News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by derefr on Sunday February 17, 2013 @04:25AM (#5234694)
After the initial reaction of "Neato!" I started thinking what it would mean if when I first got my legos (a big tub, hand-me-down from an older cousin), they had come with a few dozen of these. I can't imagine what I would have built, but it certainly would have been more interesting... and I might have grown up with somewhat stronger convictions about interoperability and the senselessness of walled gardens :)
Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by anigbrowl on Sunday February 17, 2013 @04:31AM (#5234710)
I don't find walled gardens senseless at all. One of the nice things about a box full of Lego (not legos) is that you can take consistency for granted. It's the difference between a language with a clear grammar and a pidgin language.

I'm not against things like this, but there's no guarantee of interoperability producing superior results. You're just as likely to end up with a chaotic mess if you don't build with a plan in mind; one of the other benefits of a single system is that it forces you into more creative problem-solving.

Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by danboarder on Sunday February 17, 2013 @04:42AM (#5234734)
I agree with your first point that 'walled gardens' or closed systems like Lego provide consistency, however the second video in the linked article demonstrates a kid who I would argue is more creative by thinking beyond one system. ( https://vimeo.com/37778890 ) In the video he is "thinking outside the box" and building a car by connecting three different construction kits. Of course this requires him to have an understanding of all three systems (rather than just one), but the potential is to build things by that would otherwise not be possible. [edit - link to video]
Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by derefr on Sunday February 17, 2013 @05:39AM (#5234852)
> Lego (not legos)

Actually, "Lego® bricks." Lego severely admonishes using their name as a noun, whether pluralized or not. But, due to that admonishment and a thing called reactance[1], I was being purposefully breezy with my language. :)

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reactance_(psychology)

Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by vacri on Sunday February 17, 2013 @06:12AM (#5234894)
Any time you see a demand to use special characters or formatting in 'how you should refer to our stuff', feel free to completely ignore it, since at that point it's just marketing fluff.

I remember one company whose marketing department demanded that every mention of our product be in the assigned font, bolded, with part of the name subscripted and ®'d. Even in support emails. Even in followups. They never saw just how amazingly artificial it was and how it actually created (mild) barriers to rapport with users. Needless to say, everyone in sales and support that had a clue decided to put that directive into the round file.

Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by andybak on Sunday February 17, 2013 @06:21AM (#5234905)
I agree. However - 'Legos' is just stupid. Who decided a single brick was a 'lego' and therefore the plural was 'legos'? It sounds bizarre to me as a Brit :)

PS It's maths, not math.

Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by Cyranix on Sunday February 17, 2013 @01:42PM (#5236173)
Genericization happens all the time. Many brands throughout modern history have fallen into similar patterns[0] (capitalization sometimes, but not always, survives). Where I grew up in Mississippi, many people would refer to soft drinks as "[Cc]oke" which led to interesting excerpts such as "What kind of coke do you want? We have Coke, Sprite, Dr. Pepper...".

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genericization

Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by vacri on Sunday February 17, 2013 @06:40AM (#5234936)
I was thinking about this, and I'm not sure what the rule is.

On the one hand you have 'Meccano', 'Playmobile' and similar, when referring to collections of brand items.

But on the other hand, you would refer to a single brand car park as 'Toyotas' or a collection of single brand laptops as 'Lenovos' without anyone batting an eye.

I'm with you - 'legos' sounds stupid to me - but really I need someone more formally trained in grammar for this one :)

Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by alex-g on Sunday February 17, 2013 @07:36AM (#5235036)
It comes down to whether the stuff is perceived as lots of little indistinguishable bits, or a few big chunks. The former category (mass or non-count nouns) includes water, grain (in the sense of a quantity of grain, not lots of kinds of grains), sand, snow, etc. They are not inflected for the plural and do not take numbers - we say "three grains of sand" not "three sands". It's plausible for Lego to work the same way - so "ten pieces of lego", not "ten legos".

Perhaps in these oft-cited days of lego sets that are more like a few big pieces than lots of little pieces, people will start to think differently.

Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by Timmmmbob on Monday February 18, 2013 @11:52AM (#5239155)
Exactly. In English "Lego" is a mass noun, like water and sand. We say "a piece of lego" or "a lego piece" to identify a single brick.

I guess in American they don't treat it as a mass noun, and maybe they say "a lego" instead of "a piece of lego".

Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by Swizec on Sunday February 17, 2013 @09:07AM (#5235217)
"three sands" sounds like something Clarkson would say ... I think, his image immediately flashed in my mind when reading that.
Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by tedyoung on Sunday February 17, 2013 @05:08PM (#5236932)
Look, if you're going to be pedantic about it, at least be correctly pedantic. It's not Lego®, it's LEGO® (all caps), as in "LEGO® is a trademark of the LEGO Group..." etc.

:D

Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by bostonpete on Monday February 18, 2013 @12:24PM (#5239349)
The pedantry over lego/legos debates seems to be inescapable on HN any time legos are mentioned. Some people call them legos people -- get over it.
Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by jlgaddis on Monday February 18, 2013 @01:21PM (#5239650)
The pedantry period is inescapable. I really wish that would change. Everyone wants to be right, though.
Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by unclebucknasty on Sunday February 17, 2013 @06:47AM (#5234949)
Somehow your comment reminds me of the American public education system. It enforces a rigid, highly structured, linear way of thinking. It is very much rules-based. In fact, we spend much of our time learning rules vs. how to think.

The notion that a single construction system is better fits with this. It expresses a desire to eliminate variables, clearly define the rules, create a very tight system, etc. But, I think the statement that it forces you into more creative problem solving is exactly backwards. It may encourage resourcefulness, which entails some creativity to be sure. But, it asks "what can be done within a confined, limited space?" vs. "what can be done if there were virtually no limits?"

As Americans, I think we need to improve upon the latter style of thinking. It is the source of true invention and creativity vs. mere innovation or improvement upon existing creations as encouraged by the former.

Maybe this is, in part, why we see so many copycat startups and businesses built upon some iterative improvement to an existing process or idea. Instead of always asking, "how can we do something slightly better?", we need to ask more, "what else can we do?"

Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by anigbrowl on Sunday February 17, 2013 @04:34PM (#5236822)
That's amusing, because I'm not an American.

But, it asks "what can be done within a confined, limited space?" vs. "what can be done if there were virtually no limits?"

That's magical thinking. There are always limits, it's just a matter of which set you pick to work within. You can draw anything you like with a pencil and paper, but if you intend a representational drawing you'll still need to think about things like perspective and dimension, even if you are bending them like MC Escher. Otherwise you get finger paintings, and while I enjoy some aimless noodling as much as the next person (eg http://snd.sc/XeyYnD), it doesn't go anywhere in particular.

Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by unclebucknasty on Monday February 18, 2013 @11:02PM (#5242527)
Never said that you were an American; only that your post reminded me of the American public education system. BTW, I also did not claim that tne American system is unique. It is only the one with which I am most familiar.

Otherwise, I think it's safe to say that you missed my point. I am not advocating constant aimless noodling. I am saying that we focus here entirely too much on the importance of rules and not nearly enough on the creation of new rules.

In short, perhaps you took my statement regarding "virtually no limits" a bit too literally. As it is, you present a false choice between rigid, highly structured, rules-based thinking and pointless meandering about without any basis in reality. Certainly you see a middle ground?

As for my initial read on your comments, what triggered me was your statement that one system (with more rigid rules) inspired more creativity. In my view, you can argue other merits of such a system, but creativity is exactly not one of them. And true creativity is what we are sorely missing in this country and the world.

Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by unclebucknasty on Monday February 18, 2013 @11:15PM (#5242566)
BTW, I will also take you up on your "magical thinking" comment.

In fact, removing limits is sometimes exactly what's needed to spark true creativity. Holding the rules of the current system in one's head can be terribly limiting while trying to create something new. It binds one to what is vs what could be.

One can always start with the possibilities and later apply known rules. Creation is frequently an iterative process. There are many thinking styles and what seems counterintuitive to you may be what inspires others. In any case, a system that is relentlessly focused on rules certainly could use some balance. There is virtually no emphasis on pure creation or even critical thinking vs. fact-based learning.

Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by pekk on Sunday February 17, 2013 @08:32PM (#5237608)
I don't think this is an accurate description of that system. What's true about it is that it is dealing with scale issues that don't apply for home schooling, so they need to do things like having 1st-graders line up in order to go out to recess, trying to be consistent in how rules are applied, and worrying about the cost of production of cafeteria foods. These make the system look bureaucratic because bureaucracy is the simplest way to make an institution work at scale.

Also, this is an artifact of our culture: we are socializing kids into a system where they go sit at a desk and work within a bureaucracy because these are features of our culture. We are not pastoral nomads, we are not jungle hunter-gatherers, we are not inhabitants of tiny city-states. And most people in our society are not wealthy rockstar founders working in SF.

Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by unclebucknasty on Monday February 18, 2013 @11:31PM (#5242616)
When I mentioned rules, I wasn't referring to social rules, such as lining up for recess or not punching little Billy when the teacher's not looking.

Instead, I was referring to what we teach our kids academically. That is, we focus more on them knowing the "facts". I believe that we need to spend much more time teaching how to think creatively and critically. Yes, facts are important. We just need balance.

I agree with you 100% that we are teaching kids to work in a bureaucracy; creating "cogs for the machine", I like to say. But I think that's exactly the problem. We need to open up new opportunities for life fulfillment as well as paths to societal contributions. But it's a self-serving cycle. We need cogs so we teach kids to be rule-regurgitating cogs. But, how many more photo sharing apps do we need? OTOH we could use that cure for cancer or alternative fuel source or other thing that has yet to be imagined.

I argue that we could be much further down some of these paths if we taught our kids to imagine, think, and create in addition to teaching them the rules.

Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by napoleoncomplex on Sunday February 17, 2013 @05:06AM (#5234787)
Taking an analogy to programming languages, some languages are much better at specific tasks than others. Having the ability to use those languages interoperably with others makes it possible to construct a much more efficient system than if you would be forced to use one single language for everything.
Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by brudgers on Sunday February 17, 2013 @10:08AM (#5235396)
"forces you into more creative problem-solving."

Dealing with constraints is the essence of good design.

The interface kit creates a new set of design challenges, particularly with regard to color palette and materials - e.g. Kinects and Tinkertoys have map color to dimensions. Lincoln Logs map color to function. The connectors presumably have their own color. The challenge is expressing a design aesthetic rather than making a kludge.

The physical interface isn't enough.

Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by crisnoble on Sunday February 17, 2013 @10:41AM (#5235484)
Since we are talking about digital files here, you can print them what ever color you want, and even out off different materials such as stainless steel.
Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by nickpinkston on Sunday February 17, 2013 @12:00PM (#5235765)
In theory sure, but the color 3DP won't snap fit and the stainless doesn't have the tolerances to interface well. So really, there's a couple colors from: clear, white, gray, black to choose from.
Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by crisnoble on Sunday February 17, 2013 @12:06PM (#5235801)
The technology will only get better. If you were really wanting perfect pieces and had the skills you could use the files to create a die and use all any plastic or material you wanted to.
Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by eric_bullington on Sunday February 17, 2013 @06:41AM (#5234939)
Ah yes, but after a generation, a pidgin language (if passed on to a speaker's children) turns into a creole language, which is comparable in power, vocabulary, and expressiveness to any other language[0].

0. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creole_language

Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by devcpp on Sunday February 17, 2013 @10:29AM (#5235452)
How about a garden with directions on the ground? Like Android, that gives you suggestions with most popular apps. If anything, it fits everyone.

In the example of the legos, you could include a document with examples of what you can build, and note that at any moment you can improve anything here and there.

Re:The Free Universal Construction Kit by gcb0 on Sunday February 17, 2013 @05:27AM (#5234834)
Heh, also got from older cousins a total of 3 buckets. One of Lego, the other two from non-compatible brands.

It pissed me off that the Lego bucket had tons of pieces, but one of the other two had some custom pieces from a space shuttle that were awesome, but fitted nothing else.