Edit: thanks for the suggestions so far! They all seem to be in blog style, with the typical horrible navigation (basically, you are limited to the most recent posts). I miss the huge repositories of game reviews from sites like GameSpy - being able to look up reviews of old games?
Try MobyGames [1] for that. They collect user reviews as well as quotes and scores from and links to reviews from professional reviewers. Unlike MetaCritic MobyGames has a lot of information on older games and references reviews from sources that may be long gone (e.g., Computer Gaming World).
I'd also suggest Retronauts [2] and Insert Credit [3] if you like podcasts.
[1] https://www.mobygames.com/
I haven't seen this anywhere, do you have a source? Maybe I'm just tired, but I didn't see anything about that in your links. That's kind of sad; I'm not a huge fan of the site, but I actually trust their reviews more than most other gaming sites.
edit: are you sure you don't mean gamespy? In your source I see 'subsidiary gaming sites 1UP, UGO and GameSpy are all being shut down'
In the media world most people associate 'online' with efficient, and this demonstrates that it isn't necessarily true. There is still a lot of competitive pressure if all you are doing is running a fat organization and replacing paper with a web server.
Ziff apparently only paid $100M for the business[2] (News paid $600M+ only years ago) and IGN has 53 million unique visitors (in a high yield demographic - young males) across their properties, yet they couldn't make the business model work. Demonstrates just how 'thin' the new media businesses have to become in order to survive and the challenge that old media companies are facing.
[0] http://investor.j2global.com/releasedetail.cfm?ReleaseID=737...
[1] http://kotaku.com/5986027/ziff-davis-shuts-1up-gamespy-and-u...
[2] http://pandodaily.com/2013/02/01/sources-ziff-davis-is-close...