News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is It Cheating to Have a Side Project? by aaronbrethorst on Tuesday February 12, 2013 @09:11PM (#5210913)
I've always had side projects and have always disclosed my side projects to my boss. I want to be absolutely sure there are no surprises. In one case, I let things wait almost too long and had to tell my CEO that he shouldn't be surprised to see an article about my side project in the Seattle P-I the next day[1]. That was a mistake I've never repeated. Fortunately, there were no repercussions in that case. I got lucky.

Here are my thoughts:

* My side projects have—without fail—made me better at my day job. For instance, when I had my last 'real' job as an iOS developer for a startup, my side project was Cocoa Controls[2] (http://www.cocoacontrols.com), which shaved dozens-to-hundreds of hours off our development schedule.

* My side projects don't compete with my employer's line of business (or potential future directions). The last thing I want is to get embroiled in a lawsuit down the road over IP theft.

* My side projects never use company resources. That means no working on it at work, and no using that company laptop.

* I do my best not to discuss my side projects with my coworkers. I'm happy to chat about them if they bring them up, but I don't go out of my way to discuss them.

* Way back when, when I worked at Microsoft, I had to sign a moonlighting agreement that specifically spelled out what belonged to whom and what each party's responsibilities were. If your company doesn't have one, I recommend trying to introduce one.

[1] http://www.seattlepi.com/business/article/Seattle-startup-Di...

[2] Which is now my real job. Win.

Re:Is It Cheating to Have a Side Project? by alok-g on Tuesday February 12, 2013 @09:49PM (#5211050)
Legally speaking, merely mentioning it to your boss does not necessarily shield you from a lawsuit. It certainly reduces the likeliness though in my opinion (i.e., have no data).

Further, "employer's line of business" is very loosely defined. If you could share the technical skills between your job and the side project, you are most likely in the same line of business.

Here's a book I highly recommend: http://www.amazon.com/Intellectual-Property-Open-Source-Prot...

Re:Is It Cheating to Have a Side Project? by rst on Tuesday February 12, 2013 @10:36PM (#5211230)
I've got my boss (well, actually the CEO) to sign a paper acknowledging the side project, and disclaiming any interest on behalf of the company. Hopefully, that counts for at least a little more.
Re:Is It Cheating to Have a Side Project? by taylorbuley on Tuesday February 12, 2013 @10:43PM (#5211255)
You have a very progressive boss.
Re:Is It Cheating to Have a Side Project? by StavrosK on Tuesday February 12, 2013 @10:13PM (#5211149)
Wait, if you don't work on it at work, why does your employer care?
Re:Is It Cheating to Have a Side Project? by rst on Tuesday February 12, 2013 @10:43PM (#5211256)
Many employment agreements claim rights to anything the employee invents which is related to the business, whether or not on company time. And in some states, it's common for the claim to be on all inventions, whether related to the business or not.

(California has a carve-out in state law: an employer can't claim stuff that was not done on company time, nor with company resources, and which does not relate to the company's business. But many states, perhaps most, have no such carve-out. And even the California rules are subject to interpretation; what isn't related to the company's business if the company is Google? So, it's wise to consult a lawyer regardless...)

Re:Is It Cheating to Have a Side Project? by dredmorbius on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @12:44AM (#5211620)
Which is a very good reason for the smart kids to stick to California for their professional lives.

Trying to fight your way out from under a noncompete, or lawyer up on account of a side consulting gig or independently conceived and developed idea, really stinks. And the further you get in your career the more likely you'll encounter such a situation.

Such cases ultimately seriously dampen both enthusiasm for the employer, and the odds of finding talent interested in working under such a regime.

Of course, the ultimate negative would be for California's exceptions to be attacked by corporate interests.

Re:Is It Cheating to Have a Side Project? by gte910h on Thursday February 14, 2013 @03:19PM (#5221888)
>Which is a very good reason for the smart kids to stick to California for their professional lives.

Georgia recently amended our constitution to make non-competes much more likely.

I and much of the tech scene hugely lobbied against this effort, oh well. We didn't need to work for in state companies anyhow.

Re:Is It Cheating to Have a Side Project? by rwg on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @01:54AM (#5211799)
Coincidentally, universities are the absolute worst when it comes to "we own everything you ever do or think of" clauses in employment contracts, even if you're not a student or in a teaching/research position.

Those sorts of clauses really suck the fun out of life. "Gee, I'd have a hobby and share my work with the world, but my employer owns everything I do. I think I'll play video games instead. They can't take that from me!"

Re:Is It Cheating to Have a Side Project? by alok-g on Tuesday February 12, 2013 @10:20PM (#5211172)
I am not sure of the answer, but here is what I once read somewhere:

If, according to the contract you may have signed with the employer, the IP you create belongs to the employer, and that IP is earning a lot of money, then the employer is liable to the shareholders for recovering that money or an appropriate portion since it legally belongs to them.

This is in addition to the point in the OP, which is you may be exhausted while at work.

Re:Is It Cheating to Have a Side Project? by grumps on Tuesday February 12, 2013 @10:42PM (#5211253)
Yes... I've had to sign those contracts before. They are brutal. Equivalent to selling your soul.
Re:Is It Cheating to Have a Side Project? by JensenDied on Tuesday February 12, 2013 @11:44PM (#5211443)
My company has the following statement, which basically sais they shouldn't for any purpose outside of breaking non-compete/confidentiality.

Ability for <Company> Employees to Accept Project Work Outside of <Company> Time

It is the policy of <Company> to allow employees to accept and function as independent contractors for other companies/projects while on their own personal time. That being said, the non-compete/confidentiality agreement remains in force at all times and <Company> trusts that this binding agreement will be upheld on the part of all employees and contractors.