Obviously there are some limits to this though and making software is becoming really easy for people who know very little about code. Its not good software, but it kinda works, and thats good enough a lot of the time.
I think one of the big limiting factors in how much software engineers are needed is what the potential applications for software are in the future. Maybe we'll just make all the programs we need and that will be that. Maybe there will be some huge software projects that people will be working on for the next 100+ years. Robotics, AI & Space stuff are all kinda promising for jobs if they turn out to be really useful, because there's no end to what kinds of work will be potentially needed in those areas. Too bad the people who run the robots, AI, and space companies are all assholes or morons.
and re-use is solved by the clankers.
what exactly is all this code doing that is being feverishly written / re-written?
I often wonder about that myself. It really does puzzle me!
Historically if you had a dozen software developers with deep niche knowledge of different areas (a few backend, a few front end, a database expert, whatever) now you can probably get by with 3 or 4 people running agents who lack deep knowledge of all of these areas but know enough to get by driving agents.
So, yes, there is deskilling going on, but it is also very likely to be reducing overall headcount significantly because more software can be created by less people.
I don't really buy into the Jevons paradox theory that things will equalize or expand with an explosion in new software being built. We're already starting to drown in slop. And yeah, there will be even more software being built going forward but most of it will likely be built by people who were never historically software developers (and wouldn't have become that had they aged into the labor market sooner).
In the end, AI won't eliminate every software job, but even if just eliminates 25% or 50% that's still an economic crisis that leaves the profession in ruin for most.
Nobody is handwriting code.
I suspect anyone saying AI isn't going to reduce headcount or pay, has not seen a full AI shop at work. We have integrated AI tools EVERYWHERE. Something happens in our software stack, it's audited first across the entire code base, by AI agents. These AI agents have confidence levels based on our own internal direction and instrumentation, and are able to fix code and push to production without ANY human involvement.
Slop, I hear people say. Nope. We've improved our products dramatically over the last year. We've shipped more code than ever, and have the actual metrics to prove that we are performing better across the board.
This is why I can so confidently say AI will be detrimental to the software engineering career. I can see it myself, every day. We're shipping at the most insane pace ever, and some days look around wondering what to even do. Entire apps (we have 7) are built on a days/weeks timescale, not months or years.
The number of graduates in computing programs is at an all time high. It will adjust quickly, as the message gets out (no jobs). Like 5 years.
People leave the software industry all the time. As they do every industry. A certain percent go into management. Some go into sales. Some inherit money and retire. This will be hastened if the wages are normalized closer to other professions. If my tech job paid $120K, then I would seriously consider starting a coffee truck with my friend, or going into real estate, or.... But when it is $240k, the desire is suppressed.
Reading HN, the future is a 99% drop. That will not be absorb-able.
We are going through a period of “deskilling” that many other industries have also seen in the past. This has historically resulted in pay reduction.