News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by fuzzix on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @01:33AM (#5095872)
Quite funny to read about maternity leave being an extraordinary perk - 6 months paid is the statutory minimum in Ireland and it must start a reasonable amount of time before the child is born.

Is it also true that there is no minimum amount of annual leave allowance in the US? You have to negotiate it?

edit Not to suggest Ireland is ahead of the curve here, paternity leave does not exist whereas it would in, say, Sweden.

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by patio11 on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @01:46AM (#5095905)
Many facets of US employment law are different on a state-by-state basis, so "The US sets no minimum/maximum for ..." can frequently be true but vacuous.

Broadly speaking, salaried employees in the US can expect a statutory minimum of 12 weeks of unpaid maternity leave. Fairly few states mandate paid maternity/paternity leave. They're available at many companies as a perk.

Broadly speaking, Americans enjoy broad discretion in negotiating the amount and format of paid leave. By law and custom, the practical minimum is ~2 weeks plus holidays for most white collar workers. We historically do not have European-style vacations as an expected feature of the social contract.

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by fuzzix on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @01:55AM (#5095935)
Fair point. I wonder if the increasing number of us tech firms setting up in .ie (for whatever reason, being an Irish graduate I know it's not for the skills pool) find the adjustment difficult - 20 days minimum, 25 not uncommon, with the ability to carry some leave across years generally accepted.

edit Anecdotally, even companies based in the UK have had trouble with the difference in employment law when setting up (or wrapping up) here, though I would put that down to lack of diligence rather than any cultural thing.

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by ido on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @03:01AM (#5096098)
Ireland has (or at least had as of a couple years ago) some sort of tax loophole that allows international companies to dodge paying some taxes both in their home country and in Ireland.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by gfritzsche on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @06:45AM (#5096626)
See e.g. the Double Irish Arrangement: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by easytiger on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @08:10AM (#5096901)
its not a loophole, they have very low corporation tax compared with anywhere else
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by hect0r on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @01:45PM (#5098813)
It's not a loophole. It's a competitive differentiator for Ireland in attracting MNCs to invest and hire there.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by rmc on Wednesday January 23, 2013 @10:22AM (#5103423)
the increasing number of us tech firms setting up in .ie (for whatever reason, being an Irish graduate I know it's not for the skills pool)

12½% corporate tax rate. EU base. Less strict attitude towards EU data protection et al.

find the adjustment difficult - 20 days minimum

Heh, reminds me of someone I know working for an Irish tech company that was bought by a US company. They had to sit the new owners down and say "Yes, we are actually entitled to paid holidays. No, that's the law here."

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @01:19PM (#5098648)
By custom only. There is literally no law.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by sliverstorm on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @01:56AM (#5095940)
We are also workaholics. Or, at least I am.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by fuzzix on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @02:01AM (#5095954)
As am I. I just spend a lot of time working on my own projects. I value a regular (i.e. not too long) working day for being able to actually do this.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by tedmiston on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @02:44AM (#5096059)
Out of curiosity, what is your work day like? Are you putting in something like a 9-6 as is common in the U.S.?
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by fuzzix on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @03:01AM (#5096097)
Aye, pretty much (9-5:30 with flexible start time). Thing is, I would probably work longer hours voluntarily if I could telework - give over half my usual commute time to a little extra.

But that's a different story...

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5092589

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by drKarl on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @03:35AM (#5096179)
I work in Ireland too (I moved to Ireland 3 months ago) and I work 8:30-5 with flexible start time, 8:30-4 on fridays, and I can work from home some days as well.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by codemac on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @01:48AM (#5095915)
Also - other places I have worked (NetApp notably) have had better benefits than the Google offers I have received. So don't read too much into the hype, there are several places that are on par or better when it comes to treating your employees well.

And yes, it is true that there is no minimum leave federally. I don't know about individual states. The Department of Labor is linked[0] on the wikipedia article about leave, seems to be an accurate source.

[0]: http://www.dol.gov/dol/topic/workhours/vacation_leave.htm

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by ohsnapman on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @03:05AM (#5096106)
Can you post a link? At least according to this link:

http://www.netapp.com/us/careers/your-career/benefits-new.as...

Google's actual US benefits are scattered, unfortunately, but:

http://www.glassdoor.com/Reviews/Employee-Review-Google-RVW2...

NetApp offers a $3000 401k match, whereas Google does $8750 (50% of maximum) with no vesting.

NetApp gives you 25 days vacation a year after 10 years, 15 days after year 2, 20 on year 6. You get 25 days after your 5th year at Google, 20 on 4th year, start at 15.

NetApp offers $5250/year in tuition reimbursement. Google offers $13,000/year.

In addition to all of these, it's well known that Google provides donation match to a charity, gym reimbursement, heavily subsidized massages, sick days as needed.

If Google benefits are hype, I'd love to see data that shows where other companies beat them out.

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by codemac on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @05:51AM (#5096508)
Glassdoor isn't a valid reference for anything (it's like a wikipedia page, except no one is trying to cite sources), and benefits are negotiable, including everything on that NetApp page.

Please don't misunderstand me, obviously Google is one of the better place to work these days. Their benefits are great, but it's not far and away best for every individual. Articles like this are marketing for Google.. grumble grumble link to pg's submarine article.

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by ohsnapman on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @10:27AM (#5097487)
I posted that link only because it was one of many search results for "Google benefits" - I was a bit surprised to see that the benefits aren't posted anywhere on Google's jobs site, but the fact that they're negotiable probably is why.

Anyway, the benefits are confirmable if you just ask someone who works there - those are the baseline benefits everyone already gets just by signing an employment contract. While I don't doubt that this article is a plant, I was making a point that I am pretty sure their benefits are best in industry, and I haven't seen any evidence that there are any companies that there are, as you say, several places that are on par with Google across the board. In fact, when I've spoken with people, the number of companies in Silicon Valley that are even close (NetApp is certainly one of them) can be counted on one hand.

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by nostrademons on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @11:05PM (#5101310)
The Glassdoor article is consistent with my experience (except I think the 20 days of vacation starts on year 3, not year 4). Yes, benefits are in theory negotiable, but Google very, very rarely negotiates benefits - being a large corporation with a standardized offer process and a lot of bargaining power, they can usually get an applicant to take what they offer.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by nyrulez on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @01:14PM (#5098608)
Can you provide facts to back up your statements ?
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by ceras on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @01:43AM (#5095894)
No minimum time off in the US. For most white collar jobs, 10 or 15 vacation days is typical (but many Americans feel pressure to not use all their vacation days). Some companies offer more, especially to employees with seniority. Government jobs tend to be nice about this, too. This is in addition to holidays -- about 8 or so per year is typical for these workers, I think (days like Christmas that most everyone in the company has off).

Those working blue collar jobs, however, aren't always so lucky. They might not have any vacation days or even holidays.

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by alexkus on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @10:18AM (#5097445)
It's 28 days minimum in the UK[1] (for a full time employee) but these can include the public holidays (8 a year in England/Wales, 9 a year in Scotland and 10 a year in NI).

<generalisations follow>

In reality most IT companies give ~25 days and give the 8 public holidays off too. Longer service often gets you more days. I'm up to 27 days/year (plus the 8 public holidays).

Any reasonable IT company will also require you to take all of your holiday during the year, it's a manager's responsibility to ensure that his team are using their holiday. There's certainly no pressure to not use all of the days! I can carry over the odd day or two across years but generally not allowed to accrue large amounts of unused paid leave.

We don't have a concept of an allocation of "sick days" either, if you're unwell for a day or a few days you can self certify yourself off work sick. If you're ill for longer than a week the expectation is that you'll provide a letter from a Doctor explaining the absence. If you're ill frequently then the company will discuss it with you (and if you're pulling frequent sickies then that'll be dealt with as a disciplinary). I've had 3 days off sick in the last 5 years.

1. https://www.gov.uk/bank-holidays#england-and-wales

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by fuzzix on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @01:47AM (#5095909)
Well, isn't that just disgraceful. No wonder George Costanza was a half-assing burnout...
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by krzyk on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @10:48AM (#5097625)
In Poland it's 20 or 26 days off, all state holidays are added on top of that (there are few days, probably around 8). All of those are paid. Except those one can also take unpaid vacation but that has to be negotiated with the employer.

20 days is until you have 10 years of work experience, but graduating counts as 8 years of experience so most people just have to work 2 years to jump to 26 days.

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by netcan on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @08:23AM (#5096939)
Your entitlement to pay and superannuation during maternity leave depends on the terms of your contract of employment. Employers are not obliged to pay women on maternity leave. You may qualify for Maternity Benefit which is a Department of Social Protection payment you have sufficient PRSI

http://www.citizensinformation.ie/en/employment/employment_r...

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by fuzzix on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @10:55AM (#5097672)
Ah, seems I misread the info.

An artifact of commenting at 6am.

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by rmc on Wednesday January 23, 2013 @10:25AM (#5103438)
Is it also true that there is no minimum amount of annual leave allowance in the US? You have to negotiate it?

Correct. Unlike the EU, the US has no minimum holidays. however ¾s or so of US employees have holidays. For white collar workers, you're almost certainly guaranteed holidays (from what I know).

Not to suggest Ireland is ahead of the curve here

I was talking to some Germans a few years ago. They were shocked to discover we only had 20 holiday days. You get 30 in Germany. They didn't know what they'd do with only 20.

Fun excersive: Look at the list of EU countries by how much paid holiday time they give. Look at the lowest countries. Then look at the countries that are being bailed out by other EU countries. :P

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by pjmlp on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @05:43AM (#5096487)
The more I learn about US work laws, the more I like being an European.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by Jach on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @06:31AM (#5096584)
I guess it depends where you are in Europe. I'm glad I'm in the US and not in Hungary. http://andorjakab.blog.hu/2012/01/06/this_is_why_i_don_t_giv... Edit: I found it interesting that in http://www.cso.ie/en/media/csoie/releasespublications/docume... on page 58, about 58% of sampled women in Ireland are in jobs classified as "low skilled non-manual" or "elementary" compared to about 32% for men in medium-to-large businesses, but 22% in small businesses. When your female employee might take 6 months off, paid while doing nothing useful for the company, it's best if the work they would have done can be easily (and cheaply, so that 2X isn't so much greater than X) done by another, eh?
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by pjmlp on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @09:14AM (#5097155)
Germany
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by hect0r on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @10:13AM (#5097431)
Why? Europe isn't exactly a hotbed of innovation, economic dynamism or growth; and that is largely attributable to the socialist mindset that pervades much of Europe. Although entrepreneurialism is a word that originated in Europe, it is rather hard to find much evidence of it in any meangingful way.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by binxbolling on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @10:41AM (#5097586)
Trolls be trollin'
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by nodata on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @10:39AM (#5097564)
Are you suggesting that the 50 United States are a hotbed of those things?
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by hect0r on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @11:18AM (#5097789)
No, but I am suggesting that, in general, free markets lead to growth whereas socialist experiments such as those in Europe tend to fail and lead to a variety of social and economic ills. One just look at the aging population, declining birth rate plus vast social security apparatus in some of these European states to see that they are heading yet again towards disaster.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by nodata on Wednesday January 23, 2013 @03:37AM (#5102132)
If Europe is a socialist "experiment", what "experiment" is the States?

Where have you ever lived in Europe?

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @01:26PM (#5098690)
Political concern troll detected and downvoted.

Method of detection: use of the term "free market" as a non-contextualized, noncomparative term.

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by hect0r on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @01:43PM (#5098798)
Funny. Mention "free markets" in a positive light and get downvoted as a troll.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday January 23, 2013 @11:55AM (#5103894)
It's not that you said it in a positive light. It's that you used it as a common noun. The term "free market" is only useful as a comparative, like so: "America has freer markets than India". This lets people know and contextualize what you're saying.

Otherwise, using the term just turns into a competition of politics between Republican shills (ie: you), minarcho-capitalist ("libertarian") ideologues, mutualist anarchists, and socialists on what it means to be a "free market", how "free" a market has to be to qualify for the term, and whether the relative "freedom" or lack thereof of a market matters at all.

I fall into that last camp. There are actually reputable studies showing that given 100% Free markets never occur in reality (perfect competition, perfect information, zero transaction costs were the definition they used), most not-completely-retarded allocation mechanisms other than those are more-or-less as decent as each other; there was basically a 3% allocative-efficiency advantage to the realistically imperfect market over the tested form of central planning.

A mathematician also showed that even perfect theoretical markets can oscillate neverendingly between multiple general equilibriums rather than ever converging to one efficient equilibrium.

In conclusion, stop using the term "free market" outside of meaningful context.

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by pjmlp on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @01:34PM (#5098741)
I am a firm believer of such socialist mindset as you call it.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by hect0r on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @09:54AM (#5097339)
By forcing employers to pay women six months maternity leave, it means that the cost of employing a woman of child-bearing age relative to a man is much higher and hence, all things being equal, the economically rational approach is to discriminate against women in hiring and promotion. This is just one of the many unintended consequences of government interference; the other, of course, is the minimum wage which is a particularly nefarious and wicked concept that results in the unskilled being kept unemployed and economically disadvantaged.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by binxbolling on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @10:40AM (#5097573)
You're a bit early for April Fool's Day, mate.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by hect0r on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @11:14AM (#5097776)
Err, no. What I write above is well known and proven in several studies. Try reading Jonathan Gruber's (MIT) research, for example, into the effected of mandated maternity leave on female unemployment in the US states where it was introduced in the 90s.

Your attitude -- that everything that doesn't fit into particular economic worldview -- is a "troll" or an "April Fools joke" is unfortunate.

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by nodata on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @10:37AM (#5097553)
That's short sighted: if you discriminate against women, who will give birth to the men?
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by hect0r on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @11:01AM (#5097700)
If I am an employer in a society where, for each birth, the government mandates six month minimum paid maternity leave. I am hiring for a particular role and have two candidates of equivalent skill with the only difference being one is female and of child-bearing age. Which would you hire? The female may get pregnant and impose two costs on my company: firstly, the cost of maternity leave and, secondly, the cost of finding and training a temporary replacement for a minimum of six months. The rational thing is to hire the male to mitigate this risk since the costs will be lower and productivity assumed to be higher over term of employment.

A better solution is for governments to not force such things but allow companies to negotiate freely with employees. Some may decide to offer extended maternity leave as a differentiator and to attract and retain female talent. But if they do so, they are doing so with coercion and for rational reasons.

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by sopooneo on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @12:41PM (#5098373)
I may be wrong, but I think you are double counting the cost of the maternity leave. The cost to the company is the cost of finding/training/paying a temp. The cost of paying the woman her salary while she is gone would have still occurred if she wasn't gone. Or am I missreading? You would include lost productivity due to a less effective temp worker I suppose.

My general response to letting companies negotiate freely is that it seems important, but potentially destructive at it's extreme. I think there should be certain minimum labor standards applied to all employers so that no one employer is at an economic disadvantage by treating their workers humanely. Regarding such minimum requirements including six months of paid maternity leave I'm not sure how I feel.

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by hect0r on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @01:09PM (#5098569)
The issue with minimum labour standards is that you have the question of what happens to people whose value is less than the standard. If you have a minimum wage of five dollars, what happens to the person who, for whatever reason, only produces two dollars of value? They are unemployable and hence never enter the labour market. It would be preferable to let them work at two dollars because, over time, we know that their value increases. One can see this on a global scale in how traditional sources of cheap labour have become more expensive and more skilled over time.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @01:24PM (#5098678)
If someone's labor cannot sustain their life, then it's perfectly sensible that they become a ward of their family or civil society or the state.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by hect0r on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @01:41PM (#5098784)
Perfectly sensible for those who have no potential of achieving more but for others who do have potential it seems rather cruel to lock them out of the labour market. Unless an employer is atruistic, they are not going to hire such a person and thereby help them realise their potential because to hire them at minimum wage would result in a net loss.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @04:03PM (#5099572)
And for the worker to work at less than a living wage is a net loss to them.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by rmc on Wednesday January 23, 2013 @10:28AM (#5103451)
the economically rational approach is to discriminate against women in hiring and promotion

Correct. So that's why we ban that economically rational hiring approach. Problem solved.

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by saosebastiao on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @10:37AM (#5097551)
Maternity Leave elsewhere is typically a government operated insurance program. They typically are not 100% salary, and the burden of paying the employee falls on the insurance program. Since we don't have an insurance program, paid maternity leave is a pretty big deal, as the company fronts all the costs, including the replacement/temp.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by seivan on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @05:06AM (#5096392)
Many of the Irish and Swedish safety nests are not sustainable under the current economy and will eventually crash.

I love it whenever people bring up Sweden and don't realise that countries like Sweden and Germany can't sustain the benefits they give out. When I get older I won't have the same access.

Germany pays around 50% taxes, Sweden it's around 30-40% for software developer salaries.

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by Mvandenbergh on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @06:34AM (#5096598)
Sweden had a deficit of 0.40% of GDP in 2011 (last year I have figures for), in that same year the US had a budget deficit of about 10% of GDP.

Furthermore, maternity leave and holiday time are neither expensive nor are they getting more so in the future.

What is more worrying in the long term are benefits associated with retirement because due to demographic changes that cost will continue to grow even as the number of people in the labour force stays steady or slowly shrinks. Those problems are not unique to Sweden.

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by mongol on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @12:18PM (#5098225)
Thank your making an informed statement about this. I don't think parent knew what he was talking about, his figures about tax rates in Sweden were far from accurate or knowledgeable.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by patrickg on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @08:39AM (#5097022)
50% taxes in Germany? Example: you get 42.000 Euro/year, you pay ~20% taxes. If you earn 100.000 Euro/year, you pay 30%.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by seivan on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @09:11AM (#5097146)
I am sorry, I should have said Berlin. 100k euro a year is not 30% in Berlin. Please check your source again.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by patrickg on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @09:25AM (#5097200)
Berlin is in Germany. You could check the official tax calculator: https://www.bmf-steuerrechner.de
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by seivan on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @10:01AM (#5097389)
I am aware of it being in Germany, I'm also aware of the difference in taxes between states. I used this http://www.parmentier.de/steuer/steuer.htm?wagetax.htm is it wrong?
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by patrickg on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @10:16AM (#5097440)
The taxes are the same everywhere in Germany. What differs is how much you pay for pension insurance (and how much you get out of it, IIRC).
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by seivan on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @01:26PM (#5098691)
So the numbers "If you earn 100.000 Euro/year, you pay 30%" are not wrong for a single man?
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by patrickg on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @02:38PM (#5099102)
Correct, they are not wrong.

Its like this in Germany (tax wise): (http://i.imgur.com/6oiGx5B.png) - the lower blue curve is the amount of tax you pay. The x-axis is the amount of money you get (on which you have to pay tax) and the y-axis is the tax percentage. This is for self-employed people only, regular employees will deduct 1000 Euros from the amount ("Arbeitnehmerpauschbetrag"). Other amounts such as the health insurance can also be deducted.

One side note: the link you have given also calculates health, pension and unemployment insurances. This might be confused with tax, but one should be make it clear that self-employed people don't have to have pension and unemployment insurance and health insurance is much higher than for regular employees. [But one can (in practice) get around paying for health insurance, but no sensible person will do that. - Nobody enforces that you have a health insurance if you are self employed.]

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by seivan on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @05:29PM (#5100038)
I am referring to the whole shebang. From what I know, pension and unemployment insurances are mandatory. Am I wrong?

Now, with pension and unemployment insurances, will the tax bracket be higher than 30% for 100k ?

You are right, no one sensible would go without the health care portion. But some people (moi) don't trust pension with governments. (Argentina, Hungary.. etc)

Now, if those things are mandatory, how much would be left of a 70k salary? Still on the 30%?

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by patrickg on Wednesday January 23, 2013 @04:57AM (#5102335)
For employees, pension and unemployment are mandatory, correct.

Don't mix up tax and health/pension/unemployment because (that was the starting point of this thread) one can believe that if you say 50% tax these insurances might come on top of that.

Otherwise, if you want to know how much you will have on your bank account after getting 70k/year, your link was very good AFAICS. You will most likely get something like 40k out of it.

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by VeejayRampay on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @06:14AM (#5096554)
Well, since Ireland has been abortion-retarded until very recently, I guess you guys had to implement some proper maternity care.
Re:How Google became such a great place to work by seivan on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @05:31PM (#5100052)
I suspect either people dislike the use of the word retarded in a offensive way, or they didn't get that you meant retarded as in "delayed".

I like to think you were downvoted because they didn't grasp you meant delayed or behind progress :)

Re:How Google became such a great place to work by VeejayRampay on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @11:36PM (#5101389)
Nah I meant retarded. And people are right to downvote it, I shouldn't have used that kind of language. It only goes to pollute the message which was in essence that the religious grip in Ireland has been a very detrimental factor in the progress towards proper health care for women in the country.

Sorry if I offended anyone, it was wrong.