Goggle doesn't need your optimisation "help". Just create compelling content. That means you need to be open, informative, interesting and innovative.
Sadly, that's still not entirely the case.
It's more true than it used to be that content can carry a site on its own. But I still see dozens of quality websites and writers getting far less readers than they should, purely because they don't understand the basics of formatting pages for search engines.
A little bit of optimisation FOR search engines on your own pages can do wonders for your traffic, readers and viability as a business.
(No, I don't represent an SEO agency.)
"Many SEOs and other agencies and consultants provide useful services for website owners"
http://support.google.com/webmasters/bin/answer.py?hl=en&...
As much as a misnomer as cat food. Try to think of it as Search Engine _Placement_ optimisation.
Googles heuristic would work be much more effective if people didn't screw with it.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BS75vhGO-kk
Consider reevaluating your views.
The ethical disconnect is painful.
The best we can hope for is gaming behaviors to roughly align with desirable search results.
That's oversimplifying the service and value Google offers. This is the typical passive-aggressive SEO stance. Deriding Google for the service it offers, but at the same time craving it's attention. Because you know, Google gives you a steady stream of customers.
People use Google because it helps get them to the websites that offer the content that people are looking for. It's (relatively) good at matching seekers with the information they seek. That's what brings people back to Google over and over.
And so, the page they deliver has value to people.
Yes, they scrape content from everyone else. Including themselves (e.g. a search for "Google webmaster guidelines" returns support.google.com).
They also add to that their special ingredients - algorithms that dissect pages, classifying, inferring meaning, deriving synonyms, inferring intent. Weighing, scoring, evaluating every page out there. So when a customer comes a-querying, it uses those calculated metrics to decide which 10 pages get to be mentioned on a search results page, and what snippet/extract of those 10 pages to show.
The value Google adds is the selection of which pages to link to based on the query and what it knows/infers about the pages themselves. That is no trivial thing.
I'm not saying they don't add value, I'm saying that their entire business model is built on the back of the world's content.
I'm not sure why HN hates SEO so much, since Google doesn't...they hate SPAM, not SEO.