News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google illegally cut down 250K trees in Finland for data ... by GuestFAUniverse on Saturday October 24, 2026 @10:51AM (#50221831)
Value of a mature tree is normally several thousand euros here (I don't know about Finland). Multipled by 250K. Times 3 -- a decent factor for illegal acts. Would be a appropriate compensation for Finland.
Re:Google illegally cut down 250K trees in Finland for data ... by helsinkiandrew on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:14AM (#50222074)
A 50 year old spruce is about €50 in Finland - from the map the trees don’t look that mature.

You can buy a similar sized forest for €50-150K.

https://www.metsatilat.fi/en/osta?property_type=forest&area_...

Re:Google illegally cut down 250K trees in Finland for data ... by Aurornis on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:29AM (#50222228)
Extrapolating to Finland’s entire forested area, Finland is sitting on hundreds of trillions of wealth!

Or maybe this is a bad measure?

You also forgot that Google owned the trees that they cut down, so they would be compensating themselves.

The debate is about the order in which a contractor pulled permits. It’s silly how much people are obsessing over some trees being cut down. This happens with all development.

Re:Google illegally cut down 250K trees in Finland for data ... by miohtama on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:18AM (#50222123)
Google was cutting their own trees in their own forest, not someone else's trees.

What the news is about is "environmental impact study".

Re:Google illegally cut down 250K trees in Finland for data ... by Choco31415 on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:09AM (#50222009)
To do the math, that would be 5.25 billion euros.
Re:Google illegally cut down 250K trees in Finland for data ... by sejje on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:27AM (#50222210)
Shall they pay themselves for their own trees?
Re:Google illegally cut down 250K trees in Finland for data ... by eesmith on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:12AM (#50222050)
This wasn't merely an illegal logging operation. They also stripped off the topsoil, and failed to prevent runoff into local waterways.

For Google, a fine of ~EUR 5 billion is a rounding error in their cost of doing business.

Re:Google illegally cut down 250K trees in Finland for data ... by peri-cl on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:32AM (#50222257)
> "They also stripped off the topsoil,"

That's a perfectly normal and environmentally conscious thing to do before laying down concrete foundations. Topsoil is recycled and sold to farms. To leave it in place would pointlessly waste an ecological resource.

Re:Google illegally cut down 250K trees in Finland for data ... by eesmith on Saturday October 24, 2026 @12:37PM (#50222896)
The environmentally conscious thing to do the necessary environmental impact assessments before clear-cutting the land.

According to the Guardian article, which it the source the NY Post used, if those trees were illegally logged, they cannot be sold to wood-processing plants.

Do you know if the law also prohibits the topsoil from being sold to farms?

Re:Google illegally cut down 250K trees in Finland for data ... by kristjansson on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:25AM (#50222193)
> rounding error

Not really? That’d be ~1% of global revenue and ~2% of opex? Sure they could pay it, but it’s not a negligible amount.

Re:Google illegally cut down 250K trees in Finland for data ... by eesmith on Saturday October 24, 2026 @12:30PM (#50222818)
It really does depend on your time frame, does it not?

This is part of a 2 year, €13 billion investment by Google, so €5 billion is nearly all of the yearly investment of a single project.

On the other hand, Finland is only a part of Google's world-wide projects, and these projects are expected to produce revenue for, what, decades?

A 10-year time frame changes your numbers to ~0.1% and ~0.2%.