Your ad hominem attack doesn't take away from my point.
Failing to deliver a ReactJS + web services project, and failing to catch a steel cylinder weighing thousands of tonnes, full of combustible liquids, hurtling down from space with two metal arms mounted on a pole are two different things.
If you're a billionaire and not failing enough times doing absolutely crazy things, that's a net loss for humanity. I want billionaires to fail 80% of the time. Heck even 100x millionaires should be failing a lot.
Ah, yes. Others should do more for society so I can benefit!
Innovation will always happen and Elon didn't personally inject billions into SpaceX either.
Let's cap wealth at 999M and anything over the gets redistributed to poor entrepreneurs.
That's what I'm saying. Promising to deliver brain-computer interfaces and failing at it is not the same as, pretty much anything else.
> I do not agree with the idea that Elon's companies have a culture where it is safe and repercussion-free to report that things are busted.
And this is different from say Apple (or the majority of large corporates) how?
> If you read up in this thread, the argument was that Elon is safer than NASA.
There's nothing to decide either way. There have been failures at his companies, and at the same time 13 crewed missions on SpaceX rockets without human casualties.
The idea is to set a goal to strive towards.
What he has delivered is incredible.
If you want guarantees, that's what the bond market is for (and at a suitably low ROI).
Nah, what he promises is incredible.
What he actually delivers (in space) is closer to what everyone else promises.
Everyone else promises a lot, but the US and EU space sectors seem to only deliver pork barrels since I was a kid.
I suspect we'd (not just US, I'm European) do a lot better if we supported a bunch of plucky space startups rather than the big old space companies, which is how SpaceX got its chance to shine.
Musk may have always dreamed big, but with hindsight I'd say he seems to have disconnected from the possible around 2016 or so. Too big to fail, or something.
And even then, the Venn diagram isn't one entirely inside the other.
Given where it's at right now, Starship compares as a mere rough equal on timelines and actual delivery as the N1, Space Shuttle, and Saturn V. Where it might shine, eventually, could be a lot of things, but right now it's about in line with other similar vehicles, just with more pizzazz. The main thing that's changed? We can 3D print what used to be the expensive part.
The Falcon series did good; but the changes were incremental, standing on the shoulders of what came before, and what it got from that advantage was what the Space Shuttle promised.
I can and will criticise the old space companies for their pork barreling, but Starship currently looks closer wanting in on that, than like the SpaceX of a decade ago which made Falcon the success it is.
Saturn V propellant: RP-1 (first stage), liquid hydrogen (second and third stage).
If you think Saturn V is a "just scaled up" V2, you've missed a lot.
Can you name a single western car manufacturer that sells EV at a net profit (considering only the R&D and SG&A attributable to EVs for the non-pure-play companies)? AFAIK, it's only Tesla and BYD today. I'd say Elon has delivered cars.
If you think that SpaceX is less safe than the Shuttle program, can you explain how Falcon rocket has had over 350 consecutive launches since the last in-flight failure (and only 1 failure out of 688 flights in the last 10 years), yet the Space Shuttle had two loss-of-crew failures in just 135 flights?
It seems to me that observational statistics indicate that it is approximately 10 times safer than the Shuttle. And they did that while reducing the price of a launch (including the price we taxpayers pay for NASA launches) by a factor of 10. Again, I'd call that a check mark.
The number of Criticality 1 issues on STS was incredible--literally thousands. Booster seal--yup, they knew about that; foam strikes? check; also turbine blade cracks, reaction control short-circuits, and hundreds of other problems.
They couldn't fix them because (a) the design was locked--they weren't building more orbiters, and (b) Congress controlled the budget and the Shuttle was not a priority.
The point of Starship is to build enough ships and fly enough missions that problems get fixed. And since losing a ship costs the company money, they have a strong incentive to fix the problems. That's exactly what they've done with Falcon 9, and the result speaks for itself.
They actively forced deviance.
For more details, check out Truth, Lies, and O-Rings by Allan J. McDonald, James R. Hansen, and Jonathan Yen