News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by ChuckMcM on Friday February 22, 2013 @05:00PM (#5267162)
This isn't particularly surprising, the policy at Google was (possibly still is) much the same. The theory is that you don't interact enough with your peers if you're not face to face.

I wonder if secret calibration scores are next.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by lukeschlather on Friday February 22, 2013 @05:27PM (#5267314)
Google also has legendarily bad customer support.

I'm really rather surprised that this is extending to customer support - that's one area that actually seems pretty cost-effective and efficient to use remote workers for. Face-to-face is always a great boon, but it just isn't an option for support reps at an Internet company. (At least not when speaking to customers, which is the important part of their job.)

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by toyg on Friday February 22, 2013 @08:14PM (#5268034)
Customer support depends on two things: people skills and tech skills. Because of the nature of the job and its pay levels, you often cannot find all-rounders, so you get the best specialists you can attract in these two fields, and try to mesh them. In an office, you can balance the two in real time; remotely, this can be more difficult.

Google has bad customer support because they simply don't want to put in the necessary manpower. Customer support scales much less than linearly, and to effectively support billions of users, you'd need hundreds of thousands reps, which would dramatically change the internal politics. So they just say "f*ck it, we'll do the minimum required by direct-revenue-generating services just to avoid getting sued, and everyone else can google their way out, for what we care."

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by jonknee on Friday February 22, 2013 @08:52PM (#5268159)
I don't think Google's support issues have anything to do with people, they have to do with a lack of people. Google treats customer / client problems as an engineering issue and tries to use algorithms just like they do with any other engineering issue. Unfortunately for Google it's a people problem and not a code problem. Google just needs more, vastly more, real people to be at the other end of the email.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by neckbeard on Friday February 22, 2013 @06:28PM (#5267612)
"The surprising question we get is: 'How many people telecommute at Google?' ” [Google's CFO] Mr Pichette said at a talk in Sydney on Monday. "And our answer is: 'As few as possible'."

http://www.smh.com.au/it-pro/business-it/do-as-we-say-not-as...

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by waterlesscloud on Friday February 22, 2013 @08:46PM (#5268136)
On the plus side, there are now hundreds of former Yahoo employees who also won't be working at Google.

Good chance for a savvy startup to pick up some remote talent the big boys can't.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by badgar on Friday February 22, 2013 @08:52PM (#5268160)
> Good chance for a savvy startup to pick up some remote talent the big boys can't.

No, this is a chance to pick up talent the big boys don't need. "As few as possible" telecommuters means they do hire telecommuters. Apply, see if your skills make up for your telecommuting. As a telecommuter, your application will need to be particularly strong to make up for what the company risks and loses by not having you in the office - if it isn't, a big company won't take the risk on you.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by raverbashing on Saturday February 23, 2013 @02:52AM (#5268929)
> No, this is a chance to pick up talent the big boys don't need

Considering how bad they are at hiring, there should be very competent people there.

> As a telecommuter, your application will need to be particularly strong to make up for what the company risks and loses by not having you in the office -

Which is, almost nothing, unless they are not set up for remote work, which every minimal competent company today is/should be.

> if it isn't, a big company won't take the risk on you.

Tell that to Red Hat. A big majority of their development positions (if not all) are remote.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by badgar on Saturday February 23, 2013 @03:31AM (#5269013)
> Considering how bad they are at hiring, there should be very competent people there.

The company under discussion at Google. They're great at hiring, at least by their metrics: they have thousands of the world's best engineers.

> Which is, almost nothing, unless they are not set up for remote work, which every minimal competent company today is/should be.

You're ignoring context again. Patrick Pichette, CFO of Google, said regarding the number of telecommuters: "as few as possible." In my response, I was addressing that comment by pointing out it implies the company is equipped to work with telecommuters but sees telecommuting as a disadvantage.

> Tell that to Red Hat. A big majority of their development positions (if not all) are remote.

Red Hat is a great example of a company whose unique business model lets them rely heavily on remote developers. It's unsurprising given the work they do: they take existing open-source software and package it, maintain it, and support it. This is work that can be largely done independently. They don't write OSes like the biggest software giants do - they keep the lights running for Linux, the FOSS community's shared OS.

Red Hat is an open-source utility company, and their margins (~10% - one of the lowest in software) reflect that. Few think there's room for many such large companies, given that Red Hat has only just hit $1b in revenue last year (woohoo!).

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by raverbashing on Saturday February 23, 2013 @04:37AM (#5269130)
>The company under discussion at Google. They're great at hiring, at least by their metrics

Yes, I know about the context. "At least by their metrics" which can be good, but certainly not great. To be fair they have a never ending flood of candidates and have to deal with that.

But the main issue is that it only gets candidates with a very narrow set of skills.

"it implies the company is equipped to work with telecommuters but sees telecommuting as a disadvantage"

Not necessarily, it can be a one-off setup for the few telecommuters.

"It's unsurprising given the work they do: they take existing open-source software and package it, maintain it, and support it. This is work that can be largely done independently. They don't write OSes like the biggest software giants do - they keep the lights running for Linux, the FOSS community's shared OS."

You are underestimating heavily what Red Hat does. Especially the amount of development that goes there.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by waterlesscloud on Friday February 22, 2013 @09:21PM (#5268242)
This sort of attitude is precisely why the big boys don't stay the big boys in tech.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by badgar on Friday February 22, 2013 @09:48PM (#5268327)
> This sort of attitude is precisely why the big boys don't stay the big boys in tech.

Are you saying telecommuters are the key to staying big in tech? To encourage innovation big companies want happy engineers in close proximity, talking spontaneously in varied, positive environments. Hence the free food. And the massages. And all the other perks.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by tokipin on Friday February 22, 2013 @07:42PM (#5267918)
i just got a genius idea. what if Google just declared the entire world as Google!
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by gscott on Friday February 22, 2013 @08:01PM (#5267979)
They already have. Not that they intended to but it has by default ended up that way.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by DannyBee on Friday February 22, 2013 @05:35PM (#5267346)
Well, this says "no exceptions", but at least at Google, there are exceptions. I was an exception for a while, one of my employees was an exception for 6 years :)

These exceptions are fairly rare though.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by mattwdelong on Friday February 22, 2013 @05:58PM (#5267486)
Out of curiosity, and if you don't mind divulging such details; what do you feel made you an exception?
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by DannyBee on Friday February 22, 2013 @07:56PM (#5267963)
I have a very specialized set of degrees/knowledge/experience (Actual high level software engineering on real projects and also an IP/patent lawyer who specializes in open source lawyering) that can be hard to find. Also, there was an office at least moderately nearby (within 2 hours).

I eventually became officially part of the DC office, and started a small eng team there.

Note that hiring remotees required very high level approval, even back then, and some areas of Google simply won't do it. 7 years ago, Google was also a little more lenient. :)

Nowadays I would expect that they grandfathered in most of the earlier remotees, and that there are no real remotee hires anymore, they have enough small sales/whatever offices that they just make them part of those offices, or don't hire them.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by fatman on Saturday February 23, 2013 @04:25AM (#5269107)
How do you leverage JD/Eng into a job - in my experience, it's been an either/or kind of thing.

Also, what is Open Source lawyering?

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by DannyBee on Sunday February 24, 2013 @08:07PM (#5276758)
You can leverage JD/eng into a job at most good tech companies. You just have to contact the right folks there, instead of applying through recruiters that are doing keyword scanning.

You won't be able to get work at a large law firm doing anything but lawyering, of course.

Open source lawyering = I specialize in open source related issues (be they licensing, compliance in general, whatever).

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by n09n on Saturday February 23, 2013 @11:41AM (#5270234)
If you want to work more on the law side, pretty much any sufficiently big software company is going to need someone like you. If you want to stick more to the developer stuff, try something in a more heavily regulated industry like healthcare or finance.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by MWil on Friday February 22, 2013 @08:35PM (#5268098)
Looking to do some open source lawyering myself but I don't have any engineering/cs background, just self-taught
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by michaelt on Friday February 22, 2013 @07:24PM (#5267862)
My employer won't take a new hire as a remote worker, but if you've worked on site for several years and have to move for family reasons they'd rather you work remotely than leave the company.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by mansigandhi on Friday February 22, 2013 @08:01PM (#5267980)
Yep, Oracle works the same way
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by anthemcg on Friday February 22, 2013 @05:13PM (#5267232)
I kinda agree, it makes some sense. Its easy in an office environment to forget about remote employees even if they do a lot of work. Out of sight , out of mind is quite real. It seems to matter less if you don't have a strong team dynamic; such as teams that are pieced together from contractors or work that is done mostly alone.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by shill on Friday February 22, 2013 @05:43PM (#5267398)
>> Out of sight , out of mind is quite real.

Also, resentment issues.

---

Where's Bob? He should be in this meeting.

  He's "working" from home today. (Makes quotation mark signs with fingers) 
Oh, yeah. I forgot that it's Tuesday. Let's get him on the phone.

  Don't bother. I just called him and he's at his kids swim lesson. 
Must be nice.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by ChuckMcM on Friday February 22, 2013 @06:05PM (#5267527)
I am aware of this sort of stuff that goes on, generally though I think of it as a management problem. But let me explain why I think that.

So perhaps "Bob" in our example really does have a job which allows him to work as effectively[1] at home as he can at work. Bob should also be aware of the schedule. So when the meeting comes up, Bob should be ready for it. And I've known folks working remotely who where chilling on the conference line waiting for the rest of the meeting to show up. But if either Bob isn't there when he should be, or the manager isn't organized enough to give Bob at least 12hrs notice of a meeting he should be attending, then you've got a management problem.

[1] First tip is that a manager needs to have a way of evaluating their teams effectiveness, if they don't then they can't really say if Bob is or is not as effective as others in his position.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by jmccree on Friday February 22, 2013 @07:40PM (#5267913)
I've worked on a lot of distributed teams. For an actual team (not just subcontractors) every place has had some level of "office hours". Normally a ~4+ hour block every day that you are expected to be "in office" and available for calls/chat. Some places do hardcore 9-5, even for remote workers. When teams have different time zones in play, normally everyone tries to have atleast a 2 hour overlap during a normal work day. It's during the office hours of someone the manager knows they are available for ad-hoc meetings etc.

Perhaps a more important note is that, in my experience, most distributed teams have /way/ less meetings than an in person teams. A lot of things are done informally over IRC/chat. I say informal, but since IRC is usually logged, if someone is not involved in the informal discussion at the time it takes place, they can just read it to catch up on why the decisions were made.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by slurgfest on Friday February 22, 2013 @06:58PM (#5267754)
The meeting in the fictional example isn't necessarily scheduled, so there is no way for him to be aware of it.

Also, in the example, it may be that the employees griping about Bob are not even going to try to notify him.

I agree with you that this requires an organized manager. Unfortunately, a ton of managers lack this kind of organization.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by JohnBooty on Friday February 22, 2013 @07:35PM (#5267893)
"But if either Bob isn't there when he should be, or the manager isn't organized enough to give Bob at least 12hrs notice of a meeting he should be attending, then you've got a management problem."

I agree with you, except for that part. For most jobs, it's incredibly valuable to have impromptu "hallway" discussions that can't be scheduled in advance, isn't it?

Your main point still stands - Bob needs to be available during office hours, even if he's at home.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by coldtea on Friday February 22, 2013 @09:06PM (#5268200)
>For most jobs, it's incredibly valuable to have impromptu "hallway" discussions that can't be scheduled in advance, isn't it?

No, it's not.

If your business is so undisciplined and random that it's "valuable" (and even more "incredibly valuable") to have improptu "hallway" discussions, then you're doing it wrong.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by michaelochurch on Friday February 22, 2013 @09:45PM (#5268319)
If your business is so undisciplined and random that it's "valuable" (and even more "incredibly valuable") to have improptu "hallway" discussions, then you're doing it wrong.

Disagree strongly. Creativity often comes from people synthesizing ideas that wouldn't ordinarily meet, and especially not in a way that can be planned by management.

In the typical corporate environment where employees are just expected to implement ideas handed down by management, there's no value in these unplanned discussions. However, if you're looking for creativity and organic development, then there's value in those sort of random encounters. That doesn't mean remote can't work. It does give it a different feel. But I strongly disagree that there's zero value to unplanned discussion.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by coldtea on Saturday February 23, 2013 @12:59AM (#5268738)
>Disagree strongly. Creativity often comes from people synthesizing ideas that wouldn't ordinarily meet, and especially not in a way that can be planned by management.

That's totally orthogonal to "hallway" meetings.

To put it another way, if you can't do the above over IM/Skype/email/etc, you're doing it wrong.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by JohnBooty on Saturday February 23, 2013 @10:33PM (#5272662)
I put "hallway" in quotes because it doesn't have to be a literal hallway. I agree that IM/Skype/email/etc is fine for them (and even better, in many ways).
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by JohnBooty on Friday February 22, 2013 @07:29PM (#5267874)
"Don't bother. I just called him and he's at his kids swim lesson"

There are issues with telecommuting that are difficult to overcome, but this one is ridiculously simple.

The solution (well, a solution) is to have business hours during which everybody needs to be available. I have an arrangement like that with my employer - between 9 and 5, even if I'm working at home, my manager needs to be able to pick up his phone and have me be instantly available.

At first, he was a little doubtful, but he soon realized that he can actually get a hold of me more quickly this way when compared with walking across the building from his office to mine. (And no, he doesn't abuse this... haha) :)

It gets slightly trickier when people are in different time zones, but nothing that can't be overcome. People need predictable office hours; there can't ever be a "Bob's at his kids' swim practice" moment. Barring emergency, of course.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by rhizome on Friday February 22, 2013 @05:48PM (#5267426)
"I guess we should have scheduled this meeting more than 5 minutes in advance."
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by droithomme on Friday February 22, 2013 @11:16PM (#5268529)
"I hate that stupid Bob and his kid's swimming lessons! Bob should be made to be like us and spend 9-5 in useless meetings and develop products for 13 minutes a day rather than be like dumb old Bob and spend the day with family and then work from 7pm to 3am in a solid sprint, coding."
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by ja27 on Friday February 22, 2013 @05:59PM (#5267492)
Also, productivity issues.

Oh, I'll wait until tomorrow to talk to Bob about X, when he's back in the office.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by tg3 on Friday February 22, 2013 @06:51PM (#5267729)
The problem with Bob in this example is that he's not a good worker, and doesn't keep his commitments, not that he's working remotely.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by codeonfire on Saturday February 23, 2013 @12:13AM (#5268652)
This is too funny, do I work with you? You forgot the part about when 'Bob' brings his kids into the office when anybody complains.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by taligent on Friday February 22, 2013 @06:35PM (#5267648)
What a ridiculous argument. You are talking about behavioural issues i.e. not being available for scheduled meetings not something inherent to working remotely. Or to put it more simply:

Where's Bob? He should be in this meeting.

   He's outside having a coffee and cigarette with Jane.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by xtracto on Friday February 22, 2013 @06:44PM (#5267695)
Definitely, as long as persons performance is measured in their outcomes and not in the number of meetings they attend to or the "butt hours" they make, working from home is as productive as working in the office.

I think the sweet spot is when it is a combination of both.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by shill on Friday February 22, 2013 @07:12PM (#5267825)
I could have noted that Bob manages his time well and completes all of his assigned work. The outcome is still the same. Haters gonna hate.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by cjfont on Friday February 22, 2013 @08:30PM (#5268081)
Doing good work does not compensate for being allowed to blow off meetings at will, allowing such behavior decreases morale among the group and can lower productivity as a whole.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by recycleme on Friday February 22, 2013 @05:21PM (#5267283)
One thing that can help with this is to have an open "informal" chatroom for all your employees (or for teams). Now if the person is completely silent, well, that's another issue.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by mtrimpe on Friday February 22, 2013 @05:07PM (#5267192)
What are those secret calibration scores? It sounds very Orwellian...
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by walshemj on Friday February 22, 2013 @06:32PM (#5267635)
It's the secret meeting where they fiddle the figures from a APR system to fit what ever curve HR wants - and if you need to downsize do things like dump those poor buggers with cancer in the poor performer category.

Its the main problem with APR systems they get captured by sections of an organization who use it to achieve their own agendas with no though to what it does to the company as a whole.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by asveikau on Friday February 22, 2013 @05:52PM (#5267456)
Sounds like something that turns companies into Microsoft.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by jodrellblank on Friday February 22, 2013 @06:02PM (#5267508)
Shipping mountains of high quality popular software at regular intervals? Sounds just what Yahoo! needs.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by cgh on Friday February 22, 2013 @06:18PM (#5267578)
Have you ever worked at or with MS? If so, you'd know that stack ranking is the reason MS has flopped in just about every field it's entered for the last decade.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by ryanmolden on Friday February 22, 2013 @08:43PM (#5268126)
As someone that works at Microsoft I know I can't really respond to this without being accused of being a shill/apoligist (even at a place that prides itself in logical thinking, like HN), but this is such a massive oversimplification, and likely so far off the mark as to possibly be on the wrong planet.

Microsoft has a well-known review system that engenders various feelings in various people, not all of them postive. I have posted here before how the stack ranking part is actually low on my list of objectionable things about the whole process, but it is what people know so it is what people cite. I have heard stories, always apocryphal, never by anyone willing to put their real name behind it, about how people are constantly obsessed with reviews and stabbing their teammates in the back left and right to get a leg up. I have never once witnessed that behavior or even heard of a remotely plausible instance of that happening. That said Microsoft is a big company, so I am sure it has/does happen somewhere. I dispute it is rampant or common.

I have heard stories of people that are terrible at working in groups and don't do well. I have heard stories of people that have an opinion of their own skills that seems objectively divorced from reality. I have heard stories of management hubris that ultimately doesn’t pan out. Some of the people that play a starring role in these dramas then invent conspiracies about plotting colleagues causing them to rank poorly, incompetent managers that didn’t recognize their delicate snow-flakism or any other number of explanations that conveniently don’t attribute any share of the blame to themselves. I suspect those tend to be fantasies made to soothe one’s ego.

I think anyone with knowledge of internal state at Microsoft could posit a much better explanation of why they have 'flopped in just about every field it's entered for the last decade' that doesn't involve Machiavellian competition between employees. Hell, reversion to the mean pretty much would cover most bases without any kind of comical soap opera drama needed.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by asveikau on Friday February 22, 2013 @08:51PM (#5268151)
> I have heard stories, always apocryphal, never by anyone willing to put their real name behind it,

You said that the last time I replied to you. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5100751

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by ryanmolden on Saturday February 23, 2013 @12:07PM (#5270351)
I hadn't seen your previous reply, I don't always follow up on my own posts :) I wouldn't argue there is subjectivity in reward, there always will be. I don't work in Windows but I know a few folks that do. I haven't heard any stories of people feeling they got shafted and some doofus got a reward, but I am sure it happens, and I am sure it is not unique to Microsoft in any way. My argument is with people that claim it is the norm and they base that on their own (non-verifiable) experience, or worse on some troll blog like miniMSFT.

As for comments about seeing who got rewards based on title change, a title change doesn't always mean a large pay raise, and there are hidden rewards like gold star bonuses and HiPo groups that have little/no outward evidence, unless the recipient starts talking about them (which they tell them not to do), so I would say you probably aren't seeing accurate signaling based on job titles alone. The fact that some of the best rewards are secret is one of my beefs with the system.

Also, to clarify, I am not a fan of Microsoft's system, but when I hear stories of people who claim it leads to internecine wars, well that just isn't my experience in the last 8 years, or the experience of anyone I have talked to personally.

Ultimately there has to be some kind of ranking system as there is a fixed pool of rewards. The only alternative I could see would be exactly even sharing amongst a team. You could argue for that, but even as someone that has socialist sympathies I don't think it would work or be fair. There are people on my team that produce more than me, whether it be through being smarter, working longer hours, whatever. To say I should get the same reward as them is just wrong.

So if we agree there has to be ranking, well there's your stack ranking. You could argue with the curve fitting, but your claim that 1 in a group of 10 would get no bonus is just false. Curve fitting doesn't happen on a per team basis. It's more like 10 in a group of 100 or 100 in a group of 1000. There is nothing saying that an entire team couldn't end up in the top 10% of rewards. It may well be the case that on your team of 10 superstars one doesn't get the reward they feel they deserve, but that is because someone else in the calibration meeting was deemed more worthy, your teams ranking isn't done in isolation and in a team with 10 superstars there can be other superstars in the general vicinity, even more than 10. To claim that the system results in people plotting against the ones they are ranked against in order to sabotage them just sounds like conspiracy theory thinking. In my experience it results in people upping their game, or leaving if they feel they are unappreciated. Both are reasonable responses, some attempt at sabotage is not.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by kelnos on Saturday February 23, 2013 @01:24AM (#5268774)
Doesn't affect the truth/falsehood of what he's saying.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by asveikau on Saturday February 23, 2013 @01:54AM (#5268829)
Hm. I don't think I've ever been called apocryphal before.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by jongraehl on Saturday February 23, 2013 @02:01AM (#5268842)
If asveiku is a real name, then he's heard of at least one (linked reply to "last time").
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by argonaut on Saturday February 23, 2013 @03:24AM (#5268998)
Are you aware of how devoid of logical content your comment is?
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by asveikau on Saturday February 23, 2013 @11:59AM (#5270314)
Easy for you to say. You're not being called apocryphal.

I thought readers could connect the dots but maybe a bit more explanation is due.

Having worked at the "new Microsoft" in recent history I feel like the part I quoted is highly indicative of someone who has their head in the sand. Across multiple divisions among people I've voiced opinions with openly I haven't talked to anyone at MS who shares his view. Even in his own DevDiv, I've heard people say that DevDiv is a bit better than the Microsoft average but yeah, it still has these problems.

At least, this is how I felt last month when replying to his previous comment. So I left a reply, even though it's taboo to talk this way about a former employer, even though I risked potential embarrassment attaching my name to this. And I said, hey, what they say about MS, what they said in that Vanity Fair article, it has a lot of truth in my experience, and I don't really know anyone who says otherwise without being a blind shill or a sociopath. (I'm saying it a bit more bluntly here but that was the idea.) I was reluctant to make that comment, but I did.

Then he goes around repeating still that all such comments are apocryphal and anonymous, despite the comment of a real person who is not writing anonymously. (Aside: He is probably not aware that current employees won't say this for fear of losing their job, and former employees probably feel the general taboo against speaking ill of a former employer.)

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by argonaut on Sunday February 24, 2013 @09:38PM (#5277007)
> Easy for you to say. You're not being called apocryphal.

You are literally just making my point over and over again. This sentence is, like the previous post, utterly devoid of logical content. Are you seriously taking offense at being called "apocryphal"? Nevermind that ryanmolden never actually called you apocryphal.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by xshoppyx on Saturday February 23, 2013 @05:24AM (#5269240)
True that it may not be the reason they have flopped, but honestly every co-worker of mine that has worked at Microsoft states our review process drives performance above all else. And the sample size isn't small, I'm in SLU at Amazon.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by gradys on Friday February 22, 2013 @07:35PM (#5267892)
Would you mind expanding on this a bit? How exactly does it contribute to Microsoft's performance in new fields? This is a completely genuine question. I'm not an apologist just trying to defend MS in a roundabout way.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by asveikau on Friday February 22, 2013 @07:51PM (#5267946)
People become obsessed with their scores and their peers' scores. They're wrapped up in internal competition and compete poorly with external players or when assessed honestly with most reality-based metrics.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by cgh on Friday February 22, 2013 @08:27PM (#5268071)
I worked with MS (for a consulting company, first few years of my career) back in "the day", and I got to witness first-hand the craziness of this system. But rather than blab about my own experiences, here's a recent article that sums things up pretty well: http://www.vanityfair.com/online/daily/2012/07/microsoft-dow...
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by michaelochurch on Friday February 22, 2013 @08:42PM (#5268119)
There are 4 types of workplace cultures. (See: http://michaelochurch.wordpress.com/2013/02/22/gervais-rehas... .)

Functioning planned culture: guild culture. Master crafts(wo)men and apprentices are clearly defined, but the managerial relationship is advisory and focused on mentorship. The major downside of guild culture (the rarest of the 4) is that it relies on employee loyalty to capture the value it generates.

Pathological planned culture: rank culture. (This is the most common corporate culture.) People rise or fall based on subordinacy, rather than the quality of their ideas or their level of effort. You end up with a lot of people who don't work hard because they realize that effort doesn't matter, and a lot of bad ideas getting into implementation. Rank cultures often can't compete on an open market or address new challenges.

Functioning market culture: self-executive culture. Here you have a flat hierarchy and employees have a lot of autonomy. However, they're usually expected to take responsibility for their own advancement. This is the Valve-style open allocation culture.

Pathological market culture: tough culture. High-stakes performance reviews, low trust of employees but similarly low guidance. This is the sink-or-swim culture.

Rank culture tends to turn into tough culture as it generates underperformers, and eventually the higher-ups get upset about the whole thing and have a crackdown. However, tough culture turns back into rank culture as the people who control the performance assessment become the new rank-holders and, in exchange for loyalty, offer safety and advantage in the evaluation process. So tough and rank cultures tend to fall into a degenerate, enervating pattern of oscillation from one extreme to the other. This back-and-forth eventually exhausts the company, leading to constant reorganization and turmoil.

When a company institutes permanent tough culture (stack ranking as an inflexible pillar, rather than a temporary measure) the political corrosion associated with rank culture still occurs, but there's a selection dynamic (similar to antibiotic resistance) where the forms of rank culture that survive are the least detectable. So you end up with a culture that's politicized and gamey like a tough culture, but inefficient and extortive like a rank culture, and ultimately you have a workplace where people put in lots of hours and apparent sacrifice, but there's little getting done and there's no vision.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by carlisle_ on Friday February 22, 2013 @07:37PM (#5267905)
Except the Xbox which has been wildly popular and successful right?
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by kevingadd on Friday February 22, 2013 @08:17PM (#5268042)
The team(s)/business unit responsible for XBox had a ton of independence and freedom early on and it contributed to their success. That freedom has slowly been taken away and you can see the effect in the product(s) coming out of that part of the business now.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by kvb on Friday February 22, 2013 @10:11PM (#5268379)
That's odd; I thought Kinect was widely hailed as a success.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by kevingadd on Saturday February 23, 2013 @12:08AM (#5268646)
Kinect is successful and an interesting product, but they've had a hard time producing genuinely interesting or high quality Kinect games, either first or third party. The ones that are successful tend to actually make rather minimal use of the technology, or use it in odd ways. For a couple examples, IIRC Dance Central isn't able to use the actual skeletal tracking technology, and Double Fine's Kinect games likewise take a different approach that doesn't use the skeletal tracking. Most of the games shipping labelled as 'Better with Kinect' use it as a glorified microphone, which is kind of depressing. At this point there is also a general consensus that the Kinect camera's accuracy is too low for many serious game uses and that the field of view hampers its use in many homes. In their defense, it's rumored that they have addressed this with the next revision of the hardware.

My point is more regarding things like the dashboard updates - the XBox 360 dashboard slowly turned into a glorified billboard covered in ads that has incidental features tacked onto it. They've had consistent performance problems with their system software that have never really been addressed (though thankfully they've made slight improvements here and there) - at this point people who have to interact with it on a regular basis, like journalists, are barely able to contain their hatred for the user interface.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by PeterisP on Saturday February 23, 2013 @04:41AM (#5269139)
I'm not an expert, but wasn't Kinect acquihired with a prototype product already built?
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by carlisle_ on Saturday February 23, 2013 @06:49AM (#5269400)
This is how Google launches the vast majority of their products but nobody gives them flak for it.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by g8oz on Friday February 22, 2013 @06:15PM (#5267561)
More accurately: missing industry wide shifts because of infighting and backstabbing amongst teams and individuals.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by lucisferre on Friday February 22, 2013 @06:24PM (#5267600)
ASP.NET?
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by tankenmate on Friday February 22, 2013 @05:10PM (#5267213)
Shakesperean, stack ranking by another name...
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by michaelochurch on Friday February 22, 2013 @08:12PM (#5268027)
Google claims that its performance review system is "peer-driven", but what actually exists is a bicameral system where you need strong peer reviews and good calibration scores in order to get a transfer or a promotion. If you play one game and not the other, you can get stuck.

Calibration happens every quarter and a manager can unilaterally ding you. However, a supportive manager doesn't guarantee a good score. He actually has to get involved in the horse-trading and tit-for-tat of the whole process. Some people get screwed because their managers don't show up to calibration and they get low scores.

Finally, you often have no idea what your score is. Meets Expectations is everything from the 2nd to 70th percentile of the company. At the high end of that range, you're OK-- you won't get fired, you can get a decent transfer. At the low end, you're fucked. However, you may have no idea where in that range you are.

It's a play-for-play copy of Enron's performance review system, except with even more managerial secrecy and, therefore, less accountability. In short, it's why Google has less future than past.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by seanmcdirmid on Friday February 22, 2013 @09:09PM (#5268209)
I'm not trying to give Google a pass, but this sounds like every big tech company actually. Managing is hard I guess, and opaqueness arises naturally even in meritocracies.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by michaelochurch on Friday February 22, 2013 @09:19PM (#5268235)
Even though managing is hard, that's not an excuse for being a dick when you have huge reserves of cash and could be giving employees a lot more in the way of autonomy, compensation, and advancement. Companies like Google and Microsoft can afford not to be evil.

I agree with you that Google is probably no worse than the other large tech companies, but I wouldn't call that an endorsement. For one example of something I don't like about tech culture, these firms have a tendency to throw their employees under the bus when the economy gets bad. Banks have layoffs. It's just something you get used to on the Street. Good people get let go, take their severance packages, and find other jobs. No big deal. On the other hand, many tech companies, when they do the same thing, make it look like a wave of performance-based firings so they can say they've never had a layoff. Google still claims it has never had an engineering layoff, even though it's had waves of PIPs. That's slimy.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by seanmcdirmid on Friday February 22, 2013 @10:09PM (#5268376)
As in government, we can talk about "different ways" of doing things like communism or libertarianism, but each new way seems to have just as many, if not more, problems than the previous. So ya, meritocratic companies might be the worst ones to work for, except for maybe non-meritocratic ones.

I believe managers are just human: even Google will have good and bad ones, evil but effective ones along with good but ineffective ones (wrt to biz goals), and lots of other different combinations. Until we can come up with a system that removes inconsistent human nature from the equation, we'll just have to tolerate what we have. Sliminess is just one common trait of human beings, and I'm sure even Google can't avoid hiring and promoting sociopaths.

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by mtgx on Friday February 22, 2013 @05:16PM (#5267257)
They should do Google Hangouts.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by yukoncornelius on Friday February 22, 2013 @05:28PM (#5267316)
For many workers and managers this is true. For the manager with a crack staff in which many work offsite but are great communicators and productive employees this is a nightmare.
Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by Natsu on Friday February 22, 2013 @05:40PM (#5267386)
That reminds me of this quote:

"As a manager, I can’t easily know how many hours each person on my team is working. This is actually good for me because it forces me to look at what they’ve done. It’s good for the remote person as well: they can’t fool themselves into thinking that just because they’re in an office, surfing Reddit for an hour is work. In a perfect world we’d both already have this perspective, but it’s amazing how easy it is to delude yourself into thinking that “going to the office” = work."

http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2013/02/why-we-still-believe-i...

Re:Yahoo CEO Mayer Now Requiring Employees to Not Be Remote by yuhong on Friday February 22, 2013 @05:11PM (#5267219)
I hope open allocation will be adopted instead.