Re:AIG considers suing government for bailing it out
by jbooth on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @09:40PM
(#5029814)
If a large shareholder insisted they build a moon base, would they be required to consider that, too?
This is approximately as reasonable.
Re:AIG considers suing government for bailing it out
by delinka on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @10:06PM
(#5029902)
Consider it, yes. However, how does one define 'consider'? The board looks around at one another, one or two offer negative points against the suggestion, someone calls for a vote and they decide not to do it. 60 seconds from the time the suggestion comes up, it's voted down. I'd say that they "considered" it.
But given lawyers and the unlimited ability for people to just file lawsuits, there's probably a legal definition that entails at the least a few hours "consideration" of such proposals.
/cynic
Re:AIG considers suing government for bailing it out
by untog on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @09:53PM
(#5029864)
If a large shareholder insisted that build a moon base, would they be required to consider that, too?
If they owned 51% of shares? Well, er...
Re:AIG considers suing government for bailing it out
by cmelbye on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @10:06PM
(#5029904)
Well, yeah.
Re:AIG considers suing government for bailing it out
by mikeash on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @10:05PM
(#5029900)
I think would. Note that considering it isn't the same as carrying it out. Presumably they'd consider the moon base briefly, notice that the cost/benefit ratio is enormous, and decline.
Re:AIG considers suing government for bailing it out
by pmorici on Tuesday January 08, 2013 @09:55PM
(#5029873)
Very misleading it's really Hank Greenberg the Ex-CEO of AIG who ran AIG into that mess in the first place that initiated the lawsuit.
Re:AIG considers suing government for bailing it out
by jacobwcarlson on Wednesday January 09, 2013 @02:03AM
(#5030563)
Yours is actually a very misleading comment since Greenberg stepped down as CEO in 2005.
Re:AIG considers suing government for bailing it out
by hga on Wednesday January 09, 2013 @08:38AM
(#5031390)
To be even more specific, was forced out of the company at the beginning of 2005 in a totally abusive prosecution by NY AG Eliot Spitzer, who the last time I checked completely failed to get a single big white collar crime conviction.
I find it difficult to believe there's no connection between the government's trashing of AIG's top level management, including their required vetting of the new head, and the failures in risk management that followed.
Re:AIG considers suing government for bailing it out
by pmorici on Wednesday January 09, 2013 @10:05AM
(#5031817)
Were AIG's troubles not well underway by 2005 even if they weren't public knowledge yet? Also if memory serves he was forced out over allegations of illegality in a shady deal AIG made to secretly borrow money from a subsidiary of Berkshire Hathaway to make it look like AIG was in a stronger financial position than they actually were. Also Wikipedia says he was forced out by the AIG board.
NPR's Marketplace covered this story tonight and provide a bit of context:
"[Henry Hu, a law professor at the University of Texas and a former SEC regulator] says AIG’s board has an obligation to consider the lawsuit because of shareholder interests, “but they should also consider the costs of this in terms of their relationship with the regulators.”
Don’t forget, AIG is the company that just started running ads saying -- no joke -- “Thank you America.”
A spokesman for the New York Fed said the allegations have no merit because bankruptcy was AIG’s only alternative. That would have wiped out shareholders entirely.
[Phil Angelides, who chaired the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission] thinks the board shouldn’t consider this lawsuit for more than a minute.
...
AIG issued a written statement today saying it will follow the law and consider the suit. In earlier email to Marketplace, an AIG spokesman declined to comment. Though he did say Thank You."
Source: http://www.marketplace.org/topics/business/aig-thanks-bailou...