News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by michaelochurch on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @10:32AM (#5286126)
The gap between CS majors and software jobs is misleading. You don't need a CS degree to become a decent programmer.

Still, if there's such a shortage of good programmers (and I agree that there probably is) then why aren't we playing this to our advantage? A senior engineer can't afford a house in the Bay Area or New York, and our status is low-- we still work for managers; we're a defeated tribe in this way. Most of us don't have the autonomy to choose our tools or decide whether to use or replace old legacy code. Shouldn't our top priority, as a tribe, be to change this?

We should make programmer autonomy our major issue. http://michaelochurch.wordpress.com/2012/11/25/programmer-au... This will benefit us and the economy as a whole.

Then, after we've had this victory, we can work on increasing the total number of programmers.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by lifeisstillgood on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @01:13PM (#5287277)
Fred George is interesting on this - see Programmer Anarchy. My view (and yes I am working up a blog post) is

1. Coding is the equivalent of literacy after 1451 (Gutenberg).

2. in say, one generation, any company not having literate people at all levels of the organisation, and not having then changed how they work at a fundamental level to take advantage of these programmers/business people will be at as severe a compettive dis-advantage; similar to trading company in 1600 where no-one at the top could read or write.

3. If you think that's a bit of a stretch, or say "yeah but there were loads of illiterate people on trading ships" - but the people at the top, the captains, the investors, could all read and write. So they could exchange information globally and accurately. Share a model of the market effectively.

4. So, the successful companies in a generation will have coding in their DNA. And to get there from today, companies will benefit most from hiring great coders and teaching them how to be CEOs, how to be Salespeople, how to be accountants. And letting them run the company as CEOs, and accountants do now. Let me repeat - hire people who can code and teach them to be CEOs. They will find ways to run the company with coding at its core.

5. In short programmer anarchy / autonomy is the right way forward. The advantages of running a company through code is so great (comparable to running a company through writing) that all other skills come second. They are necessary but software eats them. For a generation only.

Takebacks: I am guessing that the econmoic advantages of code-literate population is a diminishing return compared to a text-literatate population. say 50%? Thats still phenonemonal.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by frozenport on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @02:17PM (#5287753)
I humbly disagree.

Lets focus on one point.

Literacy facilitated efficient information exchange.

Likewise programming facilitated efficient information exchange.

But, not everybody needed to program the Internet for this advantage.

I think you are confusing a personal advantage and societal advantage. Certainly, we need programers but I am uncertain if everybody needs to be a programmer.

I work a full-time software job, and I can say that the software is the easiest part. I do big data HPC, C, C++, learning models and physics simulation. I need people to come up with models, Ontology and even vision. I think at the Hacker News Ivory Tower of software-for-software or software-for-programers, we often underestimates the value of domain specific knowledge.

Teaching kids is certainly rewarding and a CS degree is a bright future, but I am more worried about the lack of US PhD's then the lack of user facing javascript.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by NickPollard on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @05:23PM (#5289083)
He's not saying everyone needs to be a programmer, but everyone needs to be able to program.

The number of times in all my jobs where I've seen people working on problems that could be done orders of magnitude faster with a bit of coding knowledge, is beyond count.

Reformat that document? How about a Regex? Analyse this data? Automatic graph generation and statistical methods. Keep records updated? Database with automated queries. Always building weekly reports? Template substitution and HTML generation.

There are so many jobs, that would not be considered anything to do with programming, that can be made hugely more efficient with a bit of coding knowledge.

As this video says, for most of this you don't even need to know algorithms or data structures or the 'important' stuff for being a programmer.

You just need to understand 'SELECT date FROM records WHERE quantity > 10'.

Or 'println("Report Week Ending " + date.GetToday()))'

Or 's/\[[A-Z]*\]/(&)/'

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by dagingaa on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @05:45PM (#5289197)
In many cases the people in these positions don't even need to be able to program, they need to be able to see the solutions that programming can give them. I think this is the number one issue right now. Not everybody needs to be a programmer, but everyone needs to be educated about some of the ways programming can help you.

With that said, we mostly come up with these ideas because we are able to program, so yeah.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by argonaut on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @11:13PM (#5290512)
Uh no. He's saying everyone needs to be a programmer.

> companies will benefit most from hiring great coders and teaching them how to be CEOs

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by DeepDuh on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @01:25AM (#5290991)
The problem is that today 'being able to read/write code' and 'being a programmer' is as good as synonym. It shouldn't be, that's the issue. We won't call CEOs with programming skills 'programmer's just as we don't call them 'readers' today.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by ajasmin on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @09:04PM (#5290048)
Domain specific languages have a role to play there. You already mentioned Regex and SQL but things like R, MathLab or even Excel can be invaluable tools in some professions.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by Swizec on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @03:23PM (#5288303)
The problem is people don't even realise what types of problems can easily be solved by computers. It doesn't even cross their mind that something they do every day could be automated or made better.

That's why everyone needs to learn how to code (a bit). So they can go "Ah, I think software might improve this thingy here; let's call in an expert and ask"

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by Dove on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @03:30PM (#5288367)
Programming enables automation of your domain-specific knowledge. Animators who could program gave us CG movies. Musicians who could program gave us software music composition tools. Would garbage collectors who could program give us robots to do parts of their jobs? Or apps to communicate real-time problems? Or public education websites? I think it very likely.

Any field -- any field at all! -- that can benefit from information organization and retrieval, automation, scripting, robotics, internal wikis, private smartphone apps, information dissemination, etc., will benefit from people who have deep domain knowledge ALSO being programmers.

And I think that's just about all of them.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by derefr on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @08:35PM (#5289924)
This recent article is basically the same concept: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5275313

> Despite these challenges, we republished the updated graphic without too much delay. But I was left thinking how much easier it could have been had I simply recorded the process the first time as a makefile. I could have simply typed make in the terminal and be done!

In other words, the key "transferrable skill" of programming, is being able to describe a process in enough exacting detail, that nobody ever needs to "reconstruct" it again. The computers-being-able-to-execute-the-process thing is just a nice side-effect.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by lifeisstillgood on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @05:15PM (#5289031)
Absolutely !
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by lifeisstillgood on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @02:28PM (#5287815)
It's not about user facing JavaScript apps. It's about adding another tool to the mental toolbox.

Calculus, statistics, physics simulations - all of these will be of use in a persons career, yes, but like you I think that is not important. What is utterly important is that the most expressive and flexible tool in the mental toolbox for two hundred years is put in the hands of as many human beings as possible.

I want the next Einstein to be literate, able to use Lisp on her OLPC device and change the understanding of the universe from her school hut in Rwanda, circa 2039.

We live in a world of wonders, invented by the brightest few thousand humans who ever lived. Let's give ourselves the best chance of the next thousand adding their full worth too.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by hpvic03 on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @03:09PM (#5288195)
It sounds like you think all scientists should learn how to code.

I am certain that there are many people who rarely use calculus and physics simulations in their work, and who would never need to program even if they knew how.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by lifeisstillgood on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @05:18PM (#5289045)
I don't think I have ever used my Secondary School chemistry, or my knowledge of the biology of frogs.

But that does not mean learning those was useless - either to make me a more rounded person, or to pass me through a filter so that those who do want to contribute to society through chemistry actually discover their interests

School is a process for finding and educating those who will invent the next 100 years, and persuading the rest of us that we should support them.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by sodafountan on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @05:27PM (#5289106)
I think that what humanity gained in literacy when Gutenburg invented the printing press is akin to what humanity can gain in problem solving skills upon the invention of the microprocessor. An everyday problem solver is a more peaceful, more level headed, and more thoughtful person than someone who is not. Just like an everyday reader is someone who is more informed than someone who is illiterate.

The best way to teach problem solving skills is through computer science without a doubt. A smarter population will lead to more peace and prosperity for the human race.

Do I think that computer science can lead to a more peaceful and thoughtful society? Absolutely; therefore I think that it's crucial to teach it.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by dinkumthinkum on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @11:08PM (#5290483)
I don't think the Gutenberg thing applies at all. I think we're getting carried away. You could make a argument about digital information and the Web as a way to disseminate information as a Gutenberg style invention but I don't think programming is.

I don't think programming and learning to code is the "everyday problem solver," "more peaceful" person. I think what you're talking about is the phenomena that intellectuals tend to be more circumspect, perhaps less violent whatever. We don't need programming for that. We have a whole history of knowledge and art in philosophy, literature, other sciences, logic, mathematics etc. I fail to see how programming is special in that sense?

The average person, say in the US, may be more likely to be able to read than in the past but they do not tend to be less "ignorant" of many societal issues, cultures, etc (because you bring up peace and harmony) even thought we have educational tools long standing to solve that problem, much better than programming.

Honestly, I dispute this outright. I've been programming a long time, met many programmers and computer scientists; it does not seem like the ability to produce CRUD correlates in any real sense to a person being less likely to join the Tea Party.

You're viewing programming as this great society benefiting solution to social ills or something that makes you a better person; large swaths of people would just view it as an engineering and say "fine, sure, programming skills make it easier for you to get a job, great" but not anything that substantially creates peace in the world -- that's too much I think.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by frozenport on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @09:44AM (#5292559)
I think this is a good point and I am surprised by the downvotes your post received.

I wanted to add that Internet culture has facilitated many people to realize their most twisted fantasized this perhaps not good. Consider the desensitizing effects of r/spacedicks.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by dmoney on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @08:56PM (#5290015)
> A smarter population will lead to more peace and prosperity for the human race.

Or language wars fought with real weapons.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by jamesjporter on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @05:11PM (#5289003)
lack of US PhDs? We already produce way more PhDs than the economy can absorb; if anything we should either produce less PhDs or create a better job market for them.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by michaelochurch on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @06:50PM (#5289499)
We already produce way more PhDs than the economy can absorb; if anything we should either produce less PhDs or create a better job market for them.

When I was a kid and first learned about the Roman Empire and its fall, and of all the other historical empires that collapsed, one of the things that I wondered was how these people could be so "stupid". Of course, I didn't understand the day-to-day nuances involved. I saw these as personalized historic entities rather than complex patterns of behavior. I just couldn't grasp why such things would "allow" themselves to fall apart.

When I look at what has happened to the U.S. job market for scientists, researchers and academics and place that in the context of what we were as a society and what we've become... I get it. I now know what it is and what it looks like when a complex society "chooses" decline.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by cwzwarich on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @07:16PM (#5289606)
Historically speaking, wasn't the temporary boost in demand for PhDs after WW2 the abnormality?
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by michaelochurch on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @10:49AM (#5292921)
Personally, I dislike the argument that recent progress is an "abnormality". A large middle class (post-1925) is an "anomaly". Slavery being illegal is, historically speaking, extremely unusual.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by throwaway1979 on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @03:18PM (#5294611)
Right on. I was at the Smithsonian Natural History museum in DC a few days ago. They had an exhibit on pollution in the world's oceans. I was shocked at the reasons they gave to reduce pollution. To paraphrase: if we don't stop polluting, we will hurt the local economy, etc. My jaw dropped. That's the reason why we aren't supposed to destroy the oceans???

As a scientist, it is totally sad to see the state of research, and the standing scientists have in society. I don't understand why sane people would choose to get themselves into such career paths.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by frozenport on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @09:33PM (#5290154)
The job market certainly sucks, but it maybe because a large number have uncompromising dreams of working in academia. In EE a PhD will land you a job at a company of your choice.

As does the U.S. in general, the NavLabs suffer from an increasingly severe shortage of trained replacement civilian personnel in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (= STEM topics). The Navy’s problem is more severe than the nation’s because only U.S. citizens can work at NavLabs, and a great many U.S. STEM graduates are foreign nationals.

[1] The following is a report http://www.dtic.mil/dtic/tr/fulltext/u2/a503549.pdf.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by jamesjporter on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @12:17PM (#5293469)
This is true for EE, but that's an engineering degree. Sciences PhDs have a much harder time, even in industry (e.g. biotech is languishing).
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by acchow on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @02:35PM (#5287871)
Communication has evolved over time from hand/body gestures and noises to spoken language to reading/writing. The latter (literacy) is now a major form of communication and required in almost any job.

Coding is not a form of communication.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by civilian on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @02:11PM (#5287697)
let me know when that blog post is finished!
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by lifeisstillgood on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @02:38PM (#5287899)
I'll put up a mailchimp account :-)
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by ditonal on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @01:56PM (#5287593)
Can you explain to me what actual evidence there is that there's a shortage of good programmers? Good programmers still make less money than a good doctor or lawyer, indicating that those are even shorter in supply. Surely addressing that shortage would be a higher priority? Lots of people could use more legal services if the price was lower, and yet if someone wanted to hire a Harvard lawyer for $60k a year, we wouldn't even seriously consider it, but when someone wants an MIT programmer for $60k a year we consider it a job opening and thus a 'shortage.' Thus I find the 'job openings' a ridiculous metric of supply and demand, and I would use the metric people have always used - the market price. Using this more reasonable metric, there are careers with much more severe shortages of talent. As usual, nobody is surprised that those heavily invested in hiring programmers want a larger supply to drive down market wages.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by chrisaycock on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @02:13PM (#5287712)
My identical-twin brother is a doctor, and I make far more than he does. The reason is that I don't call myself a programmer [1]. Instead, I've built-up enormous amounts of domain knowledge [2] in addition to my software engineering skills.

As for the career prospects of anyone fresh out of law school, the legal profession suffered a massive meltdown in 2008 and hasn't recovered.

[1] http://www.kalzumeus.com/2011/10/28/dont-call-yourself-a-pro...

[2] http://jacquesmattheij.com/domain-knowledge-or-a-lack-thereo...

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by ditonal on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @02:16PM (#5287747)
Your two data points don't mean much because we're talking about macro trends and whether a 'shortage' actually exists. Specifically I'm asking someone to justify the assertion that there is a shortage of good programmers with some numbers, and I pointed out that job openings is essentially just market 'bids' and therefore not a very good metric since all markets have lots of 'bids' at well below market price. For some reason in the world of programming we take those low bids more seriously than in other fields which is inconsistent. The best metric that I know of, market price, does not indicate a shortage relative to legal and medical work, since both doctors and lawyers both have higher averages, and yet you rarely hear about shortages in those fields and how we need to more aggressively train more. So your point about how you individually make a lot of money is a bit of non-sequitur.

As for legal work, the median starting salary for the top 14 schools (remember, there is a shortage of 'good' programmers) is still 160K+. How many good programmers start there? Sure lower-grade lawyers don't make much, but neither do lower-grade programmers. Facebook and Microsoft both have reasonably high hiring standards and are complaining about a shortage of people over their threshold. As for 'the rest of us', the average lawyer salary is higher than the average software engineer salary. There are a lot of low paid software engineers too, it's absurd to compare only the highest paid software engineers to all lawyers which it seems you tried to do.

The fact that you can see the average lawyer salary being higher than the average software engineer salary, and still claim there a meltdown in the former industry while the second is struggling for people, just shows how deeply ingrained our cultural perspective of what job markets and compensation for a given career 'should be', and how it skews our perspective away from the simple econ 101 supply and demand curves that tell the real story. Markets are a lot more honest than PR releases from billionare tech executives.

But on a side note I did like your blog post, I just think it's irrelevant to this conversation.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by jfb on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @10:08PM (#5290279)
It's important to keep in mind the role of the professional guilds in controlling supply for lawyers and particularly for doctors.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by sskates on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @06:39PM (#5289443)
Speaking as one, MIT programmers go for a lot more than 60k.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by ditonal on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @12:34AM (#5290873)
That's why it's a job 'opening'. My point was that it doesn't get filled but people classify it as an opening, but if someone wanted a Harvard lawyer for $60k it wouldn't even get listed.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by sskates on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @03:31AM (#5291307)
Do you have an example of a job opening where they're offering 60k for a MIT programmer? I can give you a bunch where they offer substantially more (all $100k+ with just an undergrad degree):

https://www.google.com/about/jobs/search/#t=sq&q=j&j...

http://careers.microsoft.com/careers/en/us/grad-software-job...

https://www.dropbox.com/jobs

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by ditonal on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @10:52AM (#5292942)
You are totally missing my point. Yes, I realize MIT programmers make more and you need to pay them well to hire them. However, if you look at average software engineering salaries, you will realize most people do not pay as well as prestigious tech companies. Yet their job openings are used to indicate a shortage. Shortages are just low bids in a market, the fact that lots of people want to buy gold at $1 an ounce does not mean there is a shortage of gold. It's a bad metric if you understand anything about economics, and yet I've yet to see another metric used to argue for a 'shortage'.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by sskates on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @08:07PM (#5296256)
I'm just asking for a few examples. Do you have any where they advertise an open job but the pay is low?
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by ditonal on Friday March 01, 2013 @02:39PM (#5306468)
With exceptions, salaries aren't advertised in job openings. However you can look at average software engineering salaries to learn that most salaries are south of 100k, and it seems unlikely that on average higher salaries are getting turned down for much lower ones. Furthermore, specific examples are unnecessary. I originally asked for metric that proved there was a developer shortage, and explained why job openings are a bad indication of one. There have been none other proposed to my knowledge, so you're really just nitpicking details irrelevant to my original point.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by jseliger on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @07:31PM (#5289669)
>A senior engineer can't afford a house in the Bay Area or New York

This is an important and under-emphasized point, which is elaborated here: http://www.slate.com/articles/business/moneybox/2012/05/face... . One problem with programming salaries is that so many programming jobs and opportunities are concentrated in areas with very expensive housing, such that salaries themselves have to go up to compensate.

Before 1976, this wasn't as big a problem as it is now: most places that experienced rapid growth could build housing stock in response to that growth. In 1976, however, the Supreme Court upheld a 9th District decision allowing the City of Petaluma to impose severe restrictions on construction (see 522 F.2d 897 if you're the sort of person who likes reading court decisions).

After that, more and more cities made construction harder and harder; now areas that have a geographic advantage in some industry often can't build sufficient housing to keep up with demand because of legal barriers.

But relatively few people connect these issues.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by nazgulnarsil on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @01:10AM (#5290963)
The legal framework is the hidden-in-plain-sight gearing of civilization. Nobody pays attention because it is boring and slow.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by hamburglar on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @07:27PM (#5289652)
> "our status is low-- we still work for managers; we're a defeated tribe in this way"

As a fairly senior developer, I just can't fathom this attitude. Working for a manager means you're low status or defeated? I want to work for a manager. Reward me and give me autonomy and respect due a valuable developer, sure, but please do all that management shit for me. In my mind (and at every single company I've ever worked at), the guys who actually build stuff are high status.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by nickmain on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @11:42AM (#5286650)
Maybe we should be talking less about forming "tribes" and more about how to make programming accessible to anyone who needs to solve real problems using computers.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by aristus on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @12:32PM (#5287009)
Bingo. Reading and writing used to be a separate profession as well.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by dreamdu5t on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @01:30PM (#5287389)
It is accessible to anyone, for free. I learned everything I use in my career for free on the Internet.

Most people have better things to do than programming, and don't want to invest the time to learn just because a news article said they should.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by duaneb on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @02:32PM (#5287841)
> Most people have better things to do than programming,

Most people have no idea what programming is and can't make that judgement for themselves—coding should be taught in high school, not because everyone will code but because people need to know what kind of opportunities exist. Let's be honest, a lot of high school classes were nearly useless in terms of how much you used what you learned, but they were useful because you learned you didn't want to become a chemist (or whatever).

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by kevin_rubyhouse on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @09:23PM (#5290122)
Coding IS taught is in high school, but is not mandatory. You know this of course, but it's important to note that there is no shortage of opportunities for students to take computer science courses. Some districts will even send students to a nearby school if enough students want to do it but the school doesn't offer it. High school computer science classes were useful, but still at such a slow pace for people that were interested enough to learn at all outside of class. Anybody that was obsessed with programming outside of class probably wouldn't take the class or just snooze through it.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by crynix on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @09:43PM (#5290193)
Yes, programming is taught inside of _some_ high schools. A shockingly low amount of high schools actually teach it though. Neither my high school nor other nearby high schools have any sort of computer science curriculum.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by kevin_rubyhouse on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @09:49PM (#5290212)
These schools would offer the course if enough of the students are interested. There is no lack of information around us (internet, libraries, sit down at a book store) to learn programming. The issue is the perception of programming in high school - the stigma around it. This might be perpetuated by some of the more eccentric programmers, and these programmers are very good and tend to grow into strong programmers! But they can also repel people that might have been interested, but it conflicts with social status that is so important in high school to the majority of people.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by duaneb on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @12:08PM (#5293397)
No, this is just false. My high school was run by incompetent people, the result being Photoshop classes being offered to people wanting to program. This is further complicated by people who can't afford their own computers or internet and are explicitly disallowed from programming at the library.

You have a very optimistic view of high schools.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by kevin_rubyhouse on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @10:58PM (#5296890)
That seems like a really bad scenario, but there are computer science classes and AP/AB CS classes that need to follow a certain curriculum for the Computer Science AP Test by the College Board. I graduated from high school only a year and a half ago in Washington, so I would agree that my perception of schools is skewed towards wealthier districts.

You don't agree that any student should be allowed to program on computers in the library? It seems like a security issue, whereas in a classroom students would be supervised by a computer science instructor. I'm not saying students need to be hand held, but schools really just don't know enough about programming to open it up. Web development, Flash, and Photoshop could be installed on library computers - they were on a few where I went. Otherwise I totally understand why school district IT would not allow it or fight against it.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by jonknee on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @11:32AM (#5286568)
> Still, if there's such a shortage of good programmers (and I agree that there probably is) then why aren't we playing this to our advantage? A senior engineer can't afford a house in the Bay Area or New York, and our status is low-- we still work for managers; we're a defeated tribe in this way. Most of us don't have the autonomy to choose our tools or decide whether to use or replace old legacy code. Shouldn't our top priority, as a tribe, be to change this?

Working for someone else will almost always end up like that. Programming is interesting in that you don't have to work for someone else, you can scratch your own itch. You just need to make something that is useful.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by michaelochurch on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @11:42AM (#5286649)
I think you're off the mark, because you're always "working for someone else". Details change, but ultimately there's no difference between "mak[ing] something that is useful" and working for others. Sometimes the terms are great, and sometimes they're awful.

The implicit assumption is that "working for an established organization" must imply "working with miserably low levels of autonomy". I'm not sure that I agree.

If we negotiate better terms, we get more autonomy and more compensation. This will also give more people the financial means to start their own companies and get that level of autonomy.

The problem is that the exchange rate between capital/establishment and talent/effort is very unfavorable in comparison to what it could be.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by huherto on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @11:41AM (#5293229)
| The implicit assumption is that "working for an established organization" must imply "working with miserably low levels of autonomy". I'm not sure that I agree.

And it is not only about autonomy. It sucks to work for somebody stupid, in general somebody that doesn't understand the nature of software development, probability, statistics, etc.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by droidist2 on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @12:25PM (#5286963)
Do you mean we should unionize?
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by lifeisstillgood on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @02:38PM (#5287892)
Lawyers don't unionise - they have professional ethics bodies.

The difference is that when the law is code, and code law, we shall have a professional ethics body too. When programmers can do real damage and affect real lives they naturally gravitate to professional considered advice

Look at JPL or NASA, or a medical devices company.

The level of testing and reliability there is astounding - but so is the cost. And one day the engineers will find a way of capturing all that cost.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by michaelochurch on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @04:18PM (#5288708)
The problem with unionization is that it works well when the work is a commodity, and software engineering isn't. The 10x (and 100x, and -25x) programmer phenomenon is real, but individual performance is nearly impossible to measure on a quarterly basis.

We need some traits of old-style professionalism: autonomy and the right of self-investment. A profession is a set of ethical rights and obligations that supersede managerial authority. That's what we need. http://michaelochurch.wordpress.com/2012/11/18/programmers-d...

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by rdouble on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @04:19PM (#5288715)
Unionization works reasonably well for the entertainment industry.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by walshemj on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @06:43AM (#5291848)
One one of the reasons for the lack of push back from the unions over the modernization of the UK's telco infrastructure was that the people building system X etc where Union members.

and the BMA and AMA do quite well for there members.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by zwegner on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @12:43PM (#5287075)
> The gap between CS majors and software jobs is misleading. You don't need a CS degree to become a decent programmer.

Conversely, you don't need to be a decent programmer to get a CS degree. It's a shame that in the age of the internet and self-directed learning, degrees are so heavily weighted in the job market.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by base698 on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @01:35PM (#5287432)
And yet all of the glorious self learners can't describe when to use a hashmap, what a hash is, or even the difference between a list and set...

I'm not talking even knowing the algorithms, I mean a guy that writes list.contains(condition) in a loop and it brings the server to a halt because every call to contains runs through the entire list, when a hashset.contains(condition) would run in milliseconds.

* no I did not go to a top tier school and only have a CS Minor, but I did read the books to make sure I didn't have gaps in my knowledge. It's just rare in my experience to find people that know the basics who also claim they were self-taught. People get all pissed off if you ask them what a HashMap is, which should be the most basic thing in programming.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by zwegner on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @01:49PM (#5287544)
Yawn. I would say the same about the glorious PhD professors that attempted to teach me. Even the best professors, who were actually pretty knowledgeable, would never really code at all, pushing that off to the grad students.

Some people just don't fit into the way academia works, and making silly judgments like yours about them does nothing but entrench the status quo.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by base698 on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @02:15PM (#5287726)
I agree, but you still have to read the book. Coding can not be learned by copy and pasting other people's code. All I was trying to say is for every 20 people that say they are self-taught only one of them can write a feature from scratch from a blank slate and explain the trade offs of why they used a hashset vs a list. The other 19 may be able to get something working by copy and pasting another section and spending a week shoehorning it, but the competent person would bang out in a day without looking anywhere else.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by randomdata on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @10:46AM (#5292903)
> Coding can not be learned by copy and pasting other people's code.

Absolutely it can. I would even argue that is the best way to intro into programming, and even learning in general. You, of course, cannot stop after you have pasted it in. You have to think about why the author made the choices he made, but in doing that you will quickly build an intuition to be able to apply similar choices to entirely new problems. With a little experience, you won't even need to draw on other's code anymore.

The distinction you really seem to be making here is that self-taught programmers are able to enter the job market on day one, without that experience. While graduates have at least four years of experience under their belt before they are reasonably able to enter the job market. Of course the people with more experience are going to perform better. As more time passes, the skills between the groups will start to average out (with amazing and not-so-amazing people found in both groups).

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by zwegner on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @02:42PM (#5287932)
Well, consider me in the 5% then. And though you're probably right about the 1-in-20, I don't think I'd put the proportion much higher for CS grads.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by michaelochurch on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @06:42PM (#5289457)
There are two diverging definitions of what it means to be a programmer.

There's one set of them who can write new programs, build systems, and learn technologies they aren't familiar with, but put them on a team of 30 people for a typical enterprise project, chugging along at 10 lines per day of code, and they'll be bored out of their minds.

There's another set that can't function outside of an IDE or design new systems, have no idea how anything actually works, but they can slog through corporate stuff and follow orders well enough to stay employed.

Both are called "programmers" but they're practically different jobs. It's easy for us in the first set to look down on the second, but maybe we should just admit that they're different task categories altogether.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by spamizbad on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @02:17PM (#5287754)
Do you really need a CS degree to make that kind of judgement? Even before I was college-aged I knew (and so did several of my programming friends) about hash tables and how much faster they were than just iterating through something and checking. I didn't know Big-O but I did have a loose understanding that told me iterating through EVERYTHING is slow, and that there are smarter ways to look up values.

This sounds like a case of a programmer using the wrong datatype, realizing it, and then being too lazy to fix it.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by jes5199 on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @03:59PM (#5288578)
I've interviewed plenty of people with a degree or even a master's in CS that, while they can recite the definition of a hashmap, can't actually use one in a program.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by dreamdu5t on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @01:43PM (#5287486)
Sounds like someone from Stanford.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by dinkumthinkum on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @11:20PM (#5290554)
One thing about people that make this argument that I don't understand is do you all know about libraries? You know they've been around for a long time. I'll grant you search engines make some parts marginally easier but to get the fundamental knowledge, you don't have to have that. So why is the Internet the great panacea for this ... Or is it that autodidactism is not really that common but it's much easier to call casually watching a YouTube building a blog engine as learning?
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by zwegner on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @12:52AM (#5290926)
I guess I'm mostly going from my own experience. I have actually learned some cool stuff from library books (not in a while though), but it's mostly from the internet. The internet facilitates learning a wider variety of information without even leaving your house, allows you to download software/code, and also allows you to find communities where you can ask questions and get feedback on your progress.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by paranoiacblack on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @12:48PM (#5287125)
I basically came here to say this. Often HN is frequented by those who are go to top CS schools, but I do not think they are in the majority of most CS schools. It is really possible to escape a university with a BS and MS without knowing how to develop and learn beyond your scope of knowledge. At our university, for example, we are supposedly taught C++, but I still find myself having to explain basics like STL Containers such as Sets and Maps to 3rd and 4th year students. This is after they've run into bugs with something that would essentially take two or three lines using one of the above structures.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by TheAnimus on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @12:59PM (#5287179)
Another problem is that CS is often very, ahem, academic.

In the UK, we have the British Computer Society (BCS) who give accreditation. If your doing a CS corse without BCS accreditation everyone knows it will be a bit suspect.

However, the BCS you've probably never heard of, they aren't exactly at the forefront of anything, they are also quite stuck in the past.

In a world where dynamic or at the very least JIT'd languages are the norm, teaching Pascal or Delphi I really doubt is in the best interests of the students. Yet in 2003 that is what I was taught for first year.

So the idea that a CS graduate will be able to go in to software development immediately is a bit missleading. It's more a case of someone who has a CS degree will have demonstrated they have the aptitude to become a software dev.

tl,dr: its education, not training.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by paranoiacblack on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @01:13PM (#5287279)
I really do agree with your point, but it sounds like an excuse from academia. I can assure you that many students, when starting in their Freshman year in college, expect to be able to build the cool things they want to build or be competitive in the job after their 4 or 5 year stay is over. However, as you state, it is not necessarily the case and the problem is with the archaic nature of academia. Yet, you don't learn the things that many would define as essential knowledge in current technology.

In my university, for example, I have not once ever heard about design patterns or ever seen different coding paradigms other than OOP. What I've learned is how to solve trivial or nuanced problems in poor ways in languages not really suited for it. In job interviews, I've only passed through because of things I've personally self-taught myself due to projects I've worked on. So what's the point of an education if you have to teach yourself most things?

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by mike_herrera on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @11:37AM (#5286608)
Autonomy within an organization sounds novel for morale, but it's a major shift from today's business culture. Strategy would also be incredibly difficult to execute. Organizational leaders need to be able to align their people down a common path.

If autonomy is the end-goal, start a company or go freelance.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by michaelochurch on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @11:47AM (#5286682)
I agree that people who want outright autonomy will need to go off and start their own companies, but right now, typical employment terms for software engineers are outright bad in comparison to what they could be:

* mediocre compensation, especially considering the horrific costs of living in the places with the strongest economies.

* low autonomy, respect, and opportunity for advancement due to a scope-of-work defined to commoditize rather than grow engineering talent.

* low job security or transfer opportunity, which is the main reason for working for a large organization.

I believe that this arrangement exists because most software engineers lack the skills to negotiate for better terms.

Realistically, we need to improve organizational and independent employment at the same time. Market dynamics will corrupt one if the other is bad. Fixing one while giving up on the other is not a workable strategy.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by sp4rki on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @01:32PM (#5287403)
It's a major shift I agree... but it's a great decision if executed correctly.

Every company has a set of main goals that imply that development can't be completely autonomous, but hiring good developers is not just about code it's also about people with a vision and a sense of purpose for your product. Take the way Github works for example: at the end of the day their main goal is an accessible hosted interface to git, to make git version control easier and ubiquitous; nevertheless having that main goal does not stop their developers from creating new features (say for example a desktop client) that make the product better though it may or may not directly translate to their main goal.

If you have a company that develops software and your developers have the autonomy to work on things that they actually believe will further increase the companies value (be it an interface change, bug fixes, or the refactoring of bad code) you will most definitely have a better result than if you make people work on things that might not be their forte or that are uninteresting to them.

Now I don't mean that people should have a complete free reign of the product, as some things are too important to forgo because no one wants to do them, but giving developers the chance to work on things they actually believe in as opposed to things that might not translate to creating value in their minds can go a long way towards good morale and retention, and un-doublty a better product because of it.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by nbashaw on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @10:42AM (#5286201)
How in any way would this benefit the economy as a whole?
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by michaelochurch on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @11:34AM (#5286583)
First, the shortage of good programmers has more to do with the scarcity of high-quality work than a lack of access to knowledge. More autonomy for programmers means more high-quality work is done, which generates higher returns already but also means that programmers improve.

Second, if programmers take the decision-making roles back from smooth-talking executives, that means that smarter and more competent people will be calling the shots and society will run more efficiently.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by mike_herrera on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @11:46AM (#5286676)
> More autonomy for programmers means more high-quality work is done, which generates higher returns already but also means that programmers improve.

I disagree. The self-motivated path may be "more productive" for that one person, but it does nothing to guarantee returns or value for the larger organization.

Any employee should leave a company if they believe that their executive team is consistently shown to be inept.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by michaelochurch on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @11:55AM (#5286736)
I disagree. The self-motivated path may be "more productive" for that one person, but it does nothing to guarantee returns or value for the larger organization.

I don't think you've been in software for very long. Most software is terrible. Code and software quality are serious issues. Unmanaged complexity costs companies millions of dollars. This is a direct result of the low average competence of software engineers, which follows from their inability to get good projects on which they would improve.

If engineers had better working terms, there would be a much larger number of decent software engineers out there, and the productivity of the software industry would improve massively.

Any employee should leave a company if they believe that their executive team is consistently shown to be inept.

Bad idea. 95 percent of companies have executive teams that are either incompetent or malignant. If you have a bad immediate manager, leaving is a good idea. Leaving a company because it has worthless executives is not, because that's the norm. You'll just end up job hopping in the search for something incredibly rare. Better is to assume that most executives are harmful and minimize your career exposure to their incompetence and malice.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by mike_herrera on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @12:48PM (#5287126)
> Code and software quality are serious issues. Unmanaged complexity costs companies millions of dollars. This is a direct result of the low average competence of software engineers...

If the executives aren't aware of these facts, then it's a communication error. If they are ignoring the facts then there's little chance they would entertain a push for autonomy.

> ... You'll just end up job hopping in the search for something incredibly rare. Better is to assume that most executives are harmful and minimize your career exposure to their incompetence and malice.

Blame flows downhill, my friend. By accepting autonomy you're opening yourself to the risk of those actions. It's quite the opposite to minimization.

Conceptually, I like your ideas. Empowering smart people is rarely a bad decision. But attempting to change from within an existing behemoth, with their entrenched positions, is a far-fetched dream.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by realitygrill on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @12:58PM (#5287178)
their inability to get good projects on which they would improve.

As someone who learned to code informally and is now looking for their first real software development job, I worry about this most.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by anonymfus on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @11:14AM (#5286411)
Expensive labour provides incentives to automate it.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by throwawayG9 on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @12:20PM (#5286927)
So? It can't be done, so forget about that. Just like you can't replace the executives.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by duaneb on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @01:06PM (#5287219)
> You don't need a CS degree to become a decent programmer.

You need one to get a job, though. If not now, in twenty years when you're old in an ageist industry.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by aashaykumar92 on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @01:12PM (#5287267)
If you can learn to program on your own and become proficient in it, build great projects, and keep up to date with the languages, why does it matter what major you are?

Granted I'm 20 and still in school, but just being a CS major doesn't make someone a great programmer. I like to think that employers care about projects you've worked on as that is the best way to see a true programmers talents.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by dreamdu5t on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @01:36PM (#5287446)
Just realize that if you don't get a degree, you will always battle people who feel threatened by you. School becomes a core part of most people's identity, and they can be very protective of it in passive aggressive ways. People are told from a young age that people who didn't attend school are uneducated. At least that's been the case with me. I have a great career and no degree, and it's something I deal with constantly.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by cookiecaper on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @07:57PM (#5289779)
Yes, I'm in a similar situation and see the same reactions. People have a very irrational concept of post-secondary schooling. In many cases it's a very personal thing for them. Many've grown up thinking they'd be the first-in-family college graduate, holding that as a life goal, and listening to their parents and grandparents complain about how they never had the same opportunities as the college grads. Others have grown up with the expectation that they'll keep in the family tradition of graduates and not bring shame by failing to graduate. They've paid dozens of thousands of dollars for a degree. They've invested four years or more of their life, and all of that is epitomized in the "degree", when they're pat on the back and told they're a real grown-up now. And many seriously take this whole process to heart, and the less real value in a career, the worse this degree snobbery gets. They feel their degree has given them everything (and honestly it probably has, since their personal commercial value is often negligible). It almost becomes an idol to them. It is, therefore, considered a heresy if you speak evil of that system, and heretics are not well received.

Because of all this social programming, there are few who will admit that modern undergraduate programs, and often their graduate counterparts, are a horrendously inefficient, slow bureaucracy that provides a form of pseudo-independence for developing adults, cater classes to the lowest common denominator in order to pass more students, and occasionally have desirable network-building properties. But that's the reality.

We tie up adult identity in degrees very, very closely in our culture. Someone who never graduated college (or worse, high school) is automatically considered lower class by many. It is considered an essential of both personal and professional development in the white-collar world. Their whole lives people are told, "Go to college so you can get a good job." Is it any wonder those who've "paid their dues" and gone through these motions feel entitled to employment, even if they have no commercially viable skillset (and, this is critical to understand: most don't)? It's becoming a large social issue, but no one is willing to admit the real causes.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by pifflesnort on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @09:00PM (#5290028)
Just keep quiet about it.

I don't include 'education' on my resume, and I don't mention it to people. I can't recall the last time I was asked. Everyone seems to assume I have a degree because everyone else in the field has one.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by aashaykumar92 on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @02:02PM (#5287627)
I am not saying that a degree is not important! I'm just saying that just being a CS major does not make one a great programmer and likewise, a great programmer need not be a CS major. I believe a history major can become a great programmer...as said in the video, learning how to program just takes determination.

I was an econ major and learned html/css in a few short weeks pretty darn well. At least enough to land me a web developer position with a rising startup. I have decided to change my major to a more technical one purely because I enjoy learning both HOW to program and what I can do with it--which I'm learning is just about anything :)

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by duaneb on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @02:28PM (#5287821)
> I'm just saying that just being a CS major does not make one a great programmer and likewise, a great programmer need not be a CS major.

I'm emphatically not saying this, I'm saying that a degree is good for employment. Many places will outright refuse to hire people without at least a BA in computer science (or computer engineering, I guess? I am not aware of the related fields).

Thankfully, investors care more about the end code than degrees.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by elbear on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @04:51PM (#5288902)
Your first statement was that you need a degree to get a job. Having a degree gives you access to more jobs, but you can get a job just fine without a degree.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by duaneb on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @05:44PM (#5289189)
> but you can get a job just fine without a degree.

I have a few relatives who are well versed in computers but cannot find employment. I'm sure they would be reassured by your comment.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by cookiecaper on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @08:30PM (#5289895)
Being "well-versed in computers" is not the same thing as being a valuable programmer. If you are a valuable programmer and you still can't find a job without a degree, you're doing something wrong (what you're doing wrong varies individually, of course).

I have no degree, and have never gone more than a month without a job offer while actively looking for a position. One time it took two months to find a position with acceptable compensation, but I'd received a low-ball offer in the first month.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by doktrin on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @03:42AM (#5291336)
What exactly is a "valuable programmer"? It's about as vague a notion as being "well versed in computers".

Edit : essentially, you just re-defined bar without providing any real context.

Taken a step further (and perhaps in a different job market), someone might say "oh, well being a valuable programmer isn't the same as being a Rockstar programmer..."

The key lies in the word "valuable", which is completely situational and vague, whereas "programmer" is not.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by elbear on Thursday February 28, 2013 @04:29AM (#5297900)
I don't know exactly what a valuable programmer is, but I'll give you numbers regarding my situation, so that we talk about concrete things.

I do Python/Django work and I have 3 years of experience. I have a GitHub profile which I show when applying for jobs and my profile shows that I've made 359 contributions in the last year. I have a LinkedIn profile through which details the technologies I use and the experience I have.

Since the start of the year, I think I've been contacted by 10 recruiters with job proposals. I chose to work remotely though, with clients outside of my country.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by cookiecaper on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @03:57AM (#5291380)
A valuable programmer, in this context, is someone who seeks to get paid by a company to write code and would have a significant (as far as individual employees go) net-positive influence on that company's financials.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by doktrin on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @04:13AM (#5291420)
So returning to the statement "...you can get a job just fine without a degree..." comes with an important caveat.

Namely, that you can get a job "just fine" if you're a programmer of sufficient talent and knowledge to be able to be a net-positive influence on a company's financials.

YMMW, but that's a relatively high bar. Higher, at least, than the ease that "just fine" (IMHO) implies.

It's certainly possible, but non-trivial.

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by cookiecaper on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @04:34AM (#5291479)
I'm pretty sure the concept of employment in general is that any employee is going to supply ample net financial upside to the employer. If you have the skills to be employable as a programmer, you should not need a college degree to find work.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by randomdata on Wednesday February 27, 2013 @10:28AM (#5292782)
This is changing though. Even in just the last decade, people's attitudes towards the job/degree relationship has changed dramatically. If the trend continues, I expect in another decade or two more it probably won't even be a consideration, except perhaps where the law still requires.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by zwegner on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @01:44PM (#5287507)
But degrees are a very strong indicator to most companies that you will do what you're told, have good "work ethic", etc.

I dropped out of college because I was learning very little, at a slow pace, and mostly in areas not related to my major. I love to learn and work on interesting projects, but I've never been the type to do things just because an employer/school/society expects me to. And I've definitely had to pay for it in many ways...

Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by lifeisstillgood on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @01:17PM (#5287312)
Dont take this the wrong way, but if you are a CS major you have an opportunity to be grounded in the basics of the craft . If you are not covering SICP, algorithms and implementing them in C code at your school, demand it or just stay at home and work on those. You have a n opportunity - work it - seriously dont think flash projects will help you here - take the education time to get educated.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by dmoney on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @09:03PM (#5290045)
It may be helpful to get you past the initial Catch-22, but if you can manage to get a few years of experience (let alone 20), I doubt the degree would matter much. Lots of job postings have "Or equivalent experience" after their degree requirements.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by _alex4nder on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @01:12PM (#5287272)
Thankfully you won't need one to start a company, and hire all of your CS-degree-less old decent programming friends.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by sixothree on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @01:13PM (#5287275)
Or when you find yourself in a new city outside of you network of contacts.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by lotso on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @01:53PM (#5287573)
There are more programming/CS jobs every year than graduating CS majors.
[deleted]
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by Androsynth on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @11:26AM (#5286518)
If pilots had hangars and hangars full of free airplanes to choose from, I'm sure they would.
Re:Zuck, Bill Gates, Jack Dorsey In Short Film To Inspire Ki... by senthil_rajasek on Tuesday February 26, 2013 @12:17PM (#5286906)
What is stopping you from getting your own autonomy?

p.s - I did not read your post.