News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by zug_zug on Saturday October 31, 2026 @10:30AM (#50316542)
It's getting harder to believe this is accidental when it's 3 leftist situations in a row in such a short time.
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by Qem on Saturday October 31, 2026 @11:18AM (#50316943)
Just look at the shenanigans Meta pulled in Brazil election.
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by throwaway894345 on Saturday October 31, 2026 @10:44AM (#50316661)
It doesn’t help that Zuckerberg is recorded pledging his loyalty to Trump.
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by piva00 on Saturday October 31, 2026 @10:52AM (#50316723)
It doesn't help Joel Kaplan was their main policy executive until this year. It doesn't help either to read all the beans spilled in "Careless People" about how Zuckerberg and Sandberg discovered they could use Facebook's/Meta's reach to tilt the political landscape and force candidates to be on their side regarding regulations.

They've been doing this for a decade, no reckoning yet in sight.

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by extraextra on Saturday October 31, 2026 @11:10AM (#50316877)
Same Trump he banned a few years ago?

Lol what "loyalty" are you talking about?

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by financetechbro on Saturday October 31, 2026 @01:10PM (#50317963)
If you think Zuck has the same loyalties today as he did years ago then you are blind and willingly ignorant
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by extraextra on Saturday October 31, 2026 @01:26PM (#50318099)
Let me fix that for you: "If you think Zuck has loyalties then you are blind and willingly ignorant"

Much better

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by red_candle_wax on Saturday October 31, 2026 @01:12PM (#50317981)
Indeed, the real lesson is that these antisocial ghouls are the enemy of us all and should not be trusted in amy circumstance.
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by extraextra on Saturday October 31, 2026 @01:29PM (#50318122)
True

People that were cheering on when this happened to one side suddenly get surprised when the same thing happens to their side

Well well well how the turntables... [1]

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XFagogEOZz8

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by Xortl on Sunday November 01, 2026 @12:56PM (#50327918)
They are not the same thing, and it's hard to imagine you actually don't know that.
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by extraextra on Sunday November 01, 2026 @01:40PM (#50328376)
Yeah, they're not the same thing, DT was treated much much worse

Trump was banned for years and that seems to be ok with you

A Dem account is banned 1 hour and people here are crying wolf

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by throwaway894345 on Sunday November 01, 2026 @04:19PM (#50330000)
What is being compared here? Trump being banned from platforms for trying to use those same platforms to overthrow the government? Comparing that to Democrats being censored for … campaigning for office?
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by extraextra on Monday November 02, 2026 @07:42AM (#50336061)
The video for which Trump was deplatformed is literally a video in which he calls for peace and asks protesters to go home, and by the way, he was never convicted of anything (despite Biden's best efforts on the matter), so your accusation has no legal basis

As far as facts go, here's what's established: Trump was deplatformed for political speech for 2 years

Leftist cheer on the politically-motivated censorship of the other side, and then when Dem account is banned 1 hour and everyone is crying their eyes out

The audacity

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by throwaway894345 on Monday November 02, 2026 @12:51PM (#50340686)
> The video for which Trump was deplatformed is literally a video in which he calls for peace and asks protesters to go home

Trump received a 12 hour temporary ban for that video, because he lied that the election was stolen from him and he praised the rioters.

Trump was banned for more Tweets that Twitter judged “likely to incite more violence” like January 6th, particularly because plans for more violent attacks had begun proliferating, including more attacks on the US Capitol and state capitols on January 17.

> he was never convicted of anything

Private platforms don’t require a criminal conviction, and anyway his SCOTUS appointees invented a brand new Presidential Immunity doctrine expressly to protect him.

> so your accusation has no legal basis

“Not convicted” != “no legal basis”

> As far as facts go, here's what's established: Trump was deplatformed for political speech for 2 years

Nope, Trump was deplatformed for inciting political violence.

> Leftist cheer on the politically-motivated censorship of the other side, and then when Dem account is banned 1 hour and everyone is crying their eyes out

You would have a point if you can point to a case of leftists complaining that their candidate was deplatformed for trying to overthrow the government, but obviously that hasn’t happened so you have to pretend that attempting to overthrow the government is comparable to run-of-the-mill campaigning.

I also don’t know that I would throw stones about “crying” if my side has an annual meltdown about the decorations on Starbucks cups :)

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by extraextra on Monday November 02, 2026 @04:08PM (#50343793)
So far you're just trying to move the goalpost on multiple points and to substitute legal principles with your feelings basically.

> Trump was banned for more Tweets that Twitter judged

We were discussing Meta, why are we moving the goalpost?

> Private platforms [can do whatever they want]

That applies to Trump as much as it applies here.

> “Not convicted” != “no legal basis”

Lol, have you even heard of "innocent until proven guilty"? How about "defamation"?

So much artificial intelligence, yet we struggle with basic concepts.

> Trump was deplatformed for [commenter's opinion]

Yeah, that's your opinion.

> if you can point to a case of leftists complaining that their candidate was deplatformed for [commenter's opinion]

Again, that's your opinion, not a fact. Plus, you're trying to move the goalpost again.

> annual meltdown about the decorations on Starbucks cups

That's actually funny haha

> my side

That's were we have the real problem. "My side" vs. "your side". "I'm morally superior because [commenter's opinion]".

I literally argue that censorship is bad for everyone and people are ready to wage WW3 because of "sides".

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by throwaway894345 on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @12:18PM (#50354890)
> So far you're just trying to move the goalpost on multiple points and to substitute legal principles with your feelings basically.

Is the idea that I'm "moving the goalposts" by acknowledging that "innocent until proven guilty" does not apply to private platforms' moderation policies? Or what are you specifically objecting to here?

> We were discussing Meta, why are we moving the goalpost?

Were we? By context I thought you were talking about his Twitter suspension, because your comments were clearly incorrect as pertaining to his Meta suspension which was for violating its content policies for promoting violence. Regardless of which platform you're talking about, you still have to demonstrate that promoting violence and trying to overthrow the government are comparable to campaigning for a senate seat.

> Lol, have you even heard of "innocent until proven guilty"?

Yes, Trump should stand trial for his crimes before he's sentenced. "innocent until proven guilty" does not protect Trump from people observing that he committed crimes.

> How about "defamation"?

Lol are you arguing that I'm committing "defamation" by criticizing the president for committing crimes when he hasn't been found guilty in a court of law? Firstly, by your own logic, you aren't allowed to criticize me for defamation until I've been found guilty in a court of law. Secondly, in the United States, it's only defamation if it's _provably untrue_ which is why the famously litigious DJT won't sue anyone for these claims.

> Yeah, that's your opinion.

The platforms themselves made public statements as to why they suspended his accounts. Maybe you could argue that the platforms are lying to us about their true intentions, but you haven't presented any evidence to support your claims that he wasn't, in fact, suspended for stoking a violent insurrection or lying about election results but rather was suspended for calling for peace.

> That's actually funny haha

Thanks, it was tough to pick just one controversy (tan suit gate, dijon gate, bike helmet gate, cheesecake factory gate, etc).

> That's were we have the real problem. "My side" vs. "your side". "I'm morally superior because [commenter's opinion]".

My man, I didn't start the right vs left stuff, I was pointing out that it's a particularly bad idea to engage in that sort of partisanship when your party is so much more guilty of the criticisms you're levying at "leftists".

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by extraextra on Tuesday November 03, 2026 @01:14PM (#50355829)
TL;DR: You're trying again to move goalpost again, change the topic of the conversation, you provide fake facts and lots of emotional opinions. Honestly, you haven't made 1 coherent argument grounded in reality so far. The fact is that Trump was deplatformed for political speech (about which you have feelings, you made that clear), he was never convicted of anything and the platforms had to pay tens of millions in settlements for their actions. Censorship for political speech is bad, regardless of your feelings. People cheering Trumps deplatforming while crying here for 1 Dem account being banned for 1 hour are super hypocrites.

> what are you specifically objecting to here?

I pointed out in my previous comment 2 specific sentences where you're moving the goalpost, no point repeating

> By context I thought you were talking about his Twitter suspension

I don't know where you'd get that idea, the thread started as a conversation about Meta banning a Dem account, we're discussing about Meta

> your comments were clearly incorrect as pertaining to his Meta suspension

You're clearly wrong, here's what Wikipedia says: "Trump posted a short video. Facebook removed it and blocked Trump's ability to post new content to both platforms.[...] The next day, Facebook said the block would remain" [1]; Then Wikipedia links to the exact video I was talking about in my previous comment.

> you still have to demonstrate that [commenters emotional opinion] are comparable to campaigning for a senate seat

No, I don't. You're moving the goalpost again by trying to switch what we are discussing here. I'm not debating with your feelings Trump's actions. We were discussing political censorship, specifically by Meta.

> Trump should stand trial for his crimes before he's sentenced

That's your emotional opinion again

> you aren't allowed to criticize me for defamation until I've been found guilty

You're not making any sense now, we are literally debating with each other; Goes to show how little you understand those concepts

> in the United States, it's only defamation if it's _provably untrue_

That's incorrect actually. Just for the sake of argument, in case of defamation, the burden of proof about the truth value of the statement is on the person that published the statement. If someone calls me a murderer, it's not my burden to prove I'm not a murderer (as a negative can't be proven), it's their burden to prove the truth of what they wrote about me.

> The platforms themselves made public statements as to why they suspended his accounts.

Then all those platforms (including Meta) paid hefty settlements to Trump and reinstated his accounts. So, clearly, all of them are regretting their actions. You keep insisting about nonsense that has no factual basis.

> your party is so much more guilty

Of course, I know, the other party is always always much much more guilty, even when you have 0 facts.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_media_use_by_Donald_Tru...

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by cosmicgadget on Sunday November 01, 2026 @11:24AM (#50327078)
The loyalty that was pledged after this happened? Otherwise it would have been a vow renewal.
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by nbajka on Saturday October 31, 2026 @10:53AM (#50316727)
I assume it probably happens to right-wing candidates as well but I won’t hear about it on this website.
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by Analemma_ on Saturday October 31, 2026 @11:03AM (#50316810)
How about you find an example instead of assuming.
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by extraextra on Saturday October 31, 2026 @11:14AM (#50316907)
Donald Trump

Marjorie Taylor Greene

And others

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by watwut on Saturday October 31, 2026 @12:13PM (#50317460)
Not comparable at all.
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by extraextra on Saturday October 31, 2026 @12:47PM (#50317759)
Lol what a hypocritical thing to say

Trump was banned for years and that seems to be ok with you

A Dem account is banned 1 hour and you cry wolf

The audacity

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by amanaplanacanal on Saturday October 31, 2026 @06:10PM (#50320750)
Trump was banned for breaking the TOS. Is that the case here?
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by extraextra on Saturday October 31, 2026 @06:54PM (#50321042)
That's nonsense

You're clearly not informed here

He posted a benign video and the woke people running social media companies used that opportunity to retaliate

It was clearly a cheap shot for his political speech and political views

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by amanaplanacanal on Saturday October 31, 2026 @07:25PM (#50321245)
I'm sure that's the truth in whatever reality you are living in.
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by extraextra on Saturday October 31, 2026 @07:51PM (#50321410)
You haven't presented any facts or arguments, are you here just for an emotional conversation?

Perhaps your therapist was in vacation this week and need to vent out some feelings?

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by nbajka on Saturday October 31, 2026 @11:09AM (#50316866)
You know a guy called Donald Trump?
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by g-b-r on Saturday October 31, 2026 @12:00PM (#50317364)
When did that happens?
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by extraextra on Saturday October 31, 2026 @11:06AM (#50316835)
Let's not forget that Trump was banned as well by Meta
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by mcphage on Saturday October 31, 2026 @11:25AM (#50317015)
Oh, and what for?
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by extraextra on Saturday October 31, 2026 @11:40AM (#50317188)
For political speech

And Trump was banned for multiple years, this Dem account was blocked 1 hour and people are already crying wolf

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by watwut on Saturday October 31, 2026 @12:14PM (#50317476)
Oh yeah, which exact political speech? Cause these two things are not symmetrical at all.

Lets compare the reasons and speeches rather then hiding behind "political" euphemism.

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by extraextra on Saturday October 31, 2026 @12:51PM (#50317793)
Yeah, they're not symmetrical, DT was treated much much worse

Trump was banned for years and that seems to be ok with you

A Dem account is banned 1 hour and you cry wolf

> Lets compare the reasons and speeches rather then hiding behind "political" euphemism.

Lol here comes the thought police

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by watwut on Saturday October 31, 2026 @01:03PM (#50317906)
No, DT got away with much more and longer. And there was no real infractuon here from their side
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by extraextra on Saturday October 31, 2026 @01:31PM (#50318146)
Orwell is turning in his grave hearing all the leftist nonsense spewed out nowadays
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by lowmagnet on Saturday October 31, 2026 @04:36PM (#50319927)
What a weird thing to say about him. Clearly you haven't read his work.
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by extraextra on Saturday October 31, 2026 @05:00PM (#50320181)
“If liberty means anything at all, it means the right to tell people what they do not want to hear.” - George Orwell
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by kobalsky on Saturday October 31, 2026 @12:50PM (#50317787)
what's the point of moving the goalpost here?, are you gonna pull the terms and conditions of meta? trump wasn't prosecuted
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by extraextra on Sunday November 01, 2026 @01:45PM (#50328414)
People are too emotionally invested in their side to care about any principles unfortunately

Freedom of speech? We don't want that for the "other side"

Censorship? Yes please, but only for the "other side"

Arguing in bad faith? Anything just to make the "other side" look unflattering

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by Henchman21 on Saturday October 31, 2026 @12:49PM (#50317778)
Ah yes because the conservative movement at the moment is so entirely beaten down and hunched in a defensive crouch because they have exactly zero power in the world right now? I mean, it isn’t like ideologues on the right own the entire media landscape or anything right? Or are in the White House, hold both houses of Congress, and have little despots in training all over the fucking planet.

But yeah, sure it happens to Conservatives at the same rate. You just won’t hear about it here because the Evil Left controls a site run by Silicon Valley. In 2026.

Really just shut the fuck up pal.

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by bko on Saturday October 31, 2026 @10:36AM (#50316584)
Isn't the more likely reason due to suspicious bot activity? I doubt a trillion dollar org cares much about these small candidates.

I don't rule it out entirely. In 2021 we saw a coordinated deplatforming of a sitting president across practically every social media platform. But this seems too low stakes

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by treyd on Saturday October 31, 2026 @10:43AM (#50316653)
"Small candidates", for US senate?
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by throwaway894345 on Saturday October 31, 2026 @10:49AM (#50316693)
This is a florida senate race

EDIT: I’m mistaken, this is a US senate candidate. I was confused by the ambiguous wording in the article.

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by treyd on Saturday October 31, 2026 @10:57AM (#50316762)
Angie Nixon is currently a Florida state rep who is running for US senate: https://angienixon.com/
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by throwaway894345 on Saturday October 31, 2026 @10:31PM (#50322220)
Yes, I’m mistaken. I didn’t realize the ambiguity in the “Florida Democratic Senate candidate” (I misinterpreted it as “Democratic candidate for Florida Senate”).
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by throooooo on Saturday October 31, 2026 @10:53AM (#50316725)
Yes an extremely contentious race if you pay attention to politics. A year ago if anyone had said Dems have a chance of a Senate majority during the midterms you'd have been laughed out of the building.
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by throwaway894345 on Saturday October 31, 2026 @10:57AM (#50316755)
Again, this isn’t a US senate race, it’s a Florida senate race.

EDIT: I’m mistaken, this is a US senate candidate. I was confused by the ambiguous wording in the article.

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by bko on Saturday October 31, 2026 @01:22PM (#50318070)
It's not really competitive. She's down by ten points.
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by cogman10 on Saturday October 31, 2026 @02:35PM (#50318699)
6 points according to the latest Siena Poll [1]. The gap has been narrowing ever since she won the primary.

Still likely to lose (IMO), but it's more competitive than we've seen in Florida for a long time.

[1] https://sri.siena.edu/2026/10/28/nytimes-siena-poll-of-likel...

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by throwaway894345 on Saturday October 31, 2026 @10:54AM (#50316737)
Small candidates have a lot of impact, especially when you want to (for example) build a data center. Not that this is necessary to explain it—the cost of the censorship to Meta is negligible (an employee presses a button or an AI makes an API call), so even a small reward is worthwhile.

> In 2021 we saw a coordinated deplatforming of a sitting president across practically every social media platform.

It wasn’t coordinated, it was a bunch of social media companies responding to the same event, notably the president in question using his social media accounts to try to overthrow the US government.

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by luizfzs on Saturday October 31, 2026 @10:40AM (#50316626)
It's not. Meta did the same thing during Brazil's elections. Left-wing politicians' and influencer's accounts suspended, while right wings' stayed working. Even with the widespread knowledge that the right is notorious for using bot accounts to inflate followers and to generate engagement.

The big tech companies are on the side of power and money.

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by extraextra on Saturday October 31, 2026 @11:16AM (#50316921)
Lol, let's not forget Meta banned Donald Trump, Marjorie Taylor Greene and others before

You pretend like this is somehow a partisan issue

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by parineum on Saturday October 31, 2026 @10:56AM (#50316747)
> Even with the widespread knowledge that the right is notorious for using bot accounts...

Are you, by chance, of the left?

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by bix6 on Saturday October 31, 2026 @11:04AM (#50316823)
Because the left came up with “flood the zone”

All research I’ve seen on this shows the right significantly outbotting the left.

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by parineum on Saturday October 31, 2026 @11:10AM (#50316874)
Outbotting and implying it's a problem with the right, specifically are two very different things.
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by bix6 on Saturday October 31, 2026 @11:21AM (#50316978)
I don’t understand what you mean by this?
Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by parineum on Saturday October 31, 2026 @02:30PM (#50318649)
Your initial implication is that left wing accounts get banned while right wing accounts don't (an already spurious point), despite right wing accounts being notorious for botting.

That implies that left wing accounts shouldn't have been banned because they are not notorious for botting.

With the next reply, you hedge and say that the right "outbots" the left. That weakens your initial point that the left wing account bans are unjustified.

However, my initial reply was in response to the claim that it's "widespread knowledge" that the right outbots the left. That is not knowledge I consider to be self evident and I was assuming/asking that you got that knowledge from left leaning sources.

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by bix6 on Saturday October 31, 2026 @02:46PM (#50318822)
I am not the GP fyi.

It is widespread knowledge that the right outbots the left, presuming you bother to inform yourself about the issue.

Re:Why Did Meta Suspend a US Senate Candidate's Instagram in... by parineum on Saturday October 31, 2026 @05:20PM (#50320363)
Where does this widespread knowledge come from?