News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by ComputerGuru on Thursday January 17, 2013 @01:20PM (#5074130)
I'm a little surprised at the comments here on HN. I expected a much less sarcastic and "chip on the shoulder" attitude.

No one is saying that rich people can't afford to pay more taxes. It's not a question of they're going to starve and be out on the streets. The real issue is, approaching 50% taxes (EDIT: state + federal + medicare/medicaid + social security) is in conflict with the American concept of capitalism. The fact of the matter is, there is nothing proportionate about how much you benefit to how much you pay. The more you make, the more you pay to Uncle Sam both as a proportion of your income and as an actual number.

It is not a question of how much can you "afford to give" while remaining well off - I think it's a much more core issue at hand: is someone who makes (to bring this closer to home) $250k as a single individual, perhaps doing freelance software development and consulting, culpable to the tune of $80k out of their salary to help everyone else out?

Yes, it's a moral question. It's a philosophical question. And it's also a legal question: even if they are morally obligated - is it the government's job to enforce that?

Many people I know in that bracket actually give that much or more in very directed donations to non-profit entities (meaning they're no longer in that bracket thanks to tax deductions) because they feel they a) distrust the government to wisely spend their money to solve the problems, b) they should have a say in where their money goes, and c) it is not the government's job to take and redistribute wealth.

As for those that don't make such donations - can you absolutely say they must?

Also remember, these tax hikes are really not targeted at the so-called "filthy rich" that have been the focus of all the ire and angst in recent years by groups such as "Occupy Wall Street" - they just affect the upper middle class. Capital gains taxes are ridiculously lower than income taxes. Your wall street bankers and trust fund babies don't have "income" in the traditional sense. You're not taking this money from people that have invested money and are making more money explicitly not doing anything, these taxes are on the upper class of working citizens.

The biggest targets are small business owners, startups, lawyers, doctors, engineers, and others of their kind. Can you say for an absolute fact that they owe ~40% of their annual income to the government? I can tell you for a fact that the difference between a freelancer in high demand earning $250k/year vs $100k/year is a matter of the hours you work. If you kill yourself to work around the clock to make more money.... you are rewarded with higher taxes. It's not a different class of people that are being taxed higher - it's just people that have worked harder for longer and are, as a result, more well off. This is literally the anti-thesis of core American values: work harder and be, quite frankly, punished for it.

(I'm not saying everyone can automatically make $250k/year by working harder and that if you don't make that much then you are lazy - I'm saying the difference between $50k/year and $350k/year is a matter is a matter of quantity, not type; whereas the difference between $250k/year and $200MM/year is a different beast.)

At the end of the day, people need to decide if you are paying for services provided by the government or if we are asking the upper middle class to subsidize the rest of the country. There's nothing inherently better or worse about one or the other - it's a matter of philosophy. At the end of the day, are our core principles capitalistic or socialistic? There's something to be said for both, and I'm not saying it's wrong to have socialistic taxes such as those that were just recently repealed in France - but if that's the case, we need to own up and admit that is what we want.

It is an exercise in futility to ask to levy taxes on the middle class and above to subsidize the cost of a welfare nation while pretending that is not the case. If that's what you want to do, fine. Nothing in the constitution (despite what your favorite talk show might say) says a thing (explicitly) about capitalism vs socialism one way or the other. It's a democracy and we're free to choose our own path. But let's not do one thing while pretending to be another.

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by rayiner on Thursday January 17, 2013 @01:29PM (#5074197)
> The fact of the matter is, there is nothing proportionate about how much you benefit to how much you pay.

I strongly disagree. I think how much money you make is a very good measure of how much you benefit from the existence of government and civilized society.

Take the family of four. The father sends his kids to public school in Connecticut. But he works at an investment bank. He draws his salary from the economic activities of companies he provides M&A advice to. Those companies benefit from having a work force educated at the public expense. Does the father just benefit from the education his own kids receive, or does he benefit from the educations of the workers at each of his clients?

> The biggest targets are small business owners, startups, lawyers, doctors, engineers, and others of their kind. Can you say for an absolute fact that they owe ~40% of their annual income to the government? I can tell you for a fact that the difference between a freelancer in high demand earning $250k/year vs $100k/year is a matter of the hours you work. If you kill yourself to work around the clock to make more money.... you are rewarded with higher taxes.

No, you are rewarded with more money. If I work more and make $250k instead of $100k, I still have $80-90k extra in my pocket. As someone taxed over 40%, I don't think "man, I'm sick of carrying the weight for all these other people." I think: "all these other people ultimately generate the wealth that allows me to live the way I do." There is a point at which I'd be upset and contemplate moving, but we're not near that point.

The fact is that anywhere else I'd want to live has higher taxes. That's the relevant criterion at the end of the day. My dad, an extremely ambitious man, left Bangladesh (taxes around 8% of GDP) for the U.S. (taxes around 26% of GDP) completely unconcerned about the increased taxes. Do I ever think: "man, it'd be great to go back to Bangladesh and pay low taxes!" Of course not. When I tell my wife "hey honey we should move there" it's never to a low tax place like Botswana. It's France, Germany, Canada, etc. Hell, I could save a lot of money and move to Texas but I'm not willing to do that either. Taxes pay for a pleasant civilized society.

Indeed, it's the doctors, lawyers, engineers, etc, who benefit from that the most. We don't have "fuck you" money. We can't go to a low-tax jurisdiction in the middle east and set up a luxurious bubble for ourselves amid the squalor. We live in cities, use public transit, and have to interact with everyone else. We get to live very well in pleasant surroundings as a result of these taxes.

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by ComputerGuru on Thursday January 17, 2013 @01:38PM (#5074271)
> I think how much money you make is a very good measure of how much you benefit from the existence of government and civilized society.

Please explain how a web designer making $250k a year freelancing out of an apartment in NYC is "benefiting" from the government more than a $30k/year individual on welfare.

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by rayiner on Thursday January 17, 2013 @01:50PM (#5074356)
How much do web designers make in Somalia? How much do construction workers make in Somalia? Compute the incremental benefit for each of those people in moving from Somalia to NYC and you have your answer.
Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by cantastoria on Thursday January 17, 2013 @02:09PM (#5074497)
Comparing any Western economy to a warn-torn and completely corrupt country that just happens to not have an income tax is a bit absurd isn't it. You're implying that if only they paid a high income tax in Somalia all all their problems would be solved. To say nothing of the fact that there's a reason for it. The country basically has a barter economy making tax collection impossible. It does however have an official tax policy:

From http://www.nationsencyclopedia.com/Africa/Somalia.html: In 1986, tax rates on wages and salaries ranged from 0% to 18.9%. Income from trade and the professions was taxed at rates of up to 35%. Indirect taxes are imposed on imports, exports, mortgages, vehicle registration, sugar, alcohol, and a number of other goods and services. In 2003, Somolia's sales tax rate was 10%.

And you're ignoring the fact that many countries in the world do not charge income tax are quite nice places to live. Bermuda, Monaco, Kuwait and UAE to name a few.

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by rayiner on Thursday January 17, 2013 @02:16PM (#5074556)
> And you're ignoring the fact that many countries in the world do not charge income tax are quite nice places to live. Bermuda, Monaco, Kuwait and UAE to name a few.

I would strongly disagree that anywhere in the Middle East is a nice place to live (besides Israel), but in any case you're using four very bad examples. None of those places are sustainable societies on their own. Bermuda and Monaco are rent seekers--they are so pleasant because they are tax havens for wealth created elsewhere. Kuwait and UAE don't create any wealth to speak of either--their "GDP" is really just consumption of capital that happened to be under their ground. See: http://www.columbia.edu/~mh2245/papers1/erc01.pdf.

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by strlen on Thursday January 17, 2013 @05:37PM (#5075697)
> I would strongly disagree that anywhere in the Middle East is a nice place to live (besides Israel)

Precisely! Israel has notoriously high taxes: if you're going to make an argument about how high taxes and socialism (literal socialism, as in state-owned companies) are a bad idea, this is one country where you can confidently do this. I (and many Israelis) would agree that Israel could probably benefit from lower taxes, more privatization, and less regulation. Ironically this is why, despite being Jewish and strongly "pro-Israeli", I oppose foreign aid to Israel: it helps prop up an inefficient system in Israel and serves as corporate welfare for US arms manufacturers (I think some of it has explicit provisions that it must be spent with, e.g., Colt or Lockheed-Martin as opposed to IMI or IAI).

Yet, go up to any Ayn Rand fanatic and ask them if they'd prefer to live in UAE/Qatar/Bahrain or in Israel. They'll say they'd prefer Israel as it's a socially liberal, democratic state, that recognized basic individual rights.

Democracy and individual rights require an entire infrastructure of impartial judiciary, tightly scrutinized police, a citizen's army that can defend the borders against immense odds. A socially liberal populace is the end-result of education. None of those things are free.

There are indeed countries that are pleasant on the surface (i.e., are not Somalia), and have very low tax rates without relying on natural resources. Almost always they either a) have high amount of "hidden" inequality (some states in the US, some countries in Asia and Eastern Europe) b) are police states (Singapore) c) are both (Middle East)

I would also say states in the "a" category (with most favorable outcome -- individual rights, inequality of opportunity and income, but equality before the law) also on average have higher tax rates than states in "b" and "c" categories.

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by rayiner on Thursday January 17, 2013 @09:54PM (#5076785)
> There are indeed countries that are pleasant on the surface (i.e., are not Somalia), and have very low tax rates without relying on natural resources. Almost always they either a) have high amount of "hidden" inequality (some states in the US, some countries in Asia and Eastern Europe) b) are police states (Singapore) c) are both (Middle East)

I really can't think of any pleasant countries, to tell the truth, that have appreciably lower taxes than the U.S. Hong Kong, Taiwan, and Singapore are all special cases, and I'm not sure their examples are really generalizable.

The Middle Eastern countries (UAE, etc) can't be counted because their wealth comes from selling off their natural capital. Selling off the furniture isn't really "income". Hong Kong and Taiwan are special cases. A lot of their expenditures are heavily subsidized (e.g. defense, by China and the U.S., respectively).

See: See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_tax_revenu...

Sort by the Heritage Foundation column, from lowest to highest. The first country on that list I'd even consider living in is Lithuania. But even then it's not an entirely fair comparison. Countries like Lithuania are subsidized by regional stability propped-up by the defense spending of bigger neighbors. Moreover, the eastern european countries generally don't have the aging problem the U.S. and western european countries have. Then you've got Croatia, South Korea, and the U.S. around 27%. I'd live in any of those places. Going from there up to 35%, you've got some really livable countries: Japan, Switzerland, Australia, Ireland, Canada, New Zealand. If the U.S. eliminated it's deficit entirely based on tax increases (discounting the effects of the recession which we continue to be in) we'd probably only be around Ireland and Australia in terms of taxes.

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by strlen on Thursday January 17, 2013 @10:32PM (#5076928)
I think we're in agreement. Taxes are a small but seemingly inevitable cost to pay for living in a liberal democracy.

I am also not using pleasant literally here: as in, places stuffwhitepeoplelike.com crowd like to visit and rave about, but would not chose as a place to settle down with children.

I like US (Bay Area in specific) and am not going anywhere. As far as within the US, I considered Seattle area, Portland area, and Austin as mental exercises, but Bay Area seems to represent the best set of trade offs in terms of what I want.

US could have either lower taxes or same taxes and greater social benefits if excessive military adventures or the drug war were curtailed, however, but the change would probably come gradually.

I am curious as to how Taiwan and Singapore are able to sustain low tax rates despite welfare states, military on active alert, and in Singapore's case, an expansive police state. Would never be able to live in Singapore (I can say that with absolute certainty), slight chance I might consider Taiwan (but probably a "no" too).

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by danielweber on Thursday January 17, 2013 @01:55PM (#5074403)
It feels like you could use the exact same argument to justify a 99% income tax. If government passed a 99% income tax, would you support it with this argument, or would a different argument come into play to say it's too much?
Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by rayiner on Thursday January 17, 2013 @02:09PM (#5074498)
Yes you could, if that were the only operative consideration. The U.S.A. is a club and the people are free to charge whatever fee they wish for membership. In the absence of belonging to any such club, we'd just be subsistence farmers so any fee between that and what you can make as a member of the club is in my opinion fair in that sense.

Of course that's not the only operative consideration. There are other clubs that charge different fees, which might be less. You can always move to Club Canada or Club Germany, (or wherever). In a globalized society the "fair" tax rates are limited not by some abstract ethical consideration, but by competition between countries to offer the most pleasant societies for the lowest tax burdens.

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by ComputerGuru on Thursday January 17, 2013 @01:54PM (#5074400)
Seriously? Talk about a strawman. No one is comparing how much taxes are in Somalia to NYC. Tell me how much more a web designer in NYC benefits from the government than another random person in NYC taking welfare.
Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by rayiner on Thursday January 17, 2013 @02:01PM (#5074444)
It's not a straw man at all.

You asked: "Please explain how a web designer making $250k a year freelancing out of an apartment in NYC is "benefiting" from the government more than a $30k/year individual on welfare."

How do you measure how much someone benefits from the government? Your comment suggests you're looking only at the value of services directly received, but that's not the proper way of computing the total benefit. You have to do a marginal analysis, looking at the incremental benefit as you go from "no government" to "government."

The economic insight here is that your benefit from the existence of government is not a fixed amount valued by the services you utilize directly. Rather, it's a percentage of the incremental gain in wealth that is enabled by the existence of government. And because societies without government basically cannot create more than subsistence-level wealth, that increment is a big number.

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by yummyfajitas on Thursday January 17, 2013 @02:45PM (#5074740)
You have to do a marginal analysis, looking at the incremental benefit as you go from "no government" to "government."

That's not a marginal analysis. A marginal analysis would be going from "slightly lower taxes, slightly less government" to "slightly higher taxes, slightly more government".

You seem to want to debate (all by yourself) primitive tribal society vs civilization.

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by rayiner on Thursday January 17, 2013 @02:47PM (#5074758)
The question was: "how does someone making $250k benefit more from government than someone making $30k living on welfare?" My point is that how you calculate how much you benefit from "government" (not bigger or smaller government, just government in general) is not just a function of direct services received, but the incremental gain in wealth going from no government to the government you have. Ergo, the fact that the guy making $250k in NYC would lose a lot more than the guy making $30k if there was no "government" he benefits more from the existence of "government."

This is not an argument about the desirability or optimality of bigger or smaller government or higher or lower taxes. That should be an empirical fight.

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by RyanIyengar on Thursday January 17, 2013 @03:50PM (#5075122)
Mortgage interest deduction, corporate subsidies and tax breaks to large companies that employ that web designer, governmental subsidized infrastructure
Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by vubuntu on Thursday January 17, 2013 @05:32PM (#5075669)
Also, the kind of society, economy and marketplaces created by the existence of such a stable government (and society) that creates the demand and the need for the existence of web properties that would require a web designer to create them. I mean, come on at some point there was 'webvan' that delivered groceries to your doorstep. In somalia, you walk miles to get some or you grow your own ! And that is just one example. Even in developing countries like India, ecommerce is just picking up now a days. Few years back such 'conveniences' were non-existent, meaning no need for 'web-designers' in such a society.
Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by strlen on Thursday January 17, 2013 @05:25PM (#5075632)
> Please explain how a web designer making $250k a year freelancing out of an apartment in NYC is "benefiting" from the government more than a $30k/year individual on welfare.

Oh come on, this is ridiculous. You know this is not true given US as it is. It may be true of a social democracy in Europe, but this is just not true of the US.

The wealthy web designer in NYC benefits from police protection, public transport he can take everywhere, subsidies and grants his university (whether public or private) has received, the use of eminent domain to build said transport, the use of eminent domain to turn over land to a real estate developer that built his apartment building, and (most obviously!) the Internet (once called ArpaNet) from which he makes his living. After tax, the web designer has far more left over and suffers less anxiety as he isn't living paycheck to paycheck (unless he so wishes).

I don't know New York geography as well, so I'll switch to Bay Area to discuss the $30k/year individual (who, by the way, is not eligible for welfare). First, they likely can't even reside close to an area with public transport and jobs, so they're commuting two hours from, e.g., Stockton or Modesto (having to pay for vehicle maintenance, car insurance, license and registration fees themselves). Yes, they do benefit from the freeways, but the stress involved in driving on the freeway (high traffic, long commute, high risk of accidents) is far greater than the stress involved in taking the New York Metro.

They're far more likely to have an unpleasant experience with police personally (being pulled over, searched, etc...). Their city police forces are also reluctant to pursue anything other than violent crime. After tax, a far higher percentage of their income goes to meet the basic needs, and it usually does not -- they're underinsured, they suffer from obesity (due to eating cheaper, poor quality food: fast food joints and microwaveable mac-n-cheese, etc...), and overall poor health.

I have a lot of sympathy with libertarian views (I voted for Gary Johnson as a protest vote in 2012 elections, actually), but their sympathies are simply misplaced: argue for less welfare for the upper classes (e.g., mandate that new public transportation must cover the poor communities first, oppose use of eminent domain by real estate developers), lower taxes for the poor, higher long term capital gains in place of higher income tax (with some reasonable limitations as not to stunt economic growth), etc...

The wealthy do not mind high income taxes. Simply put, look at their voting patterns: 75% of them vote for Democrats, 25% of them vote for Giuliani/Schwarzenegger Republicans. Neither are "small government" advocates. If they did want lower taxes, they'd immediately have the government's ear: e.g., this is why capital gains remains low.

Sad fact is the government listens to wealthy more so than to the poor. This is why some "progressive" policies (that mostly benefit the wealthy) get implemented quickly and others (that mostly benefit the less well-of) linger. You can argue that in a theoretical society Internet could be built by free enterprise, cities could be built without eminent domain, etc... but we don't live in this society now. Right now, if you're concerned about government handouts, go after people like me instead of your hypothetical "$30k/year individual on welfare".

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by hnwh on Thursday January 17, 2013 @03:30PM (#5075000)
You sound like someone who's not busting their ass off, and paying half their income in taxes
Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by majormajor on Thursday January 17, 2013 @01:29PM (#5074192)
"Approaching 50%" sounds very misleading to me. The top percentage on that graphic is 30%, for 196.3/650. And before the increases, the top percentage was 27%, for 70.4/260.

From that perspective, those changes look like much ado about nothing to me. 30% is a long, long way from 50%.

Edit: it's also, other than for the retirees, not very graduated at all. 28% for the 230K earner, 30% for the 650K earners. Personally I would like to see a higher marginal rate bracket, as well as a raise on capital gains, which you mention in your edit, if we're trying to balance the budget. (Side question: are capital gains taxes done progressively at all? Would it make sense to have marginal rates and tax smaller capital gains much less than large ones? Why or why not?)

(Further edit on that note: my personal crazy idea of the moment is to have dramatically higher rates on, say, 500K+ marginal income, but not matchingly high rates on capital gains of that same amount; my idea being to try to encourage higher levels of compensation to be given in forms like equity that would require long-term business success, not just short term profits, to pay off. But I'm not tax lawyer or accountant or whatever, so I'm sure there are problems with that idea...)

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by apaprocki on Thursday January 17, 2013 @01:33PM (#5074229)
The tax amounts don't include state and local taxes. NYC residents pay ~12.8% state/local tax on top of federal taxes.
Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by rayiner on Thursday January 17, 2013 @01:57PM (#5074422)
There are people who pay 40%+, however they're a relatively small bunch. Basically singles making $250-$400k in ordinary income. Basically, no quintile, nor the top 5% or 1% sub-groups pay more than about 30% on average: http://www.ctj.org/pdf/taxday2011.pdf
Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by muzz on Thursday January 17, 2013 @01:44PM (#5074317)
They also don't include nearly the amount of deductions and exemptions that Americans actually use.

For the most recent year of data, the average American paid 7.2% of income in Federal income tax. Even the Top 1% of income earners only paid 21% and the next 4% paid 14.6% [1]

[1] http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/taxfacts/displayafact.cfm?Doc...

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by majormajor on Thursday January 17, 2013 @01:40PM (#5074281)
Including state and local taxes opens up a huge additional can of worms since that varies so much; if you want to do it really thoroughly, you have to start looking into how common renting vs buying is and how property taxes vary.

You could also throw sales taxes in. This would show how its impact is felt more at certain income levels.

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by hnwh on Thursday January 17, 2013 @03:34PM (#5075025)
And that's just coming in.. add 5%-9% as soon as you spend that dollar
Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by homosaur on Thursday January 17, 2013 @01:25PM (#5074166)
You're projecting. Most of the comments are about how ridiculous the infographic is with single moms making 250k and looking sad. It's more of a laugh at the elites who read WSJ and think these kind of incomes are NORMAL than about the tax implications.
Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by ahallock on Thursday January 17, 2013 @01:50PM (#5074355)
Morally you are not obligated to pay taxes. Forced taxation (redundant) violates the non-aggression principle. Forget the propaganda you hear; taxation is theft, regardless of the perceived benefits or ex post facto justification for the theft. People in a situation of coercion and force crave propaganda so they can feel like they still have some sort of control and that the violations of their property rights are justified.

There are plenty of government services I don't want or need but am forced to pay for, or at least my grandchildren will be forced to pay for (wars, welfare state, war on drugs, etc). It's not right and we need to evolve beyond using such violence.

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by strlen on Thursday January 17, 2013 @06:04PM (#5075827)
How do you enforce non-coercion principle against private coercion without a police and judiciary that is obligated to protect everyone fairly (including those who are unable to pay for police services at one point or another)?

Let's say I go and swing my fists, but manage to hit your nose. Then, I jump into my car and drive home on a (private owned, presumably) road. Now suppose you're in poverty: how do you pay for police to come and investigate what happened, for the prosecutor to start a trial against me. Suppose I am now assigned to pay you restitution and become indigent: how would I pay to ensure that I am not tortured in prison, appeal my case (I had a nervous tick that forced my arm to swing, so I should not have to pay as high of restitution)?

Protecting your rights from (government or individual) transgressions is a categorical imperative: we must be able to provide to everyone, even if they are fully indigent.

Yet it, absolutely, does not come for free. So we need some kind of taxation (or other income scheme) to ensure the bare minimum.

I would agree that it's unwise to spend it on foreign wars and the war on drugs: so let's first stop having foreign wars and the war on drugs!

However, the wealthier an individual is, the more it costs the government to protect their life, liberty, and property. Think of how much money is spent to keep a square foot of Manhattan safe as opposed to a square foot of Modesto.

I agree that in some cases taxes are inhumane: e.g., I think it's wrong to force pay someone who earns no income to either pay a property tax or sell their property. I also think eminent domain gets abused unfairly.

Yet, categorically, "the right to receive income in currency protected and recognized as result of government force" is an important one -- but one that can be curtailed as to allow enforcement of the more fundamental rights.

You're also ignoring the role even a minimal social safety net plays in reducing coercive power of private employers.

You may want to read what these guys have to say: http://bleedingheartlibertarians.com/, as well as actual classical liberals (see, e.g., Karl Popper's works)

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by ahallock on Thursday January 17, 2013 @07:13PM (#5076210)
I will definitely take a look at the site. I wouldn't want to ignore information based on my own bias.

I see the appeal of what you're saying, and I'm indeed concerned with private coercive power; however, explaining the "how" behind a free society is contradictory and presupposes State power. I can't tell you how it would work without the State, the same way I can't tell how an iPhone is made (besides some high-level explanation), or how the process came to be that produced it. I don't know what solutions people will come up with.

I would say, though, how is justice being served now? Is there not police corruption, abuse of power, innocent people thrown in jail (especially for drugs), unjust laws, etc? I would argue that this fair system you speak of does not exist, and would never exist under the State. I'm not saying it would exist in a free society (to err is human), but at least it wouldn't be centralized. At least we'd have third-party options. Maybe there would a financial incentive for you to not incite violence. Perhaps you'd be socially ostracized for your actions. Maybe I'd have to live with my broken nose. Again, not saying that this is the way it would work, only that there are plenty of creative solutions that don't involve a central, coercive agency.

There are a few books here that go into the possible solutions: http://freedomainradio.com/FreeBooks.aspx

Also, for any of this to happen, there must a multi-generational philosophical awakening, in which people would become less violent and more open to peaceful solutions.

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by strlen on Thursday January 17, 2013 @07:47PM (#5076333)
> Is there not police corruption, abuse of power, innocent people thrown in jail (especially for drugs), unjust laws, etc?

You can fight against drug war (and this seems to be catching on) without abandoning the idea of police and judiciary.

Indeed, several high-taxation socialist countries in Europe (and here I'm using socialist literally) have decriminalized many drugs.

I don't see a correlation between this: taxation serves a legitimate purpose of protecting society, yet most drug prohibitions do not. If we de-criminalize drugs and you, say, start your own drug factory (not saying you will): who will protect you if the Zettas decides to move and destroy you as competition?

I do commend you for having the intelectual honesty to advanced anarcho-capitalism (as opposed to "government can tax me to go to war, but taxation is slavery if they use my taxes to provide healthcare"). However, I'll suggest this: if you want to focus on advancing the cause of anarcho-capitalism and small government, focus on drug war, foreign wars, police overreach, etc... first and then start talking about taxation. If you must talk about taxes, first start talking about gross abuses of taxation and eminent domain, e.g., using tax liens to confiscate homes of otherwise poor people and put them in the hands of real-estate developers. You can also talk about how the wealthy don't actually pay very high taxes in reality (long term capital gains vs. income), and so on... but the arguments about how the government is unfairly exploiting the rich to benefit the poor are simply silly.

The wealthy want and actively benefit from big government, so policies that make the government more (not less) responsive to the wealthy, actively hurt your cause.

David D. Friedman is the one anarcho-capitalist I am familiar with, but he mostly makes a consequentialist as opposed to ethical case for anarcho-capitalism (acknowledging the imperfections his system will have).

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by yummyfajitas on Thursday January 17, 2013 @01:34PM (#5074235)
Snark is easier than addressing philosophical questions.

See also Tyler Cowen's insightful comments on a similar snark-fest: Beware of moral arguments which do not address "At which margin?"*

http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2010/09/doe...

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by mikeash on Thursday January 17, 2013 @01:36PM (#5074248)
Diminishing marginal utility tells us that a progressive tax code makes the most sense. 10% of a wealthy person's income is worth less to that person than 10% of a poor person's income. It makes sense to have higher rates on higher incomes because that's the fair way to do things.

What alternative do you propose?

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by yummyfajitas on Thursday January 17, 2013 @01:41PM (#5074289)
On the other hand, heterogeneous preferences suggest that redistribution to the lower classes might be welfare destroying.

Rich people tend to want money a lot, as demonstrated by their propensity to work very hard. In contrast, poor people tend to prefer time to money, as demonstrated by their propensity to avoid working and not even look for work. If we transfer money from people who value it to people who don't, that's hardly a good thing.

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by mikeash on Thursday January 17, 2013 @02:03PM (#5074457)
> Rich people tend to want money a lot, as demonstrated by their propensity to work very hard. In contrast, poor people tend to prefer time to money, as demonstrated by their propensity to avoid working and not even look for work.

I'm gobsmacked at this generalization. I seriously don't know what to say. I hope you realize how wrong this is, because I don't really know how to explain it.

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by yummyfajitas on Thursday January 17, 2013 @02:41PM (#5074713)
Obviously it's a generalization that only describes statistical aggregates (much like your claim about diminishing marginal utility).
Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by mikeash on Thursday January 17, 2013 @02:59PM (#5074839)
Is that generalization actually supported by data?
Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by yummyfajitas on Thursday January 17, 2013 @04:17PM (#5075275)
Here is data on the poor (note labor force participation rates, compare to the population as a whole), I'll try to dig up data on the rich later.

http://www.bls.gov/cps/cpswp2010.pdf

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by holograham on Thursday January 17, 2013 @04:06PM (#5075210)
This is where economics can become an art.

Extremely successful people tend to work for passion more than money. A progressive tax system would not lower output in this case. Think Warren Buffet.

There is a swath of upper income folks who can throttle their work to their own personal marginal utility. A lawyer can choose to work for a low pressure firm for a great (not lucrative) salary. An IBanker can choose a less demanding M&A position at an established company for a substantial paycut. A doctor can choose a hospitalist position over private practice (or regulate his/her hours/# patients at their private practice). An entrepreneur can cash out of his first company and choose to not start another company. The restauranteur can be content with launching 2 successful restaurants.

Now the trick is how do you ensure the tax code does not stop these professionals from performing that extra effort. For many 400k a year looks like a striking sum but typically these folks are killing themselves for salaries in that range. Most could easily throttle back to a 200k salaried position.