Things to notice: it's undergoing yearly upgrades despite NASA having literally decades of experience in this. They still hold a contingency reserve of 8OOL, despite being hours from the ground and being able to evacuate almost any time.
SpaceX has zero experience managing the water cycle even when it's measured in months, much less years, with spares and help many months away in the very best case. They show zero effort trying to acquire such experience.
Let's be real: at this point, Mars for Musk is about as much of a goal as Hyperloop. If we look at actions, not mere words, his goal looks much more like yeeting more GPUs into orbit as a "biological bootloader" [1] than colonising Mars. That's not even touching the fact that SpaceX is now a public company, has a duty for its shareholders, and colonising Mars is a strictly cash-negative enterprise.
Water itself is interesting because you need a lot for consumption and other purposes, but fortuitously it also works as an excellent radiation shielding. So you kill two critical birds with one stone. An initial team of ~6 would consume about 11k liters over 2 years, double that over 4. That's around 10-20 tons, on a ship with a capacity of 100 tons, and probably 200 tons when launching. Of course you'd want significantly more water for things like non-consumption use, but factor in some basic recycling and it's quite obvious that water will not be much of an issue. It's not some idealized self sustaining system where you're trying to create a perpetual base. It's going to have supplies for 2 years, ideally 4, and nothing more.
Biosphere 2 was just hippie gobbledygook.
"The Biosphere 2 project was launched in 1984 by businessman and billionaire Ed Bass and systems ecologist John P. Allen, with Bass providing US$150 million in funding until 1991.[15] Bass and Allen had met in the 1970s at the Synergia Ranch, a counterculture community led by Allen, who advocated Buckminster Fuller's "Spaceship Earth" concept and explored the idea of biospheres as a refuge from disasters such as nuclear war.[15] Several other former members of Synergia Ranch also joined the Biosphere 2 project"[0]
"Synergia Ranch is an ecovillage founded in 1969 by John P. Allen"[1]
Ed Bass inherited $2.8 million when he was a teenager from his great uncle who made his money in oil production, he's currently chairman of an investment and venture-capital management firm. In between he hung out with a bunch of hippies.[2] Just your typical nepo-boomer arc.
[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biosphere_2
Saying how you imagine a solution would look like is cheap, figuring out an actual system is expensive and slow. Hell, just very basic things like extracting water from urine is actually difficult (organic matter forms a tar of sorts and gunks up machinery) and in the past unforeseen problems did pop up (amount of calcium in urine from disintegrating bones was a problem and didn't show up until in-orbit testing).
Musk is observably not doing things that Mars colonisation would require.
The main problem really is just getting mass to orbit. Want more hull space? You need more mass. Want more fuel? Need more mass. Want more water for life support? You need more mass.
A very large launch vehicle that is rapidly reusable is exactly what you need to put more mass in orbit.
We're at the limit of what we can learn from the ISS as far as long duration stays. We need larger space stations that can accommodate more people and more equipment so we can learn ways to mitigate the effects of low g and prove new designs for manned spaceships suitable for long duration voyages or occupation. Eventually, we also need to learn how to construct centrifugal stations in orbit. The only way to work out all of the bugs is to do it and to do all of that we need more mass.
I wasn’t necessarily thinking of Biosphere 2, just the fact that you won’t be getting a resupply on short notice.
The problem is that Mars is 6-12 months away depending on launch window, at least with current rockets. If something goes wrong you must be able to respond locally and at least survive. The Moon is 3 days away (ish) and LEO is hours away (including time to align and dock).
If you want to send people to Mars you need to build a Mars sim on Earth and actually test your life support systems.
When you are taking 100 tons of supplies and landing 100 tons more first, survival for a few years is only an issue in medical emergencies, just like Antarctica.
If you make it much cheaper, then everything else flows from that. You no longer have to spend years engineering everything at the cutting edge of your mass budget. You can use off the shelf parts, you can have redundancy.
The gains will come when these flights become commonplace.