I mean, we had this discussion before a very long time ago and then it seems like libertarianism took off in start up tech spaces...who are relying on the lack of monopolies and price fixing specifically for their own businesses to be able to be successful...so I don't think the libertarian attitude of a lot of HNers really fits, given the amount of effort the government of the past has put into making the market actually "free" in a real sense and not just a liberal philosophical sense.
In some types of businesses, I think there is also good reason to not want it to be a free market. For instance, the nuclear weapons business. So we accept that the "free market" shouldn't apply to everything already.
I think the hiccup here is that government intervention into a market and market regulation are not the same thing.
A subsidy is an intervention, since it makes a product viable that otherwise might not be. Breaking up monopolies and stopping price fixing does not interfere with supply and demand setting the price. On the contrary, it helps with that.
So let's say we have regulation meant to combat price fixing or perhaps a judgement from a court of law against parties engaging in price fixing, like what happened with DRAM manufacturers 20-ish years beforehand. Well, by the logic you presented, those are also detrimental to a free market. However this leads to a contradiction, as both regulating and not regulating is a detrimental choice. Either you don't regulate, in which case price fixing -- and also we of course have to take into account that a similar argument argument against regulations also works for (unregulated) monopolies, monopsonies, and other sundry cartel actions -- will negatively undermine the free market. On the other hand, regulating price fixing, monopolies, monopsonies etc. will also negatively undermine the free market.
So, we have a logical inconsistency here as presented. So we realistically have three possibilities:
a) the free market itself is logically contradictory. I mean, many socialists in particular have argued for this position, but I at least don't find this consequent very attractive. It _could_ be true, but let's look at the other two.
b) that price fixing is not detrimental to the free market. Well mayhaps, but that really doesn't seem to correspond to the consensus around price fixing and other similar anticompetitive practices. And as said, the same argument could be made for monopolies and such, so you'd basically have to argue that none of them are detrimental to the market either.
c) that regulation isn't necessarily detrimental to the free market. You kinda already conceded this point, as you said
> Sometimes there is an argument that conditions do not favor a free market and regulation is required to fix that defect, but that's rather situational.
And if we assume this, then the question is no longer whether regulation is always bad for the market, but where the line is between regulation that is bad for the market and which is either neutral or positive for the market. But then the words no longer mean what they should mean by surface analysis, and that's a travesty!
So where does that leave us? Well, for myself the answer seems obviously to be that regulation can be non-detrimental to the free market, etymology be damned! And so in this case, at least from where I'm sitting, a free market advocate should be for legislation against price fixing. But they might think differently, in which case they should justify their views.
While I would NOT concede the premise that such armies are inevitable...
I would suggest that many of the conflicts over the last several decades would probably either not have happened, or would have ended much sooner in a "militarized free market" universe. Conflict is expensive, and trade is much more profitable: much of western democracy and its resulting cooperative foreign policy is premised on this as foundational.
Thus I find the argument to be an appeal to emotion that requires ignoring the real world. Wouldn't a corporation that starts to resemble a state start to carry a state's incentive structures and act like a state? Isn't the western system premised on the idea that commerce is a better motivator than power for "good" behavior?
Regulations are inherently against a free market. This is not an ideological stance, it's just what the words mean.
Sometimes there is an argument that conditions do not favor a free market and regulation is required to fix that defect, but that's rather situational.