News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We should only work 25 hours a week, argues professor by ekianjo on Sunday February 03, 2013 @09:23PM (#5162110)
> what will likely be a post-labor world

Says who ? This preposterous way of thinking has been around for x years already. "when the world population will reach 4 billions people, there will be no jobs for everyone", yet the population is still increasing beyond 6 billions and most people still work to live/survive. There is no hint we are moving to a post-labor world.

You will see that there is a strong relationship between reduced employment/working hours, welfare benefits when not working, and government spending. And somehow most of the countries which went down that way have now humongous public debt problems to solve. Their model is not sustainable in the long term.

Re:We should only work 25 hours a week, argues professor by zanny on Sunday February 03, 2013 @09:33PM (#5162152)
Well one, getting to post-labor has nothing to do with raw population figures. No matter how many people you have, they want to eat, probably want comfortable living (housing + climate control), and in a modern context want Internet access and electricity.

You could have a hundred billion people and everyone would still want that. The difference is post-labor comes when you don't need human capital (or at the worst, a negligible amount) to produce the necessities for people to survive. We are approaching that, look at how manufacturing is returning to the US in 99% automated facilities. Once you can grow food (or fabricate it with molecular engineering) without requiring human labor to produce it, you can already distribute it with automated vehicles, and you can produce electricity via solar, hydro, or nuclear wtih very little human capital involvement after you set the system up.

The idea is you put systems in place that the fruits of them are effectively infinite without human engagement. Once you can do that, you have post-scarcity bounded on the limits of the planet and our ability to deploy infrastructure, not in how much labor we can produce. We are getting there, but the fundamental problem is we try to squeeze these no labor return systems into classic market capitalism and it isn't working (a concentrated wealthy class ends up owning these means of production, and power and wealth are concentrated as a result).

Re:We should only work 25 hours a week, argues professor by rndmize on Sunday February 03, 2013 @09:32PM (#5162146)
You seem to be misunderstanding something. A post-labor has nothing to do with population and everything to do with automation. As it becomes more efficient to have robots and computers to do what was previously human work, we will eventually reach a point where just about every conceivable job that we currently employ people for could be automated.

Most likely, a post-labor world should be capable of arriving well before that. Once we can automate the production of basic necessities, working should become largely optional.

Re:We should only work 25 hours a week, argues professor by ekianjo on Sunday February 03, 2013 @09:43PM (#5162178)
Even if you have robots you will still need a massive workforce to produce them, to get the resources to produce them, to check them, to maintain them, to repair them, to program them, to update them and so on. Or maybe you believe in a state of singularity in which all of this will happen at the same time? :)

Automation has already been happening in many industries, in case you have not noticed, and that did not result in lost job opportunities on the whole of the economy. Agriculture is also largely mechanized all around the world and you have only a very little portion of the population (5% or so) in developed countries to produce far enough for everyone.

Most jobs in developed countries are service related. These jobs will not disappear even if you automate the production part of the economy.

Re:We should only work 25 hours a week, argues professor by mkl on Sunday February 03, 2013 @10:03PM (#5162219)
Most jobs in developed countries are service related. These jobs will not disappear even if you automate the production part of the economy.

Why not? They already are. Self-checkout, online forms and purchases, ATMs, touch tone phone menus, etc.

Here is Marshall Brain's optimistic but well explained and convincing view: http://www.marshallbrain.com/robotic-nation.htm

Re:We should only work 25 hours a week, argues professor by Strshps1MoreTim on Sunday February 03, 2013 @10:03PM (#5162218)
Exactly, nowadays the majority of people in the developed world are "working" in marketing, finance and other useless areas. It would be far better if they just stay home.
Re:We should only work 25 hours a week, argues professor by bluedanieru on Sunday February 03, 2013 @10:03PM (#5162217)
So what, then, do you think the purpose of technological advancement is? Quality of life and wages have more-or-less flat-lined while productivity is way, way up. We are producing heaps more wealth per person than at any point in history, and yet we don't have much to show for it. Nowhere near proportional to the productivity increases, that's for certain.

Don't misunderstand, I'm not a Luddite by any stretch and I'm not suggesting we should go back to an agrarian society, but we have a serious economic and political problem where the benefits of technological advancement are going in overwhelming proportion to a very small subset of the population. If something isn't done about that, and soon, the resulting upheaval may force us back to pre-industrial living anyway (or more likely, much worse).

Re:We should only work 25 hours a week, argues professor by judgardner on Sunday February 03, 2013 @10:33PM (#5162292)
> Quality of life and wages have more-or-less flat-lined while productivity is way, way up.

Can you support this? Millions of people all over the world are being lifted out of poverty.

Here is a chart of per capita GNI for the past 20 years http://www.google.com/publicdata/explore?ds=d5bncppjof8f9_&#...

edi: linked wrong chart

Re:We should only work 25 hours a week, argues professor by svachalek on Monday February 04, 2013 @01:31AM (#5162794)
GNI is just a grand total divided by population; people would be making more if the money was divided up evenly but it's not, particularly in the U.S.
Re:We should only work 25 hours a week, argues professor by judgardner on Monday February 04, 2013 @04:36AM (#5163278)
> GNI is just a grand total divided by population;

Right, per capita, as I stated, but really just GNI is fine too.

> people would be making more if the money was divided up evenly but it's not, particularly in the U.S

Unfortunately the google public data didn't have enough US data but take a look at these two charts for India.

First is just India's per capita GNI the second is India's income distribution over the same time frame. Notice how the income distribution is relatively flat and how the GNI is growing.

http://www.google.com/publicdata/explore?ds=d5bncppjof8f9_&#...

http://www.google.com/publicdata/explore?ds=d5bncppjof8f9_&#...

Re:We should only work 25 hours a week, argues professor by afterburner on Monday February 04, 2013 @01:50AM (#5162843)
Actually, the wealth has accrued quite nicely to the top 1%, even more so to the top 0.01%. Whereas the rest of the population has seen real pay flatline as you say. That is the real problem.
Re:We should only work 25 hours a week, argues professor by tossacct on Sunday February 03, 2013 @10:50PM (#5162332)
>>>Nowhere near proportional to the productivity increases, that's for certain.

What is the proper proportion?

Re:We should only work 25 hours a week, argues professor by svachalek on Monday February 04, 2013 @01:34AM (#5162805)
Why not 1:1?
Re:We should only work 25 hours a week, argues professor by tossacct on Monday February 04, 2013 @01:54AM (#5162859)
Would you care to share your measuring system for how do decide if it is 1:1 or not? It seems complex to measure health, "wealth", happiness, and security. I sure haven't found any actionable or reasonably complete metrics in my readings, maybe I am bad at searching.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quality_of_life

Re:We should only work 25 hours a week, argues professor by jdotjdot on Sunday February 03, 2013 @10:37PM (#5162306)
I think this is an excellent point.
Re:We should only work 25 hours a week, argues professor by _delirium on Sunday February 03, 2013 @09:30PM (#5162137)
> And somehow most of the countries which went down that way have now humongous public debt problems to solve.

This is just ideology, and not factually accurate. (P.S. Cheers from Scandinavia.)

Re:We should only work 25 hours a week, argues professor by ekianjo on Sunday February 03, 2013 @09:32PM (#5162145)
Not just ideology, the size of government in Scandinavia is way smaller than in other developed countries. See the economist article last week about this subject.
Re:We should only work 25 hours a week, argues professor by _delirium on Sunday February 03, 2013 @09:33PM (#5162149)
It's true that regulations are relatively low, in terms of invasive bureaucracy in the economy. Yet in Denmark we have a 37-hour maximum workweek, 8 weeks of vacation, and strong unemployment benefits, and all that doesn't seem to be ruining the country. Perhaps that can't be replicated elsewhere, but I don't see a solidly established relationship between working hours, unemployment benefits, and economic prosperity.
Re:We should only work 25 hours a week, argues professor by ekianjo on Sunday February 03, 2013 @09:39PM (#5162169)
Out of interest, can you find out where the budget of the government in Denmark is spent in, and in what proportions ? On top of that, how much of welfare system relies on private actors instead of governmental/public ones?
Re:We should only work 25 hours a week, argues professor by scotty79 on Monday February 04, 2013 @06:00AM (#5163468)
You can see transition to post-labor world in observing growth of the labor force paid with tax money (lots of them doing unnecessary or things harmful to others), growth of prison population (these are the people who are provided for because they couldn't get jobs), increase in percentage of people working in services, increase in number of lawyers...

We are moving away from doing anything useful and we are now even running out of excuses that could entitle us to getting some money to provide for ourselves.