News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by rayiner on Thursday January 17, 2013 @02:01PM (#5074444)
It's not a straw man at all.

You asked: "Please explain how a web designer making $250k a year freelancing out of an apartment in NYC is "benefiting" from the government more than a $30k/year individual on welfare."

How do you measure how much someone benefits from the government? Your comment suggests you're looking only at the value of services directly received, but that's not the proper way of computing the total benefit. You have to do a marginal analysis, looking at the incremental benefit as you go from "no government" to "government."

The economic insight here is that your benefit from the existence of government is not a fixed amount valued by the services you utilize directly. Rather, it's a percentage of the incremental gain in wealth that is enabled by the existence of government. And because societies without government basically cannot create more than subsistence-level wealth, that increment is a big number.

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by yummyfajitas on Thursday January 17, 2013 @02:45PM (#5074740)
You have to do a marginal analysis, looking at the incremental benefit as you go from "no government" to "government."

That's not a marginal analysis. A marginal analysis would be going from "slightly lower taxes, slightly less government" to "slightly higher taxes, slightly more government".

You seem to want to debate (all by yourself) primitive tribal society vs civilization.

Re:How Much Will Your Taxes Jump? by rayiner on Thursday January 17, 2013 @02:47PM (#5074758)
The question was: "how does someone making $250k benefit more from government than someone making $30k living on welfare?" My point is that how you calculate how much you benefit from "government" (not bigger or smaller government, just government in general) is not just a function of direct services received, but the incremental gain in wealth going from no government to the government you have. Ergo, the fact that the guy making $250k in NYC would lose a lot more than the guy making $30k if there was no "government" he benefits more from the existence of "government."

This is not an argument about the desirability or optimality of bigger or smaller government or higher or lower taxes. That should be an empirical fight.