Re:Three Felonies A Day - How The Feds Target The Innocent
by jamesaguilar on Sunday January 13, 2013 @12:55PM
(#5051281)
They asked the libraries. The analogy would be complete if Google had gone into the libraries uninvited and started scanning.
http://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/digital/copyrigh...
In other words, Google scanned and posted to the web first, and authors could opt-out if they so chose. So they didn't get consent first. Their rationale was good - there was no machine readable contact information and many of the authors were dead or had moved - but in this respect the situations are reasonably analogous.Had Aaron scraped say 10-100k rather than 4M articles and done some innovative NLP/data mining on the text (like Google N-grams), then showed that to JSTOR, despite the lack of up-front consent he might well have been able to get more or convince them to open up, especially if this 10-100k experiment showed monetization potential and could allow JSTOR to move to an open access model. Sadly, we'll never know.