News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by poisonborz on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:12AM (#50545903)
My problem with GTA franchise is that it doesn't try to say anything. Technically it is incredibly impressive, may be the last technically impressive game where details were made by human crafting. Stellar, even considering the 10 year dev time and $1bn+ budget.

But on the surface, the world building basically became Fast & Furious. The "witty" takes on society were reduced to "Fruit" phones and mocking recreation of daytime news. Nothing unsafe. Not wanting preachy storylines, just that there should be something to _experience_, something serious besides "oh this is realistic, let's try to land that jumbo on the beach". Maybe GTA4 was the last entry that had great overtones about migrant life.

I mean, it is a big sandbox and you can roleplay whatever, but the already thin GTA5 was diluted down to water with stupid mictrotransactions, Shark Cards, and the dumbest multiplayer experience there is, and they made a bank on that. I don't expect this to be different, and it just makes the taste sour, despite the otherwise brilliant execution.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by 4gotunameagain on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:20AM (#50545990)
It is true, GTA became from a sharp parody of American society to basically a part of it.

We should be thankful at this stage that all characters are not non binary or something.

Do you remember Vice City commercials ? They mocked everything that was wrong about the US. Now we have mainstream coachella celebrities making appearances in GTA.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by tavavex on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @12:41PM (#50549436)
While Rockstar may have lost some of the edge to being an enormous corporation getting worldwide attention, they never fully stopped with the satire. GTA 5 was packed with radio segments, in-game advertisements and dialogue that satirized the American condition and way of life. I haven't played 6 yet, but I'm cautiously optimistic. I don't think they've been entirely subsumed into the American ethos yet.

> We should be thankful at this stage that all characters are not non binary or something.

If you think that 'proper' satire of modern American culture would involve punching down on non-binary people, then you might be the part of the culture that would be made fun of. The most pointed satire about 2020s Americans would be about rural average Joes overflowing with hatred injected into them through TV and social media, spending days thinking about their biggest worry in life - trans people. All while their closest interaction with a trans person was in quietly clenching fists at a stranger a few tables over at a restaurant.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by 4gotunameagain on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @01:12PM (#50549865)
You don't understand. I want both the rural average Joes AND the hypersensitive social media addicted non binaries to be made fun of.

I am pro equality.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by BobaFloutist on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:01PM (#50552826)
What about the detached cynics mocking from the sidelines, carefully avoiding voicing an assailable stance? =P
Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by throwaway384034 on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:22AM (#50546008)
The bar for what is "unsafe" has been raised in general. Is even South Park considered that 'edgy' anymore? The last I heard about them was about mocking Trump which is hardly anything special.
Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by treetalker on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:25AM (#50546029)
Reminds me of the fourth Matrix movie and Baudrillard.
Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by dandersch on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:26AM (#50546039)
>Maybe GTA4 was the last entry that had great overtones about migrant life.

I agree, but you could also argue that GTA4 was the only entry that took a swing at having a serious, overarching narrative theme. Most of which I still believe to be the influence of the Sopranos (it was at the height of its cultural influence and actively airing as GTA4 was being developed). What was San Andreas trying to say? Was Vice City really that much more than a playable Scarface homage? GTA3's protagonist didn't even speak. Love those games, btw. But in a sense, the franchise just returned to its (much more profitable) roots.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by tavavex on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @12:14PM (#50548982)
The Sopranos probably played a major role, but the biggest obvious influence in GTA 4 is Eastern European crime and war films, and probably a bit of NYC crime media.

San Andreas did have a story and messages about loyalty, rising above your upbringing and police injustice, but it wasn't as tight of a story and it had lots of diversions to let players do fun stuff. It was a different time in gaming. They tried to bring that back in 5 after some players found the darker and more cohesive story of 4 off-putting for a GTA game.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by negura on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @06:33PM (#50553864)
I like this observation a lot. Reminds me of a blog post about Villeneuve's Dune titled "Images without metaphor".

https://archive.ph/EBscH