News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by pfdietz on Monday November 09, 2026 @11:48AM (#50428097)
CdTe panels are limited by availability of tellurium. Maybe we'll mine that in space one day; much of the Earth's Te was lost as volatile H2Te. The abundance of Te in carbonaceous chondrites is about 1000x that in the Earth's crust.
Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by chuckadams on Monday November 09, 2026 @12:15PM (#50428450)
There's the minor issue in that the technology to bring all that metal back home is also a weapon of mass destruction :-/
Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by engineer_22 on Monday November 09, 2026 @12:25PM (#50428587)
I imagine a time long long ago, early humans debating the proliferation of fire.
Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by pfdietz on Monday November 09, 2026 @12:30PM (#50428662)
If it gets separated at the asteroid the mass brought back is small. Total world production of Te is about 1000 tons/year.
Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by myrmidon on Monday November 09, 2026 @01:01PM (#50429066)
Kinetic orbital bombardment is utterly worthless from a military perspective.

People tend to have a completely inaccurate view on this because of bad popsci, out-of-context feasibility studies from the 1950s and fiction that just leans toward the "fantasy" on that.

The reasons for this is are very simple:

1) There is no "high ground". Being in orbit does not enable you to throw things "down" for free, thats simply not how orbital dynamics work. All the impact energy you have to pay for up front, and delta-v on some orbital object is almost inevitably more expensive than the equivalent amount of explosives on the ground.

2) Anything launched from beyond earth orbit would be unusably delayed. And telegraphed.

3) The concept does not have a single selling point from a military perspective; not really faster than an ICBM, penetration is limited by newtonian physics regardless of speed and more expensive than just delivering the equivalent amount of explosives (or nuclear payload) via missile.

edit: Yes an interplanetary transport system could be weaponized. But so could the explosives currently used in mining (~tens of millions of tons per year), no one cares.

Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by andrewflnr on Monday November 09, 2026 @02:38PM (#50430685)
If North Korea or Iran could hold the world hostage with a threat of a mass-extinction-level event, they absolutely would. Similar for many terrorists of various stripes. Are you sure the control systems of whatever company ends up trying to bring back mass from space will be sufficiently resilient to hacking? I'm not. So, I worry.

And we're not even talking about "orbital" bombardment. We're talking about a continuous stream of material at well above escape velocity, whose delta-V is already paid for. Simply redirecting a few pieces of this stream would not be more telegraphed than any other attack. By the way, are you sure the control systems of the mine owners are resilient to coercion of their executives by "legitimate" terrestrial governments? I'm not. None of your reasons are effective.

The energies are substantially more than mining explosives, with wildly different properties as far as threat detection and mitigation. To put it charitably, that's a quite silly comparison.

Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by pfdietz on Monday November 09, 2026 @02:46PM (#50430842)
Moving 1000 tons of Te back to Earth, and moving maybe 10^14 tons to hit Earth, are rather different capabilities.
Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by andrewflnr on Monday November 09, 2026 @03:26PM (#50431503)
1000 tons of Te would only be a fraction of what's brought back by a realistic mining operation. Don't you also want all the platinum and palladium and gold hiding out there? Don't you want the iron for building space habitats? No, we'll bring back as much as we can manage, whether it's availability or transport logistics or fear of attacks that turns out to be the limiting factor.
Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by pfdietz on Monday November 09, 2026 @03:44PM (#50431816)
1000 tons is how much Te is mined each year on Earth.

Global annual production of platinum is 180 tons.

Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by andrewflnr on Monday November 09, 2026 @03:53PM (#50431962)
How is that relevant to the weaponizability of space mining systems, the thing I was actually talking about?
Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by pfdietz on Monday November 09, 2026 @04:51PM (#50432764)
It shows that the claim that space mining enables mass-extinction level events is nonsense. Space mining can involve 11 orders of magnitude less mass annually than the K/T mass extinction impact.
Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by andrewflnr on Monday November 09, 2026 @05:41PM (#50433319)
The bar for mass extinction is much, much lower than the K/T impactor. The bar for widespread human suffering and death is much, much lower again. You and myrmidon keep trying to anchor the conversation around these strawman criteria and mechanisms (i.e. "orbital bombardment", like that was the topic). I'm sure it's just motivated reasoning but god damn is it hard to distinguish from bad faith argument.
Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by pfdietz on Monday November 09, 2026 @06:37PM (#50433946)
> The bar for mass extinction is much, much lower than the K/T impactor.

Clearly not, otherwise there would have been many more mass extinctions.

In any case, shifting that by a couple of orders of magnitude doesn't save the argument.

Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by andrewflnr on Monday November 09, 2026 @08:03PM (#50434722)
Many more mass extinctions, you say? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_extinction_events These are still just the highlights.

Meanwhile, even something like the Chelyabinsk meteor, which injured over a thousand people, would be a half-decent terror weapon. Consider what a relatively minor event caused https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Year_Without_a_Summer .

Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by pfdietz on Tuesday November 10, 2026 @12:21PM (#50443324)
Yes, many more. The rate of impacts scales as roughly inversely with mass, so if something 1000 times smaller than the K/T impactor would cause a mass extinction, we'd have a mass extinction on average every ~10^5 years.

The claim that this sort of space mining presents a mass extinction risk is obvious ludicrous nonsense and you should just stop.

Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by andrewflnr on Tuesday November 10, 2026 @02:37PM (#50445208)
Maybe I made a mistake by mentioning it, but I've made it quite clear that "mass extinction" is only one corner of my argument.
Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by myrmidon on Tuesday November 10, 2026 @10:51AM (#50442105)
The Chicxulub impactor was at least a billion tons. Interplanetary shipping of objects that size is so far into pure fantasy land it's not even really worth speculating about.

Even to just get into "very large nuke" territory, you'd require impactors in the million ton range (200m diameter stony asteroid). LEO payload for Saturn-V/Starship is in the 100 ton range, for comparison, so you'd need about 10000 of those (~10km/s of delta-v is barely enough to fish anything out of the asteroid belt, see [1]).

If your hypothetical rogue government/terrorist org adversary can get control of the equivalent of 10000 Saturn-V, then them pursuing some harebrained asteroid redirection plot afterwards is the least of your problems.

I'm not bad-faithing or strawmaning anything here-- my point is simply that any space mining program that is plausibly imaginable within the next centuries (which is gonna limit things to <10000 tons of payload in my view) is a non-concern from a military utility perspective (that would be roughly a chelyabinsk meteor at the very most, for reference, and depending on trajectory and structure might not even hit the ground).

[1]: https://planet4589.org/jcm/pubs/sci/papers/2018/Taylor18.pdf

Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by roughly on Monday November 09, 2026 @02:58PM (#50431057)
What’s your opinion on the US’s MAD nuclear strategy?
Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by andrewflnr on Monday November 09, 2026 @03:21PM (#50431420)
It's pretty bad. I wish there was a better one but I'm pretty sure that ship has sailed.
Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by myrmidon on Tuesday November 10, 2026 @06:23AM (#50438783)
> We're talking about a continuous stream of material at well above escape velocity, whose delta-V is already paid for.

I don't know what exact scenario you are talking about here.

Even a huge construct (1000 tons?) at escape velocity has less energy than the smallest of nuclear weapons (20kt), and a tiny fraction of the explosives used in mining right now (at least megaton TNT equivalent/year).

> By the way, are you sure the control systems of the mine owners are resilient to coercion of their executives by "legitimate" terrestrial governments? I'm not. None of your reasons are effective.

Are you just playing devils advocate here? There is few things that I'm less concerned about than mining explosives being confiscated and repurposed for some shady-government terror campaign.

> If North Korea or Iran could hold the world hostage with a threat of a mass-extinction-level event, they absolutely would. Similar for many terrorists of various stripes. Are you sure the control systems of whatever company ends up trying to bring back mass from space will be sufficiently resilient to hacking? I'm not. So, I worry.

North Korea has weapons of mass destruction already, and delivery vehicles for them. So what? Those destructive capabilities are already much greater than anything they could ever hope to gain from ursurping some space-mining operation within the next centuries.

Russia has even greater capabilities and plenty of imperialist desires to fulfill, but those nuclear threats did not seem to help them gain anything of consequence over the last decade, and not for lack of trying.

The thing is that any organization wealthy/powerful enough to realistically gain access to militarily relevant systems will typically also have enough to lose to disincentivize haphazard use. Rare exceptions like 9/11 demonstrate how much circumstance is required to get around this.

Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by andrewflnr on Tuesday November 10, 2026 @11:27AM (#50442616)
I'm talking about an ongoing space mining operation being hijacked by a government or for terrorism. This seems like the most obvious threat model. You seemed to figure it out later in your comment.

Anyway, in your other reply you're lecturing me about the relevance if the K/T impactor when I'm not the one who brought it up. At least we agree it's irrelevant. If you want to tell me I'm overestimating the threat per ton of incoming meteor, which might be true, go ahead and say that instead of all this other faff.

Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by chuckadams on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @10:45AM (#50454764)
But what if they attach a magically efficient engine to the rock and spray it with cloaking paint? ;p

But seriously, you convinced me: mining the fuel from the moon and assembling the delivery systems in space might change the equation slightly, but any society that has the technology to do that has much cheaper and more effective nuclear weapons at their disposal already.

Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by myrmidon on Monday November 09, 2026 @12:41PM (#50428774)
Given that it's about as abundant as platinum (which trades at ~$50000/kg), tellurium is pretty cheap right now (~120$/kg, about 10 times the price of copper).

Since it's an almost free byproduct of copper electrorefining (>1% concentration in copper anode slime, but low annual production of ~800 tons, limiting CdTe panel production to ~100GW/year short term [1]), I don't think that mining it in space is every gonna pay off for terrestrial panel production, because if it was priced somewhat comparably to platinum group metals you could never ever justify any demand for it (panels would be much too expensive compared to alternatives, tellurium is already a relevant cost factor for them despite being cheap-ish) => and you'd obviously use all interplanetary mining/transport capability on platinum and its ilk instead.

[1]: https://www.pv-magazine.com/2026/02/10/global-cadmium-tellur...

Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by nkmnz on Monday November 09, 2026 @01:19PM (#50429354)
On top of that, there are 53% more atoms in a kg of Tl than there are atoms in a kg of Pt!
Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by pfdietz on Monday November 09, 2026 @01:30PM (#50429509)
Tellurium is Te. Tl is thallium.
Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by nkmnz on Monday November 09, 2026 @04:47PM (#50432718)
Of course, thank you for pointing that out. The math still maths :)
Re:Magenta solar panels may be agrivoltaics' cleverest trick... by pfdietz on Monday November 09, 2026 @03:32PM (#50431619)
Yeah. Probably it would be better to look at alternative terrestrial sources, like manganese nuggets (which are maybe 40 ppm Te).

The layer of CdTe on a thin film PV module is extremely thin, so at current prices the cost of Te is a very small fraction of the cost of the module.