News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Testing a Trash Can Faraday Cage by varjag on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:23AM (#50497752)
Technically I'm measuring in the "wrong direction" since I would be very surprised if an EMP were initiated inside a trash can in my basement, but shielding works the same in both directions so this doesn't matter.

It really doesn't, with 1.5GHz you're still in near field regime inside the can.

Re:Testing a Trash Can Faraday Cage by jagged-chisel on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:23AM (#50498253)
He’s testing penetration from the opposite side regardless of the source location.

Yeah, you put a transmitter inside the can, and a receiver inside the can, and the receiver is gonna get signal.

Re:Testing a Trash Can Faraday Cage by LodeOfCode on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:42PM (#50499596)
As GP pointed out, the problem is that if the source is inside the can, the walls are near the source - where the EM field diverges - whereas with an EMP the source would be far away (hopefully) so the EM field lines would be roughly parallel over the surface of the cage
Re:Testing a Trash Can Faraday Cage by jagged-chisel on Sunday November 15, 2026 @09:32AM (#50507210)
Thanks for the explanation - genuinely helpful. I’m not the only one who misunderstood their intent judging by the votes.
Re:Testing a Trash Can Faraday Cage by superkuh on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:23PM (#50498795)
For those not in the know the nearfield is where the balance between the magnetic and electric component of the electromagnetic wave is not yet settled into an equilibrium. It's generally considered about 1/10th of wavelength around the emitter. For 100 MHz the can's walls are certainly near field though at 1.5 GHz nearfield is only ~2cm.

Light interactions are generally completely reciprocal and transmitting is the same as receiving. You can measure the properties of a system either by receiving or transmitting from two points and switch them around. There are some non-reciprocal mediums like arrangements of magnetic ferrites caused by zeeman splitting but that doesn't apply here.

But what does apply is that if the radio source were coming from a far field source like (~a km+ away, so tens of thousands of wavelengths) then it's electric and magnetic components would be in equilibrium when it hit the somewhat imperfect conducting surface of the can and then coupled through the seam in attenuated form. The stuff inside the can would then be exposed in the near field generated by that balanced far field wave coupling in.

This convolution of the balanced far field wave and the coupling through the imperfect seam is different than the convolution of an imbalanced EM wave generated inside in the near field and coupling out through the seam. It's hard to say if it'd be better or worse for the stuff inside though. I think this handwave can ignore the slight non-reciprocity.

Re:Testing a Trash Can Faraday Cage by superkuh on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:46PM (#50499061)
Yep. The exact placement of the monopole w/r to the close can wall will change the the polarization which changes how will it will get through the imperfections in the horizontal seam slots which will be polarized. And that's ignoring the that different places will be better or worse (vs frequency) for exciting the can's cavity modes (at $frequency) in the first place.

But a long distance high power RF source can have these properties altered too by the type of emission mechanisn, reflections, scattering, etc and items placed in such a faraday cage will be located at good and bad places to excite the cavity mode too.

So it's kind of a wash and probably okay for this kind of test. The fact that the electric and magnetic components of the field aren't in balance (near field) doesn't matter too much.