They survived and will survive based on marketing.
2. Political/ideological lobby (less today but still a factor): Grover Norquist railed against return-free filing (using the data they’ve got government sends you a number to pay, if you pay it you are 100% done with taxes no takebacks.)
Commercial lobby is an irritant but the “ideological” one is the most annoying and difficult to surmount.
Norquist & his camp says the government/IRS has fundamental conflict of interest as the collector and enforcer and taxpayers won’t bother to correct government calculation mistakes on their taxes. If there’s a real appeal process doing all the old-school recordkeeping there probably wouldn’t ever be a shortage of taxpayers eager to challenge/contest and file with their own paperwork.
Norquist and friends need taxes to remain a PITA & have high hassle factor for their fundraising and advocacy efforts. If taxes are too easy these people won’t have much political purchase railing against how annoying/$$ it is to pay taxes.
Idk anything substantive about tax policy (ie who should pay what share, best use of $$, etc I’ll leave to the “professionals”/political system) but just as an end user who uses tax prep services it sure seems like there is a concerted effort by people economically & ideologically incentivized to make taxes as annoying as possible
- https://atr.org/senate-conservatives-speak-against-return-fr...
- https://www.latimes.com/politics/story/2021-10-21/california...
- https://www.propublica.org/article/how-the-maker-of-turbotax...
Critics of the 1986 Tax Reform Act said, why bother simplifying the tax code when Congress will just make it complicated again? The response was sure, we'll just need to clean up the tax code again every 20 years or so. Well that's never happened since.
In 2017 many in Congress wanted to simplify the tax code. Unfortunately Trump said he didn't want to simplify taxes, he just wanted to lower them. As one great example, some folks wanted to eliminate the State and Local Tax deduction (SALT), as that's a complicated deduction. (Example: You file federally based on "estimated" state and local taxes, but if you get a refund or owe state and local taxes, the next year you have "adjust" your prior year's deduction.) Instead of eliminating them, the 2017 tax bill just phased them out at higher income levels, which just adds complexity to an already complex part of the tax code.
Certainly the act of filing one's taxes can be made a bit simpler, but it seems there's never any incentive behind actually simplifying the tax code itself, because every tiny change to the tax code creates winners and losers who object.
Complexity is a good thing if it allows people and businesses to do the things you want them to do and they want to do.
Now look at it! It's a key data source for humans AND AI. When did the flip happen? How did it happen?
Your views on vibecoding are going to become wrong similarly: gradually then all at once.
So keep looking for the signs and be ready to change your views - it'll happen fast to vibecoding too.
They still should, because:
> It's a key data source for humans
It shouldn't. It's not Wikipedia's project to be a source. You should use it as a good entry point to whatever topic you're researching, and use the cited sources. (and should, acknowledge Wikipedia, but it's not a source)
Everyone else that just need information for practical reasons? Wikipedia has long proven its stochastic guarantees are more than enough.
(Even if you need to cite primary sources in the end, it makes more sense to go with Wikipedia early on, and track back the sources for citation once whatever you're working on pans out.)
Previously, I used Free Fillable Forms which does force me to know more about tax forms than a more abstract software program. Most people's tax situation does not change very much year to year so it's fairly easy to verify - you can check if my tax return looks fairly similar to the previous year taking into account any differences.
If you have a substantially different year for whatever reason, sure get an accountant to double check. But if you're paying for an AI frontier agent, there's really no need to pay for a 3rd party program anymore.
It's been popular to dump on TurboTax for several years now, but I had a great experience using it.
I personally don't trust AI enough to say "here's my data, please do my taxes for me" yet, but you're right, I suppose that is just a matter of time...
That said, there's basically nothing stopping someone from creating fee software equivalent or better than TurboTax from scratch using AI. They can even decompile TurboTax source code as an input
https://sites.google.com/view/incometaxspreadsheet/home/down...
I can usually do it in a couple hours while watching TV, but I'm interested in seeing what AI can bring to it. Most of my taxes are just copying numbers from one form into the web interface and verifying everything.
Having to copy data from a form that was filed with the IRS, into another form that is going to be filed with the IRS, is idiotic.