Re:Three Felonies A Day - How The Feds Target The Innocent
by Karunamon on Sunday January 13, 2013 @01:16AM
(#5050148)
His point still rings true - even if Aaron was in it for the free exchange of information and Google was in it for the ad revenue, it's a foregone fact in the USA that the justice you receive is proportional to nothing but your cash reserves.
Re:Three Felonies A Day - How The Feds Target The Innocent
by OGinparadise on Sunday January 13, 2013 @01:22AM
(#5050155)
His other point is true but the facts are different. If Aaron had gone to the library, scanned 10 books and posted them online it would be different. Maybe a DCMA or a lawsuit.
Aaron was accused of breaking into MIT and a few other things. It's just a bad comparison on all levels IMO.
But yeah, having billions at your disposal and a great reputation can do wonders. The Feds cannot outspend you and they it's very hard to vilify you
Re:Three Felonies A Day - How The Feds Target The Innocent
by pygy_ on Sunday January 13, 2013 @05:48AM
(#5050505)
> Aaron was accused of breaking into MIT ...
Spurrious accusation, all doors were open.
Did you read this article? http://unhandled.com/2013/01/12/the-truth-about-aaron-swartz...
Re:Three Felonies A Day - How The Feds Target The Innocent
by Karunamon on Sunday January 13, 2013 @01:32PM
(#5051384)
>Spurrious accusation, all doors were open.
The crime of breaking and entering doesn't require you to defeat physical security.. even pushing open a closed (yet unlocked) door is enough.
I agree that the accusation is utter crap, but that's the law.
Re:Three Felonies A Day - How The Feds Target The Innocent
by temphn on Sunday January 13, 2013 @01:17AM
(#5050149)
Because they were already being sued by the authors of the books and couldn't push it any further? Google Books offers many out-of-print books and is very much in the spirit of what Aaron was doing.
This thread is about Aaron. But please do not tie the two cases together; at best Google (making $10 Billion a year in profit) scanned the books so they could wrap their content with ads. At worst....
Why didn't Google open source the scans if they wanted to "spread knowledge"?