There's a rather big difference in trusting their phones vs. trusting their services in this case:
Mobile network vendors (including Nokia's NSN) have a record of being very very helpful in supporting government wiretapping. see eg http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2009/apr/13/europe39s-te...
This is a much bigger problem in China, etc (the "emerging markets" under discussion) than in the west.
It's much less likely they've built backdoors into the handset, and if they do they risk getting caught.
> They are providing a service that users are opting in to use.
No, there's no opting in to the violation of end-to-end security here.
http://www.wpcentral.com/nokias-xpress-browser-has-been-bloc...
I think the major issue is that you cannot 'sell' any core mobile network-devices without: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawful_interception
So "very helpful" is kinda debatable in my opinion.
Lots of other vendors market these government espionage tools to autocratic regimes too. Eg Bluecoat, Cisco etc.
At any rate it feels bad that we have to appeal to these human rights abusing autocracies, it's not any better to have these mechanisms built into the western networks.
Also I'm very doubtful about the economics of offering a phone with a weak CPU and memory configuration. Aren't screens a big chunk of the price?
The Nokia browser is essentially a thin client that communicates with a remotely hosted web browser. The remote web browser, running on Nokia's servers, does all the complicated JavaScript and advanced CSS stuff, and converts it to a dumbed down version that can be displayed on the phone.
There clearly is a cost savings in using low-end parts. Not all screens are created equal, for example the Nokia Asha 306 uses a 240x400px resistive touchscreen. If you have ever used a phone with a resistive touchscreen you know how bad they are. It also has 32MB of RAM, 10MB of user storage, 2G data (not 3G), and no GPS. You can't run a WebKit + V8 browser on a phone with those specs, you just can't.
The BOM for a Nokia Lumia 900 (high end, with a 480x800px capacitive touchscreen) is here: http://www.isuppli.com/Teardowns/News/Pages/Nokia-900-Carrie...
It is this certificate that proves your connection is to smtp.gmail.com and not somebody else. That's the whole freaking point of HTTPS. What Google does from there, it's their business, but NO, they are not the man in the middle, as you explicitly and willfully connected to them and allowed them to send email on your behalf.
On the other hand, connecting to HTTPS with one of these Nokia phones leaves you with the impression that HTTPS connections to google.com are secure, when in fact the Nokia device is LYING TO YOU.
The example you've given couldn't have been any worst.
Here is post from the "security researcher", so you can see who the certs are issued to: http://gaurangkp.wordpress.com/2013/01/09/nokia-https-mitm/
Saying it's OK to not tell someone something important because you don't respect the intelligence of the person or people it considers is well, wrong.
It's a privacy concern as it is. Please don't muddy the waters by spreading FUD and conflating this with something it's not.
I promise I don't read your mail when I get caught.
I'm giving the first 3 months free, please provide your information below so I can get started today!
Well duh.
Remember how a while ago Nokia got a bit of bad press about developing the DPI technology for Iran and Egypt? (together in a joint venture with Siemens).
So they made a press release[1] about how it has come to their attention that this technology was being used for human-rights abuse (GASP you don't say?). As a result they "halted all work at monitoring centres" and promised they wouldn't do it again.
And now there is this. It is not quite as severe, but it's the very same careless attitude regarding people's privacy in contexts were this privacy really really should be maintained.
It seems pretty obvious they do not care, each time until they're caught red-handed.
So IMO, you can leave the "if" out of that statement and shorten it to "don't trust Nokia".
Shame on Opera for being part of this, too.
> The maker of the software and hardware always has the capability to add eavesdropping code if they want.
Well that's the point, isn't it? You always need to trust your hardware manufacturer that they won't do this. Developing DPI technology for oppressive regimes does not quite engender this type of trust. Nokia has to do a little bit more than just a press release before they earn that basic level of trust again (if ever).
[0] http://www.nokiasiemensnetworks.com/news-events/press-room/c...
[1] http://www.nokiasiemensnetworks.com/news-events/press-room/s...
These phones are too under-powered to render modern web pages. It's either this or they have to view only WAP pages. If you have never used WAP on an old phone, go login to Yahoo Mail at http://wap.yahoo.com/
Overly complicated comparison would be you controlling browser on a remote desktop. Nothing has to be cracked, yet you can see data on your computer while the other computer can see them too.
And yet there is confusion around it. The onus is on Nokia to educate their users that it isn't as secure as a HTTPS web browser.
You are right. And now I don't trust Nokia, after reading this news.
[1] http://betalabs.nokia.com/trials/nokia-xpress-internet
[2] https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/opera-mini-web-browser/id363...
There is no MITM attack. They are not spoofing DNS or forging SSL certs. They are providing a service that users are opting in to use.
If you don't trust Nokia, don't use their phones. Even with end-to-end encryption, the data (including voice calls) is unencrypted on your phone until the software and hardware encrypts it. The maker of the software and hardware always has the capability to add eavesdropping code if they want.