News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Every AI model has the same "controversial" take on humans by dandyLines on Friday October 23, 2026 @08:46AM (#50208138)
The same communities are frequently the most racist, xenophobic and homophobic. The dark side of the tribal mindset I guess.
Re:Every AI model has the same "controversial" take on humans by brabel on Friday October 23, 2026 @12:18PM (#50211433)
Doesn’t that make you think : why are they so nice on the one hand , but so bad on the other hand? Well I know why: you can’t have the cake and eat it too. One thing is the mirror image of the other, you need to choose which side you prefer to value more.
Re:Every AI model has the same "controversial" take on humans by Dylan16807 on Saturday October 24, 2026 @12:53AM (#50218442)
You can't just throw out cliches if you're going to claim something as impactful as that. You seem to be saying there's some kind of conservation of niceness so increasing your treatment of one group requires decreasing it for another group? Why is that?

And the answer couldn't be based on the amount of effort it takes, since in the small town scenario you're doing the effortful nice behavior 95% of the time.

Re:Every AI model has the same "controversial" take on humans by brabel on Saturday October 24, 2026 @04:58AM (#50219400)
First of all , this is an observation of facts in the reality we live in. I agree with the OP argument that these things are intrinsically linked when we just observe the facts without trying to impose our beliefs on them. If we accept that, we can try to theorize about why that may be. My theory is that people are nice when they live among others who look and behave like themselves because that what humans did for almost their whole existence as a species. Archeological evidence suggests that if you met a stranger, someone not from your tribe, chances were high they would be a danger, not an opportunity to make a new friend. So humans seem to have evolved to not trust outsiders, not just strangers. In a small society, conformity is highly valued because doing things without understanding its consequences could often end up in catastrophe. People didn’t understand the world, and other tribes, well enough to have any confidence in whether a new behavior would be beneficial or not. So we end up with humans who trust and depend on others from their own tribe for everything, are highly distrustful of outsiders, and not looking like yourself is the greatest sign that someone is an outsider, and who value and demand conformity as a matter of survival. The world of today breaks some of these expectations in some ways, but they are still mostly accurate in my opinion. People who are more open minded tend to be so because they live in fairly cosmopolitan areas, but those also tend to be bigger cities where you don’t really know most people and where trusting others becomes harder, especially when many people have completely different backgrounds than you.
Re:Every AI model has the same "controversial" take on humans by Dylan16807 on Saturday October 24, 2026 @08:36AM (#50220685)
Nothing you just said backs up the argument you were making earlier that who you are nice and mean to is "two sides of the same coin" and it's impossible to be nice to both (or mean to both based on the mirror comparison). You're giving a fine explanation that there are different motives involved in the treatment of insiders and outsiders, but that's much more general and nonspecific.

I'm not getting into a discussion about tribalism in general right now. You made a strong claim that goes well beyond what I normally think of as tribalism. Do you have a scrap of evidence or research for that claim?

Re:Every AI model has the same "controversial" take on humans by brabel on Saturday October 24, 2026 @09:04AM (#50220875)
I think you didn't understand my claim. My claim is simple, my long explanation above was meant for you to arrive at these conclusions yourself:

* people are nice when they still behave in the old, tribal way.

* the tribal way is always going to be creating individuals who are racist and conformant/conservative.

* not behaving the tribal way means going outside the conformist mold, which means you take risks and eventually learn by experience that taking more risks come with consequences. You become less trustful of everyone, while almost paradoxically proclaiming yourself to be more open.

This fits observation. If you believe it's wrong, you must demonstrate why with supporting evidence without contradicting the evidence I've used, obviously.

Re:Every AI model has the same "controversial" take on humans by 1718627440 on Saturday October 24, 2026 @08:26AM (#50220617)
If you want to assume you can trust your network, so you don't need security in the hosts, you need to have a sysadmin who secures the network or have it airgapped directly. You can get rid of all of that, but then you must assume your network is untrusted and need to have security in every service you run.
Re:Every AI model has the same "controversial" take on humans by Dylan16807 on Saturday October 24, 2026 @08:47AM (#50220758)
I don't think switches refusing connection to devices that don't live there is a good analogy to "racist, xenophobic and homophobic".
Re:Every AI model has the same "controversial" take on humans by 1718627440 on Saturday October 24, 2026 @09:03AM (#50220872)
Why not? The behaviour is kind of similar. The difference is that humans have an inherent right to live, while packets don't have an inherent right to be delivered.
Re:Every AI model has the same "controversial" take on humans by Viliam1234 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @03:02PM (#50234929)
Consider what happens if you have a community that is very nice, very trusting, and open to everyone including complete strangers who behave weirdly.

At the beginning it can be a nice place. Until the first abuser finds them. And then... depends on the abuser.

This is not a theory; I have seen it happen, often in groups of nerds who are somewhat naive about how real life works. Then a new guy comes, borrows some money from each of them individually, then disappears. Or a new guy comes, invites a girl to his place, and rapes her. Sometimes some people even get suspicious about the new guy, but is a taboo to express such thoughts loudly, to spread suspicion in a group based on mutual trust.

To avoid things like this, you need to split people into "those I trust" and "strangers". Different people and cultures draw the line differently. For some of them, "those I trust" only includes people they have known for a few years. It is frustrating for a newcomer, and you often wish you were able to do something so that they accept you faster. Unfortunately, if that worked, the abuser would probably do the same thing.

Another strategy is to have mutual friends vouch for someone. But this only works when it is a part of the culture, where people know that vouching for someone brings heavy consequences if that person turns out to be an abuser. In cultures that do not have such experience, abusers often do the trick where they befriend someone, use them to get introduced to their friends, and while the first target is like "this is a nice stranger that I have met yesterday", their friends are like "this is a nice person recommended by my trusted friend, which means I can trust them too", and then the abuser exploits them. (And when they complain to the first target "why did you make me trust such a horrible person", the first target is confused "well, I actually barely knew them, this was a horrible misunderstanding". But the abuser probably has a lot of experience creating such misunderstandings on purpose.)

Finally, you can have a close community that is very difficult to enter. You can trust everyone in that community, because if they do something bad, they will be kicked out, or worse. But this requires the community to be very difficult to enter, and to have ways to punish the abusers in a way that actually hurts them. (Merely kicking someone out of the community is not enough, if there are hundreds of communities, and the abuser simply infiltrates the next one.)

Abusers exist. You need to build a firewall somewhere. There are different places where you can build it, but you have to build it somewhere, or you get hurt.

Re:Every AI model has the same "controversial" take on humans by Dylan16807 on Sunday October 25, 2026 @03:52PM (#50235437)
You're talking about it being hard to join the community.

That's arguably xenophobic depending on how you interpret the word. But it doesn't require anything resembling racism or homophobia.

I'm objecting to the idea that the downside of a tight-knit community is some kind of bigotry. Not just barriers to entry.

(Alternatively, if it's not a specific community, it's some super-wide group based on some obvious feature, than that group isn't keeping out abusers and someone in a different group has probably the same odds of being an abuser.)

Re:Every AI model has the same "controversial" take on humans by spidersenses on Friday October 23, 2026 @04:33PM (#50214941)
Have you ever contemplated that the "racist, xenophobic and homophobic" behaviour is what is keeping those communities and used to keep other communities homogenous and thereby ensured high-trust? In that case the xenophobia acts like the immune system but for a community/society.
Re:Every AI model has the same "controversial" take on humans by 1718627440 on Saturday October 24, 2026 @08:24AM (#50220600)
Yeah, I guess being against anything that might be remotely disruptive, means they can trust things not to be disruptive in their daily life.
Re:Every AI model has the same "controversial" take on humans by johnnyanmac on Monday October 26, 2026 @01:51AM (#50239629)
>Have you ever contemplated that the "racist, xenophobic and homophobic" behaviour is what is keeping those communities and used to keep other communities homogenous and thereby ensured high-trust?

Not much, no. A small community that only trusts itself and pushes any out-group away (regardless of disposition) tends to be called a "cult".