The European Parliament (unlike most national parliaments within Europe) can't actually draft legislation by itself. That's reserved for the executive branch, the European Commission. These kinds of endorsements, once passed, are effectively taken by the European Commission as an indication of the opinion of the Parliament, and it then drafts bills accordingly.
If the Commission wants to introduce measures such as those found in the resolution, it'll have a mandate for them, providing the endorsement of the report (specifically an " own initiative report") passes. Then the draft bill goes back to the Parliament to vote on, and if it passes then, it becomes a legally binding directive for EU member states to follow.
...
The resolution can be seen as a call for further investigation of the issue with an extra clause that's likely to be skipped over in any later phase of legislative debate, rather than the slippery slope to an EU-wide pornography ban -- but just in case, it might be worth writing to your MEP. Otherwise it'll be back to hunting in the railway sidings, and nobody wants that.
Re:European Parliament blocks citizen e-mails protesting 'po...
by jstalin on Friday March 08, 2013 @12:11PM
(#5344489)
Wow, just reading through how the European Council, European Commission, and European Parliament work, I'm struck by the near total lack of direct accountability to voters there is.
Re:European Parliament blocks citizen e-mails protesting 'po...
by mseebach on Friday March 08, 2013 @12:21PM
(#5344539)
Symbolic institution is symbolic. Their support for the ban can lend legitimacy to a future move by the commission, conversely, the successful lobbying of the EP by citizens to shut it down early can do the opposite. Also, a sure way to make sure the institution remains toothless is to ignore it because it's toothless.
Re:European Parliament blocks citizen e-mails protesting 'po...
by DieBuche on Friday March 08, 2013 @12:03PM
(#5344453)
This is a lot of noise about nothing. They passed a well meant report on eliminating gender stereotypes in the EU (not a law) containing this sentence: Calls on the EU and its Member States to take concrete action on its resolution of 16 September 1997[1] on discrimination against women in advertising, which called for a ban on all forms of pornography in the media and on the advertising of sex tourism.
The mentioned report is itself contains this sentence:
5. Calls for statutory measures to prevent any form of pornography in the media and in advertising and for a ban on advertising for pornographic products and sex tourism;
Re:European Parliament blocks citizen e-mails protesting 'po...
by fusiongyro on Friday March 08, 2013 @11:36AM
(#5344292)
As an American, I was always under the impression we were the puritans when it comes to pornography. How much popular support does this have over there? I'm also surprised this is something the European Parliament has the power to enact.
Re:European Parliament blocks citizen e-mails protesting 'po...
by tomjen3 on Friday March 08, 2013 @11:45AM
(#5344350)
Voters in EU write to their representatives approximally never so getting 350 emails in less than a day could easily mean that there is a huge opposition.
People tend not to care about details of governship that only marginally effect their lives, but this is going to have a potentially huge effect.
Frankly though, I doubt it will pass -- anybody who votes for this risk alienating voters who normally wouldn't care, and there aren't enough proponents to make up for it.
Re:European Parliament blocks citizen e-mails protesting 'po...
by tobiasu on Friday March 08, 2013 @12:04PM
(#5344459)
Not that I'm interested in the political process as an EU citizen (because it makes my blood boil), but how credible do you think this is? It's probably been blown out of proportion three times before even reaching the so called journalists at cnet...
Specifically,
The European Parliament (unlike most national parliaments within Europe) can't actually draft legislation by itself. That's reserved for the executive branch, the European Commission. These kinds of endorsements, once passed, are effectively taken by the European Commission as an indication of the opinion of the Parliament, and it then drafts bills accordingly.
If the Commission wants to introduce measures such as those found in the resolution, it'll have a mandate for them, providing the endorsement of the report (specifically an " own initiative report") passes. Then the draft bill goes back to the Parliament to vote on, and if it passes then, it becomes a legally binding directive for EU member states to follow.
...
The resolution can be seen as a call for further investigation of the issue with an extra clause that's likely to be skipped over in any later phase of legislative debate, rather than the slippery slope to an EU-wide pornography ban -- but just in case, it might be worth writing to your MEP. Otherwise it'll be back to hunting in the railway sidings, and nobody wants that.
The mentioned report is itself contains this sentence: 5. Calls for statutory measures to prevent any form of pornography in the media and in advertising and for a ban on advertising for pornographic products and sex tourism;
This was passed already in 1997.
[1]: http://www.europarl.europa.eu/sides/getDoc.do?type=REPORT...
How is this well meaning?
People tend not to care about details of governship that only marginally effect their lives, but this is going to have a potentially huge effect.
Frankly though, I doubt it will pass -- anybody who votes for this risk alienating voters who normally wouldn't care, and there aren't enough proponents to make up for it.
I remain under the impression that this is somewhat unusual and unique to Iceland and America's puritan status isn't really threatened.
submitted HN link: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5340184
Are they insane? Really?
Not going to happen.
In fact they are actively organising to not be bothered by their constituents.