News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by rayiner on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @12:11PM (#5061316)
Come to New York! We're rolling in so much finance money we don't need to hit up small businesses.
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by btilly on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @12:40PM (#5061518)
Thanks, but no thanks. I've experienced New York's laws on intellectual property ownership.

Any programmer who thinks that they should have any right to have "their own time" and "side projects" should leave for a more friendly state. Like California.

I am not joking.

Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by daenz on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @01:33PM (#5061896)
Could you elaborate a bit more on your experiences?
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by btilly on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @02:48PM (#5062500)
No. But it is easily findable online.
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by chimeracoder on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @02:08PM (#5062179)
> Any programmer who thinks that they should have any right to have "their own time" and "side projects" should leave for a more friendly state. Like California.

In New York, you can negotiate a contract to get this clause - it's quite common. The only difference is that contracts without the exemption (ie, total assignments) are considered enforceable, whereas in California, they aren't. That doesn't mean that Californian contracts don't sometimes include those clauses anyway - from a legal strategy standpoint, it's in the company's best interest to do so.

Furthermore, my understanding is that this Californian precedent is rather limited in practice, since it's easy for a company to claim that your product is related to something that the company is doing or is planning on doing (and hard to prove otherwise), and similarly easy for them to claim that you've used company resources and/or time to do the project, as people sometimes do without thinking about it. When you start picking it apart, the Californian exemption is very narrow in letter, and even more so in practice.

In short, you're definitely not missing out on anything automatically by coming to New York, because it depends on what kind of a contract you negotiate. And Californian law won't get you home free either, because there are too many other variables at play, and too many other ways for them to wiggle around the law - they just need the incentive to do so.

Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by btilly on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @03:00PM (#5062587)
The difference is much larger than you acknowledge.

First of all in California it is against the law to fail to inform people of their rights. Thus even in the cases when contracts include those clauses, the impact is severely watered down.

Secondly in New York, even contracts without these clauses by default have them implicitly included.

Thirdly the "claim we're working on everything" issue is real in California, but only for people working for large corporations. People working for small companies can usually make a good case that they are working on something different.

Fourth, there is a real difference in culture. In California it is common for people to do things like"start companies on the side", and therefore the natural response upon finding that someone has done so is to not try to contest it unless they have specific cause to. By contrast in New York this is not common, which means that employers are much, much more likely to try to explore their legal options.

I am sure that it is possible to live in New York, sign careful contracts, and find people who will be supportive. However if management changes, or different lawyers examine those contracts, or someone just does the calculation that you won't be able to afford to assert your rights, I believe that your odds of running into trouble in New York are significantly higher than in California.

Maybe I'm overreacting. But once burned, twice shy. This is among the reasons why I never again want to live in New York. (The weather would be another. The fact that it never quiets enough for me to sleep soundly would be a third.)

Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by walshemj on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @05:02PM (#5063345)
But can you a force the lawyers to enforce your rights in this case a company with deep pockets can drag out a law case for a long and costly time.

Decades in some cases the long running section A pension case went on for well over a decade in the UK conveniently for the employer that meant that the people effected by the decision started dieing off reducing the cost.

Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by ceejayoz on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @12:19PM (#5061373)
As someone who works for a small business in New York... hahahahaha. Ha. Haha.
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by kyrra on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @12:25PM (#5061412)
Your state's gun laws prevent me from ever living there.
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by untog on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @12:31PM (#5061449)
Don't come to New York, then. If your access to rifles is more important than the tax codes your startup may or may not face, stay where you are.
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by cullenking on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @12:47PM (#5061555)
I think it might be something more about the fact that New York's interpretation of the 2nd amendment differs so greatly from mine that I am fearful for what they might do in regards to other constitutional amendments.

As a side note, I cannot move to most cities in Colorado because I happen to have two dogs who are banned by their breed. The point is, there is way more to the conversation than just taxes alone.

Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by king_magic on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @12:53PM (#5061595)
Seriously, I've been throw into the gulags and tortured at least 5 times while living in NY. It's awful - just awful. Don't come here, whatever you do.

Don't say I didn't warn you!

Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by untog on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @01:02PM (#5061653)
I've been throw into the gulags and tortured at least 5 times while living in NY

Seriously, stop going to bars around Times Square. You should know better by now.

Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by king_magic on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @02:43PM (#5062460)
I feel like this joke would also work for "rush hour subways" in place of "bars around Times Square" :)
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by Osiris on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @12:52PM (#5061582)
To other child post: FUD. What the heck does NY have to do with the federal constitution? It takes 3/4 of states to pass a new amendment, so it's not like NY can do it on it's own. The second amendment limits the federal government from passing certain kinds of laws.
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by elliptic on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @01:09PM (#5061702)
Completely false. Like much of the rest of Bill of Rights, the second amendment has been incorporated (see Chicago vs McDonald), and thus held to apply to the states.

It slightly irritates me when people say this, because usually those people have no problem accepting that other amendments that they hold to be more important (e.g, the 1st) apply to the states.

Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by nthj on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @02:02PM (#5062144)
> It slightly irritates me when people say this, because usually those people have no problem accepting that other amendments that they hold to be more important (e.g, the 1st) apply to the states.

Heck, people try to apply the 1st amendment to private corporations & online forums set up by 14 year olds.

Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by strlen on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @12:46AM (#5065531)
Exactly. A sensible position is: "Second amendment recognized an individual right, but I don't think New York's gun laws infringe on it any more than their copyright right laws infringe on first amendment rights." Of course, now you'll need a rational argument to back that position up. I personally think this will be a rather difficult case to argue, whereas most parts of a less restrictive assault weapon ban (like the one they had on books before) could probably withstand immediate scrutiny.

Similarly, gun enthusiasts can't claim that all gun control is unconstitutional. The easy days of magical thinking (whether one side arguing "Second amendment does not protect an individual right!" or the other side arguing "Thomas Jefferson wrote ``Thou needeth an HK-416 with a magazine of thirty cartridges lest black helicopters invade thy farm''!") are done.

Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by pc86 on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @01:16PM (#5061749)
Oh, so I guess there would be no recourse should NY pass a law outlawing newspapers, or barring the assembly of more than two people at any time? The Constitution absolutely does limit federal and state (and county, and municipal, and every) government. It clearly limits the federal government more but to say the second amendment isn't limiting states (either via text or SCOTUS case law) is not true.
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by bdunbar on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @01:11PM (#5061716)
I believe the poster is referring to Cuomo's press conference this morning (1/15) where he announced his intention to enact a ban on rifles, sales of rifles, ammunition, restrict magazine capacity and so on.

http://open.nysenate.gov/legislation/bill/S2230-2013

Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by strlen on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @12:28AM (#5065480)
> To other child post: FUD. What the heck does NY have to do with the federal constitution? It takes 3/4 of states to pass a new amendment, so it's not like NY can do it on it's own. The second amendment limits the federal government from passing certain kinds of laws.

This is completely wrong. Not just for the second amendment, but for pretty much every other Bill of Rights amendment that guarantees a "fundamental right" (including the first, which begins with "congress shall pass no law").

Whether or not you like the idea of private gun ownership (if you don't, you have a lot of room to argue about what is protected under the second amendment)[1], doing away with 14th amendment incorporation would be a horrible idea (Remember Jim Crow? Remember when women could not obtain an abortion, period?)

See:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incorporation_of_the_Bill_of_Ri... -- The doctrine

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McDonald_v._Chicago -- The ruling that incorporated the second amendment. Interestingly Justice Thomas' opinion (in favour of McDonald, but opposed to due process incorporation) is interesting in that it demonstrates an originalist constitutional view (opposed to the view everyone else uses) which is typically associated with conservative politics, despite the fact that joining the majority in a "due process" incorporation would mean probably mean less gun-control laws (a typically conservative opinion) than in using "equal protection" incorporation.

tl;dr 14th amendment incorporation is probably the most important evolution of US constitutional law in terms of expanding actual civil liberties as experienced by US citizens. It is not okay to be ignorant of it.

[1] Second amendment as an individual right is fairly new: first such reading in 2008 (Heller) as opposed to 1919 for first amendment -- despite, of course, both amendments dating back to the 18th century. As a result, there's not much good case law on books: it's very hard to argue a second amendment case from a criminal trial and yet it's also hard to find civil litigants with standing to sue such as Heller. It's safe to say that complete weapon bans or bans that make self-defense impossible are unconstitutional and that bans on fully automatic weapons (like the 1934 National Firearms Act) are constitutional. However, that's not where most of the debate is happening, so a clear standard has not yet evolved (but there are more cases working their way up through the federal courts).

Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by w1ntermute on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @01:23PM (#5061822)
Take a look at the Great State of Texas. It is quite free when it comes to gun laws. For example, I believe it is the only state in which you are allowed to use lethal force to defend your property.

And there's the added benefit that if you learn some basic Spanish, you can hire illegal immigrant labor to do all your housework and gardening for a pittance (this can be done without knowing Spanish, but then you end up wasting money on a middleman, and there are other benefits to knowing Spanish in Texas anyway).

Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by msmith on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @01:57PM (#5062101)
More than half of the states in the Union have some sort of Castle Doctrine or Stand Your Ground law [1]. It's not just Texas.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stand-your-ground_law#United_St...

Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by w1ntermute on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @02:00PM (#5062122)
There's a difference between just having a Castle Doctrine and being allowed to use lethal force. Because if you are not allowed to use lethal force, you always have to worry about the consequences of killing the intruder.
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by redspark on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @03:01PM (#5062599)
Having grown up in Wyoming.

While Wyoming is definitely not a tech hub, they do protect your right to use lethal force to protect your property.

Plus if they steal your horse, you can hang them and shoot them. win/win

Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by strlen on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @12:57AM (#5065564)
> Take a look at the Great State of Texas. It is quite free when it comes to gun laws. For example, I believe it is the only state in which you are allowed to use lethal force to defend your property.

Actually a "duty to retreat" is rather rare. In California, there's a right to use lethal force if you are in a situation where a reasonable person would believe they are in risk of life or limb.

I also don't think you can shoot someone for just being on your property in Texas when there's no reason to suspect they are a danger to you, or if they're just trying to steal your car while you're inside the house, etc...

Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by sl4yerr on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @12:53PM (#5061598)
At this point, mentioning gun legislation is almost an extension of Godwin's law.
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by koenigdavidmj on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @12:49PM (#5061566)
As compared to California?
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by strlen on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @01:28AM (#5065643)
It's feasible (perhaps easier than it should really be) to legally buy a handgun in California: take a test (written test and basic handling of the firearm), pass a background check, 10-day waiting period, and a limit of one per month.

Far more difficult in New York: I've heard "must wait six months", "need to document a specific reason", and both... The overall message being "don't bother."

Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by rdl on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @10:42PM (#5065101)
Congratulations :) That's one of the main factors in why I'm moving in the next year or two. It's a toss-up between WA (which has good gun laws) and TX/NV which have excellent gun laws. (I'll probably be an FFL-07 anyway, so WA's laws aren't substantially different for me, but for someone who wants regular civilian ownership of SBRs, WA is inferior to NV or TX)
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by flagnog on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @01:05PM (#5061672)
and you can't legally buy a Big Gulp. Seriously, and city/county/state govt that would do that, you can't trust them with your livelihood.
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by smsm42 on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @01:22PM (#5061809)
If the government thinks they need to tell you how big a drink you can have, and the citizens agree with it, there's something seriously wrong with both. OTOH, we have plastic bag ban in California and lightbulb ban federally, if I remember correctly, so it's not that easy nowdays to find a place to live where there's not something seriously wrong with it.
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by dragonwriter on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @01:58PM (#5062105)
You remember incorrectly.

There is no statewide plastic bag ban in California (though some California municipalities have restrictions on plastic grocery bags).

And there is no federal lightbulb ban (there is a federal rule providing energy efficiency standards for certain categories of lightbulbs which sets increasing standards including ones which many currently-popular incandescent bulbs would fail; the intent of the bill was to encourage development and sale of more efficient lighting devices, which it has done.)

Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by smsm42 on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @03:30PM (#5062777)
>>>> There is no statewide plastic bag ban in California

OK, I agree - I should have said "in many places in California". Using weasel words like "restriction" - as if only "very dangerous assault bags" were prohibited but there was no problem with regular plastic bags - does not change the fact the bags are banned - in SF, in San Jose, in LA county and in some others. In fact, in most places the regulators themselves flat out call it a "ban" in their explanatory materials.

>>>> And there is no federal lightbulb ban (there is a federal rule providing energy efficiency standards for certain categories

Which is effectively a ban on certain - very widely used - categories of lightbulbs. The fact that the it is called more verbosely does not change the fact that it is a ban. The intent also does not change the fact - I'm sure every governmental ban has tons of supposedly good intents behind it, it does not stop being a ban because of it.

Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by w1ntermute on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @01:50PM (#5062042)
Under Bloomberg, NYC has turned from a police state into a full-fledged nanny state.
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by rayiner on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @02:14PM (#5062234)
To be fair, it's also much nicer to live in (at least for white people) than it ever has been. New York before it became a police state was basically Gotham City.
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by twoodfin on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @04:13PM (#5063023)
What's the marginal improvement under Bloomberg vs. Giuliani's last year in '01? I remember NYC as being in pretty good shape by that point. Has livability improved substantially because of the Bloomberg Nanny State stuff? Smoking bans are pleasant for some, but most everywhere has those now.

Though I do have the impression that Bloomberg has done yeoman's work on public education.

Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by koenigdavidmj on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @02:17PM (#5062263)
Unless you have certain melanin levels, in which case it is still a police state too.
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by w1ntermute on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @02:31PM (#5062365)
Oh, it's still a police state as well, no doubt. It has probably gotten worse under Bloomberg.
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by whalesalad on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @12:33PM (#5061473)
NYC has the most outrageous taxes in the country. You might as well be in France giving up 75%.
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by king_magic on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @12:41PM (#5061526)
Yeah, it's rough. After federal, SS/payroll, NY state and NYC residential taxes, I take home 57.95% of my salary.

I don't have the energy to find which state would give me the best deal, but I seriously doubt it's NY. :-)

Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by almost_usual on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @12:58PM (#5061623)
Probably Texas, or some Midwestern state
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by zzzeek on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @01:47PM (#5062005)
salaries are a lot higher here than in a southern/midwest state though (largely driven by the crazy costs of housing).
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by king_magic on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @02:40PM (#5062440)
The cost of living is brutal here; e.g. $100K in NYC really isn't that great.
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by dyno12345 on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @04:22PM (#5063087)
Don't forget to factor in the savings from not needing a car.
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by almost_usual on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @06:03PM (#5063725)
I live in the Midwest and do not own a vehicle, some cities here have pretty good public transportation!
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by Gmo on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @01:43PM (#5061963)
Stop spreading FUD. You will never give up 75%, it was intended as a marginal rate AND it was even dismissed by the constitutional council.
[deleted]
Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by king_magic on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @12:46PM (#5061549)
No way is it $5,495/month in NY for $100k. $4,829 at best for $100k. With the expiration of the payroll tax, your take-home for NYC for over 100k is roughly 58% for the year.

But then again there might be some tax magic I'm missing.

Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by rayiner on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @12:50PM (#5061576)
Yeah, I can't figure out how to use the internet.

In NYC, including city tax, it's $5,203 versus $5,289 in California. If you live in NJ or Westchester, it's $5,495.

That being said you can live in New York City and get much better public services than say living in Silicon Valley. $100 per month for a MTA pass versus $100 a month for car insurance alone, etc.

Re:California To Hit Startup Founders with Big Retroactive T... by jacoblyles on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @01:36PM (#5061919)
California is now the only place in the nation where moving to NYC may lower your tax rate! (We have the top marginal income tax rate - go us!)