Fastest Falcon 9 turnaround was 9 days, I wouldn't expect Musk's 1 hour turnaround target for Starship to ever be reached.
And even 5 reuses matter if you want to do many launches. Because building them will be slow. So even if financially theoretically its not worth it, if you can increase your launch rate its still worth it.
And that gives you the time to continue iterating.
But what happens if there isn’t actually that much pent-up, latent demand for flinging heavy things into orbit? What happens if people still mostly want to launch the same size stuff they already do? Starship could become the paratransit shuttle of space: inexpensive, yes, but also inconvenient because of having to share the ride with so many other people that all have different destinations and schedules. In that case we might see that demand for Starship remains low due to potential customers deciding the extra cost of a different option is worth the added convenience. Anyone who’s chosen an Uber even though the city bus can get them to their destination for 1/10 the price should be familiar with the principle.
I can see the value in this though if we end up developing space and Moon, and a vehicle like this could open the doors for that, unlike now. If China has long term plans for that, it's probably a good indicator of future market.
That certainly doesn’t mean it will never happen or that it’s not worth trying. But I’ve noticed that in these online discussions there’s a tendency to treat moonshot programs as if they’re sure bets.
They don't need/ want to sell capacity. They want to constrain the capacity for themselves, which is obviously the better business move. Look at falcon 9 launches... It's not like they drastically lowered their pricing, they've been raising there pricing dramatically because they want to phase falcon 9 out.
What's your business / engineering case for Starlink (i.e. LEO satellites) dominating the internet market worldwide?
I was an early believer in LEO internet delivery and realise its advantage over terrestrial delivery in some regards, but I haven't seen reason to project its 'dominance'. So I'd be interested to know why you are projecting this.
You also have to collect almost every droplet, prevent the spray from drifting, and keep droplets from blocking one another's radiation. These are significant engineering challenges. Which they already use on starlink.
Until all deserts, rooftops and roads are covered with solar panels there is zero case to move things to orbit for freer energy.
Also data center cooling consumes around 40% of power, not 60%, and in cooler climates you can do much better than that.
Claude Shannon would disagree.
With fiber you can cheaply add capacity by upgrading terminal hardware where needed. With Starlink you can only add capacity to the whole world at once, and it's mostly seas and woods.
It would appear that every commercial ship and every RV has a starlink already, this is perfect application for starlink. Competing with city ISPs would require thousands times the bandwidth at lower prices, it's a non-starter.
I think the more interesting comparison is marginal cost. Fiber is extremely scalable once installed, but passing an additional household can be expensive. Starlink avoids that last mile construction entirely.
Explain to me how that can satisfy say Paris.
But that’s also why I’m skeptical about whether Starship will live up to the hype. The whole case for how it’s supposed to revolutionize spaceflight rests on the assumption that it can tap into a huge well of latent demand to put stuff in orbit. If such a well really does exist then we have to ask why Falcon 9 wasn’t able to tap into it despite all of its obvious merits.
And that was just a goal; if they actually pull it off it would be a historic first for rocketry. So let’s estimate maybe 5-10x cost reduction. Hard to know where it would fall in that band while they’re still tweaking the design. But since they made that claim Raptor’s performance has come down by quite a bit and the vehicle’s mass has gone up by quite a bit, so they’re certainly not on track to exceed it.
(obviously factor in Elon optimism and timelines)
But if you ballpark 20 reuses of the stack, minimal refurbishment, a rumored $100M cost to build the stack, $2M in fuel, 100T of payload... you're well under $100/kg. 20 flights is probably very low for their goals, Falcon boosters do that today.
There is a point where "optimism and timelines" becomes straight up bullshit.
The possibilities are that they tried and failed, or that Musk lied, and neither looks good for Starship fast turnaround.
You don’t take the 8MPG race car to deliver a package when you can take a 15MPG truck, even though the truck is hugely oversized for the package.
Do you know how expensive it is to transport a 40 ton skyscraper? Now they can just put it on the transport stand, drive it over to mega bay, refurb while they are putting they next payload on board, and drive it back over to the pad.
If you mean why catching is (anything) better than landing (anything)? Landing gear is heavy. All the weight and mechatronics and complexity of the landing gear systems takes mass that could've been payload. Put the "landing gear" on the tower instead and the launch vehicle doesn't eat the cost of the weight. It's an optimization but not an order of magnitude revolution compared to a fully reusable heavy lift platform.