I'm surprised, jerf, to see this kind of comment coming from you (as I take care to follow your comments on HN). If investors are only interested in a technology after the government lavishes your tax dollars and mine on developing it, to me the technology is surely less promising than a technology that develops mostly through private investment. People spending their own money usually does better at identifying technologies with a large upside than efforts to get government backing for this or that "strategic" or "breakthrough" technology.
The current way that objections to nuclear power from the uranium cycle (the kind of power I enjoy here as I type this) are usually dealt with is try any and every technology other than nuclear power. I agree with the statements in this thread that "nuclear" by itself isn't a label that indicates that the power source is bad, but I point out that private investors seem to be seeking to invest in a lot of other kinds of power sources more than they are seeking to invest in thorium.
AFTER EDIT: I spent a while just now searching for a linkable version of the special report on the world natural gas market published in The Economist a few months ago. (I don't know what prompted the downvote that came while I was doing that.) I haven't found a link yet, but I have to recommend that special report section of the print edition of The Economist to anyone who hasn't had a chance to read it yet.
The statement from my top-level comment above that I'm being asked to defend is "I'm not aware of any part of the world where local politics would make a thorium plant more likely than another wind power plant or natural-gas-fired power plant. So maybe thorium power generation is a technical solution looking for a problem." But I'll come right back at anyone who claims that thorium power has a big future by asking, do you have a solid estimate how much it will cost to produce electricity with thorium, considering the entire technological process from mining to by-product disposal? The production of natural gas by "fracking" is revolutionizing the world energy economy
http://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21569037-why-worlds-m...
http://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21569039-europes-ener...
and has probably given the development of renewable energy sources two extra decades to become economically competitive. That's enough. Green energy development is a necessity around the world,
http://www.economist.com/node/21556904
and all the other modalities will be researched and receive further commercial development. By the time thorium power could come on line, you and I and everybody will have renewable energy at competitive cost, with natural gas having bridged the transition.
AFTER SECOND EDIT: Thanks for your reply, jerf, which was posted as I was writing my first edit. Every which kind of power generation, as the references I've just added to this comment make clear, is developing in a market distorted by tax-funded subsidies. Better to let purer market forces sort out the trade-offs among different energy sources. I was just reminded that pg, our site founder, has been following this industry for a long time.
http://www.paulgraham.com/ladder.html
"After all, projects within big companies were always getting cancelled as a result of arbitrary decisions from higher up. My father's entire industry (breeder reactors) disappeared that way."
My comment is that any Baby Boomer who read about physics as a kid (like me) heard about thorium DECADES ago, and has heard thorium repeatedly mentioned as the energy source of the future, a future that never comes. Paul Graham's dad worked for one company in the power industry, and my late dad the industrial engineer worked for another company in the industry, manufacturing electric generators for power plants. The power sources that spin electric generators were always dinner table conversation in my home when I was growing up. I think thorium is a very interesting fissile element, but my person guess about future power development is that there will never be a thorium power plant in Japan, in Germany, in the United States, or even in nuclear-plant-friendly France.
The whole private vs. public issue is really obscured by the extreme, extreme regulation surrounding the entire area. I suspect it's overkill, while at the same time I can't deny one does not want to live anywhere near an unsafe power generation facility. (I did start to say "nuclear reactor", but it's more general than that, really.)
Take a look at what DARPA is investing in now: http://www.darpa.mil/our_work/
While much of it is unfortunately directed in part towards destruction and warfare, the projects are above and beyond what investors are investing in.
Just a quick look at the Microsystems group projects: "The Casimir Effect Enhancement (CEE) program seeks to manipulate forces very near surfaces to enable control of small-scale phenomena, including nanodevice adhesion and friction. The objectives of this single-phase DARPA program are to demonstrate unambiguous detection, neutralization, and dynamic manipulation of the Casimir force to modulate between normal and neutralized states. Some approaches to these program goals include the development of new materials, engineered nanostructures, or active elements. Recent research activities (models and experiments) have already identified manipulation of the Casimir force as an important challenge."
Edit: To clarify the feedback loop comment: I think the jury is still out on the effect of economic incentives. In my opinion, looking at the degradation of privately funded pure research over the last 30-40 years (Bell, Xerox PARC, etc), economic incentives are only effective once someone (usually academia funded by the gov't) has laid the ground work. Investors will not do that.
I don't see this argument as a specific counterpoint to Thorium-based nuclear power. That said, I am not particularly informed as to the benefits or drawbacks of Thorium -- I'm just observing that the counter-arguments don't seem to be particularly specific to Thorium and could have easily been applied to Uranium-based nuclear power had this been 1932 instead of 2012.
There is nothing that could be as remote as these two markets.
Also, aside: that guardian article isn't terrible, but the author gets half-lives backwards the way lots of authors seem to, implying that elements with long half-lives are bad, I suppose because we'll need to bury them for longer. It's the elements with short half-lives that are scary; they decay really fast and give people radiation poisoning/cancer/whatever. An element with a 16-million-year half-life is barely emitting anything at all; that's the category of waste that can, as the author of this post says, be buried in a shallow pit in the desert.
But the intermediate timescale poses problems, since there the nuclear waste is radioactive enough to be dangerous and we do not have a good idea how a facility looks like, that can survive one hundred thousand years.
It's really sad to see the different topics gets confused, because they are really different. Thorium as an alternative fuel doesn't really solve much, besides it's maybe cheaper for some countries. Of course the entire expression "Thorium reactors" are somewhat at fault. It's incredible ambiguous, especially when people inside the current nuclear establishment talks about using thorium in (slightly modified) traditional nuclear reactors, such Pressurized Water Reactors.
Of course there are many things which can be said against LFTRs, mostly that it's still an unproven technology. Sadly it'll stay that way if nobody does something about it.
http://energyfromthorium.com/ieer-rebuttal/
They take issue with the IEER report judging thorium as a fuel when they are mostly talking about it in a solid fuel reactor. I can't think of any thorium proponents who are proposing solid fuel thorium reactors. The excitement they have over thorium is almost entirely over its use in the LFTR reactor design (which is not without its own design problems but those are distinct from a solid fuel thorium reactor).
On the matter of Minnesota nuclear plants: I would caution that the perceived cheap power is a result of significant expenses born by the populous as a whole decades ago... expenses that aren't in your power bill today but worth remembering. And similarly, there will eventually be significant expenses born by society as a whole to deal with the waste.
The fact that waste is piling up at all reactor sites---and don't think that's not a hazard in natural disaster/accident situations, let alone targeted strikes---means there is a significant not-yet-quantifiable cost uncertainty inherent to nuclear power.
Cost uncertainty has to be thought of as a significant cost, even higher than the potential cost will actually turn out to be, since we need to assume the worst when we don't know.
Thus if we really want to talk about the true cost of existing nuclear power: it's far higher than what you're paying today per KWh
The fed gov has spent ~$16B on "renewable energy" recently. With 1/10th that money, LFTRs could have been coming off the assembly line at 100MW/day by now. And those plants could be eliminating that SNF as we speak.
The NPR story adds to the original article — the experimental thorium reactor ran for 14 years, not 4. The head of the project was fired by Nixon (hardly a big strike against him).
It seems to me that the NPR show simply raised two objections:
1) you still have nuclear waste — less than with current reactors but arguable how much less.
2) it does not stop nuclear proliferation (this was a heated discussion point with the thorium advocate arguing that it is much harder to harvest U233 from an MSR than plutonium or enriched uranium from other sources and the anti-nuclear guy citing a paper suggesting it's easier. (U233 is easier to make a bomb with than plutonium - i did not know this.)
Of course that's all hearsay from the LFTR advocates :P
http://www.npr.org/2012/05/04/152026805/is-thorium-a-magic-b...
Many of the issues considered in that story are glossed over by advocates of thorium reactors. The author of the blog post kindly submitted here explicitly admits, "My last article about thorium as an alternative nuclear reactor fuel drew way more readers than I expected. I intentionally glossed over the complexities of specific reactor designs for the sake of simplicity, but in this article I want to go deeper." He mentions a number of interesting technical trade-offs involved in using thorium reactor fuel and the latest reactor designs as compared to earlier nuclear reactor designs, but the tone is still largely a tone of credulity, without a lot of examination of non-nuclear means of generating electrical power.
The Physics Stack Exchange discussion of thorium reactors is interesting,
http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/20034/what-practi...
as is the article from The Guardian in June 2011, "Don't believe the spin on thorium being a greener nuclear option."
http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2011/jun/23/thorium-nu...
Advocacy groups are already mobilizing to cast doubt on thorium reactors, with webpages like "Thorium Fuel – No Panacea for Nuclear Power"
http://ieer.org/resource/factsheets/thorium-fuel-panacea-nuc...
(with a link to an interesting fact sheet,
http://ieer.org/wp/wp-content/uploads/2012/04/thorium2009fac...
that gets into the practicalities and economics of using thorium as a reactor fuel).
It's not clear yet that thorium offers any economic or political advantages over the uranium that fuels the nuclear reactor that provides much of my home electricity. The two nuclear reactors here in Minnesota result in lower-than-average cost for electricity here, compared to the rest of the United States, and have had a perfect safety record. Ongoing concern about where to store high-level radioactive waste on a long-term basis has made many politicians here reluctant ever to approve another nuclear plant in this state, despite the perfect safety record and inexpensive electricity we enjoy with the current plants. Minnesota, as a matter of state policy, is strongly promoting wind energy, fitting the wind-swept prairie geography of much of the state. I'm not aware of any part of the world where local politics would make a thorium plant more likely than another wind power plant or natural-gas-fired power plant. So maybe thorium power generation is a technical solution looking for a problem.