News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dam Removals Are Bringing Fish Back Across the Northeaste... by notabotiswear on Friday October 16, 2026 @11:40PM (#50127701)
> Many NOOMBYs consider local dams indispensable ties to their community’s past; in Billerica, some town officials have objected to the demolition of the Talbot Mills Dam on the grounds that “it has long served as a symbol of the Industrial Revolution” that remains “unquestionably one of the major focal points in the area.”

I used to hate the "but what about historical site upstream?" argument often used against dams. The prioritisation of a few tombs and piles of stone over what would improve the lives of thousands to tens of millions living now. It's kinda ironic seeing the same asinine argument being used from the other side...

That said, reducing dams to just hydroelectric generation is probably going to skew the narrative to the wrong direction.

Re:Dam Removals Are Bringing Fish Back Across the Northeaste... by jhide on Saturday October 17, 2026 @04:13PM (#50134674)
What do dams do besides hydroelectric generation?
Re:Dam Removals Are Bringing Fish Back Across the Northeaste... by ddxv on Saturday October 17, 2026 @04:19PM (#50134743)
Dams create large bodies of water that change ecosystems and provide focal points for human communities. They certainly do more than just hydroelectric.

An example would be Lake Pillsbury in Northern California which the dam has not done hydroelectric for decades but the fight to prevent demolishing the dam has had plenty of local support.

Re:Dam Removals Are Bringing Fish Back Across the Northeaste... by lukeify on Saturday October 17, 2026 @04:15PM (#50134707)
Flood control and water storage for agriculture in drier summer months are the big ones.
Re:Dam Removals Are Bringing Fish Back Across the Northeaste... by hinkley on Saturday October 17, 2026 @04:55PM (#50135048)
The one Andrew Carnegie and his friends mismanaged and killed thousands of people with was for recreation.
Re:Dam Removals Are Bringing Fish Back Across the Northeaste... by darksaints on Saturday October 17, 2026 @05:13PM (#50135188)
I think you probably meant Andrew Carnegie
Re:Dam Removals Are Bringing Fish Back Across the Northeaste... by kps on Saturday October 17, 2026 @05:36PM (#50135373)
How to Wet Friends and Inundate People
Re:Dam Removals Are Bringing Fish Back Across the Northeaste... by pfdietz on Saturday October 17, 2026 @06:38PM (#50135827)
They fill up with sediment and emit large amounts of methane from decaying organic matter.
Re:Dam Removals Are Bringing Fish Back Across the Northeaste... by toast0 on Saturday October 17, 2026 @06:48PM (#50135886)
In addition to other answers, dams are sometimes used for mechanical power without generating electricity. More likely to be historic use than current use, but also likely to be a candidate for removal for fish habitat.
Re:Dam Removals Are Bringing Fish Back Across the Northeaste... by tialaramex on Sunday October 18, 2026 @05:24AM (#50139420)
Right, it's like with literal wind mills (not wind turbines). In a very few cases it's part of a museum showing how mechanical power was used to mill flour, or power weaving machines, or whatever. Getting rid of literally every single one would be a mistake. But in the other cases they're just left to decay and so we should remove them and restore what was there before.
Re:Dam Removals Are Bringing Fish Back Across the Northeaste... by chihuahua on Saturday October 17, 2026 @04:47PM (#50135000)
I think the fact that the same bogus argument is used both against dam building and against dam removal shows that it's bogus and not compelling. When someone is against something, they will use whatever argument they can concoct. Saying that something is historically significant seems to work great. As if history is some god that must be served no matter what.
Re:Dam Removals Are Bringing Fish Back Across the Northeaste... by monomania on Saturday October 17, 2026 @07:00PM (#50135963)
They are also very difficult, and very expensive, to maintain as they age. There is a small hydro damn near where I live that predates WWII and the county/state cannot find anyone who wants to take it over because of the expense in repairing it. This is in part due to seismic retrofitting which needs to happen, but also a variety of other factors, including being built basically on silt, having a public road on top which people need to get to their homes, and simply updating the aged equipment which has been on its last leg for a while.

What's more, the dam installation changed the local water table level, and residential wells drilled since the 1940's only had to go down so far. If the dam is removed, all these wells will dry up, and the state is beginning to make it difficult to drill new wells, and they certainly don't want to shell out to install plumbing to unincorporated communities which don't vote for the majority party anyway.

Another dam nearby held a massive amount of water for one of the bigger cities in the state. This is on the west coast, and if we get the Big One, it'll flood a populated area with hundreds of thousands of people. So they've had to draw down on the water levels and it's basically useless now, but deconstructing the dam would probably be a project requiring federal money, and since it's an earthen dam in a seismic zone there isn't really any retrofitting that you can do to fix it.

Basically, dams will give you some cheap electric and a water supply for a while but after 50-70 years they're a huge liability.

Re:Dam Removals Are Bringing Fish Back Across the Northeaste... by jordanb on Saturday October 17, 2026 @10:49PM (#50137410)
Many of these weirs are extremely dangerous to swimmers. When I was young there was an incident on a nearby weir (obsolete lowhead dam) where one person got trapped and drowned and then four people who jumped in to rescue him also drowned.

https://practical.engineering/blog/2019/3/16/drowning-machin...

Re:Dam Removals Are Bringing Fish Back Across the Northeaste... by notabotiswear on Sunday October 18, 2026 @07:21AM (#50140031)
Not be insensitive to death, but this not really a damning case against the structure itself. Hazards to swimmers are pretty common and can happen with any hydraulic structure and often without. Especially in the latter cases the, expected response are warning and prohibition. Those caused by a structure should be even easier to manage because they are predictable.

That this hazard is tied to a structure with no utility is a specific scenario. But in another where the structure does serve a purpose then restricting one recreational activity in its vicinity may be an acceptable cost. Par exemple, would you be against fencing a substation or prohibiting kite/drone flying near high voltage lines?

Re:Dam Removals Are Bringing Fish Back Across the Northeaste... by jordanb on Sunday October 18, 2026 @07:40AM (#50140167)
There are far less dangerous dam designes. Again if you read the article or watch the video the weir creates a hydraulic "trap" downstream of it from which escape is essentially impossible.
Re:Dam Removals Are Bringing Fish Back Across the Northeaste... by notabotiswear on Sunday October 18, 2026 @08:21AM (#50140453)
I am aware of weir hydraulics and no one is denying the hazard they create. I am saying that everything generates a hazard and managing it is always going to be required.

That said, any structure spanning the width of a channel alters the flow in ways that are hazardous to swimmers and boats.