However, my points are that a) we routinely pay 10x the 'value' of food products, and b) supermarkets piggy back off our conditioning by brands to offer us 'value' products which still cost 8x what they are worth without any of the advertising/marketing overhead.
The parallel would be if Macbook Airs were being made and delivered to Apple stores for $100, or cars were delivered to dealers at a cost of $2,000 and then sold to you for $20,000.
Things are worth what people will pay for them. As nirvana pointed out, looking at only the marginal production cost of something is highly misleading. Heinz makes about 36% gross margins [1], which is certainly good, but it's not as if they're seeing the 'value' of that '10x' markup. And lest you think the rest of their cost is advertising to fool people into spending too much on ketchup, their total marketing (not just ads) budget is only a few hundred million[2] (at least as of 2006) vs total revenue of over $10B.
[1] http://ycharts.com/companies/HNZ/gross_profit_margin
[2] http://adage.com/article/news/heinz-ceo-boost-ad-spend-proxy...
| Things are worth what people will pay for them.
If I pay $50 million for a forged Mona Lisa, does that mean that forgeries of the Mona Lisa are all worth $50 million?But people know what's in Heinz. They know what it tastes like. They keep buying it at the price Heinz and their grocer charges.
The other food that I will only buy one brand is Kraft Mac & Cheese. I know the stuff is nasty. I know it's bad for me. But, damn it that's what boxed Mac & Cheese is suppose to taste like.
How much a person will pay for something determines its "value" to them. If a person will pay $10 for a bottle of ketchup, then it doesn't matter what the production cost was, the value they received was at least $10.
For 99% of consumers, $2 is a value because it's less expensive than making it themselves. It doesn't matter how much it cost Heinz to make.
Back in the 60's before I was around, my mum worked in the accounting department of a mid-sized car dealer. Her job title was "Computer" because she'd update their books by hand. Later on they got the first electronic desktop calculator in the city and the local paper came by to do a story on this modern marvel.
http://www.seriouseats.com/2012/10/taste-test-the-best-ketch... http://lenpenzo.com/blog/id1481-ketchup-taste-test.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/09/13/the-best-ketchup_n_... http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1387285/Red-faced-He...
and many more taste tests. Not to say that not many people honestly prefer Heinz ketchup, but there seem to be no empirical evidence proving that Heinz would be the "best" ketchup.
What you're not considering is the value to the customer.
The incremental cost of a copy of Microsoft Office (with electronic delivery they cut out virtually all of their manufacturing cost) is close to zero. Probably 12p as well.
Yet Microsoft sells that Office Suite for $99 or much much more.
If the value of one copy of that office suite to a company is $10,000 in improved efficiency (eg: salaries saved by not having to pay overtime or hire as many people-- remember when spreadsheets were physical sheets of paper and companies had staffs of dozens of women whose sole job was to type up correspondence on typewriters?) then they are "profiting" even more than Microsoft is because the spread is wider.
Further, manufacturing costs are only one part of the costs of a product. Yes there's marketing, and advertising which you may hate, but there's also the offices that house the workers that run the company, the royalties paid to people who generate formulations, the taxes paid to the government, the manifold fees, costs, and expenses involved in running a business. All of these raise the actual "cost" from above the 12p manufacturing (and delivery costs I assume you included.)
For me, the value of buying a brand that has reliable quality control is often pretty high.
If a high quality bottle of ketchup elevates the satisfaction of an inexpensive meal (say fish & chips) to the point where it is on par with a much more expensive meal, like those workers using office, I may be getting more "profit" out of the transaction than the company.
This is how I use ketchup. It means I eat out less, and spend less on food and have a higher quality of life.