News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Claude Code and Codex reverse engineered my 1994 Jeep's E... by rpcope1 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @08:59PM (#50513125)
I mean, I've seen some stupid it's told me at various stages that would never show up in a textbook like Halderman, and would get you ridiculed on a forum, and more importantly were sufficiently stupid that even a lube tech wouldn't do it. I like trying to push and see what the technology can do or suggest, but it will suggest outrageous shit. As an example I had it tell me that I should put something like ten quarts of oil in a gas engine (don't recall what). It was probably the right amount for a Duramax or Powerstroke, but if you know anything about gas engines alarm bells should be going off that that's too much by far, almost always. I've actually seen Claude say the FSM was wrong on stuff; rarely the FSM is stupid, or more likely there's a Kent-Moore or equivalent tool that's very different that's unobtanium, but it's never that which trips it up. Just dumb shit like saying suggesting tools that are inappropriate or dangerous, wrong torque values, inappropriate fluids or change proceeds, grossly wrong diagnosis (and extremely confident in being wrong). Probably most strikingly is around electric and wiring it just totally biffs it 9 out of 10 times. Claude has no concept of floating grounds, ground loops, electrical diagnostic procedures, and can't read a wiring diagram at all. Not totally unexpected, but if you believe this shit is AGI you're in for a very rude and expensive surprise.

For whatever it's worth, that a) Astra struggles less on this for some reason, and b) things tend to work better if you have a copy of the FSM and some other appropriate lit like Halderman and quality forum posts or alldata if it's appropriate and tell it to work from there. I've been working on a big search engine for this that feeds a known good corpus like an ass load of contemporary MotorAge mags, relevant technician texts, the FSM, other quality data sources like BITOG, known not-shit forums, along with OBD2 data via something like an OBDLink dongle or a J2534 setup. I still would not trust it, but it can be helpful to eliminate or brainstorm some possibilities.

Re:Claude Code and Codex reverse engineered my 1994 Jeep's E... by kilpikaarna on Monday November 16, 2026 @02:38AM (#50515062)
> FSM

Factory service manual, in case anyone else is wondering what the finite state machine in your car is for…