News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Beware Discount Steam Keys by crazygringo on Friday March 08, 2013 @07:00PM (#5346578)
Can someone who understands how chargebacks work please explain:

1) If this such an obvious case of massive fraud, isn't there any kind of protection for the seller? If they provide proof that the product keys were delivered to the customers, how can customers still arbitrarily have their requested chargebacks accepted?

2) Are chargeback fees always on the order of $22? That seems unbelievably high. Is this just a way that credit card operators take advantage of businesses, because they don't have much other choice?

I totally understand penalizing businesses for excessive chargeback levels, when it's "widespread" and due to the business's own products.

But I don't understand why credit card companies aren't going to work with businesses in case of chargeback fraud, instead of working against them. Do they really have so much monopoly power that they have no incentive to?

Re:Beware Discount Steam Keys by Negitivefrags on Friday March 08, 2013 @07:11PM (#5346617)
I work on an online game also.

In the case of virtual goods, you will never have a chargeback side with the seller. Never. You are at the complete mercy of every customer. All you can do is ban the account after there has been a chargeback.

We get reasons like "I need to pay my rent so I want the money back" or "I played the game for a few days and I don't want to play anymore". You can supply email evidence like that as part of the chargeback claim. You will still be decided against.

For virtual goods, the credit card system is just broken.

Chargeback fees tend to be around $15, but you also lose the cost of the purchase.

Re:Beware Discount Steam Keys by gamblor956 on Friday March 08, 2013 @07:13PM (#5346635)
If you can provide evidence that the charge was legitimate, the CC processor will undo the reversal of the charge (which means the charge will be placed back on the customer's bill). YMMV outside of the US, but the CC processors have lost enough court cases in the US on this point to settle the issue.
Re:Beware Discount Steam Keys by elisee on Friday March 08, 2013 @07:18PM (#5346653)
At least PayPal doesn't cover digital purchases at all for sellers.

It would basically be your word against the credit card holder anyway since there is no physical proof so I can understand why they can't. Anyone could make up some proof. The root problem is with the banks: it's their system that is being used fraudulently and they should be the ones paying for it so that they have an incentive to improve it.

Re:Beware Discount Steam Keys by gamblor956 on Friday March 08, 2013 @07:22PM (#5346669)
Paypal does cover digital purchases for US sellers. I know this for a fact because I have used Paypal as a merchant of digital goods and been in this situation. Paypal's service was exemplary; I simply provided a receipt of the transaction, the customer's IP address, and logs showing that the same IP address downloaded the software. Paypal never charged back the transaction and handled the dispute for me with the customer's bank. If the customer's bank refused to undo the chargeback, then Paypal swalled the loss on my behalf.

Anyone could make up some proof.

Well, yes. But people generally don't go through the trouble of making up proof for relatively small transactions (<$100, from the merchant's perspective). It's simply not worth the time and effort to fake up proof for something less than a $100 unless the work would take a minute or two more than simply collecting the evidence supporting the transaction.

Re:Beware Discount Steam Keys by Negitivefrags on Friday March 08, 2013 @08:39PM (#5346887)
This hasn't been my experience with PayPal, or with any other provider. We legitimately try and provide that kind of evidence.

For PayPal the user has to supply a chargeback reason. We had a user type in "I need money to pay my rent". That was the exact text. The customer has admitted fault, but paypal still decides against us.

Edit: We have a US company and paypal account so it isn't that.

Re:Beware Discount Steam Keys by elisee on Friday March 08, 2013 @07:33PM (#5346707)
Was this recent? Did you sign up for a particular PayPal service? I use the basic Express Checkout myself so maybe some of their more expensive plans cover that?

Anyway, from my own recent experience and what I heard from several indie devs, even after providing server logs & screenshots, PayPal can't do anything (and I'm not blaming them, I'm sure they do fight the charge if at all possible)

EDIT: Oh, just saw you wrote "US seller". I'm not in the US so that might have something to do with it maybe.

Re:Beware Discount Steam Keys by tantalor on Friday March 08, 2013 @07:13PM (#5346629)
Isn't this fraud? If you have evidence that customers are ripping you off, why not report to law enforcement?
Re:Beware Discount Steam Keys by elisee on Friday March 08, 2013 @07:30PM (#5346695)
I don't think it would be economically viable for most independent developers or small companies to spend time and money that could be used for productive stuff to deal with a few individual chargebacks every now and then, with no guarantee that you'll make your money back anyway. Plus what happens when you lose?

When it's on a massive scale like in TFA, they will probably work with law enforcement but 1) will they find the responsible? 2) even if they do, would the payment processor agreements with the various banks cover getting the chargeback fees cancelled? I don't know but it doesn't seem a given.

Re:Beware Discount Steam Keys by tantalor on Friday March 08, 2013 @10:58PM (#5347267)
You raise a good point about the cost of pursuing these cases.

From my naive understanding, this type of fraud would have both criminal and civil penalties. For the criminal component, determining jurisdiction might be an issue, so there ought to be a federal agency to report cases to. The civil components might be "sold" to specialized firms, e.g., debt collectors.

The point is to disincentive fraudsters and recompense victims.

Re:Beware Discount Steam Keys by elisee on Friday March 08, 2013 @07:12PM (#5346624)
1) From my understanding, the purchases were made en masse using stolen credit card info, and the game keys were then sold (maybe several times?) until they ended up in front of everyday customers looking to save a bit of money by buying one from a shady website.

The people who requested chargebacks are people who had their credit card info stolen and didn't make the purchase. From their point of view, it's completely legitimate to ask for a refund.

2) Chargebacks are in the $15-30 range I think. PayPal and similar services will fight a chargeback for you against the bank, but digital purchases are not protected so you end up loosing every time.

The big issue is that the merchant is the one bearing the risk. I recently learned that some banks allow customers to request a chargeback months or even up to a year after purchase. I had a customer do that more than 60 days after purchase. One can buy a digital good, use it until they don't want it anymore and then get their money back... and the merchant ends up loosing money on it, in addition to giving them their money back.

From my point of view, the merchants shouldn't have to pay for fraud in the banking system. The banks don't even have an incentive to secure credit card transactions if they make money on it (or at least break even)!

Re:Beware Discount Steam Keys by kalleboo on Friday March 08, 2013 @07:56PM (#5346759)
> The banks don't even have an incentive to secure credit card transactions if they make money on it (or at least break even)!

This may be changing a bit. At least in Europe, we now have Chip-and-pin for offline transactions, and 3DSecure/Verified by Visa/MasterCard SecureCode for online. One of my banks now requires these schemes for online purchases, and I can't use their card on any online stores that don't support it. I believe Chip-and-PIN shifts the burden of fraud onto the consumer (if you leak your PIN it's your fault), and I wouldn't be surprised if it's the same for 3DSecure (or my bank wouldn't have any incentive to require it)

Re:Beware Discount Steam Keys by elisee on Friday March 08, 2013 @08:25PM (#5346836)
Indeed, same here (France) and it's definitely a move in the right direction. For cases similar to Unknown Worlds' though, it's important that the whole world moves to something more secure, otherwise bad guys will still be able to get their hands on less secure credit cards and use those against them.
Re:Beware Discount Steam Keys by rgbrenner on Friday March 08, 2013 @07:16PM (#5346646)
1) There are a couple of protection for sellers. a) a floor limit - where visa/mc/etc cover the chargeback if it's under a certain amount ($5-20 is common)... if it is in your contract at all, it's limited to physical stores. Ecommerce/card-not-present is explicitly excluded.

b) if they can prove the keys were delivered to the card holder, and the cardholder is not claiming fraud/misrepresented goods/etc, then you can usually dispute the chargeback. This is harder than it sounds, because you need to ship to the billing address via a trackable service and obtain a signature from the cardholder when it is delivered. If you've ever shipped via UPS/FedEx then you know they will often not collect the signature, or they will collect it from another person at the address, or leave the package at the door, or the signature is illegible, etc, etc, etc.

2) I've seen chargeback fees between 10 and 50$ (25-30 is common). This is a fee from the bank that provides your merchant account.. so it varies. It's a fee for handling the chargeback.. keep in mind the bank must receive the chargeback, forward it to you, accept your response, send it to the customer's bank, etc. Does that cost $22? Definitely not.

Merchants are responsible for verifying the card is not fraudulent, and they accept the risk of fraud when they accept the order. If the merchant does not control the level of fraud, they'll see their merchant account terminated. The threshold varies by merchant bank.. I've seen as low as 0.2% up to 1%... but merchants usually don't get to see this number.

Re:Beware Discount Steam Keys by gamblor956 on Friday March 08, 2013 @07:18PM (#5346656)
This is why you would use a service like Paypal: the contract with PP does include digital goods, and in fact Paypal is very good about backing the merchant in situations like this, so long as you can provide evidence of the purchase (including, for example, evidence that the customer used the purchased digital good after the challenged transaction).
Re:Beware Discount Steam Keys by rgbrenner on Friday March 08, 2013 @07:23PM (#5346671)
My experience here is from running an ecommerce store.. so we actually ship the product to the customer.

I believe banks would accept digital proof as long as it established: 1) the cardholder made the purchase; 2) the cardholder received and/or used the digital goods.

But that is really only useful if the cardholder says they did not receive the license key/digital goods. If they say you misrepresented the item, or they did not make the purchase (because their card was stolen), then I can't imagine how you would dispute the chargeback.

And in that regard, PayPal is the same. If the PayPal user says their PayPal account was hacked, and they didn't make a number of transfers.. PayPal will undo the transactions.

Re:Beware Discount Steam Keys by davidandgoliath on Friday March 08, 2013 @07:12PM (#5346622)
It's up to merchants to ensure fraud is prevented, that is: refund anything sketchy before it becomes a chargeback. As for them being that high: $22 does seem excessive considering the purchase price of natural selections but I've seen higher.
Re:Beware Discount Steam Keys by seanc722 on Friday March 08, 2013 @07:21PM (#5346667)
22$ for a 25$ game? So they lose out on the 25$ sale and get charged 22$. I feel like this amount is a little excessive.
Re:Beware Discount Steam Keys by ennuihenry on Friday March 08, 2013 @07:48PM (#5346742)
The merchant bank probably has a default chargeback fee that Unknown Worlds agreed to when they signed up with them. For instance, Balanced Payments (https://www.balancedpayments.com/docs/overview?language=bash...) has a $15 chargeback fee. It's incumbent on the business to review the fees before signing up.
Re:Beware Discount Steam Keys by tantalor on Friday March 08, 2013 @07:12PM (#5346621)
The product keys were delivered to the purchaser (i.e., perpetrator of fraud), not the account holder (i.e., victim of fraud).