Re:US IT Wages set to Stagnate. Thank the Senate
by srl on Saturday February 09, 2013 @12:48AM
(#5191842)
The actual title: "Senators Marco Rubio, Orrin Hatch, Amy Klobuchar hate America". Lovely.
My political views are somewhat out of the norm for this site (even on immigration), so I'll restrain myself and just point out: if the amount the average IT worker was payed went up, that would increase the income disparity, not decrease it. The average IT wage is already higher than the average wage. So the real issue here isn't "income disparity will increase" - the real issue is "dey terk er jerbs!" A message that meshes quite nicely with the title.
Re:US IT Wages set to Stagnate. Thank the Senate
by moocow01 on Saturday February 09, 2013 @02:39AM
(#5192024)
I have to point out that this is incorrect. The simplified version is that if the workers are paid more a smaller piece of the megacorp's pie goes to the big whigs whether they are the shareholders or executives. In essence you have more distributed income amongst more people rather than it going to one or a few people. A situation where 1 person makes $20 and 9 make $1 has more income disparity than a situation where 1 person makes $15, 2 make $4 and 6 make $1.
Re:US IT Wages set to Stagnate. Thank the Senate
by jquery on Saturday February 09, 2013 @02:39AM
(#5192023)
Well, they aren't taking VC or CEO jobs. So if you're a big shot, you have nothing to worry about. Otherwise, you have a legitimate concern.
Want more Americans to major in STEM? Stop jacking up H1B visas every time the professions available start paying a wage commiserate with the intellect required.
Re:US IT Wages set to Stagnate. Thank the Senate
by daeken on Saturday February 09, 2013 @12:55AM
(#5191858)
Even if we multiplied the H1B count by 10, we still wouldn't have enough developers and other professionals to meet demand. If you look at the security industry, for instance, everyone is hiring. And hiring. And hiring. There's more work than anyone can possibly hope to meet while keeping up quality; there simply aren't enough bodies to fill chairs.
Yes, increasing the talent pool might drop the salaries of certain positions (competition does that), but it's not even a drop in the bucket in the grand scheme of things.
Re:US IT Wages set to Stagnate. Thank the Senate
by anonH1B on Saturday February 09, 2013 @10:12AM
(#5192717)
Speaking as a still-H1B techie, there are of course several shades in this issue, it's not black-and-white and definitely not pitch-black like this blog. In the bright side, I can assure you that my compensation at Google is above market average; also the company immediately sponsored my GC process so very soon I expect to be free from "H1B indenturing". Except there's no indenturing, because my stock grant is plenty motivation to not leave the company any time soon (not to mention amazing work etc.). I cannot speak for every Google hire on H1B, even less for other companies like MS; just giving my personal experience FWIW.
On the other hand, in a previous gig in the US (I first came through another H1B sponsor), I've suffered myself the consequences of low-grade H1B/tech hires; spent a few months in one of those Wall Street companies, sweating to salvage some horrendous code written by Wipro people who filled whole teams of said company. The problem of course is not their origin--I've also worked some great engineers from India--the problem is the H1B rules and GC backlogs, many Indians have to wait 10+ years for their GC, so they are easily victimized by abusive sponsors. (Some of what I say here apply to Chinese too, but let's avoid "India/China" repetition.)
To be fair, these extreme GC processing times are for EB3 (the lowest-skilled people); it could be argued that simply denying H1B for any Indian who wouldn't later qualify as EB1 or EB2 would make things better both for the American job market, and for the Indian engineers who are actually high-skilled. This solution can look unfair to others, but then again, it's hard to find a solution that's fair to everyone. For one thing, India/China's massive population is a problem; in a system without any per-country restrictions or backlogs, but with global restrictions like total H1B/year quotas, these two countries could swamp the immigration system (even more) in detriment to people from other countries who also don't have the benefit of large companies specialized in bringing people from your country to the US, or the network effect of a big, existing immigrant community. But even the EB2 backlog for Indians is long enough to often run into the 6-year H1B limit.
Another suggestion I have can sound like socialist heresy to many American ears, but... hell, just regulate the job market a little better. Or at least do that for people on H1B. Overtime work should be paid, with a premium rate of 50% minimum. Certain benefits such as decent healthcare coverage should be also mandatory. "Prevailing wage" should include average income from bonus and equity, in jobs where these benefits are prevailing. H1B workers should be allowed to easily transfer to another employer, with the only requirement that the new job pays equal or better in both salary and benefits. Companies that sponsor H1B's visa/relocation costs should be required to consider such costs fully paid in 12 months (that's typically enough to amortize those costs, as they typically put people to work in consulting jobs but take a fat markup on their salaries). Rules like these mean that H1B's would be even in some disadvantage competing with natives, but that's a good thing, would make the arguments in favor of H1B true which is good for Americans. And for us immigrants, the process wouldn't be any worse; I'll rather face the challenge of higher requirements of qualification before moving to another country, than the problem of moving easily just to be exploited for years and even suffer prejudice from native workers who blame immigrants for their low wages.
Re:US IT Wages set to Stagnate. Thank the Senate
by tcbawo on Saturday February 09, 2013 @12:49AM
(#5191844)
It all depends on whether they hire for quality or quantity. I've worked alongside some H1B workers who were top notch. But, I've seen the other side too. Finding good talent is incredibly hard. We probably won't have to worry about stagnant wages. Just don't get too attached to any employer, keep your skills marketable, and you'll be okay.
Re:US IT Wages set to Stagnate. Thank the Senate
by markahern on Saturday February 09, 2013 @02:14AM
(#5191987)
Surely having a concentration of world wide IT talent in the US is a good thing? Even aside from that, I would have thought protectionism is not something that will help the IT industry in any shape or form.
Re:US IT Wages set to Stagnate. Thank the Senate
by anonH1B on Saturday February 09, 2013 @02:02PM
(#5193554)
This doesn't look much, but that's from my perspective of a senior professional with a family and living in the greater NY region. Redmond may be cheaper, and surely for someone who is young, lives alone and doesn't yet have an exceptional resume, $100k is a ton of cash. BTW, we should all be happy to work in a profession where $100k can be even argued as "underpaid", remarkably in these difficult times... only 6.6% of individual Americans make that much (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_income_in_the_United_S...). And most of these have jobs that ain't any fun, such as lawyers or doctors. ;-)
Also you have to consider other items from his compensation. For one thing, it's well known that Microsoft's health benefit is awesome (they are self-insured so it's zero cost for employers IIRC), this alone can be worth >15K/year. And I guess he'll have 401(k) matching, some bonus, possibly a stock grant, maybe other perks like free food etc. You put all this together and this guy is certainly making better than $150k/year, possibly more.
My political views are somewhat out of the norm for this site (even on immigration), so I'll restrain myself and just point out: if the amount the average IT worker was payed went up, that would increase the income disparity, not decrease it. The average IT wage is already higher than the average wage. So the real issue here isn't "income disparity will increase" - the real issue is "dey terk er jerbs!" A message that meshes quite nicely with the title.
Want more Americans to major in STEM? Stop jacking up H1B visas every time the professions available start paying a wage commiserate with the intellect required.
Or better yet, make a better product and take the profits for yourself?
Dev is in high demand right now.
"The real issue is 'dey terk er jerbs!'" -> "I want security."
Yes, increasing the talent pool might drop the salaries of certain positions (competition does that), but it's not even a drop in the bucket in the grand scheme of things.
On the other hand, in a previous gig in the US (I first came through another H1B sponsor), I've suffered myself the consequences of low-grade H1B/tech hires; spent a few months in one of those Wall Street companies, sweating to salvage some horrendous code written by Wipro people who filled whole teams of said company. The problem of course is not their origin--I've also worked some great engineers from India--the problem is the H1B rules and GC backlogs, many Indians have to wait 10+ years for their GC, so they are easily victimized by abusive sponsors. (Some of what I say here apply to Chinese too, but let's avoid "India/China" repetition.)
To be fair, these extreme GC processing times are for EB3 (the lowest-skilled people); it could be argued that simply denying H1B for any Indian who wouldn't later qualify as EB1 or EB2 would make things better both for the American job market, and for the Indian engineers who are actually high-skilled. This solution can look unfair to others, but then again, it's hard to find a solution that's fair to everyone. For one thing, India/China's massive population is a problem; in a system without any per-country restrictions or backlogs, but with global restrictions like total H1B/year quotas, these two countries could swamp the immigration system (even more) in detriment to people from other countries who also don't have the benefit of large companies specialized in bringing people from your country to the US, or the network effect of a big, existing immigrant community. But even the EB2 backlog for Indians is long enough to often run into the 6-year H1B limit.
Another suggestion I have can sound like socialist heresy to many American ears, but... hell, just regulate the job market a little better. Or at least do that for people on H1B. Overtime work should be paid, with a premium rate of 50% minimum. Certain benefits such as decent healthcare coverage should be also mandatory. "Prevailing wage" should include average income from bonus and equity, in jobs where these benefits are prevailing. H1B workers should be allowed to easily transfer to another employer, with the only requirement that the new job pays equal or better in both salary and benefits. Companies that sponsor H1B's visa/relocation costs should be required to consider such costs fully paid in 12 months (that's typically enough to amortize those costs, as they typically put people to work in consulting jobs but take a fat markup on their salaries). Rules like these mean that H1B's would be even in some disadvantage competing with natives, but that's a good thing, would make the arguments in favor of H1B true which is good for Americans. And for us immigrants, the process wouldn't be any worse; I'll rather face the challenge of higher requirements of qualification before moving to another country, than the problem of moving easily just to be exploited for years and even suffer prejudice from native workers who blame immigrants for their low wages.
Also you have to consider other items from his compensation. For one thing, it's well known that Microsoft's health benefit is awesome (they are self-insured so it's zero cost for employers IIRC), this alone can be worth >15K/year. And I guess he'll have 401(k) matching, some bonus, possibly a stock grant, maybe other perks like free food etc. You put all this together and this guy is certainly making better than $150k/year, possibly more.