News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by vrganj on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @05:33PM (#50079149)
Safari is a dirty monopolist on mobile just as much as Chrome is on desktop.
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by simondotau on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @06:02PM (#50079525)
I reject your assertion because it promulgates the lie of "browser choice". The health of the web as an open platform is defined by browser diversity, not browser choice.

A bit of forced diversity is wildly preferable over another collapse towards monoculture.

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by bigyabai on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @06:33PM (#50079864)
> The health of the web as an open platform is defined by browser diversity, not browser choice.

Says who? I certainly don't agree with that statement, the "web as an open platform" was unrecognizable when proprietary clients were the norm.

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by simondotau on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @06:48PM (#50080029)
If web developers stop ensuring their sites work in Safari, consumers will be forced to install Chrome. That's not browser choice. An open platform means that CONSUMERS get to choose which browser they use, not web developers.

(And before you say it, consumers can choose Android, where 99.9% of people use Chrome, but apparently that's okay because they "chose" it.)

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by bigyabai on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @06:58PM (#50080140)
It's a chicken-and-egg problem. How can you get web developers to test their websites in Safari, when the majority of Mac devs haven't opened Safari in ages? We have the answer already. Safari doesn't compete on it's own merit.

WebKit is a second-class citizen on the web, and we can argue about why that is, but nobody can sincerely deny it. Apple's strategy has been dead in the water for over a decade. iOS lost.

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by simondotau on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @07:12PM (#50080267)
Safari is still relevant and iOS hasn't lost; the very existence of this thread serves as a clear rejection of that framing. If Safari wasn't competing, or if iOS had lost, nobody would care.

Meanwhile we have people bitching and moaning and meanwhile, as a Firefox user, I go to Safari when I encounter a website that doesn't work in Firefox. Because at the end of the day, developers are forced to test in Safari, and that is a Good Thing. No developer is forced to test in Firefox.

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by leptons on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @07:57PM (#50080620)
>the very existence of this thread serves as a clear rejection of that framing.

The existence of the "Switch to Safari" campaign is a clear rejection that Safari is competing - it's not, it's the laughing stock of web browsers in 2026, it holds the same place that IE6 did in the early 2000s.

>Because at the end of the day, developers are forced to test in Safari,

I'm not forced to test in Safari, because I don't have money for an iOS device. So Apple users can continue to suffer with whatever browser they use on their i-device. I really don't care, and Apple has done this - not me, because they offer no way but purchasing their hardware to test their wonky browser engine.

And yes, you can emulate an android device on MacOS, so don't bother trying that again. You don't need to purchase an android device to test on android.

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by simondotau on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @10:53PM (#50081824)
This (incredibly lame) campaign is only referring to macOS, not iOS. The grandparent asserted that "iOS lost."

On macOS, Google plays with a lot of dark patterns to get people to install Chrome. I can't count the number of times I've visited my sister or parents and seen Chrome on their Mac, and their explanation is "because Google told me I needed it."

That's not choice either.

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by bigyabai on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @11:42PM (#50082119)
Sure it's choice. I use Firefox on Linux; I have to forego a handful of websites, but nothing is a dealbreaker. YouTube works, Gmail works, my life isn't interrupted without Chrome installed.

It sounds like your family is using Chrome because it's more convenient. It's 2026, we can't blame anyone given what Safari spent the past decade doing. Apple does not provide convenient Safari sync for Windows and Android devices, which comprise the majority of smart devices sold. They don't support the normie extensions that people use on Firefox and Chrome. Safari lags behind Chrome in features, WebKit lags behind Blink in cross-platform support, and Apple doesn't allow Safari forks to boost their market share. Apple draws very clear and arbitrary lines in the sand, and then redrafts them once they finally change their mind about PWAs or notification support. By the time it reaches Safari, your parents have been using the feature in Chrome for 8 months.

We may have to agree to disagree. Apple's incessant marketing for their own inferior, ad-ridden packin software is part of why I left macOS to begin with. It's infantilizing to be told that I can't be trusted to make a smart decision, when Apple's own suggestion is a half baked, self-serving alternative. I empathize with Mac users that ignore Safari because that's exactly what I did on my Mac, too. I'd have been using Chrome if Firefox wasn't an option. And I still would, because WebKit is a dog's dinner on my OS.

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by simondotau on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @12:21AM (#50082351)
Just because you are able to make informed choices doesn't mean everyone can. Nor should everyone be expected to.

If you think my mother or sister have the faintest idea what a web browser is, or how one might be better than another, then you haven't met my mother or sister. To suggest that they made any kind of informed choice is absurd. They were influenced by marketing, plain and simple.

Personally, I'd be fascinated to see an in-depth study showing what percentage of web users chose their browser based on true/objective criteria, as opposed to marketing, brand preference, herd mentality, or wrong assumptions. Is exposing someone to marketing really what we mean by choice?

It's worth remembering that choice isn't necessarily the pure good we intuitively believe it to be. Western consumers have an extraordinary choice of food, yet that hasn't necessarily translated into healthier diets. This is especially problematic when the choices themselves are shaped by corporations whose interests aren't well aligned with the consumer's.

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by vrganj on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @03:32AM (#50083783)
This is why the EU forces the Browser Choice Dialog: https://developer.apple.com/support/browser-choice-screen/
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by bigyabai on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @12:50AM (#50082513)
99% of Mac users are installing Chrome or Firefox using Safari. They are objectively assessing it in a real-world test, and deciding that Safari lost. You're lucky there's no convenient way to uninstall Safari from the OS, the user telemetry would be a bloodbath.

Apple is a corporation too, and they have their own (quite sizable) financial interest in gimping the web as an alternative to native app distribution. Apple used to recognize this, and prioritized interoperability with OpenGL and OpenCL as a hedge against the web becoming the only cross-platform API that the Mac supported. The Apple of today has abandoned those interests and lost all pretenses of humility. They are equally as mask-off as Google or Microsoft is, pushing Metal and WebKit just as shamelessly as Microsoft crams the corpse of DirectX into things. This isn't a charity project, it is another way for Apple to control iOS software distribution, their primary service cash cow, Tim Cook's pride and joy. Apple is happy to give Google money for their Apple Intelligence integration, this isn't a grudge that they take seriously.

Apple could have supported KHTML upstream, and killed Blink in the cradle. They could have made Safari a billion-dollar cross-platform product, and won. They made this horrible bed, and now they want to users to moralize Google's victory. Why would anyone, knowledgeable or naive, insult themselves by standing with Apple here?

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by themanualstates on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @10:57PM (#50098590)
You use Firefox, but WebKit is in fact the default on Fedora
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by tisdadd on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @10:56PM (#50081847)
I do use safari in my playwright tests, and it led to me doing a note on my known limitations page - that those tests take longer than Firefox and Chrome, my daily drivers. But, that could be due to using it on Linux maybe. I do hate having to dig out ios devices for app testing.
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by themanualstates on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @10:56PM (#50098586)
Fedora’s default browser also uses WebKit
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by themacguffinman on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @08:29PM (#50080885)
If web developers stop ensuring their sites work in Safari, their sites will still work in Safari because Google ratifies and publishes the web standards that Chrome follows so that Safari and other browsers can follow it too, something that Safari actually does less than Chrome.

Consumers choosing Android isn't a choice of which browser to use, it's choosing which operating system to use. That doesn't sound like you care that consumers get to choose which browser they use, that's letting Apple choose which browser that Apple consumers use then telling them they can choose a different operating system instead.

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by leptons on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @07:49PM (#50080568)
>I reject your assertion because it promulgates the lie of "browser choice".

The only lie being told in all of this is the one Apple tells when you install Firefox on an iOS device. It's not Firefox you're installing, it's Safari. Every browser on iOS is Safari - you have no choice at all.

>The health of the web as an open platform is defined by browser diversity, not browser choice.

Then put your money where your mouth is. If Safari can compete then let other browser engines on iOS. If it can't then it deserves to die. Artificially inflating it by forcing on iOS isn't the utopia you think it is.

>A bit of forced diversity is wildly preferable over another collapse towards monoculture.

Apple iOS is a monocoulture - every browser is Safari whether you want it or not.

There's no argument you can make to escape the fact that Apple is helping nobody but Apple by forcing Safari on iOS.

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by vrganj on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @06:38PM (#50079915)
But there is no browser diversity on mobile. I'd like to use Firefox on iOS.
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by simondotau on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @06:49PM (#50080039)
There is absolutely browser diversity on mobile. ~30% of people are using Safari on iOS. ~70% of people are using Chrome on Android (and have the "choice" to use Firefox but don't).
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by edoceo on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @07:14PM (#50080289)
Maybe folk mean that iOS only uses Safari rendering regardless of which wrapper is running? Meaning Apple users don't have a choice, one rendering engine only, not diverse.
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by simondotau on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @07:18PM (#50080315)
No, vrganj said mobile. There is browser diversity on mobile devices by virtue of operating system diversity on mobile devices.
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by leptons on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @11:45PM (#50082134)
You're delusional. Safari is forced on every browser on iOS, you install Firefox but the browser engine is Safari. You install Chrome but the browser engine is forced by Apple to be Safari.

This isn't browser diversity, iOS is a browser monoculture, it's all Safari under the hood. How can you not understand this??

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by randbyte on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @08:35PM (#50080931)
There is no browser engine diversity on iOS. Reskinned Safari doesn’t count.
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by simondotau on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @12:01AM (#50082238)
That's not what diversity means. I agree there's no browser choice on iOS.

Choice is what the individual (supposedly) has. Diversity is what actually exists across an ecosystem. iOS is the last bastion of browser diversity, because despite all this supposed "choice", it's pretty much all Chrome everywhere else.

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by randbyte on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @08:55AM (#50086991)
On the contrary. There are plenty of choices on iOS but no diversity.
Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by LocalH on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @12:37PM (#50090525)
Reynard exists for those who can sideload or jailbreak iOS:

https://github.com/minh-ton/reynard-browser

Real Gecko on iOS

Re:Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you s... by themanualstates on Wednesday October 14, 2026 @10:55PM (#50098582)
Nice!

Chromium on iOS can also be compiled with blink, using the ‘use_blink’ flag.