Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by tedunangst on Friday February 08, 2013 @01:38PM
(#5189382)
I really hate free to play. Having tried a few games in this category, I generally realized about ten minutes after installation I didn't download a game, I downloaded a money funnel. A lot of my gaming these days is casual on my phone, where this shit dominates the marketplace. I sincerely wish apple would create a separate $5 max spend gaming category (even a lot of paid games seem to make most of their profit from iap).
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by bitwize on Friday February 08, 2013 @02:42PM
(#5189705)
The difference is that your typical smartphone f2p game is like a strip club: they offer a taste, but limit the amount of fun you can have without digging into your pocket. Whereas TF2 sans headgear is still a blast to play. Hats are largely Veblen goods, and the standard weapons aren't "nerfed" compared to specialized weapons.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by Goronmon on Friday February 08, 2013 @02:12PM
(#5189551)
Having tried a few games in this category, I generally realized about ten minutes after installation I didn't download a game, I downloaded a money funnel.
The snarky response to this would be to stop downloading bad games.
There are plenty of good F2P games out there. Planetside 2, League of Legends, Path of Exile, etc. On mobile, there are games like Angry Birds that aren't just a money funnel. But honestly, you're going to have a tough time on the mobile space because IMO there just aren't that many games worth playing out there.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by jquery on Friday February 08, 2013 @04:51PM
(#5190334)
Just out of curiosity, how much does it cost, in money or time, to get all the heroes in League of Legends? It may be a good game, but it's also outrageously expensive. Unless you like playing a limited set of heroes.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by cookiecaper on Friday February 08, 2013 @01:59PM
(#5189495)
That's not the kind of "free to play" that Valve promotes. The phone apps are much, much more spammy. Valve mostly takes AAA games and can open them for free because the money they make as a facilitator between content creators and consumers pays for the game. The content makers make awesome stuff and get paid, the consumers get awesome stuff and have fun. Valve takes a commission for providing both the entertainment and payment platform. Everyone wins.
It's a one-way street on most phone apps. The devs write a little phone game, and then put 90% of it behind staged paywalls. Quite a different thing than what Gabe has done, and what he discusses here.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by tedunangst on Friday February 08, 2013 @04:11PM
(#5190170)
I guess I've never thought of TF2 as a AAA game. It was just a bonus you got for buying the Orange Box, or a kind of goodwill offering that kept you hooked on valve/steam. I'm not surprised their revenue spiked after making it free, I'm surprised people paid for it in the first place. :)
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by Pkeod on Friday February 08, 2013 @05:07PM
(#5190408)
>I'm surprised people paid for it in the first place. :)
Based on this, as a developer, I wouldn't take your opinion that you hate F2P games seriously, and I would never want to make games for the audience you belong to. TF2 is one of the best games available to play and my second favorite game ever made. Haters gonna hate.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by stcredzero on Friday February 08, 2013 @04:06PM
(#5190151)
> I really hate free to play. Having tried a few games in this category, I generally realized about ten minutes after installation I didn't download a game, I downloaded a money funnel.
Widespread scammy/spammy feeling greedy money-suckage? Sounds like great news to me! That shouts opportunity.
I think Valve has a formula that could do well in a market like that described above. You keep the size of the company small, so expenses are low, thus minimizing the temptation to money-suck. On top of that, you emphasize user-generated content. This increases the game's value, harnessing resources to compete with content ground-out by larger shops' payrolls, while offloading development risk for content to the users. The game makes money as a marketplace.
Most importantly, build your brand on an emphasis on quality and playability. Steer clear of the mentality that you give people something for free so you can addict them using variable schedule of reward to suck money out of them. Be genuinely focused on delivering fun and build the brand on that.
It's those companies who will eventually stand out over self-deluded hacks who can't see up over their own swollen greed. (I like that!)
tl;dr - Be true to and work with the passions of your userbase, and you'll stand out from the crowd of self-deluded hacks who can't see up over their own swollen greed.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by obviouslygreen on Friday February 08, 2013 @02:00PM
(#5189502)
It's certainly true that many free to play games fall into this category, but definitely not all of them... I don't do a lot of mobile gaming, but I do know there are decent games out there that won't make you hate your life with inane calls to action.
Robotek is an example of a great free-to-play game that does use in-app purchases, but doesn't require them (games that claim not to but basically do if you want to actually get anywhere are horrible).
Anecdotal evidence is crap, I know, and this is only one example (I've played others but can't recall them right now)... but the top earners are obviously always going to be the kind of money-pit BS you're talking about. That's a shame, but putting all free to play games -- with or without IAP/advertising/etc. -- into that category just isn't realistic.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by archagon on Friday February 08, 2013 @02:15PM
(#5189565)
Honestly, that kind of stuff is much closer to gambling than what I would consider gaming. I just really hope (though I'm probably wrong) that "social" games occupy their own niche and aren't pulling gamers away from more honest games.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by ishansharma on Friday February 08, 2013 @01:43PM
(#5189410)
And don't forget all the stuff that is shoved down your throat to make you more "engaged" with the game! Like touching a building to make it work, getting notified every 5 minutes of a completed action and what not. I find myself playing expensive but ad-free/not so purchase based games because of this. Need For Speed, GTA, Infinity Blade are a few names that come to mind!
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by archagon on Friday February 08, 2013 @01:30PM
(#5189324)
As a longtime gamer, I desparately fear the idea of a locked-down, touch-based, and endlessly monetizable future for my favorite hobby. What if the PC simply becomes unprofitable for major game releases because of the tablet market, ARM, or whatever else? What if gamers get used to touch controls and buttons become outmoded? What if the Facebook model of "social" games consumes every other genre? I can only hope that Newell's get-out-of-jail-free card will work as intended.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by stcredzero on Friday February 08, 2013 @04:24PM
(#5190233)
> As a longtime gamer, I desparately fear the idea of a locked-down, touch-based, and endlessly monetizable future for my favorite hobby.
Games for intelligent people who aren't variable-reward-schedule drones will always be around. I would like to invent such games that are touch based. I don't see any reason why this can't be done.
One influence that the keyboard has, with it's very large number of buttons, is a tendency towards bloated, intellectually uninteresting (for most people, excepting the deep end of the Aspberger's spectrum) complexity of a phenomenological nature. Let's have lots of arbitrarily determined entities that interact in arbitrary ways, but dress this up in a sci-fi/military/fantasy context. It's the same reason card games tend to have the same sort of complexity. Lots of cards can fit in a deck. Lots of keys on a keyboard. Gotta use them!
The reason why games like Angry Birds and World of Goo have such wide appeal, is that they combine relatively few principles that have the elegance of math or physics (because they are math & physics) allowing them to generate genuinely emergent complexity of the kind most human brains find fascinating.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by untog on Friday February 08, 2013 @01:48PM
(#5189434)
I think the PC has already become unprofitable for many (Valve are one of the exceptions, and they clearly see writing on the wall). There are very few PC releases that aren't primarily console titles.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by ameen on Friday February 08, 2013 @02:21PM
(#5189602)
PC Gaming is alive and well. It's just that they don't spend millions on marketing themselves. Minecraft, GoG, Diablo 3, WoW, LoL all are standing examples that PC Gaming works.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by chc on Friday February 08, 2013 @04:22PM
(#5190224)
Going by release dates (which is how we normally gauge console games' ages), League of Legends is about three years old, MineCraft is about a year and a half old (a lot of people forget this because it had both an open alpha and open beta, unlike any console game I know of) and Diablo 3 is not even one year old yet. Their average age is less than two years unless you're counting time in development, by which standard GTA V (due to release late this year) is like three years old.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by georgemcbay on Friday February 08, 2013 @06:33PM
(#5190788)
To be fair, it throws the average way down and also it isn't entirely fair to use the 2004 date since they have been releasing expansions throughout the life of the game, but I still don't think the original list is a sign of a healthy overall market for PC games (though it is proof that the right game hitting the right market can still make a significant amount of money on the PC).
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by ryusage on Friday February 08, 2013 @03:59PM
(#5190107)
Granted I have no numbers, but between the convenience of Steam, the seasonal sales, and the fact that it's trivial to use an Xbox 360 controller on a PC...I just don't see this. Why would they bother releasing on PC at all if it wasn't profitable? If anything, it seems like more console games than ever are getting cross platform releases on to PC. Personally, I'm seeing less and less reason to own a console at all. My xbox is really just a netflix player these days.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by ishansharma on Friday February 08, 2013 @01:36PM
(#5189368)
I'd hate that future. Free to play model is not so good in my opinion, it just serves the game makers as they can make us cash cows.
I remember playing Sim City a lot on my computer. It was fun. I tried a similar game on my iPad which was free to play but it turned out very Facebook like. No options to speed up, I have to touch the buildings to make them work and all that stuff.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by drucken on Friday February 08, 2013 @01:31PM
(#5189335)
So much self-serving rhetoric.
How are "input methods" a major PC flaw? The platform is almost completely open!
Even closed platforms use input methods that can often interroperate with PCs. Or the input methods are independently available for the PC.
The only thing of interest in that speech would be just how much Newell is struggling to hedge his bets, yet completely ignoring the elephants in the room, e.g. his console competitors...
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by roc on Friday February 08, 2013 @01:46PM
(#5189430)
> "The platform is almost completely open!"
That's kind of the problem. You can do anything, and plenty of people are. But there's no platform 'boss' to lay down standards.
Aside from (fleeting) de-facto standards (particular flight sticks in years past; the 360 gamepad today) input support on the PC is a pain point for devs. Shoddy drivers, shoddy APIs, shoddy manufacturer support -- to say nothing of the state of vision, voice and touch.
There's a reason PC games are treading water with support for little-to-nothing beyond kb/m and dodgy/partial support for the 360 gamepad here and there.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by phaus on Friday February 08, 2013 @01:55PM
(#5189474)
The keyboard / mouse combo is the ideal way to control many types of games.
Edit: I was addressing this comment, not claiming that the keyboard is superior in all situations.
>There's a reason PC games are treading water with support for little-to-nothing beyond kb/m and dodgy/partial support for the 360 gamepad here and there.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by untog on Friday February 08, 2013 @02:03PM
(#5189521)
Sure. But it doesn't fit the living room environment very well. You can dispute whether that's where the PC is headed, but it's what Valve thinks, so their logic is at least consistent.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by archagon on Friday February 08, 2013 @02:18PM
(#5189584)
Yes, and not so great for others. Have you tried playing Batman: Arkham Asylum with a mouse/keyboard? Those combos are so much harder to pull off! What about 3D platformers, where analog movement is paramount? Racing games, where analog steering and acceleration really help?
Nowadays, I find that I use my PC gamepad as often as my mouse/keyboard.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by phaus on Friday February 08, 2013 @03:31PM
(#5189933)
I agree that it's not so great for others, but I never claimed it was ideal for ALL genres.
If implemented correctly, a M/K control scheme can be just as good if not better than an analog controller for a 3d platform game. I played both Tomb Raider and Super Mario 64 all the way through when they were released (which was around the same time), but neither control scheme seemed to have an obvious advantage.
More recently, I played some of the Assassin's Creed games on the PC, and the control was pretty much perfect. When the first one came out, I remember some reviewers were surprised to find that they liked the PC version's controls more than the console version's.
For racing games, I agree, the analog controller is superior. It's also superior for fighting games and sports games.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by phaus on Friday February 08, 2013 @03:36PM
(#5189971)
As I stated above, I agree that analog controllers are better than a M/K for racing games.
As for flight simulators, I guess it depends on what you mean by a flight sim. Old school flight sims are where I got my start in gaming, back in the early to mid 90s when they at least tried to seem realistic. Lately, it seems that most "flight sims" are arcade shooters with historically accurate aircraft models.
If you are playing an arcade game, the console controllers are superior; if you are playing an actual flight sim, console controllers and the mouse / keyboard combo are absolutely terrible, with the mouse/keyboard getting a slight edge due to the impossibility of implementing that many commands on a console controller.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by checker on Friday February 08, 2013 @03:59PM
(#5190112)
Hopefully a direct thought/muscle tension interpreter will become feasible and eliminate the need for this argument. It would also eliminate common cases of RSI.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by roc on Friday February 08, 2013 @08:41PM
(#5191150)
1. I never said keyboard/mouse was bad. I said no-one's branching out, despite the open platform, because the lack of standards and support makes that painful.
2. You may want to keep survivorship bias in mind. (If you had a game that kb/m wasn't ideal for, would you even bother releasing it on the PC?)
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by ishansharma on Friday February 08, 2013 @01:40PM
(#5189394)
Completely agree with you. However, one thing to note is that while PCs are open as of now, both Microsoft and Apple are moving in closed direction. With Windows and App Store, what is there that stops them from making it difficult to install anything outside the store?
Power users will surely complain a lot, but I don't think an average customer will do much!
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by untog on Friday February 08, 2013 @01:47PM
(#5189431)
How are "input methods" a major PC flaw? The platform is almost completely open!
That's kind of the problem, though- the market is too fragmented. Microsoft can release the Kinect as the control device to buy, and everyone does. Meanwhile, the PC has has five competing devices sharing a smaller market.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by mahyarm on Friday February 08, 2013 @02:06PM
(#5189530)
I think by input methods he means number of users with the input methods. Every wii user has the wiimote. MS heavily promotes the kinect. Not many users in PC land have joysticks for example and that limits games that would like to use it as a main control mechanism.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by cookiecaper on Friday February 08, 2013 @02:43PM
(#5189709)
>How are "input methods" a major PC flaw? The platform is almost completely open!
He didn't say input methods on PC were flawed, he said that PC gamers have been slow to accept and/or develop innovative input methods. This is pretty much his one and only criticism of the PC market, and he said this in the context of "PCs are super cool because they've been the best and coolest in everything forever (except new input methods)!"
>The only thing of interest in that speech would be just how much Newell is struggling to hedge his bets, yet completely ignoring the elephants in the room, e.g. his console competitors...
Wat. The whole point of the talk is that he's going to bring a small form-factor "PC box" to the living room. It will look and function like a console to the layman, but it will not require reimplementation of everything, it will automatically work with PC players online, manufacturers will be able to make and sell custom "Steam boxes" a la Android mobiles.
The whole thing says, "We're going to pwn 'consoles' with our new thing, because it's the best of both worlds; the normal person sees it as a console, but it's still a free and open ecosystem, the work is already done, and the communities are already there."
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by ameen on Friday February 08, 2013 @02:26PM
(#5189626)
Gabe Newell is only trying to realign himself. The Windows-download market is getting crowded with better and more efficient service providers - GoG.com, Humble Store, Desura, GMG, GG, Impulse, etc.
Valve will be beaten by both bigger and smaller competitors (Ouya, Apple, Sony/MS), all thanks to Valve time.
Re:Newell reveals major PC flaw, the future business of game...
by suresk on Friday February 08, 2013 @02:15PM
(#5189566)
I'm primarily a PC gamer, although I certainly see the benefits consoles bring to the table (cheaper, easier, much better for in-person multiplayer).
I'm really dreading the death of PC gaming for one reason - controls. For a lot of game types, nothing comes close to the keyboard/mouse combo. For example, how many good RTS games have shown up on consoles? That is largely because of the input situation.
I really think there needs to be a rich, precise input device for consoles, and I don't think things like Kinect, as cool as they are, are the answer. When I see games like StarCraft, Company of Heroes, and World of Warcraft ending up on consoles without being horribly dumbed-down, I'll feel a little better.
The snarky response to this would be to stop downloading bad games.
There are plenty of good F2P games out there. Planetside 2, League of Legends, Path of Exile, etc. On mobile, there are games like Angry Birds that aren't just a money funnel. But honestly, you're going to have a tough time on the mobile space because IMO there just aren't that many games worth playing out there.
It's a one-way street on most phone apps. The devs write a little phone game, and then put 90% of it behind staged paywalls. Quite a different thing than what Gabe has done, and what he discusses here.
Based on this, as a developer, I wouldn't take your opinion that you hate F2P games seriously, and I would never want to make games for the audience you belong to. TF2 is one of the best games available to play and my second favorite game ever made. Haters gonna hate.
Widespread scammy/spammy feeling greedy money-suckage? Sounds like great news to me! That shouts opportunity.
I think Valve has a formula that could do well in a market like that described above. You keep the size of the company small, so expenses are low, thus minimizing the temptation to money-suck. On top of that, you emphasize user-generated content. This increases the game's value, harnessing resources to compete with content ground-out by larger shops' payrolls, while offloading development risk for content to the users. The game makes money as a marketplace.
Most importantly, build your brand on an emphasis on quality and playability. Steer clear of the mentality that you give people something for free so you can addict them using variable schedule of reward to suck money out of them. Be genuinely focused on delivering fun and build the brand on that.
It's those companies who will eventually stand out over self-deluded hacks who can't see up over their own swollen greed. (I like that!)
tl;dr - Be true to and work with the passions of your userbase, and you'll stand out from the crowd of self-deluded hacks who can't see up over their own swollen greed.
Robotek is an example of a great free-to-play game that does use in-app purchases, but doesn't require them (games that claim not to but basically do if you want to actually get anywhere are horrible).
Anecdotal evidence is crap, I know, and this is only one example (I've played others but can't recall them right now)... but the top earners are obviously always going to be the kind of money-pit BS you're talking about. That's a shame, but putting all free to play games -- with or without IAP/advertising/etc. -- into that category just isn't realistic.
Games for intelligent people who aren't variable-reward-schedule drones will always be around. I would like to invent such games that are touch based. I don't see any reason why this can't be done.
One influence that the keyboard has, with it's very large number of buttons, is a tendency towards bloated, intellectually uninteresting (for most people, excepting the deep end of the Aspberger's spectrum) complexity of a phenomenological nature. Let's have lots of arbitrarily determined entities that interact in arbitrary ways, but dress this up in a sci-fi/military/fantasy context. It's the same reason card games tend to have the same sort of complexity. Lots of cards can fit in a deck. Lots of keys on a keyboard. Gotta use them!
The reason why games like Angry Birds and World of Goo have such wide appeal, is that they combine relatively few principles that have the elegance of math or physics (because they are math & physics) allowing them to generate genuinely emergent complexity of the kind most human brains find fascinating.
I remember playing Sim City a lot on my computer. It was fun. I tried a similar game on my iPad which was free to play but it turned out very Facebook like. No options to speed up, I have to touch the buildings to make them work and all that stuff.
How are "input methods" a major PC flaw? The platform is almost completely open!
Even closed platforms use input methods that can often interroperate with PCs. Or the input methods are independently available for the PC.
The only thing of interest in that speech would be just how much Newell is struggling to hedge his bets, yet completely ignoring the elephants in the room, e.g. his console competitors...
That's kind of the problem. You can do anything, and plenty of people are. But there's no platform 'boss' to lay down standards.
Aside from (fleeting) de-facto standards (particular flight sticks in years past; the 360 gamepad today) input support on the PC is a pain point for devs. Shoddy drivers, shoddy APIs, shoddy manufacturer support -- to say nothing of the state of vision, voice and touch.
There's a reason PC games are treading water with support for little-to-nothing beyond kb/m and dodgy/partial support for the 360 gamepad here and there.
Edit: I was addressing this comment, not claiming that the keyboard is superior in all situations.
>There's a reason PC games are treading water with support for little-to-nothing beyond kb/m and dodgy/partial support for the 360 gamepad here and there.
Nowadays, I find that I use my PC gamepad as often as my mouse/keyboard.
If implemented correctly, a M/K control scheme can be just as good if not better than an analog controller for a 3d platform game. I played both Tomb Raider and Super Mario 64 all the way through when they were released (which was around the same time), but neither control scheme seemed to have an obvious advantage.
More recently, I played some of the Assassin's Creed games on the PC, and the control was pretty much perfect. When the first one came out, I remember some reviewers were surprised to find that they liked the PC version's controls more than the console version's.
For racing games, I agree, the analog controller is superior. It's also superior for fighting games and sports games.
It is OK for most games, but not ideal.
As for flight simulators, I guess it depends on what you mean by a flight sim. Old school flight sims are where I got my start in gaming, back in the early to mid 90s when they at least tried to seem realistic. Lately, it seems that most "flight sims" are arcade shooters with historically accurate aircraft models.
If you are playing an arcade game, the console controllers are superior; if you are playing an actual flight sim, console controllers and the mouse / keyboard combo are absolutely terrible, with the mouse/keyboard getting a slight edge due to the impossibility of implementing that many commands on a console controller.
2. You may want to keep survivorship bias in mind. (If you had a game that kb/m wasn't ideal for, would you even bother releasing it on the PC?)
If you're a dev and want to make a game, do you make it so that it can only be used by a few thousand people, or by everybody on the platform?
I think Nintendo learned this lesson (somewhat) the hard way until they released the Wii. Peripherals don't sell.
Input devices like this have been common on PC for a while now, just for specialized games.
http://www.naturalpoint.com/trackir/products/trackir5/
Power users will surely complain a lot, but I don't think an average customer will do much!
That's kind of the problem, though- the market is too fragmented. Microsoft can release the Kinect as the control device to buy, and everyone does. Meanwhile, the PC has has five competing devices sharing a smaller market.
Now, you can argue about weather that's true, but it's not immediately dismissed as "self serving".
He's nodding to consoles here.
He didn't say input methods on PC were flawed, he said that PC gamers have been slow to accept and/or develop innovative input methods. This is pretty much his one and only criticism of the PC market, and he said this in the context of "PCs are super cool because they've been the best and coolest in everything forever (except new input methods)!"
>The only thing of interest in that speech would be just how much Newell is struggling to hedge his bets, yet completely ignoring the elephants in the room, e.g. his console competitors...
Wat. The whole point of the talk is that he's going to bring a small form-factor "PC box" to the living room. It will look and function like a console to the layman, but it will not require reimplementation of everything, it will automatically work with PC players online, manufacturers will be able to make and sell custom "Steam boxes" a la Android mobiles.
The whole thing says, "We're going to pwn 'consoles' with our new thing, because it's the best of both worlds; the normal person sees it as a console, but it's still a free and open ecosystem, the work is already done, and the communities are already there."
Valve will be beaten by both bigger and smaller competitors (Ouya, Apple, Sony/MS), all thanks to Valve time.
I'm really dreading the death of PC gaming for one reason - controls. For a lot of game types, nothing comes close to the keyboard/mouse combo. For example, how many good RTS games have shown up on consoles? That is largely because of the input situation.
I really think there needs to be a rich, precise input device for consoles, and I don't think things like Kinect, as cool as they are, are the answer. When I see games like StarCraft, Company of Heroes, and World of Warcraft ending up on consoles without being horribly dumbed-down, I'll feel a little better.
What is the "major PC flaw"? The input methods that did not evolve? Kinect says hello! Apart from that, many gamers use controllers on PCs.