read comments
Which guidelines are they violating? Just because their commentary is unpopular with the usual shills doesn't mean they're violating guidelines at all. I'm certainly not seeing much at all that's violating any guideline.
> Don't be curmudgeonly. Thoughtful criticism is fine, but please don't be rigidly or generically negative.
> Eschew flamebait. Avoid generic tangents. Omit internet tropes.
> Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something.
> Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. It tramples curiosity.
100 launches per landing is wrong. It's 40 launches at most and even that is somewhat pessimistic because it assumes a return starship to bypass Orion.
The simple fact is SpaceX cannot afford a program that requires 100s of launches. I recall reading somewhere that several SS will be required to land on the Moon. If we expand that to a Mars mission i think its fair to say dozens if not hundreds will be rquired for a single landing and im not even counting the research program.
In order to get passing tests, they have to fail first.
Hope is not physical reality.
Something is only successful when success is delivered.
“I have not failed. I’ve just found 10,000 ways that won’t work.” -Thomas Edison
I do however have a problem with you assuming they will succeed.
Take the idea of storing tanks in space with fuel for future use. This idea is very challenging and many have questioned if this even possible. As of today not a single starship has parked a tank in space. Given the iterative approach it will take many launches to put tanks in space and wait and measure to understand and fix problems. There is zero progress on this.
There are many other big problems that need to be done in space and none of them have started.
All these challenges will EACH take multiple if not dozens of launches to try an idea, wait and observe, study and learn, fix and relaunch. This is going to add up to at least a 100 if not more launches.
Each step can only continue if the previous is solved reasonably well, so far we are clearly at the start and no where near 1 out of 10 phases and these have cost 40 launches as you state.
Well SpaceX kinda teaches you to not dismiss crazy ideas. Pros/CEOs of competing companies have been commenting this and that ain't possible/rational/commercially viable but again and again and again been proven wrong. That alone teaches you to pause and see what happens. Because SpaceX just doesn't dream and talk, they actually pursue and work their way to reach their goals one way or another.
It may take n amounts of launches to see whether it is/is not possible/viable, but it is exciting journey. And each step they take I don't view it as a failure just because they have yet to do Y/have not proven they can do Z, etc.
Sometimes dismissing crazy ideas is a good thing, just look at the fake / alternative health industry.
Blanket statements are not really helpful.
> Pros/CEOs of competing companies have been commenting this and that ain't possible/rational/commercially viable but again and again and again been proven wrong.
CEOs say a lot of things - i think most people wouldnt place them highly on any trust list.
> It may take n amounts of launches to see whether it is/is not possible/viable, but it is exciting journey. And each step they take I don't view it as a failure just because they have yet to do Y/have not proven they can do Z, etc.
A true beleiver is not a rational person, just look at religion.