A 64 GB tablet shipping with 23 GB free is a real thing that happens even though it shouldn't, which makes his analogies fair.
Not that my vegetable analogy is not terrible, but at least it's a case where lossage is normal, and it's just excessive lossage that we would be upset about.
| But in his analogies, those are all cases where
| no one would tolerate anything more than 0%
| lossage.
If you buy a box of 100 staples, do you count to make sure that there aren't only 92 staples in the box? Would you notice if you only got 33 staples?Nobody says "I want n pounds of eggplant", rather they say "I want n eggplants". They then pay based on weight, for the convenience of the grocer.
On the other hand, you don't want "n bags of flour" but rather "n pounds of flour". If flour were being sold such that more than a miniscule single-digit percentage of that weight were actually packaging, people would be justifiably upset.
Who says the size of a TV has to be measured not including the bezel?
Who says the seats in a car have to hold anyone taller than 4 feet?
It is a bit as if they sell you a one pound coconut with a sticker "a pound of coconut milk" on it.
Historically, companies have been forced to change their ways for less (prime example: monitor sizes used to be measured on the display area, but that grew to 'visible part of the CRT' and from there to 'CRT diagonal', and, IIRC, 'diagonal extended to the edge of the housing')
In this case, some tablets are delivering on 80 or 90% of their promised capacity whilst others are only managing the vicinity of 25%.
For instance; Peas. I hate peas, so I consider them well short of one-third edible.
Maybe the Surface Pro should be called the Microsoft Eat Your Peas.
It's the Surface Pistachio.
That shit is 100% inedible.
All of my examples are high tech and recent, to the point where a lot of the customers would never have bought such a product before, thus have no idea what they are getting and not getting.
For these complicated products, it needs to be spelled out more clearly, and maybe even regulated as suggested.
(I've never bought a TV, and I'm still confused about how they're measured, for example)
Here, Calvin's dad can explain it better than I can:
A "5 seater" car, where some critical part of the car occupies 3 seats so you only have 2 for people.
A box of 100 staples, where 64 are used to hold the box together, so you only get to use 36
A 50 inch plasma TV, where the bezel accounted for 32 inches of that.
A car advertised as getting 30MPG, but when you put seats, seat belts, a heater, air conditioning and a radio in there it only gets 20 MPG
It feels a lot like getting ripped off to me.
Obviously we're power users, so we're willing to dive into this and understand that when you buy a 64GB device, you don't get that much storage. Do you think the general public understands that?