(And it did produce a very competent algorithm, though it took a few days and a metric ton of tokens; I just triggered the same task with Neon).
I was not really fabricating the example I gave too much. Here's a verbatim transcript from a session which was filled with this stuff:
... thought LET'S READ RecordReader.cs RIGHT NOW!! RecordReader.cs IS WHERE EVERY SINGLE TABLE, ReadPlan, DecideValueVisibility, ReadRowCounts , AND ShowValues READS ITS DATA!! Let's read RecordReader.cs (lines 1-300)!It seems rather ironic that Anthropic givens the most logical reasoning traces, though. You'd think if they're ahead they'd either hide them or make them produce garbage (like what seems to come out of Google's models).
Sometimes I'm like...is everybody else using the same thing that I am? This is insane.
It's obvious that what we're getting are summaries. Sometimes I think I even see vestiges of the summarizing model instructions. But, that being the case, it's bizarre why Gemini's summarizer acts like a toddler, and Claude's actually lets me learn and, more importantly, stop it at its tracks when I see it's going down the wrong path.
On the other end of the spectrum, if you toy around with the open-weights models, you see the insanity that is going on in their output. I can totally believe in a scenario where claude is basically doing that and then summarizing it into something coherent, getting rid of the 10 opposing viewpoints, "aha!" and "Hmmm, but wait!", but it does it elegantly.
I've tried constantly to use other models (and I do), but Claude spoils me to no end. I keep thinking I must be holding everything wrong.
You're of course completely right. Interestingly the "summaries" have only become more diverged over time. I now believe the big 3 are barely summarizing at all any more. I deem it likely that the small models don't get the CoT at all, they just completely make up something "plausible" solely based on the user message with a little bit of previous context. Much of the time it will be the complete opposite of something I asked for, or barely related.
Your suggestion is the right one. Everyone who uses LLMs for their job should spend some time with open models like Deepseek and see what the thinking actually looks like.
I haven't even really tried to use other models in the same way, and this thread makes me feel like I don't need to.
(After a long conversation with existing messages)
User Prompt: Ok, so SSH to the unraid server and update the plex db
Reply:
I need to think how to answer this.
The user is asking me to SSH into the unraid server. This seems to imply there is a machine to which we can SSH to. I should look for places where hosts may exist.
The implication is that once SSH is established to unraid, the plex db can be updated. It seems plex is a service that the machine has in which we can run updates.
I'm wondering if plex might be the Plex service the user has been discussing.
So the user doesn't want to SSH to the server - actually they want to SSH to the server.
... Formulating a plan ...
[some messages later]
Aha! THIS IS THE SMOKING GUN! `~/.ssh/config` HAS THE REQUESTED HOST!!! IT'S TIME TO CONNECT!!
[some messages later]
Ok, time to act. I'll ssh to the server and follow coherent rules.
----
I am shocked at how primitive its reasoning sounds (it reads just like gemini 2.5-pro's old reasoning). It often gets the job done (although it's quite slow and can't tackle more sophisticated problems).
Perhaps Anthropic's internal reasoning is also like this, but they really rewrite it to make it seem more coherent (which certainly sells it on me)? I almost want to click stop just by reading this nonsense.