Land area alone is a misleading, what matters to people is the distances between population centers and that is a huge difference between the two continents.
Two points:
- In many countries in Europe, the life is much more similar in various part of the country than in the USA (just to be clear: there exist cheap and expensive cities, and areas with much and rather no industry in nearly all countries; but the differences in one country are indeed smaller). When there exist exceptions, at least Germans love to point them out (for example: Berlin is very different from the rest of Germany). So, since US-Americans don't point out these differences all the time, many people in Europe simply don't assume that there exist so many differences in the USA.
- The media that is accessible via the web simply writes much less about these parts of the USA.
But concerning
> I feel about as free as a medieval serf between the health insurance and the landlords demanding more every year.
The hate in the USA for health insurance companies is very well-known in European countries.
Now I'm seeing our country become a nation of renters whose people have no wealth except we don't have a welfare state to save us.
The American dream is deeply ingrained in our phyche, the housing crisis is a deep existential crisis for us.
Net assets. If rents are kept at a reasonably low value one can invest the rest and become wealthy enough (at least in purchasing power terms).
> The permeance and stability it affords you is the very definition of wealth as I understand it.
In places where eviction is basically impossible, it's possible to have an even higher stability renting than owning in the US, because there's no chance that you can't afford paying property taxes if your fortunes go bad.
There are no places where eviction is basically impossible, that is conservative propaganda directed at blue states with slightly more favorable tenant protections.
Your comment perfectly highlights how clueless Europeans can be about America.
In fact in my state we have strong rental assistance programs and it has resulted in a housing crisis second only to Hawaii, we definitely aren't Europe.
It's not a big if, it's called democracy.
> In my state we have strong rental assistance programs
That's subsidizing demand. It doesn't work because it only increases rents.
Many people in Germany do rent, but for much more mundane reasons:
- In many area of high population density (where many better-paying jobs are located), buying a house or flat is simply not easily affordable.
- The job security has decreased over the decades, so you have to be more flexible with respect to relocating. You don't know where you will land in, say, a decade. A mortgage binds you to one location for a very long time; such planning is hardly possible anymore.
Concerning your argument "My American brain literally can't comprehend how one could consider themselves wealthy without owning their home. The permeance and stability it affords you is the very definition of wealth as I understand it." you posted in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50501500
- The German federal government is very creative in sucking home and flat owners dry. So, owning a house or department puts you at quite some risks with respect to the whims of the government (or some future government). Thus, there exist quite some Germans who don't have the association of home owning and "permanence and stability".
I can assure you, income and wealth difference are huge in Europe + different cultures + different laws so people are intuitively aware of these concepts.
I think it's because there is so much variation in culture, laws, and economics in Europe that, in comparison, it may appear that America is far more homogeneous than it really is.
I think we all tend to have that bias especially looking at large nations, I bet Americans and Europeans tend to imagine China as being more homogeneous than it really is too.
Europoors would assume I was well off if they saw my salary on paper yet the landlord takes the lions share of it for the privilege of living in hundred year old factory worker housing stock. I plastic the windows every winter, the tumble dryer is coin operated and shared with two other units, and I need roommates to afford this lavish American home. Our cars are small, New England cities also have old narrow streets, they are also two to three decades old and get fixed in the driveway because mechanics have become unaffordable.
I feel about as free as a medieval serf between the health insurance sword of damocles hanging over my family's head and the landlords demanding more every year.
The European brain can't seem to comprehend how big North America is and how very different life and cost of living is in different areas, they see the movies and assume we all live in fancy cali houses and have mind blowing bay area tech salaries.