Re:Show HN: Playbook - Share your hookups with your bros (at...
by rozap on Sunday January 20, 2013 @02:57PM
(#5087952)
Is this a fucking joke? Who needs this? This is not only classless, but from a purely objective standpoint, who would actually use this thing? With your target demographic in mind, it seems to me like it will turn into the greasiest, skeeziest, cesspool on the entire internet in no time.
Re:Show HN: Playbook - Share your hookups with your bros (at...
by selectout on Sunday January 20, 2013 @03:02PM
(#5087977)
I think if you have something that is "Show HN" there should be more to see than just a landing page. I'd like to see how you built it, what it looks like, something more than just "enter your email address and we'll notify you when it's available."
Re:Show HN: Playbook - Share your hookups with your bros (at...
by lazerwalker on Sunday January 20, 2013 @03:04PM
(#5087987)
Just because people are already doing some sort of negative and disrespectful thing, that doesn't make it alright to build a tool to actively encourage people to continue doing it.
Re:Show HN: Playbook - Share your hookups with your bros (at...
by stephencanon on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @10:28AM
(#5097494)
To put it succinctly: a gentleman doesn't kiss and tell.
It's disrespectful of the trust that your partner places in you by engaging in what is fundamentally a private interaction to share it publicly without their permission.
Re:Show HN: Playbook - Share your hookups with your bros (at...
by tomjen3 on Sunday January 20, 2013 @04:19PM
(#5088283)
Actually this is a natural consequence of a society strangled by church views on morality.
When can we give up the idea that sex, for no other reason than gratification, lust and desire is in any way bad?
When can we get over the idea that women don't want sex? That they shouldn't be allowed to want sex? That they should feel sorry for wanting to have sex?
If you accept that women should have the same rights as men, it should follow that they should be the one to choose when, how, where and whom to sleep with -- and how often.
But of course, if you don't, if you believe that women are somehow inferior to men in matters of judgement, then your comment makes perfect sense.
Re:Show HN: Playbook - Share your hookups with your bros (at...
by eggbrain on Sunday January 20, 2013 @04:47PM
(#5088392)
Do NOT make this community about persecution -- I see no reason to list his Facebook profile in this thread other than to harass -- even if he has it listed in his profile.
Re:Show HN: Playbook - Share your hookups with your bros (at...
by onlyup on Sunday January 20, 2013 @05:23PM
(#5088509)
Well.. you got the comments section stirred up with just a landing page and an idea. Good job.
Ignoring the moral issue of this.. can't this be replicated by making a private group on Facebook? Your friends are already on Facebook.. and the girls probably are too!
Re:Show HN: Playbook - Share your hookups with your bros (at...
by lazerwalker on Sunday January 20, 2013 @03:07PM
(#5087998)
I agree with you completely. The problem is that I don't think the behavior you're encouraging solves that.
Talking about hookups is almost always about objectification: it's encouraging people to talk openly about relationships, yes, but relationships between people and objects of sexual gratification rather than between actual mature adults.
Re:Show HN: Playbook - Share your hookups with your bros (at...
by tomjen3 on Sunday January 20, 2013 @04:12PM
(#5088252)
I always find it fascinating how the prevailing christian attitudes about sex have spread so well to the entire population, even as that same population is less and less christian.
In this case, you are implying that mature adults sex lives should not include one night stands with people they have no emotional attachment to. Why?
Re:Show HN: Playbook - Share your hookups with your bros (at...
by gailees on Sunday January 20, 2013 @02:46PM
(#5087905)
This one is an app at this point; not a business, but we will be looking at doing different things. Currently, instead of liking a friend's "play" or hookup, you can buy them a beer from a local microbrewery to get delivered to their door!
Re:Show HN: Playbook - Share your hookups with your bros (at...
by gailees on Sunday January 20, 2013 @02:46PM
(#5087907)
We are looking into making it gender-neutral, because outside of it being targeted at guys, we totally think this is something girls would love to use too!
...bro.
It's disrespectful of the trust that your partner places in you by engaging in what is fundamentally a private interaction to share it publicly without their permission.
When can we give up the idea that sex, for no other reason than gratification, lust and desire is in any way bad?
When can we get over the idea that women don't want sex? That they shouldn't be allowed to want sex? That they should feel sorry for wanting to have sex?
If you accept that women should have the same rights as men, it should follow that they should be the one to choose when, how, where and whom to sleep with -- and how often.
But of course, if you don't, if you believe that women are somehow inferior to men in matters of judgement, then your comment makes perfect sense.
That is not an argument I can support, though.
right?
tisk tisk pennApps...
Let me just say, David, that you're a cretin. You're why my female friends don't want shit to do with geek culture. You're poison in the well.
Lots of people (guys and girls) already discuss this info with their close friends so this is just taking that conversation online.
I think that linking his Facebook in an aggressive comment isn't appropriate.
Ignoring the moral issue of this.. can't this be replicated by making a private group on Facebook? Your friends are already on Facebook.. and the girls probably are too!
Leave.
Leave.
Talking about hookups is almost always about objectification: it's encouraging people to talk openly about relationships, yes, but relationships between people and objects of sexual gratification rather than between actual mature adults.
In this case, you are implying that mature adults sex lives should not include one night stands with people they have no emotional attachment to. Why?
(yes, I know they changed the definition. I pretend it never happened!)