News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by maxerickson on Friday March 08, 2013 @10:18AM (#5343837)
It isn't that hard to factor the downsides into the price you are willing to pay.

The internet whinging machine should focus on clear statements of what the product does and consumer education. EA should only get in trouble if they fail to make it clear that the game requires a network connection or if they fail to provide servers for the advertised period.

Selling a game with online features should not have to be a commitment to provide those features forever, so finding decent middle ground is the only solution.

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by T-hawk on Friday March 08, 2013 @10:23AM (#5343874)
> It isn't that hard to factor the downsides into the price you are willing to pay.

This. I've bought a number of $10 games on Steam because I figure I'll get that much value out of a game even if Steam disappears next month. But I won't go much higher for anything encumbered by online DRM or other means of remote shutdown.

I can afford more, but the reasoning is psychological. I'll care and get agitated if a $60 investment disappears, but I can write off $10.

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by nemof on Friday March 08, 2013 @11:16AM (#5344164)
Steam have always said that if for some unfathomable reason they shut down the service they would make sure our games would continue to be playable.
Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by T-hawk on Friday March 08, 2013 @11:41AM (#5344332)
Yes, they have said that, and with the best intentions. But one can never predict what will actually happen with a company in the throes of shutting down. The lawyers could kick out the programmers before they can throw the killswitch, or even obtain an injunction against doing so. Picture a hypothetical event where Valve enters bankruptcy and shuts down service, but an acquirer intends to resume it, but the case gets stuck in the courts for years. (IANAL and I'm exaggerating to make the point, but you get the idea.)

We're dependent on Valve's good will and intentions for Steam. There is no technical solution that the community can implement without Valve's blessing.

All of the above should be factored into the grandparent post about factoring DRM into discounting the price you're willing to pay. Valve's reassurance reduces but does not eliminate my personal DRM discount. By contrast but also comparison with Valve/Steam, the attitude of EA and many other publishers and platforms instantly pegs my personal DRM discount at 100%.

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by nemof on Friday March 08, 2013 @12:08PM (#5344476)
Not just with the best of intentions.

Valve have always treated their customers pretty well. They're not viewed like EA or Activision for a good reason, they've garnered a great deal of good will by behaving in an exemplary way. You're envisioning a hypothetical of the all the worst possible outcomes. At the moment we have no reason to imagine anything other than them keeping their word. I do agree that it's not ideal having no solution we can implement ourselves.

My criteria for price is actually mainly dependent on how many hours of enjoyment I get out of something. I'm not willing to spend the cost of a triple A game for 10-12 hours gameplay. If it's got something upwards of 40+ hours then I'm quite happy to spend money on it.

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by sirclueless on Saturday March 09, 2013 @01:58PM (#5349226)
One thing that could be a big factor in their favor that such a claim could be credible, is that Valve is privately owned. While that doesn't necessarily mean that greed won't rule the day, but it does mean that if the company leadership prioritizes something besides fiscal performance as it goes through its death throes, it won't be considered criminal negligence.
Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by whatshisface on Friday March 08, 2013 @11:32AM (#5344256)
Yeah, I've always wondered about that...

I have a small number of games in my library, maybe 12, and I only have 3 of them installed on this computer. If they went out of business, it would be physically impossible for them to send me the files.

Yes, I know they could have some sort of "graceful shutdown period", but what if I don't hear about it?

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by jlgreco on Friday March 08, 2013 @11:50AM (#5344384)
Aside from the other issues listed here by others, would they even legally be allowed to do that for the majority of the games they sell? Most of those games are not their games, but rather the games of other companies that publish with Steam.
Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by DanBC on Friday March 08, 2013 @10:25AM (#5343884)
> Selling a game with online features should not have to be a commitment to provide those features forever,

Selling a game that requires online features to work is very different to eventually shutting off the servers of a game that has some online features.

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by maxerickson on Friday March 08, 2013 @10:40AM (#5343969)
I don't think I implied otherwise.

Stating it a little bit differently, if it is ok to put "Some features require an internet connection and are only promised to be supported until Jan, 2015" on a box, then I think it is ok to put "Game requires an internet connection and will be supported until at least Jan, 2015".

A requirement for accurate labeling is reasonably simple, especially in comparison to hairsplitting over whether it is appropriate or allowable to depend on the internet for a particular feature.

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by bobsy on Friday March 08, 2013 @11:58AM (#5344425)
This isn't clearly on boxes though.

Look at Amazon: http://www.amazon.co.uk/Electronic-Arts-Simcity-PC-DVD/dp/B0...

It doesn't say anywhere that you must have an internet connection to play at all. Amazon add this text. "Some customers have reported issues when trying to connect to the SimCity servers." Again this gives little indication it will leave you with a broken game.

The labeling you suggest wouldn't get past advertising watch dogs as it would be confusing. Both are too similar.

"Some features require an internet connection and are only promised to be supported until Jan, 2015"

"Game requires an internet connection and will be supported until at least Jan, 2015"

I didn't know Diablo 3, Sim City or Starcraft 2 required an Internet connection to play single player until people were complaining about it.

Also, after the collapse of THQ how valid would such promises be? If EA failed next month and no one purchased the Sim City franchise the game wouldn't work..

Digital or not you assume that in purchasing a game the game will work for the foreseeable future. It isn't like an MMO where you pay for a month's access. You are paying for a license to play the game. You accept that multiplayer servers will eventually be turned off. Generally you don't expect largely single player experiences to stop working.

A lot of PC gamers specifically expect games to always work. Starcraft:Brood War is like 15 years old and I have installed and working on my Windows 7 PC. I gave Grim Fandango a spin a little while ago. Remember that game? Fantastic.

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by maxerickson on Friday March 08, 2013 @12:12PM (#5344493)
I understand that it isn't on boxes.

My point is that 'works forever' isn't a battle you are going to win, so aim low and succeed.

My wording doesn't have to be what ends up on boxes. The point is that it should be possible to clearly communicate connection requirements to the purchaser. Do that and they have all the information they need to make (or not make!) the purchase. I'm not terribly sympathetic to the 'the consumer is a moron so you can't try to inform him' line of reasoning.

The fact that companies go out of business isn't that big a deal, if you are concerned EA is going bankrupt, don't believe their promise to provide servers for 18 months and spend your dollars elsewhere.

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by eropple on Saturday March 09, 2013 @02:28AM (#5347724)
> Selling a game with online features should not have to be a commitment to provide those features forever, so finding decent middle ground is the only solution.

I bought the damned thing. I didn't buy it "for X years".

The only "middle ground" that works is that if you take down the servers, you must provide the ability for end users to run their own. But that'll never happen, because then they can't sell you New SimCity as easily.

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by saraid216 on Saturday March 09, 2013 @06:20AM (#5348089)
> I bought the damned thing. I didn't buy it "for X years".

Misunderstanding what you bought doesn't actually entitle you to anything more than what you bought. No one promised you that your game would last forever. It was clearly advertised as reliant on an online connection to their servers, and the overwhelming majority of plaintiffs here demonstrate an understanding that such a connection connotes an eventual cessation of service.

If you want to have full ownership over the capability of running the game, get it in writing before you pay.

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by eropple on Saturday March 09, 2013 @01:44PM (#5349187)
And your rationale is why we have consumer protection laws: because that behavior is bullshit and cannot be accepted by a reasonable society. It cannot be acceptable to sell one game for $60 that works in perpetuity and one for $60 that gets the plug pulled after two or three years.

Shame that those consumer protection laws are toothless.

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by maxerickson on Saturday March 09, 2013 @02:38PM (#5349348)
Games are fruit, not apples.

That is, if a company wants to sell bananas, they shouldn't have to meet your expectations surrounding apples.

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by eropple on Saturday March 09, 2013 @05:40PM (#5349878)
Except they're not even selling bananas. They're selling you maybe-bananas. You don't know what you're buying, you don't know the term of the product's lifetime, and they won't tell you.

Markets don't work without fair access to information. If a company commits, with a posted bond, to support the game through date X--sure, you're right. But they're not. They are selling the proverbial cat in a bag. That is anti-consumer, and consumers--people--are more important than the companies that exist to serve them.

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by maxerickson on Saturday March 09, 2013 @07:30PM (#5350145)
If you look up a few levels of the comment tree, you will see that I say people should be focusing on requiring accurate labeling.

The company longevity thing is problematic, but I have trouble getting worked up about it for $50 luxury purchases.

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by eropple on Sunday March 10, 2013 @03:40AM (#5351084)
I make games. I consider them important enough to get worked up over. =)
Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by saraid216 on Sunday March 10, 2013 @02:28PM (#5352868)
I wasn't sure whether to respond to this comment or the ones further up the tree...

Long story short, I agree. maxerickson's idea of labeling is a good one, since the point isn't really the mechanism so much as the principle of stipulating the contents of the contract in detail. If the game industry decided to standardize on only promising a year of service, I suspect that would be fine: it's explicit, it's well-known, and the game-maker will almost certainly run longer than that if their product is remotely successful.

Re:EA refuses to refund user for SimCity, threatens account ban by maxerickson on Saturday March 09, 2013 @07:36AM (#5348223)
This quickly turns into EA not being allowed to sell other people a $5 game because you only want the $10 version.

Which is the point of accurate labeling, it creates fewer restrictions for everybody.

(I do think fit for purpose is a good test, but it can't just apply to any imagined purpose that any person can come up with)