News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by sp332 on Friday February 01, 2013 @01:49PM (#5152539)
The women don't exactly look degraded. I can understand how people would be offended by this, but I don't see it being sexist. As they pointed out, both men and women were involved in putting together the booth, so it's not like this is universally offensive to women.
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by nollidge on Friday February 01, 2013 @01:54PM (#5152581)
Just because women were involved in creating something doesn't make it not sexist.
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by sp332 on Friday February 01, 2013 @01:56PM (#5152591)
Well it's no guarantee, but does make it a lot less likely.
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by UnoriginalGuy on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:06PM (#5152670)
The more I think about that statement the less sense it makes to me.

Why does being born a certain gender make one less likely to do something negative either to their own gender or the other gender?

If we take your statement at face value then we have to make a whole bunch of assumptions that make little sense to me (e.g. that people have the same opinions of what is sexist, that all women are "sensitive" to such issues, that women never actively take part in sexism of women on purpose, that women being sexist to men doesn't exist, etc).

So yeah... I'm going to go ahead and say that that statement is just false unless you can show me something that indicates it is true.

Women are people. People are "sexist." More or less likelihood of such sexism is hard to track because there is no fixed definition (or "line") of sexism its self, nor is there an easy way to /prove/ that someone is or isn't sexist/being sexist.

Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by sp332 on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:14PM (#5152728)
Wow, can you at least pay attention to the context here? We're talking about a group of mostly women who are complaining about treatment of women.

1. It's not "being born" but identifying with a group. Gender, race, sports team, etc. You're more likely to act favorably toward people in your group.

2. Clearly not everyone has the same opinion of what's sexist.

3. If women were not "sensitive" to this, then they wouldn't be complaining so much. They are complaining, therefore I conclude that they are sensitive to it.

4. Women can be mean to other women, but why would they be sexist against women on purpose?

5. Women being sexist to men is not relevant to this context. We're talking about treatment of women.

Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by king_jester on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:39PM (#5152913)
> 1. It's not "being born" but identifying with a group. Gender, race, sports team, etc. You're more likely to act favorably toward people in your group.

Gender is a performance, not a thing. You act in alignment with what you portray to others as your gender.

> 2. Clearly not everyone has the same opinion of what's sexist.

While this is true, the vast majority of disagreement about what sexism is are deflections that serve to discredit actual instances of sexism or to pretend that sexism doesn't happen.

> 3. If women were not "sensitive" to this, then they wouldn't be complaining so much. They are complaining, therefore I conclude that they are sensitive to it.

This is totally true, women are sensitive to sexist depictions of their gender that are objectifying. Who wouldn't be?

> 4. Women can be mean to other women, but why would they be sexist against women on purpose?

Sexism is more than just conscious actions taken against others, it is about cultural and social contexts and structures. The same misogynistic messages in our culture are heard by men and women and that means everyone is affected by them to some extent. Misogyny isn't limited to men against women, some women may have internalized misogyny: http://finallyfeminism101.wordpress.com/2007/10/20/internali...

> 5. Women being sexist to men is not relevant to this context. We're talking about treatment of women.

Women cannot be sexist against men in a systemic way. Advertising that objectifies men's bodies doesn't increase the rhetoric that devalues men nor does it contribute to a culture where sexual assault against men is the vast majority of occurrences.

Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by sp332 on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:47PM (#5152978)
I agree with you on points 1-3. I think your point 4 is not relevant; the question was about women being sexist on purpose and not just incidentally. Also in the situation in the article, the question is not whether the degradation was intentional, but rather whether there was any degradation at all.
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by king_jester on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:59PM (#5153059)
Whether someone is sexist on purpose or not is irrelevant, it doesn't make things any less sexist. Often people will claim lack of knowledge when they do something that is sexist and use that as an accuse to continue engaging in sexist behavior, so its important to call out sexism regardless of how it occurs and for those responsible to make that apology and commit to recognizing that sexism.

As to whether or not this marketing event was degrading, the answer is quite clearly yes. Women's bodies were used as a marketing ploy to sell a product. Women's bodies as a commodity is a long running sexist theme in our society, including marketing. Commodify-ing women's bodies is dangerous and is directly related to violence against women. For an overview, see: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexual_objectification#Sexual_o...

Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by UnoriginalGuy on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:26PM (#5152805)
The context here is someone claiming that women are less sexist than men simply /because/ they're women. I was responding to this one comment/sentiment, rather than to the thread as a whole.

#1, while I will accept that at face value you're more likely to root for the home team - I disagree with the unspoken assumption that that translates into less sexism.

#2, right, but even with that being the case we know enough about what sexism is to blanket say that an entire gender is less likely to conduct it?

#3, some women are complaining, some men are complaining about the reverse (e.g. /r/mensrights). Therefore using identical logic I can claim that because some men have complained about sexism that men are "less likely" than women to be sexist. See how that works (or doesn't)?

#4, because women are people and people are sexist? What is it you want me to explain? If someone calls something sexist and it was produced by a women, earlier discussion not withstanding, it is.

#5, women being sexist to ANYONE is entirely relevant to this discussion. The discussion is: "women are less sexist." Therefore ANY sexism on the part of a women is fair game.

Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by sp332 on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:33PM (#5152865)
Oh, OK, this is about some kind of misunderstanding upthread. I didn't mean that women are universally less sexist, but that including women on the team means the "message" of the booth is less likely to be offensive to women.
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by mherkender on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:54PM (#5153023)
Don't we all experience moments where our jobs require things of us that our moral compass disagrees with? The fact that women were involved (which is incredibly vague by the way) says just about nothing of the women or men that find this kind of thing sexist.

It's not like sexism at tech trade shows is a new thing, but there always seems to be people to defend it. They are using naked women as attention-getting displays to sell laptop batteries to a largely male audience. Forget blaming the company, maybe they had to do it to sell their product, but surely there is some sexism involved here.

Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by dkador on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:02PM (#5152632)
That's definitely not true.
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by dkador on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:11PM (#5152713)
It's not true because men and women are both brought up in the same power structures. There are plenty of women who believe that women's rightful place is in the home, that buy into the notion of modern beauty, and that don't care about women's rights (aka abortion, rape, etc).

That being said, I'd buy an argument that said women are more likely to be aware of these issues. Or even that women are less likely to be sexist. I suppose I took issue with your assertion that women are MUCH less likely to be sexist. I guess it's an argument of degrees.

Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by sp332 on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:27PM (#5152806)
Thanks, and sorry for the snark but it's way too easy to just talk past each other about feminist issues in general.

My memory is a bit fuzzy but from interviews I've read with models, most of them (male and female) are against the "power structures" you're talking about. The only model I'm friends with is definitely not the sort of girl who believes her place is in the home etc.

Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by sp332 on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:05PM (#5152665)
Please be specific. I don't feel like guessing what you mean.
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by jamesaguilar on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:10PM (#5152701)
I think he meant that what you said is not true. I.e. he is stating the inverse: "Having women involved in the creation of something does not have significant impact on whether it is sexist." Although I don't get how that needs to be clarified.
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by TheCapn on Friday February 01, 2013 @01:53PM (#5152569)
I understand how it can be offensive and why it is but in this particular situation I can't help but feel the publicity being provided to the company is doing them a favor. Sometimes these campaigns go a little overboard and become zealous when they aren't making much of a difference.

I have never heard of Hyper-whatever. I have now. In 5 months time if I come across their name I may not remember the controversy but I will remember the brand, and they know it.

Its a little different however if their core customer base was the ones in arms, not people like me who have never heard of them. Non-customers rallying doesn't do anything but spread their name about I feel.

Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by mwetzler on Saturday February 02, 2013 @05:13PM (#5157585)
I wrote the piece and I worry about this too :( My hope is that even if they get more brand awareness out of it, they'll at least think twice about their next booth.
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by crindy on Friday February 01, 2013 @01:59PM (#5152615)
The problem isn't that women are being degraded. The problem is that women are being presented as bodies that can help sell laptop batteries.
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by sp332 on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:04PM (#5152652)
Women are bodies, among other things. They can pose for a display for tech junk without giving up other aspects of their humanity. In other words they are not reduced to being bodies, they are just choosing to express that facet of themselves. Tomorrow they'll show off some other aspect.

Edited to add: I'm good friends with a model. She does stuff like this for fun.

Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by mwetzler on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:51PM (#5152997)
Hi there. I wrote the post and just wanted to let you and the models know that I fully support them and their right to do whatever kind of work they want to do. I don't see them as victims and I didn't write the article to be a voice for them. I wrote it for myself, as a woman in tech. It's awkward when women are used at a tech trade show to attract men to the booth. And it's offensive when a company like HyperMac calls us crazy for pointing it out.
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by rooshdi on Friday February 01, 2013 @03:12PM (#5153147)
Thank you for writing that post. You're not crazy, you're right. Hell, I would feel awkward too if some painted up butt-naked guys became the norm at tech conferences. Unfortunately some people just don't get it, because they fail to see outside themselves. Keep writing more about this. People need the perspective.
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by sp332 on Friday February 01, 2013 @03:12PM (#5153146)
That's not what I got from your article. I saw HyperMac responding to the people who said the display was degrading and dehumanizing, not to the ones who "passed it around the twitter-verse, rolling our eyes and having a good laugh." This part especially seemed odd: "What HyperMac failed to realize was that all the community wanted from them was acknowledgment and support." Really? Then why did the community boycott and attack them instead of asking for acknowledgement and support?
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by rooshdi on Friday February 01, 2013 @03:16PM (#5153170)
Because they got an apathetic, arrogant, selfish, shitty response, that's why. You respond to people like shit, you get shit back. It's not rocket science.
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by sp332 on Friday February 01, 2013 @03:24PM (#5153232)
That is exactly my point. People started jumping all over HyperMac, and HyperMac dismissed the twitter pile-on as an uninformed mob.
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by rooshdi on Friday February 01, 2013 @03:29PM (#5153268)
Which was exactly the wrong way to go about things. You don't dismiss a large demographic's concerns by trying to throw it back at them.
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by Kalium on Friday February 01, 2013 @04:06PM (#5153489)
The alternative being... what, sitting down, listening to what they want to say, and then giving them what they want?

Bear in mind that there's nothing more frustrating that someone apparently taking you seriously and listening to you and then flat-out refusing to give you any of what you want from them. It makes you feel like you were tricked by someone who never took you seriously at all.

Fundamentally, this is about a company facing off against an angry group of people who want to force the company to action that pleases them. No CEO is going to enjoy that.

Also, if the demographic in question isn't your customer base you're likely to treat them somewhat less seriously.

Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by mwetzler on Saturday February 02, 2013 @05:11PM (#5157580)
As far as I can tell, HyperMac's customer base is people who own macs.

Miss Rep is a bay area non-profit so I'm sure they have a very large base here. And a lot of macs.

Not to mention all the techies, not at all affiliated with Miss Rep, who were tweeting about this event.

Many tweeters and posters stated specifically that they were former or potential customers who will now look elsewhere.

Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by rooshdi on Friday February 01, 2013 @04:38PM (#5153661)
Well, I too was part of their customer base, but not anymore. If this is what the company stands for, consider me out. I'd much prefer purchasing products on their merits than some played out douchey marketing scheme.
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by king_jester on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:43PM (#5152946)
This is a point of contention for a lot of people. For myself, reduction of a women to their body in order to sell a product is objectification that appeals to a message that women are commodities. The majority of objectifying advertising has this implicit message built it. You might enjoy Killing Us Softly for more information about women and advertising (this link is trailer only, I'm afraid): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PTlmho_RovY
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by randomdata on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:30PM (#5152836)
I'm not sure I like that explanation. If the laptop batteries were sold using women's brains, we'd be celebrating how far women's rights have come, despite completely ignoring that women are human and also have bodies.

The real issue here seems to just be a puritanical view of nakedness/sexiness.

Women most certainly do deal with problems in the workplace, but having the ability to choose to stand mostly naked to sell batteries doesn't seem like one of them.

Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by mwetzler on Friday February 01, 2013 @03:25PM (#5153241)
I'm comfortable with nakedness and sexiness. I doubt the booth would have hit my radar at all if they'd included male models too. Honestly, this wouldn't be a blog post if the CEO had responded in a thoughtful way. It's his response that is most offensive.
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by sp332 on Friday February 01, 2013 @04:29PM (#5153610)
>I doubt the booth would have hit my radar at all if they'd included male models too.

I'm sorry but this was not at all clear from what you had written. Or any of the tweets you quoted. I tried to be pretty careful, thoughtful, and understanding but apparently I failed badly. After all this discussion I have no idea what your objection actually is. Sorry for wasting everyone's time, I wish there was something I could actually take away from this but I just feel defeated by this whole conversation.

Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by mwetzler on Saturday February 02, 2013 @05:16PM (#5157603)
Thank you for reading and trying to understand. I really mean that. I hope some of my other comments will help explain it better.

Here is a link to one of them: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5157470

Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by randomdata on Friday February 01, 2013 @04:02PM (#5153465)
I appreciate the response. It was actually the original tweet that made me feel it was about the generally negative view of bodies, and not any kind of women's rights issue. It mentions appropriateness, which is usually associated with people, of all sexes, needing to covering up to be appropriate.

Obviously the whole thing runs much deeper and I agree that things could be handled much more effectively.

Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by Cowen on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:35PM (#5152876)
There are very few things that are "universally offensive." As nollidge accurately pointed out, just because women were involved doesn't mean it's not sexist.

The fact is that this was widely considered offensive and unnecessary, and the CEOs response only made it worse. No one has the right not to be offended, but everyone has the right to speak out and not buy a product for whatever reasons they choose, which is exactly what happened.

Personally, I don't have a problem with naked people in body paint as part of a display; it does everything you want a display to do, it catches eyes and it sticks in memory.

But why did they only choose naked women? There are no painted male models in their staff photo from the event.[1] Was it decided that including naked men would somehow hurt the effectiveness of the display, and if so, why? Certainly there were willing male models, so it seems that HyperMac just steered clear of hiring men. The accusations of sexism (or more accurately, objectification) all springs from that, and the unwillingness of the CEO to even acknowledge that as a concern is honestly disturbing.

[1] http://www.hyperblog.com/2013/01/thanks-for-an-amazing-ces-2...

Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by sp332 on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:38PM (#5152898)
The complaint in the article was that the display was degrading to the women. Including men in the display just would have degraded men as well as women. It's not a numbers game.
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by Cowen on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:43PM (#5152953)
That's nothing but blind speculation.

There is absolutely no evidence that it would have been considered that way.

Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by sp332 on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:55PM (#5153029)
I don't follow. How would putting men in the same display change how degraded the women in the display were?
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by Cowen on Friday February 01, 2013 @03:20PM (#5153198)
The argument isn't about whether or not they're being degraded, but whether women as a group are being objectified by the people who organized the display. That argument is significantly enhanced by the fact that women were the only "objects" that were on display, especially when women were far from the only "objects" that were appropriate for this display. There's nothing about HyperMac's products that figuratively or literally only applies to naked, painted women. Naked, painted men were just as appropriate as women, but they were completely avoided for reasons that are unknown to the public.

Right now, the display is "naked women in body paint", but with men it would be "naked people in body paint." The gender neutrality of the display would exist in more than just a semantic sense, but also in a deeper sense that gender wasn't considered a factor when they were making this display. Right now, that's not how it looks at all. It looks like they only wanted naked women to be associated with HyperMac's products. And the CEO's comments do absolutely nothing to dissuade that viewpoint.

Would people have still complained about objectification of women if there were men in the display too? Maybe. But they would have a much weaker case than they do now.

Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by sp332 on Friday February 01, 2013 @04:44PM (#5153695)
I really don't understand how objectifying men makes objectification of women less offensive. It's OK to dehumanize people as long as we do it equally?
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by Cowen on Friday February 01, 2013 @05:08PM (#5153828)
Do you see nude, painted models at a trade event as being inherently dehumanizing? Because that would be a separate issue from what's being discussed here.

The problem -- at least as it seems to me -- is not that there were nude, painted people hired for the event, but that there were only nude, painted women hired for the event for no apparent reason other than their presumed sex appeal to the predominantly male attendees.

That's where the objectification argument comes in, at least in my eyes. Like I said from the start, I don't have an inherent issue with using nude, painted models for a display.

Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by sp332 on Friday February 01, 2013 @05:18PM (#5153881)
No, but I didn't see the display as being degrading to women, which is why I'm looking for other people's perspectives. You make it sound like someone hijacked these women and used them in a degrading way. I don't see any evidence of that. Also I see no basis for presuming that they were hired only for sex appeal.
Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by Cowen on Friday February 01, 2013 @05:43PM (#5154006)
I have no idea where or how I made it sound like someone hijacked these women. That's obviously not the case. They were paid models who likely have no qualms with this work, and again, that's perfectly fine.

My issue with the display is it that HyperMac only hired female models when males would have sufficed just as well. That's the only real basis for claiming objectification of women in my eyes. Because the CEO gave absolutely no answers -- refusing to acknowledge that could even be a concern -- Occam's razor suggests going with the simplest explanation of why only nude female models were chosen to represent HyperMac, and the simplest explanation (at least in my eyes) is their sex appeal.

Models are chosen primarily for their looks, so why was the look of the nude female body the only one HyperMac had representing them at the show?

Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by sp332 on Friday February 01, 2013 @05:51PM (#5154055)
OK, actually to me the nude models did not seem to me to be for sex appeal, but the 8 women with "HyperMac" on their breasts convinced me. Given that women were hired for their sex appeal: why is that a problem?

Edited to add: at least the CEO claims they were knowledgeable, which takes care of the main problem with booth babes. Both men and women had been trained to ignore women at the conferences, as a kind of mental spam filter just because many of the booth babes were clueless about the products.

About the depth thing: click the "link" button if you want to reply. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5154055

Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by mwetzler on Saturday February 02, 2013 @05:06PM (#5157565)
Thanks for asking. This is a huge topic of research for decades. Here are a few starting points.

http://www.netmagazine.com/features/primer-sexism-tech-indus... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexual_objectification

Re:Sexism in Tech: A Good Apology is Better than No Mistakes by sp332 on Friday February 01, 2013 @07:46PM (#5154534)
Sorry, I asked the wrong question. Given that they were hired for sex appeal, how would hiring more men have helped?