI patches can make a world of difference.
(although, arguably, a macro-level simulation could have resulted in a much better SimCity because that would allow for more depth and larger city areas. And arguably a sim-level simulation is a bit of a gimmick that doesn't add enough to the game to justify the complexity and PR buzz, but that's a different issue)
If the only way you play is to build large, spread out suburbs full of low-density buildings then yeah, you can conceivably play the game without seeing the ill effects of the bad pathfinding.
But as soon as you even see your first high-density high-rise the whole thing starts to fall apart.
I don't think this is necessarily unfixable - but it does require a level of reimplementation that I don't think EA would be willing to make.
The real horror comes when you start a region's great work. A significant number of people will leave the city in the mornings to work at the great work. If you are making a great work you are probably sending dozens of trucks with resources to it as well. The end result is you get easily 10x more vehicles leaving/entering the city. The queue to get in through the single lane off-ramp from the highway then ends up stretching all the way to the next city, and it takes a good 24 hours for the cars at the end to get in. It then ends up stabilizing, taking maybe 4-6 hours for someone to get into the city.
Also, a large number of cars 'just passing through' will use your city entrance as a 'quick' way to do a U-turn on the highway, blocking traffic even more.
Though even SimCity 4 actually assigned each sim a specific home and workplace. Their travels/resources were calculated on the macro scale though.
Actually this does not seem to be the case at all [0]. Some people have figured out that the total population numbers are are either bugged or faked. For a supposed 100,000 pop town, the actual population is around 15,000.
simcity.GetFudgedPopulation = function (a) {
a = "undefined" !== typeof a ? a : simcity.gGlobalUIHandler.mLastPopulation;
if (500 >= a)
return a;
if (40845 < a)
return Math.floor(8.25 * a);
a = Math.pow(a - 500, 1.2) + 500;
return Math.floor(a)
};
https://gist.github.com/anonymous/5133829#file-simcityui-js-...http://np.reddit.com/r/SimCity/comments/1a6oeo/proof_that_th...
Did you read the article? The congestion makes no sense.
And to the best of my recollection previous versions of SimCity were able to handle traffic just fine. I certainly do not remember them suffering from the congestion problems this version seems to be afflicted by.
edit: clarity
But the videos clearly showing that cars take nothing other than shortest path into consideration. They don't even check if their destination is still valid. This does not make sense.
So asking if you read the article is not rude because your quote seems to be in direct conflict with the article.
That's not really true. Sim City 4 did have congestion problems and it did simulate Sims going from point A to B. It wasn't as granular as SC5 simulating individual cars, but it did simulate groups of Sims traveling to and from work. It was also infamously buggy (something the modding community spent a lot of effort fixing) but it still was better than what we have now.
Indeed. For the amount of time I spent playing Sim City 4 with the Network Addon Mod (the one that changes the pathfinding and tweaks transportation usage to be more sane), I was taking for granted that Maxis would learn from those mistakes, and even take a nod from the community in terms of what is believable transit behavior.
SC4 was the one that actually tried to model traffic flow throughout your city to locate bottlenecks. The pathfinding algorithm used looks like a variant of A, with the caveat that it would never explore nodes that weren't between you and your destination. This resulted in a lot of finicky behavior - things like your sim not taking the subway to work because he had to walk back a single block to catch it, and insisting on joining the gridlock instead.
This is largely fixed with the NAM mod though, which restored proper pathfinding.
The nice part about SC4 was that you could actually zoom in and see the gridlock. Sure, these weren't actual citizens in their cars, but it is a correct visualization of the simulation's traffic analysis. I for one will gladly give up the ability to follow a sim home for a faster, more scalable, more accurate simulation.
Reminds me a lot of most consumer GPS today that avoids backtracking whenever possible, even if that means a more congested or convoluted route.
I've seen this behavior too many times, from systems ranging from Google Nav to TomTom to the OEM Nav in my Mercedes.
Or you can just suck it up and create real complexity, which can be awesome!
Like down a dead end street to one house? Did you read the article?
With SimCity 5 you can easily have over 100.000 Sims in one city region. SimCity has to model the economy, happiness, education, water, waste, power, pollution, traffic, industry, and much more. So if you want to do this for 100.000 Sims in real-time you've got to cut many corners. There's just no other way. And the illusion in SimCity 5 is pretty damn good, from what I've seen. Cars drive with purpose from one place to another. Traffic congestion seems to make sense. Air flow affects pollution in a sensible way. Sure, there are a bunch of bugs but in general the illusion holds up. It's really quite impressive.