Rich people tend to want money a lot, as demonstrated by their propensity to work very hard. In contrast, poor people tend to prefer time to money, as demonstrated by their propensity to avoid working and not even look for work. If we transfer money from people who value it to people who don't, that's hardly a good thing.
I'm gobsmacked at this generalization. I seriously don't know what to say. I hope you realize how wrong this is, because I don't really know how to explain it.
Extremely successful people tend to work for passion more than money. A progressive tax system would not lower output in this case. Think Warren Buffet.
There is a swath of upper income folks who can throttle their work to their own personal marginal utility. A lawyer can choose to work for a low pressure firm for a great (not lucrative) salary. An IBanker can choose a less demanding M&A position at an established company for a substantial paycut. A doctor can choose a hospitalist position over private practice (or regulate his/her hours/# patients at their private practice). An entrepreneur can cash out of his first company and choose to not start another company. The restauranteur can be content with launching 2 successful restaurants.
Now the trick is how do you ensure the tax code does not stop these professionals from performing that extra effort. For many 400k a year looks like a striking sum but typically these folks are killing themselves for salaries in that range. Most could easily throttle back to a 200k salaried position.
What alternative do you propose?