W.r.t the United States government and its people restricting sales of the most advanced chips form Nvidia there are two realistic conclusions you can draw (neither of which result in SMIC and/or Huawei "obliterating" anyone):
1. China is behind and needs to catch up, and the way to do that is through subterfuge to get more chips imported into the country. In other words, they can't match Nvidia + American tech stack for the foreseeable future.
2. China can "just catch up", which begs the question why they don't have their own Nvidia already, and so it doesn't matter whether the US restricts the sale or not other than maybe a few billion dollars in lost sales to a few companies which isn't really relevant.
With respect to Chinese electric cars and the American market, the American market is highly profitable and while we don't have great EVs we also don't really need them for anything, and while China maintains a stranglehold on rare earth mineral processing we can't put ourselves in a position where an adversary can effectively shut down our auto industry and leave us in a bad position. Of course there are existing single points of failure, chokeholds, and things like that, but there's no need to add fuel to the fire.
Most Chinese automakers are not competitive, the Chinese auto market is slowing down, and many of the automakers are operating on state subsidies and have built factories which are not able due to lack of demand to produce the volumes of vehicles that were expected. American strategy (and soon European strategy) to limit imports of Chinese vehicles results in a resounding win for union jobs, stability of American, European, Japanese, and Korean automakers, and uses what I'll describe as a judo move (using your opponents strengths and momentum against them) to harm the Chinese economy and their goal of instituting mass manufacturing overcapacity.
Because they don't have TSMC or ASML and the Dutch can turn those lithography machines off from the other side of the world. Nvidia is likely the least important part of the supply chain which is why governments were not very concerned with the behavior which they would have been aware of for a while.
Nvidia might be the easiest to replicate (I'm not sure if that's true or not) but my point was that you can draw the conclusion either they can't actually replicate this supply chain so they are behind and are importing as many chips as they can get away with or certain companies are trying to (which may not be a distinction since many Chinese companies have CCP officers inside the company), or they can do it and haven't... but that doesn't make any sense because they would obviously want that entire stack.
Can't actually replicate this supply chain yet.
2. You live under a rock it you don't see the earthquake that Chinese automakers are.
3. European carmakers are by nature export oriented and they oppose tariffs on Chinese cars, especially German carmakers. Reality is that neither European nor US carmakers (and many other technological sectors) can't keep the pace with Asians, whether it's making ships, steel, chips, tvs, or cars. We just don't.
No it's never just about market share. Market share and accumulating it would just be a means to an end of either eventually making a profit, or squeezing out competitors to raise prices later. At the end of the day you'd 100% of the time rather be Apple (it's objectively irrational to suggest otherwise) than another player in this space.
Besides the American market which is where the profits are is also the second largest market by volume. In China the car companies are struggling to make money because of state subsidies, aggressive pricing, and very intense competition. Those companies that are looking to survive are looking to global markets (primarily the EU and US) so that they can actually survive and make money. As they increasingly get shut out of these two markets China is in for a consolidation of automakers which will result in a lot of lost jobs and companies going bankrupt. China's internal auto market was down 22% YoY for example [1].
> You live under a rock it you don't see the earthquake that Chinese automakers are.
Please stop writing things like this as it's a violation of site guidelines.
> European carmakers are by nature export oriented and they oppose tariffs on Chinese cars, especially German carmakers.
That's false. You can do a cursory Google search for the latest here but in general the EU is taking action, led by Germany, to introduce tariffs or other market restrictions to slow the import of Chinese cars. Germany has been shedding 10s of thousands of jobs in the automotive and machinery sector.
> Reality is that neither European nor US carmakers (and many other technological sectors) can't keep the pace with Asians, whether it's making ships, steel, chips, tvs, or cars. We just don't.
This is also false. There's nothing special about "Asians" that enable them to make things. Countries like China by virtue of their incredibly deep labor pool enabled them to scale up mass manufacturing, but in the United States for example we can compete (and the Chinese are doing this too) with robotics and other automation tools. Most of our alleged inability to manufacture these products just stems from decades of industrial policy assuming that China in particular would be a welcoming and liberalizing partner but that assumption turned out to be false.
[1] https://www.wsj.com/business/autos/everyone-loves-chinese-ca...
[2] I want to be clear here. While I detest the authoritarian Chinese Communist Party and all communist ideology, I'm not trying to suggest that China's auto market or manufacturers suck, or don't make great cars, or whatever. My point of view is that the arguments put forth about Chinese dominance seem incorrect to me as stated and I'm in principle arguing against the arguments because they're in my view bad, not because of anything to do with the Chinese.
BYD assembles 95%+ of their cars with robots.
You keep talking nonsense and stereotypes, exactly the kind of things that keep west non competitive in manufacturing and technology.
I also wrote that "but in the United States for example we can compete (and the Chinese are doing this too) with robotics and other automation tools.".
As you can see, I wrote, explicitly, that the Chinese are competing with robotics and automation tools, and I wrote that America can also do this, and we'll have to, because automation and robotics are the future.
You're so quick to be argumentative and jump to defend China that you are missing key points that others have written. Please engage with the substance of the post and what was written and stop with the low-quality comments. Thanks!
Chinese cars are selling less in China (20% less this year IIRC) so that is the reason why they must sell abroad. Not that they are not good.
Wall Street can and does demand that companies pay them dividends instead of investing in capacity. What you need is a willingness to accept lower returns on capital and higher savings rates. China makes those things happen, and that's why its manufacturing sector is able to grow the way that it does.
American technology and European technology are, of course, top-notch. What's different is the required return on capital and the labor market. Both of those are primarily dictated by industrial policies of the respective governments.
What about Huawei and their Ascend chips?
DeepSeek and z.ai now run their models on Ascends, and inference is basically a solved problem (especially with the architectural optimizations).
From what I understand, they lack compute for training - their own chips can do it too but they're slower and you need more of them. Slower = lagging behind the US further over tome. As long as China can buy Nvidia chips, it's cheaper and easier to just use smuggled chips but it doesn't mean they desperately need them.
>many of the automakers are operating on state subsidies
As opposed to US companies living off investments without being profitable for years?
It's a catch-22 of sorts.
Either China can catch up (what exactly that will mean I'm unsure but I believe they will be able to), in which case we don't need to sell them the chips to let them do it faster, or they can't catch up in which case we shouldn't sell them chips allowing them to do so.
I'm just not seeing a compelling argument to sell them state of the art chips here.
> As opposed to many US companies living off investments without being profitable for years (or ever)?
No it's not comparable
It’s just a combination of wilful ignorance or otherwise being stuck in past modes of thinking of the US being ahead of the world technologically. It’s not just elites, “USA #1” is an important aspect of American culture.
But regardless the policy is not the issue here, it’s the open corruption, allowing laws to be circumvented due to connections to the White House or people connected to them.
In fact, China has been quite transparent about heavily investing and subsidizing key industries to dominate export markets.
I just don't understand this American elites view that cutting off China from acquiring Nvidia chips will result in a strengthened American position instead of getting obliterated by SMIC+Huawei.