News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by jobu on Thursday February 21, 2013 @12:39PM (#5258732)
Fast forward to next week:

"The White House announces a new threshold of 500,000 signatures before it will respond to online petitions."

I was initially enthusiastic about these online petitions, but it doesn't seem like any of them have had an effect.

Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by ajross on Thursday February 21, 2013 @01:24PM (#5259059)
What kind of effect were you expecting? The president promises to do whatever you want as long as you get N "signatures" on a weakly authenticated website? Even if you got those N people to all show up in person at the White House door, wrapping policy around the desires of a vocal minority is not a valid or just way to structure a government.

They promised to respond, which is about all they can promise. And this gives them a reasonable metric for how many voters care about an issue, which is a good thing. And they can probably even infer some demographic data from the results, which is another good thing.

Basically this is a tool to better inform policy decisions, and the evidence is that it's "working". If you were expecting more then I think your hopes were a little unfounded.

Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by jlgreco on Thursday February 21, 2013 @03:08PM (#5259951)
> Basically this is a tool to better inform policy decisions

No, it is actually a safety valve. If the public gets a little too agitated about anything they can go sign a petition to let of some steam. This petition site furthers couch-potato politics; it enables people to 'do their bit' without actually moving their ass. It neutralizes those who are naturally prone to apathy already.

Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by ajross on Thursday February 21, 2013 @03:24PM (#5260100)
Fair enough. Let's just agree to disagree on that. Your explanation is a bit too far on the "been reading a bit too much dystopian pulp" side of the spectrum.

To argue that the practice of policy is cynical and easily corrupted is a truism. To say that the white house deliberately threw up a petition system to actively "neutralize" inconvenient opinions is just ridiculous, sorry. The white house staff are people just like you and I, and they care about many of the same things you do and truly want to do the right thing in the face of many competing interests. Don't turn them into Orwellian villains, it's not helpful.

Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by jlgreco on Thursday February 21, 2013 @03:29PM (#5260137)
The less dystopic version of my interpretation is that the site is just a way of keeping people happy, rather than "neutralized". Does that seem so implausible to you?

> The white house staff are people just like you and I

See, that realization is what enables me to believe they would make a petition site just to keep people happy. It is something rather frequently seen in the "real world" from "normal people" (see: suggestion boxes in the breakroom at work), and is exactly the sort of thing I could see myself doing. Hell, I have done it. Have someone that is mad at you? Let them vent for a while until they calm down, then tell them why they are wrong.

This sort of tactic isn't unique bizarre super-villian behavior. It is standard bullshit.

If the intent were completely pure, merely to educate, they wouldn't have people perform a meaningless action before they got their cookie. You don't get that far in politics by being clueless about how to gauge public interest in a topic without resorting to an online tally of interest. That is simply inconceivable.

Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by writtles on Thursday February 21, 2013 @06:23PM (#5261332)
Yeah, lets just go back to the days of hitting the streets with those paper petitions, and gathering signatures at bus stops and Phish concerts! Why get the internet involved in politics at all?
Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by zanny on Thursday February 21, 2013 @07:00PM (#5261548)
Because anonymous forums on the internet have proven for a decade sane discourse goes out the window due to the Internet Fuckwad Theorem. It is an entirely different dynamic to be in someones face and have to fear consequences beyond words from your behavior, and honestly, that is what almost any protest in history was for - to try to shake the boots of those who are gifted with power.

An internet petition is just a number and a paragraph that people clicked a thumbs up on. Nobody would ever care unless those people actually started voting differently, and by differently, that means something other than just going across the isle and shaking hands with their neighbor politician in the other camp.

It is the same reason you don't argue with businesses with petition letters, you argue with them with their bottom line. If you are in a state of demanding something, the other party has a power and influence you don't, and you need some pull in the relationship or else you will be walked all over.

Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by writtles on Thursday February 21, 2013 @11:44PM (#5262750)
After rereading your contribution, I realize you were agreeing. therefore, I had become for a moment the "Internet Fuckwad" you warned me of. Sorry. Dis acknowledge previous post. ... I've been drinking...
Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by 1123581321 on Friday February 22, 2013 @02:26AM (#5263168)
You have been one your entire time on Hacker News. Please contribute, not argue.
Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by writtles on Thursday February 21, 2013 @11:18PM (#5262644)
>Because anonymous forums on the internet have proven for a decade sane discourse goes out the window due to the Internet Fuckwad Theorem. It is an entirely different dynamic to be in someones face and have to fear consequences beyond words from your behavior

Heh. And here you are, in said forums! Somewhat perfecting the voice of righteous judgement! Bravo, but no. I see what you came to represent here, but if you think trumpeting loudly some bad-ass anti-establishment intellectual philosophy while standing on the tiny issue of "the right to cell-phone-unlocking-regardless-of-lender-contract" as a basis for your purist reasoning, then you sir/ma'am, live in a first world overrun with problems of the same degree! There is wisdom in "choosing your battles," and this, my dear zanny, is not the one. Trust me.

Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by jlgreco on Thursday February 21, 2013 @07:20PM (#5261661)
How are you reading an opposition to involving the internet in any way out of my post?
Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by graysnorf on Thursday February 21, 2013 @08:51PM (#5262022)
i think you're missing some sarcasm.

edit: alternatively, I'm finding some non-existent sarcasm.

Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by jlgreco on Thursday February 21, 2013 @11:36PM (#5262723)
No, his sarcasm came across loud and clear. He was sarcastically "agreeing" with me in order to mock me... except the position he was mocking is not one I have endorsed. On the contrary, I embrace the role of the internet in protest and politics.
Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by writtles on Thursday February 21, 2013 @11:28PM (#5262682)
Just to clarify: sarcasm.
Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by lotu on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:21PM (#5260503)
Bullshit, the idea that this website is just a plane to place and pacify the public is simply silly. First the issues handled on this site are not the type that will spill out into the streets if ignored people simply will not riot over being unable to legally unlock their phones (this is the definition of a first world problem b.t.w.).

The fact of the matter is their aren't any looming issues facing the US that are likely to result in widespread riots today. But let's assume we are back in the 1950s during the Civil Rights Movement, I can't imagine a non-reply to a "We the People" petition doing anything to quell the Civil Rights Movement. Frankly, I suspect it would just further fan the flames.

The only way I could see this working as a "safety value" is if people confuse signing an online petition with actually voting. Something I find unlikely. Now if the government uses the site inform their opinions of the populace and shape their actions this could influence policy but only if it has been shown that if you oppose a petition than you will get voted out next election. The elderly are great at doing this which is why no one touches Social Security and Medicare. A lot of people think the Internet is a representative sample of the general population, and if something is massively popular online than the fact the the government isn't doing is means that they are usurping the will of the people.

Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by jlgreco on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:46PM (#5260676)
You are the one talking about riots, not me.
Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by einhverfr on Thursday February 21, 2013 @11:18PM (#5262641)
Keep in mind that all the white house agrees to do is to send out a PR piece justifying their current position if the petition threshold is reached.

I don't see online petitions as very helpful in any way.

Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by bjustin on Thursday February 21, 2013 @01:10PM (#5258953)
Now come on, the reason they raised the bar from 25,000 to 100,000 is to keep up with the site's increasing popularity. They could have set the bar to 100,000 at the site's launch instead of 5,000, but no petitions would have reached the threshold.

As for petitions actually having results, I imagine they are the weakest form of lobbying possible. The executive branch sees them and that is all.

Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by frostmatthew on Thursday February 21, 2013 @06:35PM (#5261401)
Instead of setting a hard number (that requires adjustments) they should change it to responding to the top X petitions with the most signatures each month.
Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by xur17 on Friday February 22, 2013 @10:25AM (#5264596)
I disagree. Setting a hard number gives a threshold for people to fight for, and allows for a variable number of issues to make it to the top each month. It gives people a number to push for.
Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by dguaraglia on Thursday February 21, 2013 @01:25PM (#5259066)
Yep. Unfortunately you can't counter voices with fat checks and campaign contributions. That's a shame, to be honest.
Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by Nursie on Thursday February 21, 2013 @12:58PM (#5258873)
Are they new? We've had them in the UK starting from about 7 or 8 years ago, unsure if we still do.

All that ever happened when one reached the 'must get a response' threshold was some staffer would write a couple of quick sentences about how they weren't going to do whatever the thing was, and how you were wrong for wanting it.

Useless exercise all round.

Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by ratherbefuddled on Thursday February 21, 2013 @02:26PM (#5259542)
Actually in the UK anything getting 100k signatures is considered for debate in the House of Commons. You can see a list of debates that began in this manner (warning, pdf) here:

http://www.parliament.uk/documents/commons-committees/backbe...

Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by Nursie on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:06PM (#5260374)
Is that new? Under Blair/Brown it was a waste of time and I've mostly been out of the country since then.
Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by rgbrenner on Thursday February 21, 2013 @08:48PM (#5262014)
"but it doesn't seem like any of them have had an effect."

100,000 out of 300,000,000 people. What effect do you imagine it should have?

If you really want to give these petitions some weight, they should raise the threshold to 150,000,000. And there should be some way of letting people without computers sign it too. Maybe we could have places where people come to sign the petition. But that sounds like a big undertaking. Maybe we could gather several petitions and let people sign the ones they like, every say 4 years.. maybe with a smaller event in-between. And the results should be counted, and then the government forced to do what is decided.

Hmmm... If only there was something like that. That would be awesome.

Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by devcpp on Friday February 22, 2013 @03:07AM (#5263260)
You're thinking of referendums. A petition is a small number of people pissed about something that not everyone may be interested in. I'm sure my grandparents have never heard of Aaron Swartz and don't know what "jailbreaking" means, so it makes no sense to make them take a decision.
Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by rgbrenner on Friday February 22, 2013 @10:05AM (#5264487)
my post was tongue-in-cheek...

We have elections. Demanding that a petition from 100,000 people override the results of an election is ridiculous. The administration is responding to the petitions with their position -- I think that's about all they have the right to expect.

Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by jacoblyles on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:25PM (#5260534)
I'm keeping track of people who are actually doing politics in Silicon Valley, as well as running a group of my own (http://www.meetup.com/Politihacks-of-Silicon-Valley/). Outside of politihacks, these guys seem interesting: http://engine.is/
Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by duncan_bayne on Thursday February 21, 2013 @09:28PM (#5262153)
> I was initially enthusiastic about these online petitions

Really? I'm honestly surprised to find anyone who is genuinely surprised to discover State malfeasance these days.

Did you really, honestly, hand-on-heart believe that these petitions would change anything?

I think it was P. J. O'Rourke who opined that if voting could change anything, it'd be outlawed.

Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by scarmig on Thursday February 21, 2013 @01:52PM (#5259268)
Hell, 40,000 people are demonstrating on the National Mall about climate change/Keystone XL, getting arrested, and the Obama administration doesn't give a damn. Why the hell would anyone think 100,000 "signatures" on an online petition site would make a difference?
Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by jacoblyles on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:33PM (#5260601)
Obviously there's other political considerations going on besides demonstration size. The March for Life draws ~300,000 people every year, but I doubt the Obama administration changes its position on abortion anytime soon.
Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by marcia17 on Thursday February 21, 2013 @02:31PM (#5259595)
Well, they've done a good job at ignoring the subject matter even for those petitions which elicited a response. No reason to suggest they'll do anything different this time...
Re:Petition to make unlocking phones legal again passes 100,... by knowaveragejoe on Thursday February 21, 2013 @01:38PM (#5259159)
I'm not sure what people are expecting. All the petitions guarantee is a response from the WH, not action.