They are intentional.
They aren’t loopholes. They are just laws.
Some people just call them loopholes because they dont like them.
There are quotes from at least Madison, Hamilton, and Jefferson that support the idea that this was intentional.
Law is basically a representation of societal judgement. While criminal law is intended to be clear enough to know when you've violated it, that is not the same as beimg logical or consistent. Civil law is even less logical and consistent. Formalizing it into logic generally does not make sense overall - it isn't really broken in most cases because it was never intended to be totally consistent. There are certainly areas that could use cleaner rewriting but courts are generally well equipped to figure out what it means. Congress and the states can always overturn interpretations of law, but the rate at which they rewrite laws because they thought courts interpreted it wrong is very, very low.
Extremely funny to say that about US law when it is entirely based on precedent, and a single judge having vibes on a particular day changes how your entire country works for the next 50 years.
US law is explicitly made to be skirted, as is every common law system in the world and they are all irrevocably flawed.
All human systems are flawed because humans are flawed.
https://taxfoundation.org/data/all/federal/latest-federal-in...
The tax code benefits certain types of income, but it does not uniformly benefit high earners, as you say.
I feel like this attitude is responsible for the modern destruction of the rule of law.
It doesn't matter what the law says, the only thing that matters is vibes! And whether you play golf with the right government officials.
> You can't "Trick" them by saying "well technically this is allowed!".
The obvious problem being that sometimes it is allowed. And then do you want that being decided by democratically elected representatives and specified ahead of time so the public can know what's expected of them and of others, or decided ex post facto on the basis of feels and discrimination?
> Laws aren't computer code. They are vague on purpose.
Yes... but. Tax law is a bit different because it is similar to an equation: you put in your inputs and you get your outputs.
There have been famous cases where the courts have said in essence, "yes you completely and exactly and precisely followed the law, but we're not going to allow you to do that anyway." Those rulings have become less frequent.
I’m not saying judges are useless but a system that operates in a less clear way only favors those with money and influence
Anyone with a few hundred dollars of liquidity can afford a CPA-filed tax return, and it's only worth if it saves you more on taxes than its cost anyway, so it's practically free (paid for) from that standpoint. It's not lack of access to CPA that is critical here. It's lack of access to the loopholes themselves: carried interest, RE depreciation, self-employment, etc.
They are also left there so there is wiggle room for interpretation if it comes in front of an auditor or a judge.
And also, it's important to remember that in tax matters, the final arbiter of interpretation is a judge. Judges are humans, not machines. You can't "Trick" them by saying "well technically this is allowed!". Because they rule on the sprit of the law, not as it was written. Judges aren't amused when you try to be cute with how you interpret a law. And some Judges have biases, where you get a different ruling depending on if you play at their golf club or not.
Laws aren't computer code. They are vague on purpose.