And it is really sad that such officials often go unpunished. Like a case here for example: http://www.aopa.org/aircraft/articles/2013/130110secret-no-f...
They've put this 70 year old pilot: http://www.aopa.org/aircraft/articles/2013/130110secret-zone... in jail, without any violations on the part of the pilot or any ill intents. And what was the result of the hearing?
> "his case went before the judge. When his attorney returned and said the case would be dismissed if he agreed not to take any legal action against Darlington County law enforcement, he said, he reluctantly agreed"
Great. Just great.
The problem with letting prosecutors not prosecute to the full extent of the law on their own judgement allows for selective favouritism, like white college kids getting off with a warning where a black street kid gets serious time.
Relying on prosecutors to be lenient or "do the right thing" places the defence in the wrong hands - a court that allows a strong defence to succeed over or moderate a prosecution should be at the heart of the justice system.
If something can go wrong when people with handguns shoot near a nuclear power plant, then something has already gone horribly wrong.
Also while I'm sure there would be no problems with the nuclear part, there are things in and around a power plant that being struck by bullets might be... inconvenient.
http://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/digital/copyrigh...
The Association of American Publishers and Google’s
agreement last week to settle the publishers’ long-running
litigation over Google’s library scanning program put an
end to the lengthy and expensive suit, but without
resolving any of the underlying copyright and fair use
issues. The main component of the deal: copyright owners
with books scanned by Google under its library program can
choose to “opt out” of the program and have their books
removed. Of course, that settlement condition is something
Google has offered copyright owners with books in the
program all along.
In other words, Google scanned and posted to the web first, and authors could opt-out if they so chose. So they didn't get consent first. Their rationale was good - there was no machine readable contact information and many of the authors were dead or had moved - but in this respect the situations are reasonably analogous.Had Aaron scraped say 10-100k rather than 4M articles and done some innovative NLP/data mining on the text (like Google N-grams), then showed that to JSTOR, despite the lack of up-front consent he might well have been able to get more or convince them to open up, especially if this 10-100k experiment showed monetization potential and could allow JSTOR to move to an open access model. Sadly, we'll never know.
Aaron was not a bad guy, nor did he seem to ever act with malicious intent. He broke some rules, certainly, but should the punishment for rule breaking be the destruction of someone's life or should it be just enough of a push to make them avoid rule breaking while keeping them a productive member of society?
This thread is about Aaron. But please do not tie the two cases together; at best Google (making $10 Billion a year in profit) scanned the books so they could wrap their content with ads. At worst....
Why didn't Google open source the scans if they wanted to "spread knowledge"?
Aaron was accused of breaking into MIT and a few other things. It's just a bad comparison on all levels IMO.
But yeah, having billions at your disposal and a great reputation can do wonders. The Feds cannot outspend you and they it's very hard to vilify you
Spurrious accusation, all doors were open.
Did you read this article? http://unhandled.com/2013/01/12/the-truth-about-aaron-swartz...
The crime of breaking and entering doesn't require you to defeat physical security.. even pushing open a closed (yet unlocked) door is enough.
I agree that the accusation is utter crap, but that's the law.
As it was, DOJ did get involved in the Google Books case, pushing for a harsher civil settlement against Google:
http://news.cnet.com/8301-30684_3-10357097-265.html