News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by dangrossman on Thursday February 21, 2013 @03:24AM (#5256175)
I have two machines running Windows 8: a 2-year-old laptop, and a Surface Pro tablet. I've never shut down either of them.

The laptop just gets closed when I'm not using it -- so it goes to sleep. If I leave it like that long enough it'll hibernate itself when the battery gets low.

The tablet I either press the power button on, or if I have the keyboard cover attached, just flip the cover shut which has the same effect. It goes to sleep and shuts itself down after 15?30? minutes of inactivity. Win8 on an SSD cold boots to a working desktop with network connection in 7 seconds flat.

Explicitly navigating to a software shutdown button just isn't part of a normal workflow on modern devices. The only time I think I'd use it would be to fix some kind of bug like a wonky driver. Desktops are going the way of the dodo -- my dinky little tablet can now drive a 2560x1440 monitor and run modern games. Adding one extra click to reach the old software shutdown button to keep the UX simple for what most people will be doing makes sense.

Heck, if you have a keyboard with the new Win8 shortcuts, it's the same amount of clicks as it was in WinVista and Win7. Charm button -> Power button -> Shut Down, versus Start Button -> Arrow next to the power icon -> Shut down.

Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by gordaco on Thursday February 21, 2013 @03:50AM (#5256251)
> Desktops are going the way of the dodo

Frankly, I'm tired of reading this. Desktops are going to lower their market share, yes, but that's all. The desktop has quite a few advantages: modularity (i.e.: want a new graphics card or a bigger hard disk? No problem. Is some hardware failing? Just replace it, not the whole thing; it's much easier than on a laptop), compatibility with a LOT of software (including a whole world of office applications and games from a very wide range of time. Laptops also share this; tablets and phones, not so much), price (compare any PC with a laptop with the same specs, especially if you select each component instead of relying on a pre-made computer), etc.

Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by dangrossman on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:00AM (#5256297)
You're going to be reading it for a long time, because it's true. The desktop is going extinct, and it's going extinct at a faster rate every month. Q4 desktop sales were 6.4% lower than Q4 2011. The advantages you mention are largely irrelevant outside specific professional niches, the only place desktops will stick around for a while.

The cheapest laptops are cheaper than the cheapest desktops in stores, and are cheap enough that it doesn't matter if you have to replace the whole thing if it's broken. Both laptops and tablets are compatible with the entire Windows legacy ecosystem. They're portable, they're what the workers and the managers making purchase decisions want to work on, and they cut the company's electric bill by more than half. Towers are going extinct.

Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by Svip on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:07AM (#5256337)
So what you are saying is that they are not going to go extinct? They will likely still be used in work environments, by software developers and by gamers. Yes, these areas sure are professional niches.
Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by bunderbunder on Thursday February 21, 2013 @10:48AM (#5258048)
Corporate's taking away my desktop, and replacing it with a laptop. The old computer's being retired, and all of the computers on the menu of replacements I had to pick from were laptops. Developers like me who want performance get a beefy desktop replacement model that I have to admit is on par with what we'd have gotten in an actual desktop computer.
Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by dangrossman on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:09AM (#5256349)
I didn't say any of that, and I disagree with all of it.
Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by Svip on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:11AM (#5256353)
So work environments, software developers and gamers will all abandon desktops? And go where?
Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by dangrossman on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:12AM (#5256358)
Laptops, tablets, smartphones and hybrids. As already makes up more than 80% of computing device sales today, with the desktop slice shrinking (in absolute quantity, not just percentage) every quarter. There's no way for that to happen unless either (a) businesses got hold of desktops that never need replacement, or (b) employees that were previously provided desktops are now using something else.
Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by gordaco on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:30AM (#5256425)
I don't think gamers will be ditching desktop for laptops anytime soon (for example: better cooling allows for more performance; plus, multiple graphic cards, and, as I said previously, modularity). There still exists a difference in the higher end, and, while this may make some workers (be it software developers or just people who work with office software) prefer a laptop, many still won't because of the price. Yes, for Facebook and such you are fine with a tablet or a shitty laptop (although in my experience, the cheapest desktop is cheaper than the cheapest laptop; it may just be due to geographic location), and the desktop may lose the lower end; but, when you have higher needs, laptops start to get pricier and less performant, thus becomming less of an adequate option.

About the ratio of computing devices, it's not only because desktop sell less; there are many more devices being used now than 5 years ago, and most of the new ones are tablets and smartphones. The absolute decline of the desktop is less marked.

Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by Svip on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:19AM (#5256390)
But work environments, software developers and gamers don't make up more than 20% of computing device sales. And most of those sales figures are for consumers, so they are ignoring work places all together.

Software developers might get by on a laptop, but most I know most prefer to have a desktop at home. That may be rather anecdotal evidence, but so is reading statistics wrong.

And gamers, well, they sure value their customised rigs. Some of them might prefer consoles, but there is still a huge range of gamers preferring desktops over everything.

Niche, perhaps, but just like there is some value to having a landline telephone (call a place rather than a person), so is there value to having a desktop.

Most consumers won't care, I imagine. But that doesn't mean the desktop will go extinct.

Regarding your a) and b); I am certain some businesses are moving to laptops and other non-desktop entities. But that doesn't mean all businesses are or will. It is most likely the lack of end consumers buying them that is reducing the total sales of desktops and not businesses.

Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by Shorel on Thursday February 21, 2013 @05:02PM (#5260785)
I don't expect desktops to disappear in at least 10 or 15 years.

But sure as hell I expect them to become more expensive over time, to a point where to have a desktop means paying a premium price over an equivalent laptop.

In fact, I'm just making plans to buy a new Desktop. On the other hand, I don't have any plans to purchase any mobile device, at least until I can install Ubuntu on it and expect it to work just as well as my Ubuntu 12.04 install.

Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by masklinn on Thursday February 21, 2013 @03:54AM (#5256268)
> Explicitly navigating to a software shutdown button just isn't part of a normal workflow on modern devices.

It's not part of the normal workflow on older ones either, mine anyway: I only ever shut down my desktop computer when it nags me after updates, or when I go on extended holidays and shut off all devices in the house.

> my dinky little tablet can now drive a 2560x1440 monitor and run modern games.

Good joke, that.

Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by calciphus on Friday February 22, 2013 @04:36AM (#5263495)
Sorry, have to disagree with your little potshot. I can run Starcraft II and Diablo3 on my Surface Pro. Not with everything maxed out, but a damn sight better than my 2011 Macbook Pro. It drives my 27" Dell display with no difficulty.
Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by nwh on Thursday February 21, 2013 @03:40AM (#5256218)
> Win8 on an SSD cold boots to a working desktop with network connection in 7 seconds flat.

Oddly enough, it's not booting. Clicking "Shut down" is hibernation in Windows 8.

Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by ygra on Thursday February 21, 2013 @03:47AM (#5256239)
It hibernates session 0 and the kernel, indeed. But that's a nitpicker's distinction. To the end user the result is the same, it just boots faster.
Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by Dylan16807 on Thursday February 21, 2013 @03:55AM (#5256274)
It's not a nitpick when you're trying to use the high-success-rate "turn it off and on again" method of fixing problems.
Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by raverbashing on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:13AM (#5256364)
That died around Windows 2000. Really

Restarting a software is one thing. Windows?

(Well, sometimes it locks up or reboots by itself, usually because of a bad driver or bad hardware)

Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by Dylan16807 on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:16AM (#5256375)
I'm worried about flaky drivers, really. Drivers lead to most of my reboots. If it only purges the user state then it's not resetting what I need.
Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by raverbashing on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:20AM (#5256396)
Yes. I'm skeptical with this "saves the state of drives" because that's not 100% possible, there's always some reinitializing that should take place

So I'm assuming it redoes some things and doesn't just uses everything, so it's something like a partial reinitialization

But maybe MS thought of that and you have an option to start/stop drivers (actually you can do that on any modern windows)

Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by ygra on Thursday February 21, 2013 @05:01AM (#5256547)
If you do a reboot (i.e. click Restart, not Shut down) it won't half-hibernate.
Re:Why did Microsoft make Windows 8 hard to Power Off? by UnoriginalGuy on Thursday February 21, 2013 @04:46AM (#5256488)
It is only nitpicking until it causes problems (e.g. driver XYZ tells you to "restart" your PC, so you "shutdown" for the night expecting it to do the job - but it won't).

I have no issue with Fast Startup in Windows 8, but frankly feel like the way Microsoft is abusing terminology is borderline lying to people.

They're trying to mislead people into thinking that Windows 8 has a better boot performance than Windows 7, when in fact Windows 8 and Windows 7 have very similar boot performance (from real cold-boot).